Rendered from docs/probe-runs/campaign-of-2026-10-05-campaign-tier-no-skills-arm-discovery.md in the Headwater
corpus. Every document on this half of the site is typed by the taxonomy
the descriptor names: corpus.json.
Campaign of 2026-10-05, campaign tier, no-skills arm, discovery
Run identity
model: claude-sonnet-5
served_version: claude-sonnet-5
tree: sha256:81d5f62acb289022175d192df0a61faf5f71eb4b79e8dd1f4efae4532ebdd916
lock: sha256:b768fe795c8d44a882e8604a5012c2eb5f2b4d584e7445367dfb24bb21c3585d
selection: sha256:c84af3cc500bdabda0be3c6dd5e76b38223d5e9950b0fc012f9fc68e7c9a1e32
read_set: sha256:0934c679a536b4e44258201b27ca9ee9bea11fa827b636e241fed118610860c7
seed: 0
harness: 0.5.0
tier: campaign
arm: no-skills
at: 2026-10-05
cost_cents: 14027
This line is one of the paid layer campaign that #1659 asked for. tools/probe/campaign.sh recorded it as line 4 of the plan of batch B, a plan that draws its lines from tools/probe/layer-campaign.spec. It is the no-skills arm of the campaign tier over the discovery selection, at 118 repetitions per probe, on claude-sonnet-5 under Claude Code 2.1.288 with a cap of 80 turns for each session. The line leaves out HW-PROBE-the-authoring-skill-reaches-an-agent-that-is-about-to-write-a-governed-document, because no arm without .claude/ can satisfy it.
One tree. Every session ran in a fresh copy of a git archive of commit debe0c70, with the engine of that commit. Batch B ran after batch A on the same pin that batch A ended on.
What the recorder counted. The line holds 354 sessions and cost 14027 cents. The intent hook was live in 354 of them. None stopped at the turn cap, and none at the session budget. The recorder reports 28 paths outside the workspace named in a call of this line, 0 sessions uncounted, and 0 web-tool calls.
The contract of this batch. The sessions ran under the recorder contract of spec 15: a bwrap sandbox with no network of its own, an empty configuration directory, --setting-sources project,local, the permission mode dontAsk, and WebSearch and WebFetch denied. The batches of 2026-09-28 and 2026-09-30 ran under bypassPermissions and the configuration of the host, so a rate from this batch does not compare with a rate from those batches.
Where the figures are. The rates, the intervals and the comparisons of this line are in the generated result that reads this transcript, and this document states none of them.
Events
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r1"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo --- && find . -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level repo structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-engine\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find docs/taxonomies .headwater/packages -maxdepth 3 | sort\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy and packages directory contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine/crates -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List engine crates\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== taxonomy.yml head ===\\\"; sed -n '1,80p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"=== grep rule ids in taxonomy.yml ===\\\"; grep -n \\\"^ - id:\\\\|^- id:\\\\|severity\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -80\",\"description\":\"Inspect taxonomy.yml structure for rule declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater -maxdepth 2 -type f | sort; echo ---; cat .headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null | head -100\",\"description\":\"List .headwater top-level files and show overlay.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"retired_terms\\\\|^rules\\\\|rules:\\\\|check\\\\.\\\" .headwater/overlay.yml | head -50\",\"description\":\"Search overlay.yml for rule declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l .headwater/overlay.yml .headwater/taxonomy.yml; echo ---; grep -n \\\"retired_terms\\\" -r .headwater docs engine tools 2>/dev/null | head -50\",\"description\":\"Search for retired_terms across repo\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"summary\\\" docs/spec/*.md | head -40\",\"description\":\"Search spec docs for 'summary' facet references\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rln \\\"summary\\\" engine/crates/check/src engine/crates/meta engine/crates/doc/src engine/crates/scaffold/src 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Search engine crates for summary handling\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,400p' engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^##\\\\|^###\\\\|severity\\\\|rule id\\\\|\\\\`[a-z_]*\\\\.[a-z_]*\\\\.[a-z_]*\\\\`\\\" docs/spec/12-check-layer.md | head -120\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"is_empty\\\\|trim()\\\\|blank\\\" engine/crates/check/src/*.rs | grep -v test | head -40\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls engine/crates/check/src; echo ---; grep -n \\\"pub const RULE\\\" engine/crates/check/src/*.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r1/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r1/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n -B2 -A6 \\\"^ summary:\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"RULES\\\\b\\\" -A60 engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs | grep -n \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet.required.missing\\\" \"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r10"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Inspect working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater -maxdepth 4 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine -maxdepth 4 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List engine directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/packages"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/doctrine -maxdepth 3 | sort\",\"description\":\"List doctrine directory contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Count lines in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r10/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls engine/crates/check/src\",\"description\":\"List check crate source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r10/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r10/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls engine/crates/check/tests | grep -i blank; echo \\\"---\\\"; grep -rl \\\"summary\\\" engine/crates/check/tests 2>/dev/null | head -20\",\"description\":\"Find blank-rule tests and summary test fixtures\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "engine/crates/check"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r10/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md"
result: "sha256:ab8d0eb139f3733cde3ca712a0f637ff8fe82f70fc93a55f87b27273fad00d57"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"18-blank-facets\\\\|facet.value.blank\\\" -r engine/crates/check/fixtures/check.report\",\"description\":\"Check report fixture for blank facets expectations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r10/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check.report"
result: "sha256:1120731ba9752b904d987911fa2678a4cc5ce5b60badebecfdfa7e9bc50e3e4b"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r100"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo --- && ls .headwater 2>/dev/null && echo --- && ls docs/taxonomies 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List repo root and taxonomy directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la | grep -i git; ls -la .git 2>&1 | head -5\",\"description\":\"Check for .git directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls .headwater/packages; echo ---; cat .headwater/taxonomy.yml | head -100\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy packages and view taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Find rule declaration and implementation pattern\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"I'm working in a repository called Headwater (a documentation-governance engine). I need to add a new check rule that reports a document whose `summary` front-matter field is empty. Before I write anything, I need to understand the existing pattern for how a rule is declared and how it is implemented, by finding an existing analogous rule — ideally one that already checks a front-matter field for presence/emptiness, or any simple metadata-shape rule (not a prose/line-wrap rule).\\n\\nPlease investigate and report back (don't edit anything, read-only):\\n\\n1. Where rules are DECLARED in the taxonomy — look at `taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/` (the authored source of the package) and `.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/` (the vendored copy) and `.headwater/overlay.yml`. Find the YAML/schema files that declare rules (look for files with rule ids, severity fields like `error`/`advisory`, categories). Show me the full declaration of one existing rule that checks a required field (e.g. something checking front matter like `summary`, `title`, `status`, or similar — look for schema/field \\\"required\\\" or \\\"non-empty\\\" style rules). Quote the exact file path and the YAML block.\\n\\n2. Where rules are IMPLEMENTED in the engine — look under `engine/` (likely a Rust workspace, crate `headwater-cli` or similar, maybe `headwater-check` or `headwater-taxonomy` crates). Find the Rust source file(s) implementing a rule analogous to \\\"field X must not be empty\\\" — ideally something checking the `summary` field already partially (e.g. maybe `summary` must be present, or under some length, or `title` non-empty). Show me the function/struct implementing one such rule, with file path and line numbers, and explain how a rule id in the taxonomy maps to a Rust implementation (e.g. is there a registry, a match statement, a trait `Rule` with an id constant?).\\n\\n3. Find out if `summary` is already a declared front-matter field in the schema (e.g. required: true) somewhere — grep for `summary` across `taxonomy-source/`, `.headwater/packages/`, `docs/taxonomies/`, and `engine/`. Report every place `summary` appears as a schema/field name (not as prose).\\n\\n4. Find out the severity taxonomy: what are the possible severity values (error, advisory, etc.), where declared, and what determines whether a NEW rule you'd write should be \\\"error\\\" or \\\"advisory\\\" — is there a convention doc (e.g. in DEVELOPING.md or a taxonomy README) laying out when a rule is which severity?\\n\\n5. Find how rule severity and \\\"mechanical remedy\\\" (fixable via `--fix`) relate — is there a `fixable: true/false` field or similar?\\n\\nReport concrete file paths, line numbers, and quoted snippets. Keep the report organized under the 5 numbered questions above. This is purely investigative — do not write or edit any file.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && echo \\\"---\\\" && ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r100\",\"description\":\"Show working directory contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"**/taxonomy-source/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"**/.headwater/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".headwater/packages/**/taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r100/.claude/skills -maxdepth 1 2>/dev/null; echo ---; find / -maxdepth 6 -iname \\\"*headwater-taxonomy*\\\" 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Check for headwater skill directories on disk\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r100/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Count lines in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r100/.headwater/\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"What holds this repository\\\" -A 5 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r100/DEVELOPING.md\",\"description\":\"Locate the 'What holds this repository' section in DEVELOPING.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r100/DEVELOPING.md"
result: "sha256:8fbd8eb18a5b58dcbf5bfa3a763cea8bd99c0f877dfbc00aff7af74c9c9888cb"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"summary\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard --include=\\\"*.yml\\\" -l 2>/dev/null; echo ---schema---; grep -rln \\\"summary\\\" taxonomy-source 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Search for 'summary' references in taxonomy package and source\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r100/taxonomy-source"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r100/.headwater/packages"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" -B3 -A15 taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Show context around 'summary' in taxonomy source\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r100/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine -type d -maxdepth 3 | sort; echo ---; grep -rln \\\"facet.required\\\" engine docs taxonomy-source .headwater 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List engine crate directories and search for facet.required rule id\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r100/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/ && find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r100/taxonomy-source -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy-source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r100/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^id:\\\\|^ id:\\\\|rule_id\\\\|severity:\\\\|category:\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r100/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -80\",\"description\":\"Find rule id, severity, category markers in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r100/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r100/docs/decisions/0058-a-blank-facet-value-is-a-rule-of-its-own-and-it-reads-every-string-facet.md"
result: "sha256:7c1e03d300ff01f37bf38245f8adbfb1b6ef00e6dcc45839abd740efdb29ad21"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r100/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r100/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^rules:\\\\|^checks:\\\\|^controls:\\\\|^obligations:\\\\|^facets:\\\\|^kinds:\\\\|^relations:\\\\|^vocabularies:\\\\|^anchors:\\\\|^regimes:\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r100/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Find top-level YAML keys in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^[A-Za-z_]*:$\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r100/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Find top-level YAML sections in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"facet_blank\\\\|Blank\\\\|facet.value.blank\\\" engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs\",\"description\":\"Check how the Blank rule is registered in check/src/lib.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r100/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\\|title\\\\|empty\\\\|blank\\\\|no-summary\\\\|no_summary\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r100/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml -i\",\"description\":\"Search for summary/title/empty/blank keywords in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "TaskStop"
argument: "{\"task_id\":\"ada316a151993543e\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r101"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r101\",\"description\":\"List top-level repository contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".headwater/packages/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-engine\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r101/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -50\",\"description\":\"Search taxonomy for existing summary-related rules\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^- id:\\\\|^ id:\\\\|severity\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r101/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -100\",\"description\":\"List rule ids and severities in taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r101/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r101/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r101/engine && grep -rln \\\"OB-FACET-1\\\\|OB_FACET_1\\\" --include=*.rs . ; echo ---; grep -rn \\\"fn .*required\\\\|is_empty\\\" --include=*.rs -l . | head -20\",\"description\":\"Find where OB-FACET-1 and required-facet checks are implemented\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls crates/ && echo --- && grep -rln \\\"facet.*required\\\\|required.*facet\\\\|FacetRequired\\\\|facet_required\\\" --include=*.rs . \",\"description\":\"List engine crates and search for facet-required check logic\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r101/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r101/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r101/engine/crates/cli/tests/blank_facet.rs"
result: "sha256:2803c8c086f63283529fe721a2702cd8dcfd91e4754bdfa17b1423e2ed105143"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r101 && grep -n \\\"OB-FACET-3\\\" -r . --include=*.yml --include=*.rs --include=*.md 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Find all references to OB-FACET-3 obligation\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r101/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r101/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r101/engine/crates/cli/tests/standard_controls.rs"
result: "sha256:77070d1d494f09596ff0ed9bcd399b92cddec7a6a710b2a34020894e2f67943c"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"forbid\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check for any kind that forbids the summary facet\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r102"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo --- && cat .headwater/corpus.json 2>/dev/null | head -100\",\"description\":\"List repo root and view corpus descriptor\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Locate rule declaration and implementation patterns\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"I'm working in the Headwater repository at /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r102 (a documentation-governance engine called \\\"headwater\\\" with a Rust CLI). I need to add a new rule to the check engine that reports a document whose `summary` front-matter field is empty. To do this correctly I need to understand the existing pattern for how a rule is declared and implemented. Please investigate and report back:\\n\\n1. Where is the taxonomy/rule catalog declared? Look under `.headwater/packages/` and `docs/taxonomies/` (there's a `headwater/standard` package per `.headwater/corpus.json`). Find the file format used to declare a rule (id, severity, description, remedy, etc.) — show me a full example of one existing rule's declaration, especially one with severity \\\"error\\\" and one with severity \\\"advisory\\\" (or whatever the severity enum values are called — CLAUDE.md mentions \\\"error\\\" and \\\"advisory\\\" categories).\\n\\n2. Where are rules implemented in the Rust engine source under `engine/`? Find the crate/module that implements checks (likely something like `headwater-check` or similar). Show me how one existing rule (ideally something simple like a required-field or empty-field check, e.g. related to front matter fields) is implemented in Rust — the function/struct, how it reads the rule id, how severity is wired up, and how it emits a finding/diagnostic.\\n\\n3. Is there an existing rule that checks for an empty/missing field in front matter (e.g., title, summary, description)? If so give exact file path and line numbers.\\n\\n4. What is the front-matter schema for a document — is `summary` an existing recognized field? Find where front matter fields are defined/validated (likely in a schema file or Rust struct) and confirm whether `summary` already exists as a field so I know if I just need a new validation rule vs. also defining the field.\\n\\n5. How does a rule declaration get wired to its Rust implementation (is it just matching on rule id string, a trait, a macro, a generated binding)?\\n\\nReport file paths with line numbers for everything so I can go edit directly. Be thorough — this is the main research step before I write code.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo \\\"---corpus---\\\" && cat .headwater/corpus.json 2>/dev/null | head -100\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo waiting\",\"description\":\"no-op placeholder\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater -maxdepth 6 -type d 2>/dev/null && echo \\\"---taxonomies---\\\" && find docs/taxonomies -maxdepth 6 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine -maxdepth 4 -type d 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la engine/crates/check/src/ && echo \\\"---\\\" && find .headwater/packages/headwater-standard -iname \\\"*rule*\\\" 2>/dev/null && echo \\\"---doctrine grep---\\\" && grep -rl \\\"severity\\\" docs/taxonomies/*/doctrine.md .headwater/packages 2>/dev/null | head -20\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"\\\\\\\"error\\\\\\\"\\\\|'error'\\\\|advisory\\\" CLAUDE.md | head -40\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r102/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r102/engine/crates/check/src/frontmatter.rs"
result: "sha256:b6864d616cbf7133eb84efa03e36c9092b9a2aa50c6e7d0e87408bfd68914f8a"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r102/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r102/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r102/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r102/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r102/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r102/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r102/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r102/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r102/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r102/engine/crates/check/src/register.rs"
result: "sha256:52031940b257aae736f4ee275b599207b10a9774d05b6934c201a66749b9f224"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r102/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r102/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r102/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '375,390p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml && echo ---OBL--- && sed -n '820,835p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml && echo ---CTL--- && sed -n '1280,1300p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Verify taxonomy.yml summary facet, obligation, and control entries\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,30p' engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs && echo ...60-220... && sed -n '60,220p' engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs\",\"description\":\"Read facet_blank.rs implementation\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r103"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check working directory contents and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Map how Headwater rules are declared and implemented\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"This is the Headwater repository, a documentation-governance engine. I need to add a new check rule: \\\"a document whose summary field is empty should be reported.\\\" Before implementing, I need to understand the existing pattern for how rules work end-to-end.\\n\\nPlease investigate and report back (with exact file paths and line numbers):\\n\\n1. Where rules are DECLARED (the taxonomy). Look under `.headwater/packages/`, `taxonomy-source/`, and `docs/taxonomies/`. Find the taxonomy package file(s) that list rules like \\\"no-contraction\\\", \\\"british-spelling\\\", \\\"hard-wrap\\\"/line-break rule, \\\"retired-term\\\" (stock AI phrasing), and any rule about documents having a \\\"summary\\\" field already (e.g. required front matter fields). Show the schema/shape used to declare a rule entry (fields like id, severity, remedy, description, etc.) with a couple of concrete examples copied verbatim.\\n\\n2. Where rules are IMPLEMENTED in the engine. Look under `engine/` (likely Rust, crate `headwater-cli` or similar, maybe a `headwater-check` or `headwater-rules` crate). Find the source file(s) implementing a couple of existing rules referenced above — especially anything that already deals with \\\"summary\\\" or front matter metadata validation (e.g. a rule that requires a summary/description field to exist, or validates front matter shape). Show the function/struct names, file paths, and how a rule registers itself (trait, enum variant, registry, etc.).\\n\\n3. How SEVERITY is defined/declared — is it a field in the taxonomy YAML/TOML/JSON entry (e.g. severity: error | advisory), or is it in code? Show the enum/type definition and the taxonomy field name.\\n\\n4. Find any existing rule that is closest in nature to \\\"field X is empty/missing\\\" (e.g. a required-field check, or a \\\"document has no front matter\\\" check mentioned in docs/decisions/0029). Show its full declaration and implementation as a template to copy.\\n\\n5. Find where \\\"summary\\\" as a concept is defined for documents in this corpus — is it a front-matter field documented in docs/spec/ or docs/interfaces/ (e.g. docs/interfaces/headwater-generate.md, or a schema doc)? Quote the relevant lines defining what a document's \\\"summary\\\" is and whether it's required already.\\n\\n6. Note the file(s) that would need to change to add a brand new rule: likely one taxonomy declaration file, one engine implementation file, and possibly a test fixture directory (look for `engine/**/tests/` or `fixtures/` directories used for rule tests).\\n\\nReport concisely with exact paths/line numbers for everything above so I can make the edits myself without re-searching.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r103 -maxdepth 3 | head -100\",\"description\":\"List top-level directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "ScheduleWakeup"
argument: "{\"delaySeconds\":300,\"noop\":true,\"reason\":\"waiting on background Explore agent mapping the rule declaration/implementation pattern\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"---engine---\\\"; find . -maxdepth 2 -iname \\\"engine*\\\"; echo \\\"---.headwater---\\\"; find . -maxdepth 4 -path \\\"*.headwater*\\\"; echo \\\"---taxonomy-source---\\\"; find . -maxdepth 4 -iname \\\"*taxonom*\\\"; echo \\\"---docs/taxonomies---\\\"; find docs -maxdepth 2 -iname \\\"*taxonom*\\\"; echo \\\"---docs/spec---\\\"; find docs -maxdepth 2 -iname \\\"*spec*\\\"; echo \\\"---docs/interfaces---\\\"; find docs -maxdepth 2 -iname \\\"*interface*\\\"\",\"description\":\"Search for engine, taxonomy, spec, interface directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml size ===\\\"; wc -l taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"=== engine dir ===\\\"; find engine -maxdepth 4 -type d\\necho \\\"=== docs/interfaces ===\\\"; ls docs/interfaces\\necho \\\"=== docs/spec ===\\\"; ls docs/spec\",\"description\":\"Inspect taxonomy file size, engine dirs, interfaces, spec listing\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== check crate src files ===\\\"; find engine/crates/check/src -type f\\necho\\necho \\\"=== check crate tests files ===\\\"; find engine/crates/check/tests -type f | head -30\\necho\\necho \\\"=== search taxonomy.yml for rule-like keys ===\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"^- id:\\\\|^ id:\\\\|no-contraction\\\\|british-spelling\\\\|hard-wrap\\\\|retired-term\\\\|summary\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -80\",\"description\":\"List check crate files and search taxonomy for rule entries\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r103\\necho \\\"=== contraction ===\\\"; grep -n -i \\\"contraction\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"=== british ===\\\"; grep -n -i \\\"british\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"=== wrap ===\\\"; grep -n -i \\\"wrap\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"=== retired ===\\\"; grep -n -i \\\"retired\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"=== facets: block near 370-440 ===\\\"\\nsed -n '1,60p' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Search taxonomy for rule keywords and view header\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r103/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r103/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r103/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r103\\ngrep -n \\\"^controls:\\\\|^obligations:\\\\|mechanism:\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Find controls and obligations sections in taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r103/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r103/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r103\\ngrep -n \\\"OB-FACET-1\\\\|OB-FACET-3\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Find obligation declarations for OB-FACET-1 and OB-FACET-3\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r103/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r103/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r103/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r103\\necho \\\"=== lib.rs registry section ===\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"facet_blank\\\\|facet_required\\\\|Blank\\\\|Required\\\\b\\\\|mod \\\\|register\\\\|Registry\\\\|pub fn all\\\\|checks(\\\" engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs | head -80\",\"description\":\"Search lib.rs for rule registration pattern\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r103/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r103/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r103\\necho \\\"=== grep facet_blank in tests ===\\\"\\ngrep -rln \\\"facet_blank\\\\|facet\\\\.value\\\\.blank\\\" engine/crates/check/tests\\necho\\necho \\\"=== fixtures/facet-values dir ===\\\"\\nfind engine/crates/check/fixtures/facet-values -maxdepth 2\\necho\\necho \\\"=== tests/facet_values.rs head ===\\\"\\nsed -n '1,80p' engine/crates/check/tests/facet_values.rs\",\"description\":\"Find facet_blank test coverage and fixtures\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r103\\necho \\\"=== fixtures.rs facet_blank mention ===\\\"\\ngrep -n -B3 -A15 \\\"facet_blank\\\" engine/crates/check/tests/fixtures.rs\\necho\\necho \\\"=== docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md summary mentions ===\\\"\\ngrep -n -i \\\"summary\\\" docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md\\necho\\necho \\\"=== docs/interfaces/headwater-generate.md summary mentions ===\\\"\\ngrep -n -i \\\"summary\\\" docs/interfaces/headwater-generate.md\",\"description\":\"Check fixtures.rs for facet_blank and search spec/interfaces for summary field\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r103/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r103\\ngrep -n \\\"struct Facet\\\\|severity\\\" engine/crates/check/src/shape.rs | head -30\",\"description\":\"Check Facet struct definition for a severity field\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r103\\nsed -n '1,40p' docs/decisions/0029-q29-whether-a-corpus-root-may-contain-code-and-what-an-interface-contract-may-reach.md\",\"description\":\"Peek at decision 0029 content\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '375,400p;820,835p;1280,1300p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r103/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Read taxonomy entries for summary facet, OB-FACET-3, CT-FACET-3\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"RULE\\\\|Severity::\\\\|fn evaluate\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r103/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs | head -30\",\"description\":\"Check facet_blank.rs rule id and severity usage\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r103/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r103/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104\",\"description\":\"List top-level repo contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/.headwater -maxdepth 3 -type d 2>/dev/null; echo ---; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/.headwater -maxdepth 2 -type f 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Inspect .headwater directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/.headwater/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:0aa1b806b4bc44af26c12dc624643169bddb3583054e78db3873c23ca8e4bb12"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/.headwater/packages -maxdepth 4 -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List files under .headwater/packages\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/taxonomy-source -maxdepth 4 | sort\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy-source directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/engine -maxdepth 3 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List engine directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Map rule declaration and implementation pattern\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"I'm working in the Headwater repository at /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104. This is a documentation-governance engine: a Rust engine under engine/crates/ implements checks (\\\"rules\\\") over a corpus of Markdown documents, and those rules are declared/configured in a taxonomy package under taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/ (vendored copy under .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/).\\n\\nI need to add a new rule: \\\"report a document whose summary field (front matter) is empty.\\\" To do that correctly I need to understand the existing pattern for a similar rule, e.g. a rule that checks a front-matter field for emptiness/presence (title, summary, or any required string field). I need to know:\\n\\n1. Where rules are DECLARED — look at taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml (and any related yml files under taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/, like bundle.yml files, or a rules/ subdirectory if one exists). Show the exact YAML shape used to declare a rule: its id/name, severity field and the allowed severity values (e.g. error vs advisory, or some other vocabulary), and any \\\"remedy\\\" or \\\"fix\\\" field. If there's an existing rule that checks for an empty or missing field (e.g. title, summary, description), quote it in full with surrounding context and its file path + line numbers.\\n\\n2. Where rules are IMPLEMENTED — look at engine/crates/check/src/ (and engine/crates/meta/src if relevant — \\\"meta\\\" might hold front-matter parsing). Find the Rust code that implements a similar \\\"field is empty/missing\\\" check already (search for \\\"summary\\\" field handling, or \\\"title\\\" emptiness, or any rule that reports on front matter field content). Quote the relevant function(s) with file path + line numbers. Explain how a rule's output (a \\\"finding\\\") is structured — what fields it has (id, severity, message, document path, line, fix suggestion etc.), and how severity is represented in Rust (an enum? what are its variants — error/advisory/warning?).\\n\\n3. Is there a test fixture pattern for rules (engine/crates/check/fixtures/) — show one example fixture + its expected-output file for an existing \\\"field emptiness\\\" or similar simple rule, with file paths.\\n\\n4. Does \\\"summary\\\" already exist as a recognized front-matter field in this schema (check doctrine.md files under taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/bundles/*/doctrine.md, and any front-matter schema files) — i.e., is \\\"summary\\\" already a field documents have, just not yet checked for emptiness? Quote where \\\"summary\\\" is defined as a field.\\n\\nReport back with concrete file paths, line numbers, and quoted snippets (not paraphrased) for all of the above, organized under these four headings. Keep total report under 600 lines.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find taxonomy-source/headwater-standard -type f | head -100\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine/crates/check -type f -name \\\"*.rs\\\" | head -100\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine/crates/meta -type f -name \\\"*.rs\\\" 2>/dev/null | head -100\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "ScheduleWakeup"
argument: "{\"delaySeconds\":180,\"reason\":\"waiting on background Explore agent mapping rule declaration/implementation pattern before writing code\",\"noop\":true,\"prompt\":\"Check whether the Explore agent investigating Headwater rule declaration/implementation pattern has completed; if so, use its findings to implement the empty-summary rule (taxonomy declaration + Rust check implementation + fixture/test) and report where it's declared, implemented, and its severity. If not yet done, keep waiting.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat -n /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat -n /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat -n /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/engine/crates/check/src/frontmatter.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat -n /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/conformance.yml /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/package.yml /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/assemblies/starter/assembly.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat -n /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine/crates/check/fixtures -iname \\\"*blank*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*facet*\\\" 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/engine/crates/check/tests"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/doctrine/starter.md"
result: "sha256:0fa70c1338a7e24ec5a3e0f8202cceffb1ea53182ce2ba91341a8ecf8d1e104a"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check -maxdepth 2 | sort\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md"
result: "sha256:ab8d0eb139f3733cde3ca712a0f637ff8fe82f70fc93a55f87b27273fad00d57"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/engine/crates/check/tests/fixtures.rs"
result: "sha256:7b17c7814d7d48dc348043a7ac9daad7c6839f90f2bdbf21996b66ccc6f34749"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/05-no-summary.md"
result: "sha256:e93ab39ba0f3d03cf7593bc046d7c0a5aa0fbf102df0e02e2dbf34c263aa346d"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check.report"
result: "sha256:1120731ba9752b904d987911fa2678a4cc5ce5b60badebecfdfa7e9bc50e3e4b"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check.taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:105e82f4b4435094f6bfd8ba5b3c3f3380341b35aeebc9aca2c3d508726d1601"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/bundles -maxdepth 3 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---\\\"; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard -maxdepth 2 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/doctrine/starter.md"
result: "sha256:0fa70c1338a7e24ec5a3e0f8202cceffb1ea53182ce2ba91341a8ecf8d1e104a"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/taxonomy-source -maxdepth 4 -type d; echo \\\"===\\\"; ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"diff -rq /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard 2>&1 | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"diff /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/package.yml /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/package.yml | head -40\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/docs/taxonomies -maxdepth 2 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/docs/taxonomies"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/docs/taxonomies/design-spec/doctrine.md"
result: "sha256:6448a79c3e236dd11fb631235f4005e63bc43edaf381961fdf18dcc5281f67d6"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/docs/taxonomies/design-spec/doctrine.md"
result: "sha256:6448a79c3e236dd11fb631235f4005e63bc43edaf381961fdf18dcc5281f67d6"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '70,100p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -5; echo '...'; grep -n \\\"lib.rs\\\" -r /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs | head -1\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r104/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md"
result: "sha256:ab8d0eb139f3733cde3ca712a0f637ff8fe82f70fc93a55f87b27273fad00d57"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r105"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r105 -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r105/.headwater -maxdepth 4 | sort\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r105/taxonomy-source -maxdepth 4 | sort | head -100\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy-source contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r105/.agents/skills -maxdepth 2 | sort; echo ---; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r105/.claude -maxdepth 3 | sort\",\"description\":\"List agent skills and claude config dirs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r105/.agents/skills/headwater-taxonomy/SKILL.md"
result: "sha256:f5b9c95bb000782be9586c1b1e263d934d09fc84e8e444ed89c24325004d7220"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r105/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r105/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r105/engine/crates -maxdepth 1 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List engine crates\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r105/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r105/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r105/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r105/engine/crates/cli/tests/blank_facet.rs"
result: "sha256:2803c8c086f63283529fe721a2702cd8dcfd91e4754bdfa17b1423e2ed105143"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r105/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md"
result: "sha256:ab8d0eb139f3733cde3ca712a0f637ff8fe82f70fc93a55f87b27273fad00d57"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls && echo --- && ls .headwater 2>/dev/null && echo --- && ls docs/taxonomies 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List repo root and key config dirs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-engine\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls .headwater/packages && echo --- && ls taxonomy-source && echo --- && find engine -maxdepth 3 -type d | head -50\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy packages and engine structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Map existing rule declaration/implementation pattern\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"I'm working in a repository called Headwater (a documentation-governance engine). I need to add a new check rule to the engine that reports a document whose \\\"summary\\\" field is empty, and I need to understand the existing pattern for how rules are declared and implemented so I can follow it exactly.\\n\\nPlease investigate and report back (with exact file paths and line numbers):\\n\\n1. Where are existing check rules DECLARED? Look at `.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/` and `taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/` — find the taxonomy/package files that declare rules (look for things like rule ids, severity levels e.g. \\\"error\\\"/\\\"advisory\\\", and existing rules similar to things mentioned in the repo's CLAUDE.md such as: no hard-wrapped markdown, American spelling, retired/stock AI terms, contractions, British spelling). Show me the structure of one or two complete rule declarations, including how severity (error vs advisory) is expressed, and any schema/field that defines what the rule checks for (e.g. does a rule for \\\"a field must not be empty\\\" or \\\"a document must have a non-empty X\\\" already exist as a pattern - e.g. is there a rule about missing/empty fields in front matter, like a missing title or missing owner)?\\n\\n2. Where are rules IMPLEMENTED in the engine? Look under `engine/crates/` — especially crates like `audit`, `conformance`, `doc`, `graph` — find the Rust source files that implement a check rule, especially one similar in shape to \\\"a required field is empty/missing\\\" (e.g. checking front matter fields on a document). Show me one complete example implementation (file path + the function/struct that implements it), and how it's registered/wired up to the rule id from the taxonomy declaration.\\n\\n3. Is there an existing field called \\\"summary\\\" in the document front matter schema (search for \\\"summary:\\\" in docs/ front matter, or in schema files, or in `docs/interfaces/`)? Where is that front matter schema defined?\\n\\n4. What severities exist in this system (error vs advisory), and what's the rule for which is which (CLAUDE.md says: \\\"A rule is an error when its remedy is mechanical and total... A rule is advisory when the remedy is a rewrite\\\")? For a rule like \\\"summary is empty\\\" — is the remedy mechanical (just flag it, can't auto-fix) — find any existing similar rule that is \\\"advisory\\\" because it requires a human rewrite, like a missing summary/description would need a human to write content, not something `--fix` can derive.\\n\\nReport file paths, line numbers, and relevant code/taxonomy snippets. Keep the report focused and under 600 words of prose (quoted snippets don't count against that).\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"--- find taxonomy/package dirs ---\\\"; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106 -maxdepth 6 -ipath \\\"*headwater-standard*\\\" 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"--- engine crates ---\\\"; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106/engine/crates -maxdepth 1 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat DEVELOPING.md | head -100\",\"description\":\"Read DEVELOPING.md for enforcement mechanism overview\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/conformance.yml"
result: "sha256:47ef5283be6f8872d13ebf1cd12fb7bd644efd015d23c8e9071e248f8d6f5904"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine/crates -maxdepth 1 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List all engine crates\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine/crates/check -maxdepth 2 | sort\",\"description\":\"List check crate contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106/engine/crates/check"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Check summary facet declaration in taxonomy\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"In this repository (Headwater), I found that the engine/crates/check crate has two \\\"Shape-origin\\\" generated rules:\\n- `facet.required.missing` (engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs) — reports when a document is missing a facet/field that its kind's taxonomy declaration marks required.\\n- `facet.value.blank` (engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs) — reports when a string-typed facet/field is present but blank (null, empty text, or non-scalar), for every facet the taxonomy declares `type: string`.\\n\\nBoth are \\\"generated, not written\\\": they automatically cover every facet declared `type: string` in the taxonomy's Shape declarations — no new Rust code needed per facet.\\n\\nI need to find out: is there already a facet/field called `summary` declared in this repository's taxonomy (the Shape declarations)? Specifically look under `.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/` and `taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/` for a YAML (or similar) file that declares facets with `type: string`, and check whether one of them is named `summary`. Report:\\n\\n1. The exact file path and line number(s) where `summary` is declared (if it exists), including its `type:` and whether it's listed as `required` for any kind(s).\\n2. If `summary` does NOT exist as a declared facet anywhere, say so clearly, and show me the file path and format of an existing similar facet declaration (e.g. `title` or another required string facet) that I could copy as a template to add one — show the full block including surrounding YAML structure (indentation, how `required` is expressed per kind, etc.).\\n3. Also look for a corresponding JSON Schema or front-matter schema file (search `docs/interfaces/` or similar) that might separately define a `summary` field, to see if the front-matter schema and the taxonomy Shape declaration are the same file or two different files that need to agree.\\n\\nReport file paths, line numbers, and exact YAML snippets. Keep prose under 400 words (snippets don't count).\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106 -maxdepth 2 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---\\\"; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106 -iname \\\"*headwater-standard*\\\" -maxdepth 6 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106/CLAUDE.md 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---\\\"; grep -rn \\\"summary:\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106/docs --include=\\\"*.md\\\" -l | head -5; echo \\\"---doc front matter schema---\\\"; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106/docs/interfaces -type f 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"summary\\\" docs/spec/12-check-layer.md 2>/dev/null | head -30\",\"description\":\"Search spec 12 for mentions of summary\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard -type f | head -100\\necho \\\"---taxonomy-source---\\\"\\nfind /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard -type f | head -100\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106 -maxdepth 1 -iname \\\"CLAUDE.md\\\"; echo \\\"---\\\"; grep -n -i \\\"mechanical\\\\|advisory\\\\|remedy\\\\|hard-wrap\\\\|contraction\\\\|American\\\\|British\\\\|stock AI\\\\|retired\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106/CLAUDE.md 2>/dev/null | head -60\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== grep summary ===\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"summary\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"=== diff source vs compiled ===\\\"\\ndiff /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"=== wc ===\\\"\\nwc -l /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"Severity::\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106/engine/crates/check/src/voice.rs /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106/engine/crates/check/src/language.rs | head -20\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== all facets.require lines in taxonomy-source ===\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"facets:\\\" -A2 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | grep -n \\\"require\\\"\\necho \\\"=== bundle facets require (search bundles dirs) ===\\\"\\ngrep -rn \\\"summary\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/*/bundle.yml 2>/dev/null\\necho \\\"=== docs/interfaces ===\\\"\\nfind /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106/docs/interfaces -type f | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"summary\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/ taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/ 2>/dev/null | grep -v \\\"^.*:.*#.*summary\\\" | head -60\",\"description\":\"Search taxonomy packages for summary facet declaration\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106 -iname \\\"*schema*\\\" -not -path \\\"*/target/*\\\" -not -path \\\"*/node_modules/*\\\" 2>/dev/null | head -50\\necho \\\"---\\\"\\ngrep -rln \\\"frontmatter\\\\|front_matter\\\\|front-matter\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106/docs 2>/dev/null | head -20\\necho \\\"--- facet_required.rs / facet_blank.rs source-of-truth check ---\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"taxonomy\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs | head -20\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r106/engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r107"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo \\\"---\\\" && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"List working directory contents and check git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r107/.headwater -maxdepth 4 -type d\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/doctrine -maxdepth 2 | head -50\",\"description\":\"List doctrine directory (likely rule declarations)\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine -maxdepth 3 -type d\",\"description\":\"List engine directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r107/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/doctrine/starter.md"
result: "sha256:0fa70c1338a7e24ec5a3e0f8202cceffb1ea53182ce2ba91341a8ecf8d1e104a"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls engine/crates/check/src engine/crates/check/fixtures | head -100\",\"description\":\"List check crate source and fixtures\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r107/engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r107/.headwater"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r107/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r107/engine/crates/check/src/frontmatter.rs"
result: "sha256:b6864d616cbf7133eb84efa03e36c9092b9a2aa50c6e7d0e87408bfd68914f8a"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r107/engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"rule\\\\|id:\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -60\",\"description\":\"Look at rule declarations in base taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r107/docs/subsystems/checks-and-cache.md"
result: "sha256:77f405d4561949b1ed2a521ea0b7409e8a5cfa992deab46ac827a3d2792b87e1"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r107/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r107/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r107/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^ summary:\\\\|^ summary:\\\\|summary:\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Find summary facet declaration in base taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r107/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r107/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"facet.value.blank\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Find lines mentioning the rule id in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r107/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"OB-FACET-3\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Find the obligation entry OB-FACET-3\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r107/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|summary\\\" engine/crates/check/tests/*.rs 2>/dev/null | head -30\",\"description\":\"Check existing tests referencing the blank-facet rule or summary\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine/crates/check -iname \\\"*facet_blank*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*blank*\\\" | grep -v target\",\"description\":\"Find facet_blank related test/fixture files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r107/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md"
result: "sha256:ab8d0eb139f3733cde3ca712a0f637ff8fe82f70fc93a55f87b27273fad00d57"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r108"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r108 | head -50\",\"description\":\"List working directory contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la .git 2>&1 | head -5; git status 2>&1 | head -5\",\"description\":\"Check for .git directory and repo status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r108/.headwater -maxdepth 4 -type d | head -50\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Locate rule declaration and implementation pattern\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"I'm working in the repository at /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r108, which is \\\"Headwater\\\" — a documentation-governance engine. It has a `headwater check` CLI (built from engine/ crates) that runs rules declared in a taxonomy (under .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/doctrine and related) and implemented in the engine (under engine/).\\n\\nI need to add a new rule: \\\"report a document whose `summary` front-matter field is empty.\\\" I need to find:\\n\\n1. Where rules/checks are DECLARED in the taxonomy — find the doctrine file(s) under .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/doctrine/ (or taxonomy-source/) that declare existing rules analogous to this one (e.g., a rule about a missing/empty required front-matter field, or a metadata completeness rule). Show me the exact file path and the YAML/structure used to declare a rule, including fields like id, severity, description, remedy.\\n\\n2. Where rules are IMPLEMENTED in the engine — find the Rust (or other) source under engine/ that implements an analogous existing rule (ideally one that checks a front-matter field, like a \\\"summary\\\" or \\\"description\\\" field, or checks for emptiness/presence). Show me the exact file path, the function/struct name, and how it's wired up (e.g., a registry of checks, a trait impl, severity enum).\\n\\n3. Find how severity is defined — the exact enum or classification (e.g., `error` vs `advisory`) and where in code/taxonomy that's set, matching the CLAUDE.md claim: \\\"A rule is an error when its remedy is mechanical and total... A rule is advisory when the remedy is a rewrite.\\\"\\n\\n4. Find the taxonomy-source/ directory too — is there a separate \\\"source\\\" representation of taxonomy that compiles into .headwater/packages? Explain the relationship/build step if any (e.g. a generate step).\\n\\n5. Look at docs/spec or docs/decisions for anything describing the \\\"summary\\\" field itself (is it a required front-matter field on governed documents? what's it called — \\\"summary\\\", \\\"description\\\"?) to confirm the exact field name I should target, and whether a rule like \\\"empty summary\\\" already exists somewhere (search for \\\"summary\\\" \\\"empty\\\" \\\"blank\\\").\\n\\nReport back: exact file paths and line numbers/snippets for all of the above, plus a recommendation for where the new rule's declaration and implementation should go, following the existing pattern as closely as possible. Keep the report focused and under 600 words plus code snippets.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater -type d | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "ScheduleWakeup"
argument: "{\"delaySeconds\":180,\"reason\":\"waiting on Explore agent to map rule declaration/implementation pattern\",\"noop\":true}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find . -maxdepth 2 -type d\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/doctrine -maxdepth 3 | head -80\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find taxonomy-source -maxdepth 4 | head -100\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine/crates -maxdepth 2\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r108/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine/crates/check/src -maxdepth 3; echo ---; find engine/crates/meta/src -maxdepth 3\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" -ri /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r108/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/doctrine/starter.md | head -30\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r108/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r108/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r108/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r108/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r108/engine/crates/check/src/register.rs"
result: "sha256:52031940b257aae736f4ee275b599207b10a9774d05b6934c201a66749b9f224"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r108/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r108/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r108/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r108/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r108/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r108"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r108"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"diff /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r108/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r108/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -20\\necho \\\"---doctrine diff---\\\"\\ndiff /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r108/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/doctrine/starter.md /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r108/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/doctrine/starter.md | head -20\\necho \\\"---package.yml---\\\"\\ncat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r108/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/package.yml\\necho \\\"---tools/taxonomy---\\\"\\nfind /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r108/tools/taxonomy -maxdepth 2\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r108/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r108/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '820,840p;1280,1300p' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Inspect OB-FACET-3 / CT-FACET-3 declarations in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"RULE\\\\|Severity::\\\\|summary\\\\|blank\\\" engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs | head -40\",\"description\":\"Check facet_blank.rs for rule constant and severity\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r109"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r109/.headwater/packages -maxdepth 3 -type f | head -50\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy package files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml && grep -n -i \\\"summary\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -50\",\"description\":\"Search taxonomy for summary-related rules\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r109/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^rules:\\\\|^ rules:\\\\|severity\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/*.yml | head -60\",\"description\":\"Search for rules/severity declarations in taxonomy package files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r109/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd engine && grep -rn \\\"OB-FACET-1\\\\|OB-FACET-2\\\" --include=*.rs -l\",\"description\":\"Find engine source files referencing facet obligations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd engine && find . -type f -name \\\"*.rs\\\" | xargs grep -ln \\\"facet\\\" -i | head -30\",\"description\":\"Find Rust files referencing facets\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd crates/resolve/src && wc -l rules.rs && grep -n \\\"fn \\\\|pub fn\\\\|struct Rule\\\\|severity\\\\|Severity\\\" rules.rs | head -80\",\"description\":\"Inspect rules.rs structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r109/engine && ls crates\",\"description\":\"List engine crates\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd crates/check && find . -name \\\"*.rs\\\" | xargs wc -l | tail -1 && find . -name \\\"*.rs\\\" | sort\",\"description\":\"List files in check crate\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r109/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r109/engine/crates/check/src && grep -n \\\"facet_blank\\\\|Blank::over\\\\|facet_required\\\\|Required::over\\\" lib.rs\",\"description\":\"Check lib.rs registration of facet_blank and facet_required rules\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r109 && grep -n \\\"forbid\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Check for any kind-level facet forbid declarations\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r11"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r11\",\"description\":\"List top-level repo contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r11/.headwater/corpus.json"
result: "sha256:98145f6c9809d18ccfb6a5eeb55313c5c1c436eb4ecc848f3bfb02943be81874"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r11/.headwater -maxdepth 4 -type d 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---\\\"; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r11/docs/taxonomies -maxdepth 3 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List .headwater and docs/taxonomies directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r11/.headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null | head -100\",\"description\":\"Show overlay.yml contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r11/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r11/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard -maxdepth 2 -type d; echo ---; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r11/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard -iname \\\"*rule*\\\"\",\"description\":\"Explore headwater-standard package layout and rule files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r11/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r11/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r11/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -50\",\"description\":\"Search taxonomy.yml for summary field references\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r11/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r11/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r11/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r11/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r11/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r11/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r11/engine/crates/cli/tests/blank_facet.rs"
result: "sha256:2803c8c086f63283529fe721a2702cd8dcfd91e4754bdfa17b1423e2ed105143"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r11/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r11/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r110"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la | head -30 && echo --- && git status 2>&1 | head -5\",\"description\":\"Check working directory contents and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater -maxdepth 4 -type d; echo ---; find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 6 | head -100\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml; echo ---; grep -n \\\"rule\\\\|summary\\\\|severity\\\\|empty\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -80\",\"description\":\"Inspect taxonomy.yml for rule declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r110/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r110/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^rules:\\\\|^controls:\\\\|^ facet\\\\.\\\\|facet\\\\.blank\\\\|facet\\\\.missing\\\\|facet\\\\.empty\\\\|empty\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Search for rule ids and controls section related to facets\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r110/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"posture:\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | sort | uniq -c | sort -rn | head -20\\necho ---\\ngrep -n \\\"OB-FACET-3\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Check posture values used and find OB-FACET-3 control\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r110/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet_value_blank\\\\|FacetValueBlank\\\" engine/ --include=*.rs -l 2>/dev/null\\necho ---rust-search---\\ngrep -rln \\\"facet.value.blank\\\" engine/ 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Search engine source for facet.value.blank implementation\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r110/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,120p' engine/crates/cli/tests/blank_facet.rs\",\"description\":\"Inspect blank facet test fixture to confirm coverage\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r111"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-engine\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"--- .headwater ---\\\"; find .headwater -maxdepth 3 -type d; echo \\\"--- .headwater/packages ---\\\"; find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 4 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"--- docs/taxonomies ---\\\"; find docs/taxonomies -maxdepth 3 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List .headwater and taxonomy directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r111/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r111/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r111/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r111/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r111/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r112"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r112\",\"description\":\"List repository root\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r112/.headwater -maxdepth 3 -type d\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r112/.headwater/packages -type f | head -100\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy package files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r112/engine -maxdepth 4 -type d\",\"description\":\"List engine directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,400p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r112/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | grep -n \\\"rule\\\\|severity\\\\|summary\\\" | head -80\",\"description\":\"Search taxonomy.yml for rule/severity/summary entries\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r112/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r112/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r112/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r112/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml; grep -n \\\"^[a-z_]*:\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r112/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Show top-level keys in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r112/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r112/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r112/engine/crates/check/src\",\"description\":\"List check crate source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r112/engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r112/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r112/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r112/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"forbid\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r112/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Check for any facet-forbid entries affecting summary\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r113"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git status 2>&1 | head -20 && echo \\\"---\\\" && git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1\",\"description\":\"Check whether current directory is a git repository\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && ls -la\",\"description\":\"List working directory contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find / -maxdepth 6 -iname \\\"*.git\\\" -type d 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---settings---\\\"; cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r113/.claude/settings.json 2>/dev/null | head -50\",\"description\":\"Search for a .git directory and inspect project settings\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r113/.claude/hooks/read.sh 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Inspect the read.sh pre-tool-use hook\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Locate rule declaration and implementation pattern\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"In this repository (Headwater), I need to add a new check rule to the `headwater check` engine: a rule that reports a document whose summary (front matter field) is empty.\\n\\nI need to understand the existing pattern for how rules are declared and implemented, so I can add a new one consistently. Please find and report back (with file paths and line numbers):\\n\\n1. Where rules are DECLARED — look for a taxonomy file (likely under `.headwater/packages/` or `docs/taxonomies/`) that lists rule identifiers, their severity (error vs advisory), and descriptions. Find an existing rule that's similar in shape to \\\"a document field is empty/missing\\\" (e.g. search for \\\"summary\\\" as a front-matter field, or rules about empty/missing fields) so I can see the declaration shape: what keys it has (id, severity, message, remedy, etc).\\n\\n2. Where rules are IMPLEMENTED — look under `engine/` (likely a Rust crate, e.g. `headwater-cli` or similar, possibly a `checks` or `rules` module) for how an existing rule is implemented in code — especially one that checks a front-matter field for emptiness/presence, or a similarly-shaped simple rule (mechanical, error severity). Show the actual code of 1-2 example rule implementations in full, with file path and line numbers, including how the rule registers itself / how severity is wired (error vs advisory) and how the rule ID connects the declaration to the implementation.\\n\\n3. Find where \\\"summary\\\" is defined as a front-matter field for documents (e.g. in a schema or front-matter struct) to confirm the field name and type.\\n\\n4. Find the severity model: what are the possible severity levels (error/advisory) and how is \\\"error = mechanical and total remedy\\\" vs \\\"advisory = remedy is a rewrite\\\" encoded/enforced in code or taxonomy.\\n\\nReport file paths, line numbers, and relevant code/config snippets. Keep the report focused and under 500 lines of quoted material — summarize surrounding context in prose instead of quoting everything.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r113 -maxdepth 3 | head -100\",\"description\":\"List top-level directories of the repo\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r113\\necho \\\"--- engine dir ---\\\"\\nfind \\\"$ROOT/engine\\\" -maxdepth 3 -type d 2>/dev/null\\necho \\\"--- .headwater dir ---\\\"\\nfind \\\"$ROOT/.headwater\\\" -maxdepth 4 2>/dev/null | head -100\\necho \\\"--- docs/taxonomies ---\\\"\\nfind \\\"$ROOT/docs\\\" -iname \\\"*taxonom*\\\" 2>/dev/null\\n\",\"description\":\"Locate engine and taxonomy directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r113\\necho \\\"--- docs/taxonomies top ---\\\"\\nfind \\\"$ROOT/docs/taxonomies\\\" -maxdepth 2\\necho \\\"--- check crate src ---\\\"\\nfind \\\"$ROOT/engine/crates/check/src\\\" -type f\\n\",\"description\":\"List taxonomies dir and check crate source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r113/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r113/engine/crates/check/src/register.rs"
result: "sha256:52031940b257aae736f4ee275b599207b10a9774d05b6934c201a66749b9f224"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r113/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r113/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r113/docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r113/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r113/docs/taxonomies"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r113/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r113/docs/taxonomies/diataxis/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:3c2eb1d555366ea6b73bf87a748de65fbd95c88c489a4e4bf63bba9c4273d135"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r113/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r113/docs/taxonomies/diataxis/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:3c2eb1d555366ea6b73bf87a748de65fbd95c88c489a4e4bf63bba9c4273d135"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r113\\ngrep -rn \\\"summary\\\" \\\"$ROOT/docs/taxonomies/diataxis-site/bundle.yml\\\" \\\"$ROOT/docs/taxonomies/design-spec/bundle.yml\\\" \\\"$ROOT/docs/taxonomies/decision-record/bundle.yml\\\" 2>/dev/null | head -50\",\"description\":\"Search bundle.yml files for summary facet declaration\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r113"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r113"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r113/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r113/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r113/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r113\\necho \\\"--- CLAUDE.md search ---\\\"\\nfind \\\"$ROOT\\\" -iname \\\"CLAUDE.md\\\" -maxdepth 2\\necho \\\"--- grep severity doctrine ---\\\"\\ngrep -n -C3 \\\"mechanical\\\" \\\"$ROOT/CLAUDE.md\\\" 2>/dev/null | head -60\",\"description\":\"Find CLAUDE.md and check mechanical/severity doctrine\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r113/CLAUDE.md"
result: "sha256:c92caed27f86014c5f496edda4ca85568e1da2a44e9c15e4aece92ff9b5bbfd2"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r113/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r113/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r113/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r113/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r114"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== .headwater/packages ===\\\"; find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 3 2>/dev/null; echo; echo \\\"=== docs/taxonomies ===\\\"; find docs/taxonomies -maxdepth 2 2>/dev/null; echo; echo \\\"=== engine structure ===\\\"; find engine -maxdepth 3 -type d\",\"description\":\"Survey taxonomy declaration and engine directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== taxonomy.yml rules section ===\\\"; grep -n \\\"rule\\\\|severity\\\\|id:\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -100\",\"description\":\"Look at taxonomy.yml structure for rule declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== grep summary in taxonomy.yml ===\\\"; grep -n \\\"summary\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -50\\necho\\necho \\\"=== grep summary in check crate ===\\\"; grep -rn \\\"summary\\\" engine/crates/check/src | head -80\",\"description\":\"Search for existing summary-related rules\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r114/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '800,900p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"OB-FACET-3\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '140,200p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml; echo \\\"---1260-1300---\\\"; sed -n '1260,1300p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== search for facet.value.blank in engine ===\\\"; grep -rln \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet_value_blank\\\\|ValueBlank\\\\|value_blank\\\" engine/crates 2>/dev/null\\necho\\necho \\\"=== search in docs ===\\\"; grep -rln \\\"facet.value.blank\\\" docs 2>/dev/null\\necho\\necho \\\"=== ls check/src ===\\\"; ls engine/crates/check/src\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r114/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r114/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"enum Severity\\\" -A 15 engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r115"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check working directory state and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r115/taxonomy-source -type f | head -100\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r115/engine -type d | head -100\",\"description\":\"List engine directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r115/engine/crates -maxdepth 1 -type d\",\"description\":\"List engine crates\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rl \\\"summary\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r115/engine/crates --include=*.rs -l | head -30\",\"description\":\"Find rust files referencing summary field\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r115/engine/crates/check -type f -name \\\"*.rs\\\" | xargs ls -la\",\"description\":\"List check crate source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r115/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -200\",\"description\":\"View taxonomy.yml head\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r115/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r115/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r115/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet_blank\\\\|OB-FACET\\\\|CT-FACET\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r115/engine/crates/check/src/register.rs | head -30\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rln \\\"summary\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r115/engine/crates/check/tests/ 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"OB-FACET\\\\|facet.value.blank\\\" -r /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r115/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r115/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r115/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,60p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r115/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r116"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo --- && cat .headwater/corpus.json 2>/dev/null | head -100\",\"description\":\"List repo root and peek at corpus descriptor\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 4 2>/dev/null | head -50; echo ---; find docs/taxonomies -maxdepth 2 2>/dev/null | head -50\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy package structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .claude -maxdepth 3 -iname \\\"*taxonomy*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*engine*\\\" 2>/dev/null | head -30; echo ---; find . -maxdepth 2 -iname \\\"*skill*\\\"\",\"description\":\"Find skill definition files for taxonomy/engine\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .agents/skills -maxdepth 2; echo ---; ls .claude; find .claude -maxdepth 2\",\"description\":\"Inspect .agents/skills and .claude directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r116/.agents/skills/headwater-taxonomy/SKILL.md"
result: "sha256:f5b9c95bb000782be9586c1b1e263d934d09fc84e8e444ed89c24325004d7220"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rln \\\"summary\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard --include=\\\"*.yml\\\" | head -20\",\"description\":\"Search taxonomy package for summary field declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Show summary field context in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r116/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine -maxdepth 3 -type d | head -50\",\"description\":\"List engine crate directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine/crates/conformance/src -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List conformance crate source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r116/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine/crates/check/src -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List check crate source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r116/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd engine/crates/check && grep -rn \\\"summary\\\" tests/ fixtures/ 2>/dev/null | grep -i blank; echo ---; grep -rln \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet_blank\\\" tests/ 2>/dev/null; echo ---; find . -iname \\\"*blank*\\\"\",\"description\":\"Search for existing test coverage of summary-blank interaction\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r116/engine/crates/check/src && grep -n \\\"facet_blank\\\\|Blank\\\" lib.rs\",\"description\":\"Confirm facet_blank rule is wired into the check engine\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r117"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r117\",\"description\":\"List top-level repo contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".headwater/packages/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r117"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r117/engine -maxdepth 3 -type d\",\"description\":\"List engine subdirectories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r117/engine/crates/check/src\",\"description\":\"List check crate source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r117/engine/crates/check/src/shape.rs"
result: "sha256:9fef54f6760d4bdf2822bdad2e975a4adba4f775446454bb0a5c228da7246067"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r117/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r117/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r117/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r117/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r117/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check.taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:105e82f4b4435094f6bfd8ba5b3c3f3380341b35aeebc9aca2c3d508726d1601"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r117/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check.report"
result: "sha256:1120731ba9752b904d987911fa2678a4cc5ce5b60badebecfdfa7e9bc50e3e4b"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r118"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && ls -la && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Inspect working directory and git state\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r118/.headwater -maxdepth 4 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List .headwater subdirectories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r118/.headwater"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,400p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r118/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"View taxonomy.yml rule declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r118/engine -maxdepth 6 -iname \\\"*rule*\\\" | sort\",\"description\":\"Find rule-related files in engine\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r118/engine/crates/resolve/src"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r118/engine/crates/resolve/src/rules.rs; ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r118/engine/crates/resolve/src/\",\"description\":\"Check rules.rs size and sibling files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r118/engine/crates/\",\"description\":\"List engine crates\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r118/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r118/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r118/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r118/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md"
result: "sha256:ab8d0eb139f3733cde3ca712a0f637ff8fe82f70fc93a55f87b27273fad00d57"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"forbid\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/*.yml .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/**/*.yml 2>/dev/null | head -30\",\"description\":\"Check for facet forbid declarations around summary\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r118/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r118/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r118/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r12"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo --- && git status 2>&1 | head -5\",\"description\":\"Check working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .claude -maxdepth 3 -iname \\\"*skill*\\\" ; echo ---; find . -maxdepth 2 -iname \\\"*taxonomy*\\\"\",\"description\":\"Find skill definitions and taxonomy directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .claude -maxdepth 4 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List .claude subdirectories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find taxonomy-source -maxdepth 4 | sort | head -80\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy-source contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r12/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r12/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r12/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r12/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat \\\"/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r12/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md\\\"; echo ---CLI---; cat \\\"/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r12/engine/crates/cli/tests/blank_facet.rs\\\" | head -100\",\"description\":\"Inspect fixture and CLI test for the blank-facet rule\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r13"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls && echo --- && find . -maxdepth 3 -iname \\\"*taxonom*\\\" 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List repo root and find taxonomy-related paths\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== taxonomy-source grep summary ===\\\"; grep -rn \\\"summary\\\" taxonomy-source/ | head -50; echo \\\"=== engine dir listing ===\\\"; find engine -maxdepth 3 -type d | head -50\",\"description\":\"Search taxonomy source for existing summary-related rules and list engine structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r13/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== taxonomy.yml top ===\\\"; sed -n '1,80p' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml; echo \\\"=== grep rules: in taxonomy ===\\\"; grep -n \\\"^rules:\\\\|^ [a-z_]*:$\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -60\",\"description\":\"Inspect taxonomy.yml header and locate rules section\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/spec/ | head -30; echo \\\"---\\\"; grep -l \\\"rule\\\" docs/spec/*.md | head; echo \\\"=== overlay.yml ===\\\"; cat .headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null | head -80\",\"description\":\"List spec docs and inspect overlay.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r13/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r13/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r13/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== grep facet.value.blank in docs ===\\\"; grep -rn \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet_blank\\\\|Blank::over\\\" --include=*.md --include=*.rs . 2>/dev/null | grep -v \\\"engine/target\\\" | head -60\",\"description\":\"Find where the blank-value rule is declared/registered/documented\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r13/engine/crates/cli/tests/standard_controls.rs"
result: "sha256:77070d1d494f09596ff0ed9bcd399b92cddec7a6a710b2a34020894e2f67943c"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r14"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r14/taxonomy-source -type f | head -100\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r14/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r14/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r14/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r14/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r14/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r14/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r15"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo \\\"---\\\" && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check working directory contents and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Map rule declaration and implementation pattern\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"This is the Headwater repository (a documentation-governance engine). I need to add a new check rule: \\\"reports a document whose summary is empty.\\\" To do this correctly I need to understand the existing pattern for how rules are declared and implemented. Please answer with concrete file paths, line ranges, and code/config snippets (not just prose) for:\\n\\n1. Where rules are DECLARED — look for a taxonomy file (likely under `.headwater/packages/` or `taxonomy-source/` or `docs/taxonomies/`) that lists rule IDs, their names, descriptions, and severity (error vs advisory). Find at least 2-3 example rule declarations, especially ones that are about a document's metadata/front matter (e.g. anything about a \\\"summary\\\" field, or similar structural/front-matter checks), and show the exact schema/shape used (fields like id, severity, remedy type, description).\\n\\n2. Where rules are IMPLEMENTED — look under `engine/` (likely a Rust crate, e.g. `headwater-cli` or similar, maybe `headwater-check` or `headwater-taxonomy`). Find the Rust source file(s) where individual rule checks are implemented as functions/structs, especially ones that check a document's front matter/metadata for presence/non-emptiness of a field. Show the function signature, how a rule registers itself (trait impl, registry, match statement, etc.), and how severity (error vs advisory) is wired from the rule ID to behavior.\\n\\n3. Find out if there is already a \\\"summary\\\" field in the document front matter schema (search for `summary:` in docs front matter, and the Rust struct that deserializes front matter — likely something like `FrontMatter` or `DocumentMetadata`). Confirm whether a field literally named `summary` exists, and if not, what the closest equivalent field is called (e.g. `description`, `abstract`, `purpose`).\\n\\n4. Find an existing simple rule that is structurally analogous (checks a single front-matter field for emptiness/absence) end-to-end: its declaration entry, its Rust implementation function, and any test fixture for it (search `engine/**/tests` or `engine/**/fixtures`). Give exact file paths and line numbers for all three (declaration, implementation, test).\\n\\nReport back with file paths and line numbers/snippets. Keep the report structured under the 4 numbered headings above. This is research only — do not edit any files.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== root ===\\\"; ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r15 2>/dev/null || echo \\\"NOT FOUND\\\"; echo \\\"=== search broader ===\\\"; find / -maxdepth 6 -iname \\\"*headwater*\\\" -not -path \\\"*/node_modules/*\\\" 2>/dev/null | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r15\\necho \\\"=== taxonomy-source ===\\\"; find $ROOT/taxonomy-source -type f | head -100\\necho \\\"=== .headwater ===\\\"; find $ROOT/.headwater -type f | head -100\\necho \\\"=== engine top ===\\\"; find $ROOT/engine -maxdepth 3 -type d\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r15\\necho \\\"=== taxonomy.yml size ===\\\"; wc -l $ROOT/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"=== check crate src ===\\\"; find $ROOT/engine/crates/check/src -type f\\necho \\\"=== check crate tests ===\\\"; find $ROOT/engine/crates/check/tests -type f\\necho \\\"=== check crate fixtures ===\\\"; find $ROOT/engine/crates/check/fixtures -type f | head -50\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r15\\necho \\\"=== grep summary in taxonomy ===\\\"; grep -n -i \\\"summary\\\" $ROOT/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"=== grep summary in docs frontmatter ===\\\"; grep -rn \\\"^summary:\\\" $ROOT/docs | head -20\\necho \\\"=== grep FrontMatter struct ===\\\"; grep -rln \\\"struct FrontMatter\\\\|struct DocumentMetadata\\\\|struct Frontmatter\\\" $ROOT/engine\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "ScheduleWakeup"
argument: "{\"delaySeconds\":300,\"reason\":\"waiting on background Explore agent mapping rule declaration/implementation pattern\",\"noop\":true,\"prompt\":\"Check whether the Explore agent researching rule declaration/implementation pattern has completed; if so, use its findings to add the new rule and report back to the user.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r15/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "ScheduleWakeup"
argument: "{\"stop\":true}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r15\\ngrep -n \\\"^rules:\\\\|^ [a-z_]*:$\\\\|severity:\\\\|remedy:\\\" $ROOT/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -80\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"true\",\"description\":\"no-op\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r15/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r15\\ngrep -rn \\\"OB-FACET-1\\\\|OB-FACET-2\\\" $ROOT/engine/crates/check/src $ROOT/engine/crates/check/tests\\necho \\\"---\\\"\\ncat $ROOT/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r15/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r15/engine/crates/check/src/register.rs"
result: "sha256:52031940b257aae736f4ee275b599207b10a9774d05b6934c201a66749b9f224"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r15\\necho \\\"=== lib.rs RULES ===\\\"; grep -n \\\"RULES\\\\|mod facet_blank\\\\|mod facet_required\\\\|mod facet_value\\\\b\\\" $ROOT/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs\\necho \\\"=== where checks get built (builder/registry) ===\\\"; grep -rn \\\"facet_blank::Blank\\\\|facet_required::Required\\\\|Blank::over\\\\|Required::over\\\" $ROOT/engine/crates --include=*.rs | grep -v \\\"/check/src/facet_blank.rs\\\\|/check/src/facet_required.rs\\\"\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r15/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r15\\ngrep -n \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet.required.missing\\\\|CT-FACET\\\" $ROOT/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r15/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r15/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r15\\ngrep -n \\\"OB-FACET-3\\\" -A6 $ROOT/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r15/engine/crates/check/tests/facet_values.rs"
result: "sha256:985d05f78c0a118cc2508c398b07a1832e97dca207d830a46e002a6576c1c822"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r15\\ngrep -rln \\\"facet_blank\\\\|facet.value.blank\\\\|Blank::over\\\" $ROOT/engine/crates/check/tests\\necho \\\"---fixtures---\\\"\\nfind $ROOT/engine/crates/check/fixtures -iname \\\"*blank*\\\"\\ngrep -rln \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|Blank\\\" $ROOT/engine/crates --include=*.rs | grep -v check/src/facet_blank.rs\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r15/engine/crates/cli/tests/blank_facet.rs"
result: "sha256:2803c8c086f63283529fe721a2702cd8dcfd91e4754bdfa17b1423e2ed105143"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r15/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r15\\ngrep -n \\\"pub trait DocumentCheck\\\" -A 40 $ROOT/engine/crates/check/src/scope.rs | head -60\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '355,400p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r15/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"View facets declaration including summary\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== OB-FACET-3 ===\\\" && sed -n '820,835p' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml && echo \\\"=== CT-FACET-3 ===\\\" && sed -n '1280,1300p' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"View obligation and control declarations for blank facet rule\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r15/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '275,300p' engine/crates/check/tests/facet_values.rs 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---RULES ARRAY---\\\"; grep -n \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|RULES:\\\" -n engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check facet_values.rs summary reference and RULES array registration\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r16"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r16 -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r16/.headwater -maxdepth 4 | sort\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r16/.headwater/packages -type f | sort | head -100\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy package files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r16/docs/taxonomies -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List docs/taxonomies files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-engine\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r16/engine/crates -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List engine crates\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r16/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r16/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r16/engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r16/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r16/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r16/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r16/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r17"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo --- && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Inspect working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find taxonomy-source -maxdepth 4 -type f | head -50\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy-source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r17/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"OB-FACET-3\\\" -A 10 taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -40\",\"description\":\"Find control discharging OB-FACET-3\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r17/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r17/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r17/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r17/.headwater/overlay.yml 2>&1 | head -60\",\"description\":\"Check overlay.yml for package adoption\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|CT-FACET-3\\\\|OB-FACET-3\\\" .headwater/taxonomy.lock 2>/dev/null | head -20\",\"description\":\"Confirm CT-FACET-3 is resolved in this corpus's taxonomy lock\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r17/.headwater/taxonomy.lock"
result: "sha256:1ea570f4a22e19db2ed394a89bbb5f47f2908847514bb3417fd7a88820333650"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r18"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Inspect working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r18/.headwater -maxdepth 3 -type d; echo \\\"---\\\"; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r18/.headwater -maxdepth 3 -type f | head -50\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r18/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard -maxdepth 4 | sort\",\"description\":\"List headwater-standard package contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r18/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r18/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r18/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r18/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r19"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git status 2>&1 | head -20; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls -la\",\"description\":\"Check git status and list repo root\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r19/.headwater -maxdepth 4 -type d; echo \\\"---packages---\\\"; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r19/.headwater/packages -maxdepth 3 2>&1\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r19/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"View taxonomy.yml declaring rules\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -50\",\"description\":\"Search for summary field in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r19/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"rules:\\\\|rule:\\\\|severity\\\\|error:\\\\|advisory\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -80\",\"description\":\"Search taxonomy.yml for rules/severity declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r19/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^checks:\\\\|^ [a-z_.]*:$\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | sed -n '1,120p'\",\"description\":\"Find top-level and nested keys in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine -maxdepth 3 -type d | head -50\",\"description\":\"List engine subdirectories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls engine/crates/conformance/src; echo \\\"---\\\"; wc -l engine/crates/conformance/src/*.rs\",\"description\":\"List conformance crate source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"fn check\\\\|OB-FACET\\\\|required\\\\|facet_role\\\\|Severity\\\\|severity\\\\|struct Finding\\\\|empty\\\" engine/crates/conformance/src/lib.rs | head -100\",\"description\":\"Search conformance lib.rs for rule implementation patterns\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls engine/crates; echo \\\"---search check cli---\\\"; grep -rn \\\"\\\\\\\"check\\\\\\\"\\\" engine/crates/cli/src | head -20\",\"description\":\"List all crates and find check subcommand wiring\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls engine/crates/check/src; echo \\\"---\\\"; wc -l engine/crates/check/src/*.rs 2>/dev/null | tail -30\",\"description\":\"List check crate source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r19/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"---Severity enum---\\\" && grep -n \\\"enum Severity\\\" -A 10 engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs && echo \\\"---forbid near governed_document/decision/specification---\\\" && grep -n \\\"forbid\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml && echo \\\"---fixtures for facet_blank---\\\" && find engine/crates/check -iname \\\"*facet_blank*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*blank*\\\" | head -30 && echo \\\"---tests referencing facet.value.blank---\\\" && grep -rln \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet_blank\\\" engine/crates/check/tests engine/crates/check/fixtures 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Check severity enum, forbid lists, and facet_blank test fixtures\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r19/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md"
result: "sha256:ab8d0eb139f3733cde3ca712a0f637ff8fe82f70fc93a55f87b27273fad00d57"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n -B2 -A8 \\\"facet.value.blank\\\" engine/crates/check/fixtures/check.report | head -60\",\"description\":\"Check expected report fixture for facet.value.blank finding\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r2"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && git status 2>&1 | head -20 && echo \\\"---\\\" && ls -la\",\"description\":\"Check git status and directory listing\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r2/.headwater -maxdepth 4 -type d 2>&1 | head -50\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Map rule declaration and check implementation pattern\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"This is the Headwater repository (a documentation-governance engine). I need to add a new rule to the engine's `headwater check` command: \\\"report a document whose summary is empty.\\\" I need to understand the existing pattern for how a rule is declared (taxonomy/doctrine) and how it's implemented (Rust engine code), so I can add a new one consistently.\\n\\nPlease investigate and report back with specific file paths and line numbers:\\n\\n1. **Rule declaration site**: Find where existing check rules (like the ones named in CLAUDE.md: \\\"no arbitrary line breaks\\\", \\\"American spelling\\\", \\\"avoid stock AI phrasing\\\"/retired_term, \\\"contraction\\\", \\\"British spelling\\\") are declared as data/config — likely under `.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/doctrine/` or `taxonomy-source/`. Show the structure/schema used for one or two example rules, including how severity (error vs advisory) is expressed, and how a rule's id, description, and remedy are expressed. Also check if there's a generated/compiled taxonomy lock file (e.g. `.headwater/taxonomy.lock` or similar) that mirrors these declarations.\\n\\n2. **Rule implementation site**: Find where in `engine/` (Rust crates) these same rules are actually implemented/checked — e.g. search for \\\"retired_term\\\", \\\"hard-wrap\\\" / \\\"hard_wrap\\\", \\\"contraction\\\", or \\\"British spelling\\\" / \\\"british\\\" in engine source. Report the crate name, file path, and how a single rule's check function is structured (signature, how it reports a finding, how severity is attached to the finding).\\n\\n3. **Document \\\"summary\\\" field**: Find whether documents under `docs/` have a \\\"summary\\\" field in front matter (YAML), and how `.headwater/corpus.json` (the generated descriptor) represents it — look at `docs/interfaces/headwater-generate.md` and a few example docs' front matter, plus check the corpus.json schema/generator code in engine/ for a \\\"summary\\\" field. Determine whether \\\"empty\\\" would mean the field is missing, an empty string, or whitespace-only.\\n\\n4. **Where would a brand-new rule like \\\"document summary is empty\\\" fit**: based on the existing taxonomy categories (e.g. is there a category for front-matter/metadata completeness rules distinct from prose-style rules like line-wrap/spelling?), report which taxonomy package file a new rule entry should be added to, and which engine source file (or new file) would hold its check function, following the existing pattern for similarly-scoped rules (e.g. any existing rule that already checks a front-matter field for presence/non-emptiness, if one exists).\\n\\nReport concisely with exact paths and line numbers/snippets. Don't try to implement anything — this is research only. Aim to be thorough since this determines a real code change.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo \\\"---\\\" && find . -maxdepth 3 -iname \\\"*headwater*\\\" 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat CLAUDE.md 2>/dev/null | head -200\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r2/taxonomy-source -type f | head -100\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r2/.headwater -maxdepth 6 -type f | head -200\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r2/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r2/.headwater/packages -type f\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r2/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r2/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r2/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r2/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r2/engine -maxdepth 2 -type d\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r2/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r2/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r2/engine/crates/check/src/retired.rs"
result: "sha256:f5b731fb776bd69f60f0c9e65d04df7010f76cedbb783a817509504d83bcf934"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r2/engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r2/engine/crates/check/src/\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r2/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r2/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,30p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r2/docs/decisions/0067-the-vendored-package-root-moves-under-headwater-and-the-old-root-is-named-in-a-refusal.md 2>/dev/null | head -20\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r2/docs/interfaces/headwater-generate.md"
result: "sha256:037666200bb5888102f75b034aeb6161280740d5fbbee00ec3bfd8b86192e031"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r2/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r2 -iname \\\"corpus.json\\\" -not -path \\\"*/target/*\\\" 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r2/engine/crates/generate/src/descriptor.rs"
result: "sha256:38329ffb69afffe18584547ad5ce84059d1e2432645dd270980bb0dbf649ad7d"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"python3 -c \\\"\\nimport json\\nd=json.load(open('/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r2/.headwater/corpus.json'))\\nprint(type(d))\\nprint(list(d.keys())[:20] if isinstance(d, dict) else d[:2])\\n\\\"\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r2/engine/crates/generate/src/descriptor.rs"
result: "sha256:38329ffb69afffe18584547ad5ce84059d1e2432645dd270980bb0dbf649ad7d"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r2/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md"
result: "sha256:ab8d0eb139f3733cde3ca712a0f637ff8fe82f70fc93a55f87b27273fad00d57"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,60p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r2/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/21-summary-facet-prose.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r2/engine/crates/meta/meta-schema.yml"
result: "sha256:0d1aa16b0e480df957cd26eff02af8402831c9847e4bc429ac3b3f988c4cf0e2"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r2/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '820,835p;1280,1300p' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Check obligation and control entries for facet blank rule\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r2/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r20"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo --- && git status 2>&1 | head -5\",\"description\":\"List working directory and check git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 3 2>/dev/null; echo ---; find taxonomy-source -maxdepth 4 2>/dev/null; echo ---; find docs/taxonomies -maxdepth 2 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Explore taxonomy package directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .claude -maxdepth 3 -iname \\\"*skill*\\\" 2>/dev/null; echo ---; find . -maxdepth 4 -iname \\\"SKILL.md\\\" 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Look for skill definitions in repo\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r20/.agents/skills/headwater-taxonomy/SKILL.md"
result: "sha256:f5b9c95bb000782be9586c1b1e263d934d09fc84e8e444ed89c24325004d7220"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat .headwater/taxonomy.yml 2>/dev/null | head -100\",\"description\":\"Show consumer taxonomy declaration\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"retired_term\\\" --include=*.yml --include=*.md -l . 2>/dev/null | grep -v site/ | grep -v mkdocs/\",\"description\":\"Find files referencing retired_term rule\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"retired_term\\\" -A3 -B3 .headwater/overlay.yml .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Show retired_term rule declaration context\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"mechanism: check:\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | sed -E 's/.*check:/check:/'\",\"description\":\"List all declared check rule mechanisms\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -50\",\"description\":\"Find summary field declaration in taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r20/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"facet.value.blank\\\" -B5 -A20 .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Show facet.value.blank rule declaration\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|FacetValueBlank\\\\|facet_value_blank\\\" engine/ 2>/dev/null | grep -v fixtures\",\"description\":\"Find engine implementation of facet.value.blank rule\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r20/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"posture\\\" docs/spec/12-check-layer.md 2>/dev/null | head -20; echo ---; grep -rn \\\"enum Severity\\\" engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs\",\"description\":\"Check meaning of posture field and Severity enum\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r20/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r21"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo --- && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Inspect working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== docs/taxonomies ===\\\" && find docs/taxonomies -maxdepth 2 2>&1 | head -50\\necho \\\"=== .headwater/packages ===\\\" && find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 3 2>&1 | head -80\\necho \\\"=== engine dirs ===\\\" && find engine -maxdepth 3 -type d 2>&1 | head -80\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy and engine directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r21/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r21/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "engine/crates/check/src/shape.rs"
result: "sha256:9fef54f6760d4bdf2822bdad2e975a4adba4f775446454bb0a5c228da7246067"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== fixtures dir for facet_blank ===\\\" \\nfind engine/crates/check/fixtures -iname \\\"*blank*\\\" 2>&1\\necho \\\"=== grep summary in check fixtures/tests ===\\\"\\ngrep -rln \\\"summary\\\" engine/crates/check/fixtures engine/crates/check/tests 2>/dev/null\\necho \\\"=== grep facet.value.blank across repo (obligations, docs) ===\\\"\\ngrep -rl \\\"facet.value.blank\\\" docs engine/crates/check 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Search for existing summary-related test fixtures and obligation references\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r21/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/05-no-summary.md"
result: "sha256:e93ab39ba0f3d03cf7593bc046d7c0a5aa0fbf102df0e02e2dbf34c263aa346d"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r21/docs/decisions/0058-a-blank-facet-value-is-a-rule-of-its-own-and-it-reads-every-string-facet.md"
result: "sha256:7c1e03d300ff01f37bf38245f8adbfb1b6ef00e6dcc45839abd740efdb29ad21"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r22"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r22 -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level directories in the repo\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r22/CLAUDE.md"
result: "sha256:c92caed27f86014c5f496edda4ca85568e1da2a44e9c15e4aece92ff9b5bbfd2"
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-engine\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r22/.headwater/packages -maxdepth 3 | sort\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy package files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r22/engine/crates -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List engine crates\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r22/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r22/engine/crates/check/src\",\"description\":\"List check crate source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r22/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r22/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r22"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r22/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r22/docs/decisions/0058-a-blank-facet-value-is-a-rule-of-its-own-and-it-reads-every-string-facet.md"
result: "sha256:7c1e03d300ff01f37bf38245f8adbfb1b6ef00e6dcc45839abd740efdb29ad21"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r23"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Inspect working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r23/.headwater -maxdepth 4 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rl \\\"retired_term\\\" --include=\\\"*.yml\\\" --include=\\\"*.yaml\\\" --include=\\\"*.toml\\\" . 2>/dev/null | grep -v node_modules; echo \\\"---\\\"; grep -rl \\\"retired_term\\\" engine/ 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Find where retired_term rule is declared and implemented\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r23/engine/crates/check && ls src/ && echo \\\"---tests---\\\" && ls tests/ 2>/dev/null && echo \\\"---fixtures---\\\" && ls fixtures/ | head -30\",\"description\":\"List check crate source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r23/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r23 && grep -n -A5 \\\"name: summary\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -60\",\"description\":\"Find summary facet declaration in taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -60\",\"description\":\"Search for summary in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r23/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r23/engine/crates/check && grep -rln \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet_blank\\\\|Blank::over\\\" tests/ src/lib.rs 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Find tests referencing facet.value.blank rule\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"facet_blank\\\\|Blank::over\\\\|facet.value.blank\\\" src/lib.rs tests/fixtures.rs\",\"description\":\"Show registration lines\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r23/engine/crates/check/tests/fixtures.rs"
result: "sha256:7b17c7814d7d48dc348043a7ac9daad7c6839f90f2bdbf21996b66ccc6f34749"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rln \\\"summary:\\\" fixtures/ | xargs grep -n \\\"^summary:\\\\s*$\\\\|summary: \\\\\\\"\\\\\\\"\\\\|summary: ~\\\\|summary: null\\\" 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Search fixtures for an empty summary value\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md; echo \\\"---report excerpt---\\\"; grep -n \\\"18-blank-facets\\\\|facet.value.blank\\\" fixtures/check.report | head -20\",\"description\":\"Show blank-facets fixture and matching report lines\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r23 && grep -n \\\"^rules:\\\\|^ rules:\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml .headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---\\\"; sed -n '1,40p' .headwater/overlay.yml\",\"description\":\"Check for a rules declaration block and overlay structure\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r24"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls && echo --- && ls .headwater 2>/dev/null && echo --- && ls .headwater/packages 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List repo root and .headwater directory contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find . -maxdepth 3 -iname \\\"*taxonom*\\\" 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Find taxonomy-related files/dirs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,120p' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -200\",\"description\":\"Peek at taxonomy source structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -50\",\"description\":\"Search for existing summary-related rules in taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r24/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r24/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r24/engine -iname \\\"*.rs\\\" | xargs grep -ln \\\"facet\\\" 2>/dev/null | head -30\",\"description\":\"Find rust files in engine referencing facet\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r24/engine/crates/check -iname \\\"*.rs\\\" | sort\",\"description\":\"List files in check crate\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r24/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r24/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r24/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r24/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r24/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r24/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r24/engine/crates/check/tests/facet_values.rs"
result: "sha256:985d05f78c0a118cc2508c398b07a1832e97dca207d830a46e002a6576c1c822"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"value_type\\\\|type: string\\\\|facet_blank\\\\|facet.value.blank\\\" -r /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r24/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check rule registration in lib.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r24/engine/crates/check/tests/facet_values.rs"
result: "sha256:985d05f78c0a118cc2508c398b07a1832e97dca207d830a46e002a6576c1c822"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r25"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r25/.headwater -maxdepth 4 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r25/engine -maxdepth 4 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List engine directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater/packages -iname '*doctrine*' | head -50\",\"description\":\"Find doctrine files in taxonomy package\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find taxonomy-source -maxdepth 5 | head -100\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy-source directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml; grep -n \\\"severity\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -30\",\"description\":\"Check taxonomy.yml size and severity declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -30\",\"description\":\"Check for existing summary field references\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r25/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r25/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r25/engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r25/engine/crates/check/src\",\"description\":\"List check crate source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r25/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet_blank\\\\|summary\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r25/engine/crates/check/tests 2>/dev/null | head -30\",\"description\":\"Search tests referencing facet.value.blank rule or summary\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r25/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r25/engine/crates/check/tests"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r25/engine/crates/check/tests/fixtures.rs"
result: "sha256:7b17c7814d7d48dc348043a7ac9daad7c6839f90f2bdbf21996b66ccc6f34749"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r25/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard -maxdepth 1 -type f; echo ---; grep -n \\\"summary\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r25/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/*.yml 2>/dev/null | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check built taxonomy package for summary facet\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r26"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Inspect working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== .headwater top level ===\\\" && ls -la .headwater && echo \\\"=== .headwater/packages ===\\\" && find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 3 2>/dev/null && echo \\\"=== docs/taxonomies ===\\\" && ls docs/taxonomies 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Inspect .headwater taxonomy structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== engine top level ===\\\" && find engine -maxdepth 3 -type d\",\"description\":\"Inspect engine crate structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml engine/crates/check/src/*.rs 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---\\\"; find engine/crates/check/src -type f\",\"description\":\"Size up taxonomy and check crate source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r26/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r26/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r26/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r26/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Find rule declaration and implementation pattern\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"This is the Headwater repo (a documentation-governance engine written in Rust, with a taxonomy of \\\"rules\\\" that `headwater check` enforces). I need to add a new rule that reports a document whose \\\"summary\\\" field is empty, and I need to understand the existing pattern for how rules are declared and implemented, so I can follow it exactly.\\n\\nPlease find and report back (with file paths and line numbers):\\n\\n1. Where rules are DECLARED — look for a taxonomy directory (likely `.headwater/packages/` or `docs/taxonomies/`) containing rule definitions (ids, names, severity levels like error/advisory). Show me a full example of one existing rule's declaration (ideally one that already deals with document metadata/front matter, e.g. a \\\"summary\\\" or \\\"front matter\\\" related rule, or any simple metadata-presence rule), including its id, category, severity, and any fields like remedy/mechanical-vs-rewrite.\\n\\n2. Where rules are IMPLEMENTED — look in `engine/` (a Rust workspace, likely `engine/crates/.../src/...` with a crate like `headwater-cli` or `headwater-check` or similar) for the Rust code that implements checks. Find the function/module that implements a simple existing check analogous to \\\"field X is empty\\\" — ideally something checking front matter fields on a document (title, summary, owner, etc.). Show the full function and how it registers with the rule id from the taxonomy, and how severity (error vs advisory) is wired in code.\\n\\n3. What severities exist (error vs advisory) and the rule for when each applies (search CLAUDE.md-stated rule: \\\"A rule is an error when its remedy is mechanical and total... A rule is advisory when the remedy is a rewrite\\\"). Confirm: is \\\"report a document whose summary is empty\\\" mechanical-total (error) or rewrite (advisory)? Note any other advisory rules whose remedy is \\\"a rewrite\\\" that might match this shape (since \\\"write a summary\\\" is a rewrite, not a mechanical fix).\\n\\n4. Is there an existing \\\"document\\\" model/struct in the engine that already has a `summary` field or similar, so I can see what accessing it looks like (e.g. front matter parsing, document struct with Option<String> summary).\\n\\n5. Any existing rule that checks for an EMPTY or MISSING field already (e.g. \\\"missing title\\\", \\\"empty description\\\") — show its full declaration and implementation as the closest template to copy.\\n\\nReport file paths and line numbers precisely, and quote the relevant code/YAML/TOML snippets. Do not edit anything — this is research only.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo \\\"---\\\" && find . -maxdepth 3 -iname \\\"*headwater*\\\" 2>/dev/null | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"**/CLAUDE.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard -maxdepth 3 | head -80\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/engine -maxdepth 4 -type d\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/CLAUDE.md"
result: "sha256:c92caed27f86014c5f496edda4ca85568e1da2a44e9c15e4aece92ff9b5bbfd2"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"mechanical\\\\|advisory\\\\|rewrite\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/CLAUDE.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^id:\\\\|^- id:\\\\|^ id:\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -60\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^rules:\\\\|severity:\\\\|remedy:\\\\|category:\\\\|^ - id:\\\\|facets:\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -100\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"error\\\\|advisory\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -60\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^controls:\\\\|posture: error\\\\|posture:\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"contraction\\\\|British spelling\\\\|hard-wrapped\\\\|retired term\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/.headwater/ /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/engine 2>/dev/null | grep -v \\\"/target/\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27 -iname \\\"*ste-editor*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*ste_editor*\\\" 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/engine/crates/cli/harness/skills/headwater-taxonomy/SKILL.md"
result: "sha256:cc779c2ec7660016e8927ed62e17b91c7a847a09cb70ec0d22c6c2c89a88e545"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"enum Severity\\\\|Severity::\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs | head -30\",\"description\":\"Find Severity enum definition\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"fixability\\\\|Fixability\\\" -i /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"is_empty()\\\\|\\\\.trim().is_empty\\\\|empty\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/engine/crates/check/src/*.rs | grep -vi \\\"test\\\\|//!\\\\|///\\\" | head -40\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/engine/crates/check/src/register.rs"
result: "sha256:52031940b257aae736f4ee275b599207b10a9774d05b6934c201a66749b9f224"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"pub const RULES\\\\|RULES:\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,50p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/engine/crates/check/src/frontmatter.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/engine/crates/check/src/frontmatter.rs"
result: "sha256:b6864d616cbf7133eb84efa03e36c9092b9a2aa50c6e7d0e87408bfd68914f8a"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet.required.missing\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"OB-FACET-3\\\\|OB-FACET-1\\\" -A6 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -40\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"pub struct DocumentView\\\\|impl.*DocumentView\\\\|fn facets\\\\|fn kind\\\\|fn path(\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/engine/crates/check/src/scope.rs | head -30\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/engine/crates/check/src/scope.rs"
result: "sha256:9d8effbb1237866bf2abbe5667f5c1cbb47a73ab14b50e3f54991c3ee810ad0d"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|FACET-3\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/engine/crates/check/tests/*.rs 2>/dev/null | head -20\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/engine/crates/check -iname \\\"*blank*\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md"
result: "sha256:ab8d0eb139f3733cde3ca712a0f637ff8fe82f70fc93a55f87b27273fad00d57"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r27/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r28"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r28/.headwater -maxdepth 4 -type d 2>/dev/null; echo ---; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r28/.headwater/packages -maxdepth 5 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List .headwater taxonomy directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r28 -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level repo directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find taxonomy-source -maxdepth 4 -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy-source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine/crates -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List engine crates\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml; echo ---; grep -n \\\"summary\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -50\",\"description\":\"Check taxonomy.yml size and summary references\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^\\\\s*- id:\\\\|^rules:\\\\|severity\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -80\",\"description\":\"Find rule declarations and severities in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r28/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"empty\\\\|blank\\\\|whitespace\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Search for existing empty/blank-related rules in taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r28/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r28/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"posture:\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | sort | uniq -c | sort -rn | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check distinct posture values used for controls\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"facet.value.blank\\\" --include=*.rs engine/crates | head -30\",\"description\":\"Find implementation of facet.value.blank rule in engine\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r28/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"forbid\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Check for any facet forbid declarations by kind\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"OB-FACET-3\\\\|CT-FACET-3\\\\|summary:\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r28/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Confirm generated taxonomy copy carries the same rule and facet\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r29"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo \\\"---\\\" && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"List working directory contents and check git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater -maxdepth 3 -type d; echo \\\"---taxonomy-source---\\\"; find taxonomy-source -maxdepth 4 -type f | head -50; echo \\\"---engine---\\\"; find engine -maxdepth 3 -type d\",\"description\":\"Explore headwater taxonomy and engine directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,400p' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"View taxonomy.yml contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine/crates/check/src -type f | xargs wc -l | tail -1; echo \\\"---\\\"; find engine/crates/check/src -type f\",\"description\":\"List files in check crate source\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== facet_blank.rs ===\\\"; cat engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs\",\"description\":\"Read facet_blank.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"facet_blank\\\\|Blank\\\\|facet\\\\.value\\\\.blank\\\" engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs\",\"description\":\"Find how facet_blank's Blank check is registered in lib.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '200,260p' engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs\",\"description\":\"View rule registry context around line 236\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"--- tests ---\\\"; cat engine/crates/check/tests/facet_blank.rs 2>/dev/null | head -100; echo \\\"--- fixtures dir ---\\\"; find engine/crates/check/fixtures -iname \\\"*blank*\\\"\",\"description\":\"Check facet_blank tests and fixtures\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r29/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md"
result: "sha256:ab8d0eb139f3733cde3ca712a0f637ff8fe82f70fc93a55f87b27273fad00d57"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r3"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r3\",\"description\":\"List repository root contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r3/.headwater -maxdepth 4 -type d\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Locate rule declaration and implementation pattern\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"I'm working in the repository at /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r3 (a system called \\\"Headwater\\\"). This repo has a `headwater check` engine that runs rules against documents under `docs/`. Rules are declared in a taxonomy somewhere under `.headwater/packages/` or `taxonomy-source/`, and implemented in Rust code under `engine/`.\\n\\nI need to add a new rule: \\\"reports a document whose summary is empty\\\" (i.e., every governed document has a front-matter `summary` field, and the rule should fire when that field is present but empty/blank). To do this correctly I need to understand the FULL existing pattern for how a similar, already-existing rule is declared and implemented, so I can follow the same conventions exactly.\\n\\nPlease investigate and report back (don't edit anything, just research):\\n\\n1. Find an existing rule that is structurally similar — ideally something that checks a front-matter field for presence/emptiness (e.g., a rule about a missing title, missing owner, empty description, or similar). Give me its exact rule identifier/name.\\n\\n2. For that example rule, show me:\\n - WHERE it is declared: the exact file path(s) under `.headwater/packages/` or `taxonomy-source/` (or wherever taxonomy lives), and the exact YAML/TOML/whatever snippet that declares it (identifier, severity: error/advisory, description, which taxonomy/package it belongs to).\\n - WHERE it is implemented: the exact Rust file path(s) under `engine/`, the function/struct name, and a short excerpt of the implementing code (enough to see the pattern: how it reads the rule id, how it matches/reports a finding, how severity is wired from declaration to implementation).\\n - Whether severity is defined in the taxonomy declaration, in the Rust implementation, or both (and how they're kept in sync — is there a lookup/mapping, or a code-generation step, or a lint that checks consistency?).\\n\\n3. Find the general taxonomy schema/spec that documents what fields a rule declaration needs (likely under `docs/spec/` or `docs/taxonomies/`) and summarize the required fields and valid severity values (I saw mention that severity can be \\\"error\\\" when the remedy is mechanical and total, vs \\\"advisory\\\" when it requires a rewrite — confirm this and find exact field names in the schema).\\n\\n4. Find how a rule is wired into `headwater check`'s execution: is there a central registry file in the engine that lists all rule implementations and binds them by id to the taxonomy declaration? Show that file and how a new rule would be registered/added there.\\n\\n5. Check whether there's a document front-matter field that already represents \\\"summary\\\" (e.g. is it called `summary`, `description`, `abstract`?) — look at a few real docs under `docs/` for the actual front matter field name used, since my new rule needs to check the real field name, not an assumed one.\\n\\n6. Note any existing test fixtures for rules (e.g. under `engine/**/tests/` or `engine/**/fixtures/`) so I know where to add a fixture/test for the new rule.\\n\\nReport back with concrete file paths, line numbers/ranges, and short code/config excerpts for each of the above. Keep the report organized by these 6 numbered items. This is read-only research — do not edit any files.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "ScheduleWakeup"
argument: "{\"delaySeconds\":300,\"reason\":\"waiting on Explore agent researching rule declaration/implementation pattern\",\"noop\":true}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== top level ===\\\" && ls -la && echo \\\"=== .headwater ===\\\" && find .headwater -maxdepth 4 -type d 2>/dev/null && echo \\\"=== taxonomy-source ===\\\" && find taxonomy-source -maxdepth 4 2>/dev/null && echo \\\"=== engine ===\\\" && find engine -maxdepth 3 -type d 2>/dev/null && echo \\\"=== docs ===\\\" && find docs -maxdepth 3 -type d 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"true\",\"description\":\"no-op, waiting for agent notification\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml; grep -n \\\"summary\\\\|title\\\\|owner\\\\|description\\\\|blank\\\\|empty\\\\|missing\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -100\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r3/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r3/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard\\ngrep -n \\\"^ OB-FACET\\\" taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"---\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"posture:\\\" taxonomy.yml | sed -n '1,50p' | awk -F'posture: ' '{print $2}' | sort -u\\necho \\\"--- OB-FACET-3 block ---\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"OB-FACET-3\\\" taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r3/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r3/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r3/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r3/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard\\ngrep -n \\\"CT-FACET-1:\\\" -A 10 taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"---CT-FACET-2---\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"CT-FACET-2:\\\" -A 10 taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r3/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r3/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r3/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r3\\necho \\\"=== lib.rs registry in check crate ===\\\" \\nfind engine/crates/check/src -maxdepth 1 -name \\\"*.rs\\\" | sort\\necho \\\"=== finding.rs Severity enum ===\\\"\\nsed -n '1,80p' engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r3/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r3\\necho \\\"=== register.rs head ===\\\" \\nsed -n '1,120p' engine/crates/check/src/register.rs\\necho \\\"=== spec dir listing ===\\\"\\nls docs/spec\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r3\\ngrep -n \\\"severity\\\\|posture\\\\|error\\\\|advisory\\\\|mechanical\\\\|total\\\" docs/spec/12-check-layer.md | head -80\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r3/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r3\\ngrep -n \\\"^#\\\\|posture\\\\|severity\\\\|mechanism\\\\|discharges\\\\|trigger\\\\|acts:\\\\|class:\\\\|prevents\\\\|promotion\\\" docs/spec/04-assurance-model.md | sed -n '1,120p'\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r3\\necho \\\"=== real doc frontmatter sample ===\\\" \\nfor f in $(find docs/decisions -name \\\"*.md\\\" | head -2); do echo \\\"--- $f ---\\\"; sed -n '1,15p' \\\"$f\\\"; done\\necho \\\"=== fixture for blank facets ===\\\" \\nsed -n '1,40p' engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md\\necho \\\"=== blank_facet test ===\\\"\\nsed -n '1,80p' engine/crates/cli/tests/blank_facet.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r3\\necho \\\"=== engine/crates/check/tests ===\\\"\\nls engine/crates/check/tests\\necho \\\"=== engine/crates/check/fixtures ===\\\"\\nfind engine/crates/check/fixtures -maxdepth 3 | sort\\necho \\\"=== engine/crates/cli/tests ===\\\"\\nls engine/crates/cli/tests\\necho \\\"=== engine/crates/cli/fixtures (if related) ===\\\"\\nfind engine/crates/cli/fixtures -maxdepth 2 | head -40\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r3\\ncat taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/package.yml\\necho \\\"=== fixtures.rs relevant bit ===\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"check.taxonomy.yml\\\\|check.report\\\\|spec/18\\\\|blank\\\" engine/crates/check/tests/fixtures.rs | head -20\\necho \\\"=== check.taxonomy.yml head ===\\\"\\nsed -n '1,20p' engine/crates/check/fixtures/check.taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r3\\nsed -n '1,60p' engine/crates/cli/tests/standard_controls.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '370,440p' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Inspect summary facet declaration in taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '815,835p;1275,1300p' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Inspect OB-FACET-3 and CT-FACET-3 blocks\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r3/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"posture\\\" docs/spec/12-check-layer.md | head -30\",\"description\":\"Find posture semantics in check-layer spec\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r3/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r30"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo --- && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Inspect working directory and check git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater -maxdepth 4 -type d | sort; echo ---; find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 6 | sort | head -100\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml; echo ---; grep -n \\\"rule\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -80\",\"description\":\"Inspect taxonomy.yml for rule declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^ [a-z_]*:$\\\\|^checks:\\\\|^rules:\\\\|^obligations:\\\\|^controls:\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -60\",\"description\":\"Find top-level section headers in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r30/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r30/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"OB-FACET-3\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Find references to OB-FACET-3 obligation\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r30/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet_value_blank\\\\|FacetValueBlank\\\" engine/ --include=*.rs -l 2>/dev/null; echo ---; grep -rln \\\"facet.value.blank\\\" engine/ 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Search engine source for facet.value.blank implementation\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r30/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---BLANK_FACET_TEST---\\\"; sed -n '1,80p' engine/crates/cli/tests/blank_facet.rs 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Inspect fixture and test for blank facet rule covering summary\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r31"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo --- && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Inspect working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater/packages -iname \\\"*.yml\\\" -o -iname \\\"*.yaml\\\" 2>/dev/null | head -50; echo ---; find .headwater -maxdepth 3 -type d; echo ---; find docs/taxonomies -maxdepth 2 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Explore taxonomy package files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find . -iname \\\"*taxonomy*\\\" -path \\\"*skills*\\\" 2>/dev/null; echo ---; find .claude/skills -maxdepth 2 2>/dev/null; echo ---; find . -path \\\"*/skills/*SKILL*\\\" 2>/dev/null | head -30\",\"description\":\"Locate skill definition files for headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r31/.agents/skills/headwater-taxonomy/SKILL.md"
result: "sha256:f5b9c95bb000782be9586c1b1e263d934d09fc84e8e444ed89c24325004d7220"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat .headwater/taxonomy.yml 2>/dev/null | head -100\",\"description\":\"View repo's taxonomy declaration file\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r31/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^rules:\\\\| rules:\\\\|rule:\\\" -r .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/*.yml | head -40\",\"description\":\"Search for rule declarations in package taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine -maxdepth 3 -type d | sort; echo ---; grep -rln \\\"pin.current\\\\|corpus.classified\\\\|identifier.unusable\\\" engine --include=*.rs | head -20\",\"description\":\"List engine crate structure and find rule id references in Rust source\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls engine/crates/check/src/; echo ---; wc -l engine/crates/check/src/*.rs | tail -1\",\"description\":\"List files in the check crate\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r31/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "engine/crates/check/fixtures"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r31/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md"
result: "sha256:ab8d0eb139f3733cde3ca712a0f637ff8fe82f70fc93a55f87b27273fad00d57"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary:\\\" -A6 taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Show the summary facet declaration in the authoritative taxonomy source\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r32"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater -maxdepth 3 -type d; echo \\\"---\\\"; find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 2 2>&1 | head -50\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r32/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r32/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r32/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r32/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r32/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r32/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"OB-FACET-3:\\\" -A8 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r32/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml; echo ---; grep -n \\\"CT-FACET-3:\\\" -A10 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r32/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml; echo ---; grep -n \\\"summary:\\\" -A6 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r32/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -10\",\"description\":\"Show exact OB-FACET-3, CT-FACET-3, and summary facet declarations with line numbers\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r33"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r33/ 2>&1 | head -50\",\"description\":\"List top-level contents of working directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"--git--\\\"; git status 2>&1 | head -5; echo \\\"--packages--\\\"; find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 3 2>&1 | head -50; echo \\\"--taxonomy-source--\\\"; find taxonomy-source -maxdepth 3 2>&1 | head -50\",\"description\":\"Check git status and list taxonomy package directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== taxonomy.yml ===\\\"; cat taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -100\",\"description\":\"Show the start of the taxonomy.yml rule declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r33/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r33"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r33/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r33"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r33/docs/decisions/0058-a-blank-facet-value-is-a-rule-of-its-own-and-it-reads-every-string-facet.md"
result: "sha256:7c1e03d300ff01f37bf38245f8adbfb1b6ef00e6dcc45839abd740efdb29ad21"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r33/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r33/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/conformance.yml"
result: "sha256:47ef5283be6f8872d13ebf1cd12fb7bd644efd015d23c8e9071e248f8d6f5904"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r33"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r33/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"facet_blank\\\\|Blank\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r33/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs\",\"description\":\"Confirm the facet_blank check is registered in the check crate\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r34"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r34 -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level directories of the repo\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r34/.headwater/packages -maxdepth 3 | sort\",\"description\":\"List headwater taxonomy packages\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r34/taxonomy-source -maxdepth 4 | sort\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy-source directory tree\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r34/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r34/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r34/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r34"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r34/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r35"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r35\",\"description\":\"List repo root contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".headwater/packages/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r35/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r35/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r35/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r35/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r35/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r35/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r35/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r36"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo --- && find . -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level repo structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .agents/skills .claude -maxdepth 3 -iname \\\"*taxonomy*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*authoring*\\\" 2>/dev/null | sort\",\"description\":\"Look for taxonomy/authoring skill files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .agents/skills/headwater-taxonomy -maxdepth 2 | sort; echo ---; find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 3 | sort\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy skill files and taxonomy packages\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r36/.agents/skills/headwater-taxonomy/SKILL.md"
result: "sha256:f5b9c95bb000782be9586c1b1e263d934d09fc84e8e444ed89c24325004d7220"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml .headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null; echo ---; grep -n \\\"summary\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml .headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null; echo ---RULES---; grep -n \\\"^rules:\\\\| - id:\\\\|rule:\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -80\",\"description\":\"Search taxonomy files for summary field and rules section\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"severity\\\\|advisory\\\\|^ - \\\\|^rules\\\\|check:\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -100\",\"description\":\"Search for severity/rules declarations in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r36/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r36/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"posture: error\\\\|posture:\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml .headwater/overlay.yml | sort | uniq -c -f2 | head -40\",\"description\":\"Find posture values used across taxonomy files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r36/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"OB-FACET\\\\|CT-FACET\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Find all FACET obligation/control references\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r36/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find taxonomy-source -maxdepth 4 | sort; echo ---DIFF---; diff -q taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml 2>/dev/null && echo SAME || echo DIFFERS\",\"description\":\"Inspect taxonomy-source directory and compare with vendored copy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r36/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd engine && grep -rn \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet\\\\.value\\\\.blank\\\\|value_blank\\\\|FacetValueBlank\\\" --include=\\\"*.rs\\\" . | head -50\",\"description\":\"Search engine Rust source for facet.value.blank rule implementation\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r36/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r36/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r36 && grep -n \\\"forbid\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml .headwater/overlay.yml | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check for any forbid clauses that might exclude summary\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r37"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Find rule declaration and implementation pattern\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"I'm working in a Headwater repo (a documentation/taxonomy-governed engine). I need to add a new rule to the engine's check system: \\\"reports a document whose summary is empty.\\\" I need to understand the existing pattern for how rules are declared and implemented, so I can add a new one consistently.\\n\\nPlease investigate and report back:\\n\\n1. Where are rules declared in the taxonomy? Look under `.headwater/packages/` and `docs/taxonomies/` for a taxonomy package file format (YAML/TOML/etc) that lists rule identifiers, severities (error vs advisory), descriptions, remedies. Show me 1-2 full example rule declarations, especially ones with similar shape (e.g. checking a document's front matter / metadata field for emptiness or presence), and tell me the exact file path(s).\\n\\n2. Where is the engine that implements checks? Look under `engine/` (likely a Rust crate given Cargo.toml mentions in CLAUDE.md, e.g. `headwater-cli`). Find the source file(s) where individual rule checks are implemented in Rust — show me the implementation of 1-2 existing rules of similar shape (something that inspects document front matter / metadata, especially anything checking for an empty/missing field like a title or summary), including the function signature, how it reads the field, and how it reports a finding with a rule identifier and severity.\\n\\n3. Does a `summary` field already exist in the document front matter schema? Find where document front matter fields are defined/validated (look for 'summary', 'title', 'description' as front matter keys) to see if 'summary' is already a recognized field, and where.\\n\\n4. What are the two severity levels called in code/taxonomy (e.g. 'error' vs 'advisory') and what exact string/enum values are used for each in both the taxonomy declaration and the Rust implementation?\\n\\n5. Is there a naming convention for rule identifiers (e.g. dotted like `language.retired_term.used` mentioned in CLAUDE.md, or `metadata.title.missing`)? Show a few existing identifiers so I can match the convention for something like a 'summary empty' rule.\\n\\nReport exact file paths and line numbers/ranges for everything so I can go edit directly. Be thorough — this determines where I write new code.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r37/docs/decisions/0014-discovery-surface.md"
result: "sha256:6eef63703f179a2d9b738bee73916ef271b405fe7cd290bf2a47cf8d2a59b830"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"WD listing:\\\"; ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r37; echo \\\"---headwater packages---\\\"; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r37 -iname \\\"*headwater*\\\" -maxdepth 3 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r37/.headwater/corpus.json"
result: "sha256:98145f6c9809d18ccfb6a5eeb55313c5c1c436eb4ecc848f3bfb02943be81874"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"WD=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r37\\necho \\\"=== .headwater/packages/headwater-standard ===\\\"; find \\\"$WD/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard\\\" -maxdepth 3\\necho \\\"=== taxonomy-source/headwater-standard ===\\\"; find \\\"$WD/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard\\\" -maxdepth 3\\necho \\\"=== engine ===\\\"; find \\\"$WD/engine\\\" -maxdepth 3\\necho \\\"=== docs/taxonomies ===\\\"; find \\\"$WD/docs\\\" -iname \\\"*taxonom*\\\" -maxdepth 2\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r37/docs/interfaces/headwater-generate.md"
result: "sha256:037666200bb5888102f75b034aeb6161280740d5fbbee00ec3bfd8b86192e031"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"WD=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r37\\necho \\\"=== docs/taxonomies dir ===\\\"; find \\\"$WD/docs/taxonomies\\\" -maxdepth 3\\necho \\\"=== taxonomy.yml line count ===\\\"; wc -l \\\"$WD/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\\"\\necho \\\"=== check crate src ===\\\"; find \\\"$WD/engine/crates/check/src\\\" -maxdepth 2\\necho \\\"=== meta crate src ===\\\"; find \\\"$WD/engine/crates/meta/src\\\" -maxdepth 2\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r37"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"true\",\"description\":\"no-op, waiting for background agent\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r37/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "TaskCreate"
argument: "{\"subject\":\"Locate taxonomy rule declaration pattern and engine check implementation\",\"description\":\"Find where rules are declared in .headwater/packages/ taxonomy and where checks are implemented in engine/ Rust crates, plus severity levels and ID conventions (delegated to Explore agent).\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "TaskCreate"
argument: "{\"subject\":\"Declare the empty-summary rule in the taxonomy package\",\"description\":\"Add a new rule declaration (identifier, severity, description/remedy) to the taxonomy package file for a document whose summary front-matter field is empty.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r37/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "TaskCreate"
argument: "{\"subject\":\"Implement the empty-summary check in the engine\",\"description\":\"Add the Rust implementation of the rule in the appropriate check crate, following the existing pattern for front-matter field checks, reporting a finding with the rule id and severity.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r37/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "TaskCreate"
argument: "{\"subject\":\"Verify with headwater check / cargo build\",\"description\":\"Build the engine per DEVELOPING.md (cargo build --profile dev-release, never --release) and run headwater check to confirm the new rule fires correctly, including on a fixture.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r37/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "TaskUpdate"
argument: "{\"taskId\":\"1\",\"status\":\"in_progress\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "ScheduleWakeup"
argument: "{\"delaySeconds\":180,\"reason\":\"fallback check on Explore agent researching rule declaration/implementation pattern\",\"prompt\":\"Check whether the Explore agent (task: Find rule declaration and implementation pattern) has completed. If so, use its findings to proceed with adding the empty-summary rule. If not, continue waiting.\",\"noop\":true}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r37/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r37/docs/decisions/0058-a-blank-facet-value-is-a-rule-of-its-own-and-it-reads-every-string-facet.md"
result: "sha256:7c1e03d300ff01f37bf38245f8adbfb1b6ef00e6dcc45839abd740efdb29ad21"
- tool: "CronList"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "CronDelete"
argument: "{\"id\":\"28edff2c\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r37/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r37/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r37/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r37/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r37/engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r37/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"Severity::Warn\\\" engine/crates/check/src | head -20\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r37\\ngrep -n \\\"blocking\\\\|posture\\\\|advisory\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -30\\necho \\\"---\\\"\\nsed -n '550,600p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r37\\nsed -n '900,1000p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r37\\ngrep -n \\\"OB-FACET-3\\\\|CT-FACET-3\\\" -A8 .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r37\\ngrep -n \\\"posture: blocking\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -5\\necho \\\"---lib.rs RULES array context---\\\"\\nsed -n '220,260p' engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs\\necho \\\"---register.rs---\\\"\\nsed -n '1,60p' engine/crates/check/src/register.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r37/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r37/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r37/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r37/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r37/engine/target/dev-release/ 2>&1 | head -20; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r37/engine -maxdepth 1 -name target\",\"description\":\"Check if engine is already built\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat > /tmp/probe.md << 'EOF'\\n---\\nid: HW-DR-9999\\ntitle: Probe document for empty summary\\nstatus: current\\nstatus_since: 2026-10-05\\nlast_verified: 2026-10-05\\nsummary: \\\"\\\"\\nprovenance:\\n warrant: accepted\\n agency: mixed\\n drafted_by: claude-sonnet-5\\n activity: draft\\n accepted_by: probe\\n evidence_basis: evidenced\\n---\\n\\n# Probe document for empty summary\\nEOF\\nmkdir -p docs/decisions_probe_tmp 2>/dev/null\\ncp /tmp/probe.md docs/decisions/9999-probe-empty-summary.md\\n./engine/target/dev-release/headwater check 2>&1 | grep -i \\\"9999\\\\|facet.value.blank\\\" | head -20\\nrm -f docs/decisions/9999-probe-empty-summary.md\\nrmdir docs/decisions_probe_tmp 2>/dev/null\\ntrue\",\"description\":\"Create a probe document with empty summary and run headwater check against it\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r37/docs/decisions/ | grep -i 9999; ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r37/docs/ | grep -i probe_tmp; echo \\\"clean check done\\\"\",\"description\":\"Confirm probe file and temp directory were cleaned up\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "TaskUpdate"
argument: "{\"taskId\":\"1\",\"status\":\"completed\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "TaskUpdate"
argument: "{\"taskId\":\"2\",\"status\":\"deleted\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "TaskUpdate"
argument: "{\"taskId\":\"3\",\"status\":\"deleted\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "TaskUpdate"
argument: "{\"taskId\":\"4\",\"status\":\"completed\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r38"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo --- && find . -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level repo structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== .headwater/packages ===\\\" && find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 3 | sort\\necho \\\"=== docs/taxonomies ===\\\" && find docs/taxonomies -maxdepth 2 | sort\\necho \\\"=== taxonomy-source ===\\\" && find taxonomy-source -maxdepth 4 | sort\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy package and source directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine/crates -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List engine crates\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -50\",\"description\":\"Search taxonomy.yml for existing summary-related rules\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml && sed -n '1,120p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Peek at the start of taxonomy.yml for structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '350,460p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"View facets section including summary facet definition\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^rules:\\\\|^controls:\\\\|severity:\\\\|^ [a-z_.]*:$\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -100\",\"description\":\"Search for rule/control declarations and severity field\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r38/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r38/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"facet.required.missing\\\\|facet.value.not_permitted\\\" engine/crates --include=*.rs -l\",\"description\":\"Find where these check rule ids are implemented in Rust source\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine/crates/check/src -maxdepth 2 -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List check crate source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r38/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|OB-FACET\\\\|CT-FACET\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Check whether facet.value.blank has an obligation/control entry in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r38/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r38/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"enum Severity\\\" -A 10 engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs\",\"description\":\"Look at the Severity enum definition\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rln \\\"facet_blank\\\\|facet.value.blank\\\\|summary\\\" engine/crates/check/fixtures engine/crates/check/tests 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Look for fixtures/tests covering summary via facet_blank\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r38/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/05-no-summary.md"
result: "sha256:e93ab39ba0f3d03cf7593bc046d7c0a5aa0fbf102df0e02e2dbf34c263aa346d"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"05-no-summary\\\\|facet.value.blank\\\" engine/crates/check/tests/fixtures.rs | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check how the no-summary fixture is exercised in tests\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r38/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md"
result: "sha256:ab8d0eb139f3733cde3ca712a0f637ff8fe82f70fc93a55f87b27273fad00d57"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"18-blank-facets\\\\|facet_blank\\\\|facet.value.blank\\\" engine/crates/check/tests/fixtures.rs\",\"description\":\"Check the test assertions tied to the blank-facets fixture\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && ls -la && echo \\\"---\\\" && find . -maxdepth 2 -name \\\".git\\\" 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Inspect working directory for git repo presence\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"rule that reports a document whose summary is empty — where rules are declared and implemented, severity conventions\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\",\"args\":\"adding a new check rule for a document with an empty summary — declaration location and severity\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Locate rule declaration and implementation pattern\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"This is the Headwater repository (a documentation-governance engine with a Rust CLI called `headwater`). I need to add a new check rule: \\\"a document whose summary field is empty gets reported.\\\" To do this correctly I need to understand the existing pattern used by similar rules. Please answer with specifics (file paths and line numbers):\\n\\n1. Where are check rules DECLARED (the taxonomy)? Look under `.headwater/packages/`, `docs/taxonomies/`, `taxonomy-source/`, and `.headwater/overlay.yml` / `.headwater/taxonomy.lock`. Find an example of an existing rule declaration (e.g. a rule about front matter fields, like a required `summary` field, or similar metadata-presence rule) — show its full YAML/structure, including how severity (error vs advisory) is declared, and how a rule ID/name is formed (e.g. `language.retired_term.used` was mentioned in CLAUDE.md as an example rule id).\\n\\n2. Where are check rules IMPLEMENTED in the Rust engine? Look under `engine/` (likely a crate like `headwater-cli` or `headwater-check` or similar). Find the module/file that implements a rule checking front-matter metadata (e.g. presence/emptiness of a field like `summary`, `title`, or similar), and show how a rule is registered/wired to its declared taxonomy ID. Show the function signature and how severity is returned (e.g. an enum Error/Advisory).\\n\\n3. Find any existing rule that already deals with \\\"empty\\\" or \\\"missing\\\" field values, to use as a template.\\n\\n4. Confirm: does every document's front matter have a `summary` field? Find the front-matter schema definition (likely a JSON schema or Rust struct) that defines `summary`.\\n\\nReport back: exact file paths + line ranges for (a) where to declare the new rule, (b) where to implement it, (c) a concrete similar rule's full definition to use as a template, (d) the severity taxonomy (what values exist, e.g. error/advisory/pending, and the rule given in CLAUDE.md for classifying mechanical vs rewrite remedies).\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/docs/spec/09-decisions.md"
result: "sha256:0c0c538720be0d70206ed1adb3d695531e5b1c9c975b992ad56c4c0df1896e0a"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39\",\"description\":\"List workspace root contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"--- .headwater ---\\\"; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/.headwater -maxdepth 4 -type f | head -100\\necho \\\"--- taxonomy-source ---\\\"; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/taxonomy-source -type f | head -100\\necho \\\"--- docs/taxonomies ---\\\"; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/docs -maxdepth 3 -type d | head -50\",\"description\":\"List headwater config, taxonomy source, and docs taxonomy directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/engine -maxdepth 3 -type d; echo \\\"---files in engine---\\\"; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/engine -maxdepth 5 -iname \\\"Cargo.toml\\\"\",\"description\":\"Explore engine crate directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/CLAUDE.md"
result: "sha256:c92caed27f86014c5f496edda4ca85568e1da2a44e9c15e4aece92ff9b5bbfd2"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/.headwater/corpus.json 2>/dev/null | head -c 3000\",\"description\":\"Peek at the corpus descriptor\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/docs/taxonomies/ 2>/dev/null && echo \\\"---engine---\\\" && find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/engine -maxdepth 3 -type d 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy directory and engine crate structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"CT-FACET-3\\\\|facet.required.missing\\\\|facet.value.not_permitted\\\\|facet\\\\.\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Find facet-related control declarations in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/engine/crates/check/src/ && echo \\\"---\\\" && ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/docs/taxonomies/standards-spec/ 2>/dev/null && find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/docs/taxonomies -iname \\\"*rule*\\\" 2>/dev/null | head -30\",\"description\":\"List check crate source files and taxonomy rule files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rln \\\"facet.required.missing\\\\|facet.value.not_permitted\\\\|facet\\\\b\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/engine/crates/check/src/\",\"description\":\"Find rust files implementing facet checks\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/.headwater/ 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"enum Severity\\\" -A 10 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs\",\"description\":\"Show Severity enum definition\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"struct FrontMatter\\\\|pub fn entry\\\\|pub struct Facets\\\\|fn facets(\\\" -r /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/engine/crates/doc/src /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/engine/crates/check/src/scope.rs 2>/dev/null | head -30\",\"description\":\"Find FrontMatter struct and facets() accessor definitions\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/.headwater/taxonomy.yml 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Peek at taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/taxonomy-source -maxdepth 4 -type f | head -50\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy-source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/.headwater/*.yml /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/.headwater/*.lock 2>/dev/null\\necho \\\"---packages---\\\"\\nfind /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/.headwater/packages -maxdepth 3 2>/dev/null\\necho \\\"---overlay head---\\\"\\nsed -n '1,40p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/.headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Check for overlay.yml, taxonomy.lock, and packages directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/taxonomy-source"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/.headwater/packages"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r39/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "TaskStop"
argument: "{\"task_id\":\"a561211c57bbeaa25\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r4"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo --- && find . -maxdepth 2 -name \\\".git\\\" 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List top-level repo contents and check for .git\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater/packages docs/taxonomies -maxdepth 3 2>/dev/null | head -80\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy package files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,400p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -400\",\"description\":\"View taxonomy.yml rule declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"summary\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/*.yml engine/ docs/spec/ 2>/dev/null | grep -vi \\\"fixtures\\\" | head -80\",\"description\":\"Search for existing references to summary facet in taxonomy/spec/engine\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls engine/crates/ && echo --- && grep -rln \\\"facet.required\\\\|required.missing\\\\|facet_required\\\" engine/crates --include=*.rs | head -30\",\"description\":\"List engine crates and search for facet required rule\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r4/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rln \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet\\\\\\\\.value\\\\\\\\.blank\\\" --include=*.yml --include=*.md --include=*.rs . 2>/dev/null | grep -v \\\"/target/\\\"\",\"description\":\"Find all references to the facet.value.blank rule across docs, yaml and rust\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"facet.value.blank\\\" -A3 -B10 .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Show context of facet.value.blank rule in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"OB-FACET-3\\\\|CT-FACET-3\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Find line numbers for OB-FACET-3 and CT-FACET-3 declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r4/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,200p' engine/crates/cli/tests/blank_facet.rs | grep -n \\\"summary\\\\|title\\\\|fn test\\\\|#\\\\[test\\\\]\\\" \",\"description\":\"Check blank_facet.rs test file for summary coverage\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"\\\\\\\"summary\\\\\\\"\\\\|'summary'\\\" engine/crates/check/src/*.rs engine/crates/check/fixtures/check.taxonomy.yml 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Search for summary-specific handling inside check crate\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,60p' engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md; echo ---; grep -n \\\"summary\\\\|type: string\\\" engine/crates/check/fixtures/check.taxonomy.yml | head -20\",\"description\":\"Inspect blank-facets fixture and taxonomy fixture for summary coverage\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r40"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Find rule declaration and implementation pattern\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"I need to add a new check rule to the Headwater engine: \\\"a document whose summary is empty should be reported.\\\" I need to understand the existing pattern for how rules are declared and implemented, so I can add a new one consistently.\\n\\nPlease investigate and report back:\\n\\n1. Where is the taxonomy of rules declared? Look for `.headwater/packages/` and `docs/taxonomies/` — find the file(s) that declare existing rules (e.g. things like hard-wrapped markdown, British spelling, retired terms, line-length/sentence-length, contractions, etc. mentioned in the root CLAUDE.md). Show the structure/schema used to declare a rule: what fields exist (id, severity, category, description, remedy type, etc.) and give 2-3 full example rule declarations verbatim (especially one error-severity and one advisory-severity rule), including exact file paths and line numbers.\\n\\n2. Where is severity determined/distinguished in the schema? Is severity itself declared per-rule in the taxonomy, or is it derived from some other field like \\\"remedy: mechanical\\\" vs \\\"remedy: rewrite\\\"? Quote the relevant schema/docs.\\n\\n3. Where is a rule like this actually implemented in code — find the engine crate(s) under `engine/` (Rust, per CLAUDE.md mentioning `headwater-cli`). Find how an existing simple rule is implemented (e.g. a rule that checks a property of a document's front matter, ideally something checking for presence/emptiness of a field, or similar structural check on a document). Give exact file paths, line numbers, and the surrounding code/module structure (e.g. is there a `rules/` directory with one file per rule, a trait each rule implements, a registry, etc.).\\n\\n4. Look for what \\\"summary\\\" means for a document in this corpus — is there a front-matter field literally called `summary`? Check `docs/spec/`, `docs/decisions/`, or any schema/front-matter definition docs, and any existing document examples, to confirm the field name and whether existing docs have it.\\n\\n5. Check `.headwater/corpus.json` (the generated descriptor) to see if it already surfaces per-document summary data, and whether this generated file structure is affected at all by adding this new rule (probably not, but confirm).\\n\\n6. Find docs/acceptance-criteria/ or docs/requirements/ for any similar existing rule about empty/missing fields, to see the pattern for how such a rule's acceptance criteria doc is written (field name, severity, test fixture references).\\n\\nReport file paths with line numbers for everything so I can go edit precisely. Do not make any edits — this is read-only investigation. Keep your final report focused and well-organized by my 6 numbered questions above, but be thorough and quote exact text/code where relevant.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo \\\"---\\\" && find . -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "ScheduleWakeup"
argument: "{\"delaySeconds\":300,\"noop\":true,\"reason\":\"waiting on background Explore agent investigating rule declaration/implementation pattern\",\"prompt\":\"Check on the Explore agent (ac9b9dbfc33316138) investigating where rules are declared/implemented in the Headwater engine for the empty-summary rule task. If it has completed, synthesize its findings and proceed to implement the rule (declare in taxonomy, implement in engine, determine severity per CLAUDE.md's error/advisory distinction, add acceptance criteria doc if that's the pattern). If still running, wait longer.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat CLAUDE.md\",\"description\":\"Read root CLAUDE.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la .headwater/packages/ && echo --- && find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 3 | sort\",\"description\":\"List headwater packages directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la docs/taxonomies/ && echo --- && find docs/taxonomies -maxdepth 3 | sort\",\"description\":\"List docs/taxonomies directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine/crates -maxdepth 2 | sort\",\"description\":\"List engine crates\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml && echo --- && cat .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Show full taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine/crates/check/src -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List check crate source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^ - id:\\\\|^- id:\\\\|severity:\\\\|remedy:\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -100\",\"description\":\"Find rule id/severity/remedy lines in taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r40/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r40/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Search for summary field in taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^rules:\\\\|^facets:\\\\|^kinds:\\\\|^checks:\\\\|^ [a-z_]*:$\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -60\",\"description\":\"Find top-level sections in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r40/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r40/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"retired_term\\\\|contraction\\\\|hard_wrap\\\\|line_length\\\\|sentence_length\\\\|mechanical\\\\|rewrite\\\\|category:\\\\|remedy:\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -80\",\"description\":\"Search for rule schema fields in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '550,620p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Show lines 550-620 of taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1190,1260p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Show context around retired_term mechanism declaration\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^checks:\\\\|^ CT-\\\\|mechanism:\\\\|posture:\\\\| CT-\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -80\",\"description\":\"Find checks section and CT- identifiers\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet\\\\.value\\\\.blank\\\\|FACET-3\\\\|OB-FACET-3\\\\|CT-FACET-3\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Search for facet blank rule's obligation/control entries\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r40/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '150,175p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml; echo ===; sed -n '820,845p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml; echo ===; sed -n '1280,1300p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Show OB-FACET-3 and CT-FACET-3 context\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rln \\\"contraction\\\\|british\\\\|hard_wrap\\\\|retired_term\\\\|sentence_length\\\\|word limit\\\\|controlled\\\" engine/crates/check/src/ | sort\",\"description\":\"Find rule files implementing contraction/spelling/wrap checks\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"pub const RULE\\\" engine/crates/check/src/*.rs\",\"description\":\"List all RULE constants declared in check crate\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rln \\\"summary\\\" engine/crates/check/fixtures engine/crates/check/tests 2>/dev/null | sort\",\"description\":\"Find summary usage in check crate fixtures and tests\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine/crates/check/fixtures -iname \\\"*blank*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*facet*\\\" | sort\",\"description\":\"Find fixture files related to facet/blank checks\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r40/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md"
result: "sha256:ab8d0eb139f3733cde3ca712a0f637ff8fe82f70fc93a55f87b27273fad00d57"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r40/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/05-no-summary.md"
result: "sha256:e93ab39ba0f3d03cf7593bc046d7c0a5aa0fbf102df0e02e2dbf34c263aa346d"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r40/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/21-summary-facet-prose.md"
result: "sha256:16254913bd0c34a373fdb76b1a6acd730f6bd03bdd1ad47b2d964a496aaf6695"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"blank-facets\\\\|no-summary\\\\|summary-facet-prose\\\\|facet.value.blank\\\\|facet.required.missing\\\" engine/crates/check/fixtures/check.report\",\"description\":\"Find expected report lines for blank/summary fixtures\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r40/engine/crates/check/src/gate.rs"
result: "sha256:def50b7a95faabb9aeb27380fa87b460eca58ea4969b095129f5d72054bc13e8"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"posture\\\\|blocking\\\\|Posture\\\" engine/crates/check/src/*.rs engine/crates/cli/src/*.rs 2>/dev/null | grep -v \\\"^.*test\\\" | head -60\",\"description\":\"Find where posture/blocking logic lives in check and cli crates\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '5850,5995p' engine/crates/cli/src/main.rs\",\"description\":\"Read CLI logic around strict/exit status for check\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"fn check\\\\b\\\\|strict\\\\b\\\" engine/crates/cli/src/main.rs | head -40\",\"description\":\"Find check function and strict flag handling\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"severity-is-the-checks-posture-is-the-controls\\\\|## Severity is the check\\\" -A 40 docs/spec/12-check-layer.md | head -80\",\"description\":\"Read spec 12 section on severity vs posture\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '6850,6940p' engine/crates/cli/src/main.rs\",\"description\":\"Read check function around has_errors and strict handling\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"fn has_errors\\\" engine/crates/check/src/*.rs\",\"description\":\"Find has_errors definition\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1400,1450p' engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs\",\"description\":\"Read has_errors implementation\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls .headwater/ 2>/dev/null; echo ---; find . -maxdepth 2 -iname \\\"corpus.json\\\" 2>/dev/null; echo ---; find / -maxdepth 6 -iname \\\"corpus.json\\\" 2>/dev/null | head\",\"description\":\"Check for corpus.json descriptor file\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rln \\\"scent\\\\b\\\" docs/spec/ docs/decisions/ 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Find docs mentioning scent role for summary facet\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rln \\\"OB-FACET\\\\|facet.required.missing\\\\|facet.value.blank\\\" docs/acceptance-criteria/ docs/requirements/ 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Find acceptance criteria / requirements docs referencing facet rules\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r40/docs/decisions/0020-where-scent-lives.md"
result: "sha256:9a6c7b0b7893386e7564e2a38a53cfdaacc53303563751be07d094bcf835c39f"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/acceptance-criteria/ | head -30; echo ---count---; ls docs/acceptance-criteria/ | wc -l; echo ---requirements---; ls docs/requirements/ | head -30\",\"description\":\"List acceptance-criteria and requirements docs directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l .headwater/corpus.json; echo ---; head -c 3000 .headwater/corpus.json\",\"description\":\"Show size and head of corpus.json\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r40/docs/acceptance-criteria/0002-every-required-section-of-every-governed-document-has-a-heading.md"
result: "sha256:a7c2e83ca126772b502628fe129e8e3d915faedd4c2d553cdcd62b06ef1e7680"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r40/docs/requirements/0002-every-document-of-a-kind-that-requires-sections-carries-all-of-them.md"
result: "sha256:0e0418303617eed28cb7da1c628cef91f74d295337cfb8b780992c33e2f8886a"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '225,290p' engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs\",\"description\":\"Show RULES array and surrounding registration code\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"facet_blank\\\\|facet_required\\\\|Blank::over\\\\|Required::over\\\\|mod facet_blank\\\\|mod facet_required\\\" engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs\",\"description\":\"Find where facet_blank and facet_required are wired into the check runner\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,60p' docs/subsystems/checks-and-cache.md\",\"description\":\"Read the start of checks-and-cache subsystem doc\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,15p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/package.yml 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Peek at package.yml for version context\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find taxonomy-source -maxdepth 3 | sort\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy-source directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"diff .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml && echo IDENTICAL; grep -n \\\"^facets:\\\\|^ summary:\\\\|^kinds:\\\\|^ governed_document:\\\\|^obligations:\\\\|^ OB-FACET-3:\\\\|^controls:\\\\|^ CT-FACET-3:\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Diff vendored vs source taxonomy and confirm line numbers in source copy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,10p' docs/requirements/README.md 2>/dev/null; echo ---; sed -n '1,10p' docs/acceptance-criteria/README.md 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Peek at README files of requirements and acceptance-criteria shelves\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "CronDelete"
argument: "{\"id\":\"dummy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "ScheduleWakeup"
argument: "{\"stop\":true}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r40/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r40/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r40/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r41"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls && echo --- && find .headwater -maxdepth 3 -type d 2>/dev/null && echo --- && find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 4 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List repo root and headwater config directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine -maxdepth 4 -type d 2>/dev/null | head -50\",\"description\":\"List engine crate directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine/crates -maxdepth 1 -type d; echo ---; find engine/crates/check -maxdepth 3 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List all engine crates and check crate structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -30\",\"description\":\"Find summary field declaration in taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r41/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r41/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd engine/crates/check && grep -rn \\\"summary\\\" tests/*.rs 2>/dev/null; echo ---; grep -rln \\\"summary\\\" fixtures/*.taxonomy.yml 2>/dev/null; echo ---; grep -n \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet_blank\\\" src/lib.rs\",\"description\":\"Check for existing tests covering summary-blank case and rule registration\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"facet_blank::RULE\\\\|facet.value.blank\\\" tests/fixtures.rs | head -20\",\"description\":\"Find test coverage referencing facet_blank rule for summary\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"summary:\\\" fixtures/check/spec/*.md 2>/dev/null | head -30\",\"description\":\"Look at summary field values in spec fixture documents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r41/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md"
result: "sha256:ab8d0eb139f3733cde3ca712a0f637ff8fe82f70fc93a55f87b27273fad00d57"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1970,2015p' tests/fixtures.rs\",\"description\":\"Show test context around the facet_blank assertion for summary\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r42"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r42\",\"description\":\"List top-level repo contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r42/.headwater -maxdepth 4 -type d\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r42/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/doctrine -maxdepth 2\\necho ---\\nfind /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r42/taxonomy-source -maxdepth 3\",\"description\":\"List doctrine and taxonomy-source contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r42/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r42/engine -maxdepth 3 -type d\",\"description\":\"List engine directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r42/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r42/engine/crates/check/src\",\"description\":\"List check crate source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r42/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r42/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r42/engine/crates/check"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r42/engine/crates/check/fixtures -iname \\\"*blank*\\\"\",\"description\":\"Find facet_blank fixtures\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r42/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md"
result: "sha256:ab8d0eb139f3733cde3ca712a0f637ff8fe82f70fc93a55f87b27273fad00d57"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r42/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/05-no-summary.md"
result: "sha256:e93ab39ba0f3d03cf7593bc046d7c0a5aa0fbf102df0e02e2dbf34c263aa346d"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r42/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check.report"
result: "sha256:1120731ba9752b904d987911fa2678a4cc5ce5b60badebecfdfa7e9bc50e3e4b"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r43"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && ls -la | head -30 && git status 2>&1 | head -5\",\"description\":\"Inspect working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Locate rule declaration and implementation pattern\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"This is the Headwater repository (a documentation-governance engine). I need to add a new check rule: \\\"reports a document whose summary is empty\\\" (i.e., a document has a `summary` front-matter field that is present but empty, or missing/blank).\\n\\nI need to understand the existing pattern for how a rule is:\\n1. DECLARED in the taxonomy (likely under `.headwater/packages/` or `taxonomy-source/` — some YAML/TOML/JSON definition of a rule with an id, severity like error/advisory, description).\\n2. IMPLEMENTED in the engine (likely Rust code under `engine/` — a crate implementing checks, e.g. `headwater-cli` or similar, with a match on rule ids or a trait for checks).\\n3. What severities exist (error vs advisory) and how they're assigned — CLAUDE.md in the repo root says \\\"A rule is an error when its remedy is mechanical and total... A rule is advisory when the remedy is a rewrite\\\".\\n\\nPlease find and report back, concretely with file paths and line numbers/snippets:\\n- The taxonomy file(s) that declare existing rules (e.g., look for the retired_terms rule, the line-break rule, the American-spelling rule, or any rule about document metadata/front matter like `summary`, `title`, etc.). Show the exact schema/format used to declare a rule (fields like id, severity, message, scope).\\n- Whether there's already a rule about missing/empty fields in front matter (e.g., \\\"summary\\\" or \\\"title\\\" required) that I could model this new rule after — this is the best template to copy.\\n- The Rust engine code location(s) that implement document-level checks over front matter — show the module/file path and how a check function is registered/dispatched (e.g., a registry, a trait impl list, or a match statement).\\n- Any existing severity enum/levels in the engine code (error/advisory) and exactly how a rule is marked with one.\\n- The taxonomy lock file or schema (`.headwater/taxonomy.lock` or similar) to see if newly added rules need a corresponding entry there.\\n- Whether `docs/*` documents have a `summary` field in their front matter today (grep a few docs/*.md files for `summary:` in YAML front matter) — confirm the field name and whether it's commonly empty vs populated.\\n\\nReport concrete file paths, line ranges, and short code/config excerpts I can use to write the new rule myself. Keep the report focused and under 600 words of prose (quoted snippets don't count against that).\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo \\\"---\\\" && find . -maxdepth 3 -iname \\\"*headwater*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*.lock\\\" 2>/dev/null | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la .headwater 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---engine---\\\"; ls -la engine 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---taxonomy-source---\\\"; find . -iname \\\"*taxonomy*\\\" -not -path \\\"*/node_modules/*\\\" -not -path \\\"*/.git/*\\\" 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "ScheduleWakeup"
argument: "{\"delaySeconds\":300,\"reason\":\"fallback check in case the explore agent's completion notification is missed\",\"prompt\":\"Check whether the Explore agent researching Headwater rule declaration/implementation pattern has completed; if so, synthesize findings and proceed to add the new 'empty summary' rule.\",\"noop\":true}"
result: ""
- tool: "ScheduleWakeup"
argument: "{\"stop\":true}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r43/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"---\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"summary\\\\|title\\\\|front.matter\\\\|frontmatter\\\" -i /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r43/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r43/engine/crates/check\\necho \\\"---src---\\\"\\nls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r43/engine/crates/check/src\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r43/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r43/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r43/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r43\\ngrep -n \\\"enum Severity\\\" -A 15 engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs\\necho \\\"---lib.rs registry---\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"facet_blank\\\\|facet_required\\\\|FacetBlank\\\\|Blank\\\\|Required\\\" engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs\\necho \\\"---taxonomy.lock summary---\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"summary\\\" .headwater/taxonomy.lock | head -20\\necho \\\"---docs sample summary---\\\"\\ngrep -rn \\\"^summary:\\\" docs/*.md docs/**/*.md 2>/dev/null | head -10\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r43\\nsed -n '1,30p' engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs\\necho \\\"---223-260---\\\"\\nsed -n '215,260p' engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs\\necho \\\"---CLAUDE.md severity---\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"error when\\\\|advisory when\\\\|mechanical\\\\|rewrite\\\" CLAUDE.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,70p' engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs\",\"description\":\"Read facet_blank.rs header and doc comments\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"RULE\\\\|Severity\\\\|fn instantiates\\\\|fn evaluate\\\" engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs | head -30\\necho ---\\ngrep -n \\\"RULE\\\\|Severity\\\" engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs | head -20\\necho ---\\nsed -n '375,435p' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Check rule ids, severities, and taxonomy summary facet declaration\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r44"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls -la\",\"description\":\"Check if directory is a git repo and list contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"Where is the rule taxonomy declared for headwater check rules (e.g. document-level rules like empty summary), and where is the check engine implemented? Looking for how to add a new rule that reports a document whose summary is empty.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r44/.headwater -maxdepth 3 -type d; echo \\\"---packages---\\\"; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r44/.headwater/packages -maxdepth 4 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r44/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine -maxdepth 3 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List engine directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r44/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r44/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r44/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r44/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r44/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md"
result: "sha256:ab8d0eb139f3733cde3ca712a0f637ff8fe82f70fc93a55f87b27273fad00d57"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n -i \\\"summary\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r44/engine/crates/cli/tests/blank_facet.rs | head -50\",\"description\":\"Search blank_facet test for summary coverage\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|summary\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r44/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check.report | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check reported output fixture for the blank-facets case\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r45"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls && echo --- && find .headwater -maxdepth 3 -type d && echo --- && find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 4 2>/dev/null | head -50\",\"description\":\"List repo root and headwater taxonomy structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"severity\\\\|^ - id:\\\\|rule\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -80\",\"description\":\"Scan taxonomy.yml for rule declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r45/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r45/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^ [a-z_]*\\\\.[a-z_.]*:\\\\|^rules:\\\\|^findings:\\\\|^checks:\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -60\",\"description\":\"Find section headers and rule-id keyed entries in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r45/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"OB-FACET-3\\\" -A6 .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Find OB-FACET-3 obligation details\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd engine && grep -rn \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet_value_blank\\\\|FacetValueBlank\\\\|ValueBlank\\\" --include=*.rs -l 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Find engine implementation of facet.value.blank rule\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r45/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r45 && grep -n \\\"forbid\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -30\",\"description\":\"Check for any kind-level forbid of the summary facet\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd engine && grep -n \\\"summary\\\" crates/cli/tests/blank_facet.rs crates/cli/tests/standard_controls.rs 2>/dev/null | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check existing tests for summary coverage under the blank-facet rule\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r46"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; git worktree list 2>&1\",\"description\":\"Check if directory is a git repository and list worktrees\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r46\",\"description\":\"List top-level repository contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r46/.git 2>&1 | head -5; echo \\\"---\\\"; cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r46/.git 2>&1 | head -5\",\"description\":\"Check for .git directory or gitdir file\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater -maxdepth 4 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List directory structure under .headwater\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/doctrine -maxdepth 3 | sort | head -80\",\"description\":\"List doctrine directory contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r46"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r46/.headwater"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r46/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Count lines in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r46/docs/obligations/0076-a-generated-check-reads-its-severity-from-the-taxonomy.md"
result: "sha256:ff92c1810365ab30bdd92de93e1402aa69dad479fb4a0836e17215d377ea0430"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r46/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r46/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r46/docs/decisions/0058-a-blank-facet-value-is-a-rule-of-its-own-and-it-reads-every-string-facet.md"
result: "sha256:7c1e03d300ff01f37bf38245f8adbfb1b6ef00e6dcc45839abd740efdb29ad21"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r46"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r46/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r46/.headwater/taxonomy.lock"
result: "sha256:1ea570f4a22e19db2ed394a89bbb5f47f2908847514bb3417fd7a88820333650"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r47"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo --- && find . -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level repository structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 3 | sort; echo ---; find engine/crates -maxdepth 2 | sort\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy packages and engine crates structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,120p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"View start of taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^rules:\\\\|severity:\\\\| - id:\\\\|facets\\\\.summary\\\\|summary\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -80\",\"description\":\"Search taxonomy.yml for rules and summary references\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r47/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^controls:\\\\|CT-FACET\\\\|CT-COV\\\\|^ CT-\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -40\",\"description\":\"Search for controls section mapping obligations to checks\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r47/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"required.missing\\\\|facet.required\\\\|RequiredMissing\\\\|rule_id\\\\|\\\\\\\"facet\\\\.\\\" engine/crates/check/src | head -60\",\"description\":\"Find facet.required.missing rule implementation in check crate\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r47/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"facet.value.blank\\\" -r .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml; echo ---; grep -n \\\"CT-FACET-3\\\\|OB-FACET-3\\\" -A8 .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Check whether facet.value.blank has a control/obligation entry in taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"enum Severity\\\" -A10 engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs\",\"description\":\"Check Severity enum definition\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r48"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check working directory contents and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r48/.headwater/packages"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".claude/skills/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r48/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r48"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r48/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r48/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r48/docs/decisions/0058-a-blank-facet-value-is-a-rule-of-its-own-and-it-reads-every-string-facet.md"
result: "sha256:7c1e03d300ff01f37bf38245f8adbfb1b6ef00e6dcc45839abd740efdb29ad21"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r48/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r48/engine/crates/cli/tests/blank_facet.rs"
result: "sha256:2803c8c086f63283529fe721a2702cd8dcfd91e4754bdfa17b1423e2ed105143"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r49"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git status 2>&1 | head -20; echo \\\"---\\\"; git rev-parse --show-toplevel 2>&1\",\"description\":\"Check git repository status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r49/ 2>&1 | head -50\",\"description\":\"List top-level contents of working directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r49/.claude -maxdepth 3 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List .claude directory structure to find skills\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater taxonomy-source -maxdepth 4 -type f | sort | head -100\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy and headwater config files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find taxonomy-source -maxdepth 6 -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy-source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 6 -type f 2>/dev/null | sort; echo \\\"---overlay---\\\"; cat .headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null | head -100\",\"description\":\"List headwater packages and overlay config\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"rules\\\\|severity\\\\|summary\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -80\",\"description\":\"Search taxonomy.yml for rules/severity/summary keys\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r49/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r49/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r49/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r49/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r49/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r49/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet_value_blank\\\\|FacetValueBlank\\\\|FACET-3\\\\|CT-FACET-3\\\" engine/ 2>/dev/null | head -50\",\"description\":\"Search engine source for the facet.value.blank check implementation\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rln \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|FacetValueBlank\\\\|facet_value_blank\\\" engine/crates/check/src 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---\\\"; find engine/crates/check/src -iname \\\"*blank*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*facet*\\\" 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Find the check implementation source file for facet.value.blank\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r49/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"enum Severity\\\" -A 10 engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs\",\"description\":\"Check the Severity enum definition\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,20p' engine/crates/check/fixtures/check.report | head -5; echo \\\"...\\\"; grep -n \\\"05-no-summary\\\" -r engine/crates/check/fixtures/ | head -10\",\"description\":\"Check fixture referencing no-summary case\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r5"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Research rule declaration and implementation pattern\",\"prompt\":\"This is the Headwater repository (a documentation-governance engine). I need to add a new check rule to the engine: \\\"a document whose summary is empty gets reported.\\\" I need to understand the existing convention for how rules are declared (taxonomy) and implemented (engine code), by finding an existing, similar, already-implemented rule to use as a template.\\n\\nPlease investigate and report back (don't write anything, just research):\\n\\n1. Where is the rule taxonomy declared? Look at `.headwater/packages/` and `docs/taxonomies/` — find the file(s) that declare rules (e.g., with ids, names, severities like error/advisory). Show me the structure/schema used for declaring a rule (full text of one example rule declaration, e.g. something about document metadata, front matter, or summary fields).\\n\\n2. Where is the rule engine implemented? Look under `engine/` (likely a Rust workspace, `engine/Cargo.toml`). Find the crate(s) that implement checks (e.g., something like `headwater-check`, `headwater-taxonomy`, or similar). Find an existing rule implementation that's similar in spirit (checks a document field like front matter, summary, title, or similar empty/missing field) and show me its full code, plus how it's wired up (registered) to the taxonomy id declared in step 1.\\n\\n3. Is there a notion of \\\"summary\\\" already in the document front matter / schema? Search for \\\"summary\\\" across `docs/spec/`, `.headwater/packages/`, and `engine/` to see if \\\"summary\\\" is an existing recognized front-matter field, and what its type/shape is.\\n\\n4. What severities exist (error vs advisory) and what distinguishes them per CLAUDE.md (\\\"a rule is an error when its remedy is mechanical and total... advisory when the remedy is a rewrite\\\")? For \\\"empty summary\\\", which severity fits, and is there a precedent (e.g., a similar missing-mechanical-field rule that's an error)?\\n\\n5. Is there a specific document (e.g. under docs/spec/, docs/decisions/, or DEVELOPING.md) that lists ALL current rules with their ids/severities, which I should update too?\\n\\nReport concrete file paths, line numbers, and exact text/code snippets. Keep the report focused and under 600 words of prose, but include the full code/text snippets I asked for verbatim.\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"run_in_background\":false}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== root ===\\\" && ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r5 && echo \\\"=== .headwater/packages ===\\\" && find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r5/.headwater/packages -maxdepth 4 2>/dev/null && echo \\\"=== docs/taxonomies ===\\\" && find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r5/docs/taxonomies -maxdepth 4 2>/dev/null && echo \\\"=== engine ===\\\" && find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r5/engine -maxdepth 3 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== taxonomy.yml head ===\\\" && sed -n '1,120p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml && echo \\\"...\\\" && wc -l .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^rules:\\\\|^controls:\\\\|^obligations:\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r5/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== grep summary in docs/spec ===\\\" && grep -rn \\\"summary\\\" docs/spec/ 2>/dev/null | head -50\\necho \\\"=== grep summary in .headwater/packages ===\\\" && grep -rn \\\"summary\\\" .headwater/packages/ 2>/dev/null | head -50\\necho \\\"=== grep summary in engine (excluding target) ===\\\" && grep -rln \\\"summary\\\" engine/crates --include=*.rs 2>/dev/null | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r5/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '933,1423p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | grep -n \\\"CT-FACET\\\\|CT-ID\\\\|CT-REL\\\\|CT-PLACE\\\\|^ CT-\\\" | head -40\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '990,1010p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n -i \\\"advisory\\\\|severity\\\\|mechanical\\\" CLAUDE.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n -i \\\"severity\\\\|fixability\\\\|advisory\\\\|mechanical\\\" docs/spec/12-check-layer.md | head -60\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '300,340p' docs/spec/12-check-layer.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls engine/crates/check/src/ && echo \\\"---\\\" && grep -rn \\\"facet.required.missing\\\\|facet_required_missing\\\\|FacetRequired\\\" engine/crates/check/src/ | head -20\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r5/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"OB-FACET-3\\\\|CT-FACET-3\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"---\\\"\\nawk '/OB-FACET-3:/,/^$/' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -20\\necho \\\"---CT-FACET-3---\\\"\\nsed -n '1280,1300p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"Blank\\\\|facet_blank\\\\|Required\\\\b\\\\|facet_required\\\" engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r5/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rln \\\"OB-FACET-1\\\\b\\\" docs/ 2>/dev/null\\necho \\\"---\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"CT-FACET-1\\\\|rules.*index\\\\|all.*rule\\\\|RULES\\\\b\\\" docs/spec/04-assurance-model.md | head -20\\necho \\\"---check RULES array in lib.rs for total count context---\\\"\\nsed -n '220,245p' engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet.required.missing\\\" DEVELOPING.md docs/spec/*.md 2>/dev/null | head -20\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,40p' engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs | grep -n \\\"Severity\\\" -A 8\\necho \\\"---facet_required.rs (first 60 lines)---\\\"\\nsed -n '1,60p' engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r5/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"enum Severity\\\" -A 10 engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r5 -iname \\\"taxonomy.yml\\\" 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Locate taxonomy.yml file\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r5"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r5/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r5/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r5/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r50"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && ls -la && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check working directory state and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Find rule declaration and implementation pattern\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"This is the Headwater repository (a documentation-governance engine). I need to add a new check rule: \\\"reports a document whose summary is empty.\\\" I need to find the existing pattern for how rules are declared and implemented, so I can follow it exactly.\\n\\nPlease find and report back (with file paths and line numbers/snippets):\\n\\n1. Where rules are DECLARED in the taxonomy — look under `.headwater/packages/` and `docs/taxonomies/` for a taxonomy definition file (likely YAML) that lists existing check rules, their names (e.g. something like `language.retired_term.used` mentioned in CLAUDE.md), their severity (error vs advisory), and any schema/fields each rule declaration has (id, description, severity, category, etc).\\n\\n2. Where rules are IMPLEMENTED in the engine — look under `engine/` (likely a Rust crate `headwater-cli` or similar, maybe a `headwater-check` or `headwater-rules` crate) for the source files implementing individual check rules. Find an existing rule that's similar in shape — e.g. a rule about a document having an empty or missing field (front matter field), or empty title, something structural like \\\"document whose X is empty\\\" — show its full implementation file.\\n\\n3. Is there an existing field called \\\"summary\\\" in the document front matter schema? Search docs/spec or docs/taxonomies or engine for \\\"summary\\\" field on documents, to see if it already exists as a front-matter field that could be empty.\\n\\n4. What severities exist (error vs advisory) and the rule for which is which (per CLAUDE.md: error = mechanical total remedy, advisory = rewrite remedy). Find 2-3 example rule declarations of each severity.\\n\\n5. Is there a test fixture pattern for rules (e.g. docs/acceptance-criteria/ or engine test fixtures) that I should also add for this new rule?\\n\\nReport concrete file paths, line numbers, and relevant code/YAML snippets. Keep the report focused and under 600 words of prose, but include the snippets needed for me to write the new rule declaration + implementation by example.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls && echo --- && find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 3 2>/dev/null && echo --- && find docs/taxonomies -maxdepth 3 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List repo root and taxonomy directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r50/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r50/engine -maxdepth 4 -type d\",\"description\":\"List engine directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"true\",\"description\":\"No-op while waiting for background agent\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls engine/crates/check/src && echo --- && grep -rn \\\"facet.required.missing\\\\|facet_required\\\\|RequiredMissing\\\" engine/crates/check/src | head -50\",\"description\":\"List check crate source and find facet required rule\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r50/CLAUDE.md"
result: "sha256:c92caed27f86014c5f496edda4ca85568e1da2a44e9c15e4aece92ff9b5bbfd2"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r50/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r50/CLAUDE.md"
result: "sha256:c92caed27f86014c5f496edda4ca85568e1da2a44e9c15e4aece92ff9b5bbfd2"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"severity\\\\|advisory\\\\|Severity::Error\\\\|Severity::Warning\\\\|Severity::Advisory\\\\|mechanical\\\\|rewrite\\\" CLAUDE.md | head -60\",\"description\":\"Search CLAUDE.md for severity rules\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r50/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r50\\necho \\\"--- lib.rs facet_blank registration ---\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"facet_blank\\\\|facet_required\\\" engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs\\necho \\\"--- obligations/controls for facet.value.blank ---\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|OB-FACET-3\\\\|CT-FACET-3\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"--- Severity enum ---\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"enum Severity\\\" -A 10 engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs\\necho \\\"--- language.retired_term rule file ---\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"pub const RULE\\\" engine/crates/check/src/retired.rs engine/crates/check/src/language.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r50\\necho \\\"--- CT-FACET-3 full ---\\\"\\nsed -n '1283,1300p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"--- posture: blocking examples ---\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"posture: blocking\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"--- severities used in Rust rule files ---\\\"\\ngrep -rln \\\"Severity::Warn\\\\|Severity::Info\\\" engine/crates/check/src/*.rs\\necho \\\"--- test fixture pattern for facet_blank ---\\\"\\nfind engine/crates/check -iname \\\"*blank*\\\"\\nfind docs/acceptance-criteria -iname \\\"*facet*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*blank*\\\" 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r50\\necho \\\"--- fixture file ---\\\"\\ncat engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md\\necho \\\"--- grep tests referencing it ---\\\"\\ngrep -rln \\\"18-blank-facets\\\\|facet.value.blank\\\\|facet_blank\\\" engine/crates/check/tests\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r50\\ngrep -n \\\"18-blank-facets\\\\|facet.value.blank\\\" -A 15 engine/crates/check/tests/fixtures.rs | head -40\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r50\\nsed -n '1,80p' engine/crates/check/tests/fixtures.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r50\\nfind engine/crates/check/fixtures/check -maxdepth 2 | head -30\\necho ---\\nfind engine/crates/check/tests -maxdepth 1\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r50\\nfind engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec -iname \\\"*report*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*.txt\\\" -o -iname \\\"*.json\\\" 2>/dev/null | head\\nfind engine/crates/check/fixtures -maxdepth 1\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '350,440p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r50/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"View facets block around summary field declaration\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r50/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"OB-FACET-3\\\" -A 8 .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -20\\necho \\\"---\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"CT-FACET-3\\\" -A 12 .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -20\\necho \\\"---lib.rs---\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"facet_blank\\\\|facet\\\\.value\\\\.blank\\\" engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs\",\"description\":\"View obligation and control declarations for facet.value.blank, and lib.rs registration\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r51"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo --- && test -d .git && echo \\\"has .git\\\" || echo \\\"no .git\\\"\",\"description\":\"List working directory contents and check for git repo\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .claude -iname '*taxonomy*' -o -iname '*skill*' | head -50\",\"description\":\"Look for taxonomy or skill files under .claude\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .claude -maxdepth 4 -type d; echo ---; find . -iname '*.headwater*' -maxdepth 2; echo ---; ls .headwater\",\"description\":\"List .claude directories and .headwater top-level contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls .headwater/packages; echo ---; find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 3 -type f | head -50\",\"description\":\"Explore taxonomy packages directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"== .headwater/taxonomy.yml (head) ==\\\"; sed -n '1,60p' .headwater/taxonomy.yml; echo; echo \\\"== taxonomy-source ==\\\"; find taxonomy-source -maxdepth 4 -type f | head -80\",\"description\":\"Peek at main taxonomy.yml and taxonomy-source layout\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -50\",\"description\":\"Search taxonomy.yml for existing summary field references\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r51/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^checks:\\\\|^rules:\\\\|severity\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -80\",\"description\":\"Find checks/rules sections and severity declarations in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r51/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n -i \\\"empty\\\\|blank\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml .headwater/overlay.yml\",\"description\":\"Search for existing empty/blank-related rules in taxonomy sources\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r51/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"controls:\\\\|check:facet\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -30\",\"description\":\"Find controls section and facet check mechanisms\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r51/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r51/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet_value_blank\\\\|ValueBlank\\\\|value_blank\\\" engine/ --include=*.rs | head -30\",\"description\":\"Search engine Rust source for the facet.value.blank rule implementation\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r51/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"enum Severity\\\" engine/crates/check/src/ -A 10\",\"description\":\"Find Severity enum definition\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" .headwater/overlay.yml\",\"description\":\"Check overlay.yml for any summary facet customization\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r52"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && ls -la | head -30 && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r52/.headwater -maxdepth 4 -type d\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r52/docs/taxonomies -maxdepth 3 2>&1\",\"description\":\"List docs/taxonomies structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r52/engine -maxdepth 4 -type d\",\"description\":\"List engine directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r52/engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r52/engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r52/engine/crates/check/src -maxdepth 2 -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List check crate source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r52/engine/crates/check/src/frontmatter.rs"
result: "sha256:b6864d616cbf7133eb84efa03e36c9092b9a2aa50c6e7d0e87408bfd68914f8a"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r52/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r52/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r52/.headwater/packages"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r52/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/doctrine"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r52/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/doctrine -maxdepth 2 -type f\",\"description\":\"List doctrine directory files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r52/docs/taxonomies"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r52"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r52/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"diff <(grep -n \\\"summary:\\\" -A4 taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml) <(grep -n \\\"summary:\\\" -A4 .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml) ; echo \\\"---README---\\\"; find . -maxdepth 1 -iname \\\"README*\\\"; grep -rn \\\"taxonomy-source\\\" docs/interfaces/*.md docs/spec/*.md 2>/dev/null | head -10\",\"description\":\"Compare summary facet declarations and find taxonomy-source documentation\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r52/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"python3 -c \\\"\\nimport json\\nd = json.load(open('.headwater/corpus.json'))\\nprint(type(d), list(d.keys()) if isinstance(d, dict) else len(d))\\n\\\" 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Inspect corpus.json top-level structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r52/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r53"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo \\\"---git---\\\" && git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1\",\"description\":\"Check repo root contents and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"Looking for how rules are declared in the taxonomy and how severity (error/advisory) is assigned, plus examples of existing document-level rules (e.g. checks on front matter fields like summary) to model a new rule: \\\"report a document whose summary is empty.\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\",\"args\":\"About to add a new rule to the taxonomy that flags a document whose summary field is empty, and find/implement it in the engine. Need to know the taxonomy package layout, how rules are declared with severity, and overlay.yml conventions.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Locate rule declaration and implementation patterns\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"I'm working in a repository called Headwater (a documentation-governance engine). I need to add a new rule to the engine that reports a document whose \\\"summary\\\" field is empty, and I need to describe where rules are DECLARED (taxonomy) and where they are IMPLEMENTED (engine code), and what SEVERITY levels exist (error vs advisory).\\n\\nPlease investigate and report back with concrete file paths, line numbers, and code/config snippets for:\\n\\n1. Where taxonomy rules are declared. Look under `.headwater/packages/`, `docs/taxonomies/`, `taxonomy-source/`, and `.headwater/overlay.yml`. Find the schema/format used to declare a rule (id, description, severity, category, etc). Show at least two full example rule declarations, ideally one that's an \\\"error\\\" severity and one that's \\\"advisory\\\" severity, so I understand the pattern. Also find any existing rule that already deals with a document's \\\"summary\\\" field, or with \\\"empty\\\" fields in general (e.g., front matter emptiness checks), to see if something similar already exists.\\n\\n2. Where rules are IMPLEMENTED in the engine. Look under `engine/` (likely a Rust crate `headwater-cli` or similar, per CLAUDE.md which mentions `cargo build --profile dev-release -p headwater-cli --manifest-path engine/Cargo.toml --locked`). Find the module/file structure for rule implementations — e.g. is there a `checks/` or `rules/` directory, a trait each rule implements, how a rule reads a document's front matter (specifically how \\\"summary\\\" is represented — is it a front-matter field?), and how severity is wired from taxonomy declaration to the Rust implementation. Show the specific file(s) and line ranges for an existing rule implementation that is structurally similar (e.g., checks a required front-matter field, or checks for emptiness) so I can model the new rule after it.\\n\\n3. Find the canonical list of severities (just \\\"error\\\" and \\\"advisory\\\" per CLAUDE.md, but confirm in code/docs) and how a rule config/declaration specifies which severity it is — is it per-rule in the taxonomy, or inherent to the rule's remedy type?\\n\\n4. Find out what field in front matter is called \\\"summary\\\" — confirm the exact field name (could be `summary`, `description`, `abstract`) used across `docs/` front matter, and whether there's already a schema (e.g. JSON schema, or Rust struct) listing required/optional front-matter fields.\\n\\nReport file paths with line numbers, and quote the relevant snippets directly (don't paraphrase code). Keep the report focused and under 600 lines of quoted material total.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo \\\"---\\\" && find . -maxdepth 3 -type d | head -100\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"== .headwater/packages ==\\\" && find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r53/.headwater/packages -maxdepth 3\\necho \\\"== taxonomy-source ==\\\" && find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r53/taxonomy-source -maxdepth 4\\necho \\\"== overlay.yml exists? ==\\\" && ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r53/.headwater/*.yml 2>/dev/null\\necho \\\"== engine/crates ==\\\" && find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r53/engine/crates -maxdepth 2 -type d\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r53\\necho \\\"=== taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml wc ===\\\"\\nwc -l taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"=== head of taxonomy.yml ===\\\"\\nsed -n '1,80p' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r53\\necho \\\"=== grep severity in taxonomy-source ===\\\"\\ngrep -rn \\\"severity\\\" taxonomy-source/ | head -50\\necho \\\"=== grep severity in docs/taxonomies ===\\\"\\ngrep -rln \\\"severity\\\" docs/taxonomies/ | head -50\\necho \\\"=== grep advisory repo wide (non engine/target) ===\\\"\\ngrep -rln \\\"advisory\\\" --include=\\\"*.yml\\\" --include=\\\"*.md\\\" --include=\\\"*.rs\\\" . 2>/dev/null | grep -v \\\"engine/target\\\" | head -80\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r53\\necho \\\"=== CLAUDE.md severity/advisory/error mentions ===\\\"\\ngrep -n -i \\\"advisory\\\\|severity\\\\|error\\\" CLAUDE.md\\necho\\necho \\\"=== context around taxonomy.yml:555-575 ===\\\"\\nsed -n '540,600p' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r53\\necho \\\"=== grep remedy in taxonomy-source ===\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"remedy\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -30\\necho \\\"=== top-level keys in taxonomy.yml ===\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"^[a-zA-Z_]*:\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r53\\nsed -n '918,1000p' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r53\\necho \\\"=== posture values ===\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"posture:\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | sort -t: -k3 | uniq -c -f2 | sort -rn | head -20\\ngrep -on \\\"posture: [a-z_]*\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | awk -F': ' '{print $3}' | sort | uniq -c\\necho \\\"=== mechanism:check. values - list all check: mechanisms ===\\\"\\ngrep -o \\\"mechanism: check:[a-z_.]*\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"=== any facet/field about 'empty' or 'summary' ===\\\"\\ngrep -n -i \\\"empty\\\\|blank\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -30\\ngrep -n -i \\\"summary\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -30\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r53\\necho \\\"=== facets: summary (359-420) ===\\\"\\nsed -n '359,420p' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"=== kinds section around 429-449 ===\\\"\\nsed -n '429,449p' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r53\\necho \\\"=== search obligations for blank/FACET-3 ===\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"OB-FACET\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho\\nsed -n '600,625p' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"=== control CT-FACET-3 or blank around line 1270-1300 ===\\\"\\nsed -n '1260,1300p' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r53\\nsed -n '820,833p' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"=== blocking postures context ===\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"posture: blocking\\\" -B6 taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -60\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r53/engine\\necho \\\"=== grep Severity across engine/crates src ===\\\"\\ngrep -rn \\\"enum Severity\\\\|Severity::\\\" crates --include=\\\"*.rs\\\" | grep -v \\\"/tests/\\\" | head -60\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r53/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r53/engine\\necho \\\"=== finding.rs Severity enum ===\\\"\\nsed -n '1,100p' crates/check/src/finding.rs\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r53/engine\\necho \\\"=== find register module ===\\\"\\nfind crates/check/src -iname \\\"register*\\\"\\necho \\\"=== grep RULE const to mechanism mapping ===\\\"\\ngrep -rn \\\"pub const RULE\\\" crates/check/src | head -60\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r53/engine\\necho \\\"=== facet_required.rs (full) ===\\\"\\nsed -n '1,120p' crates/check/src/facet_required.rs\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r53/engine\\ngrep -n \\\"facet_blank\\\\|facet_required\\\\|Blank::over\\\\|Required::over\\\" crates/check/src/lib.rs\\necho \\\"---\\\"\\nsed -n '225,290p' crates/check/src/lib.rs\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r53\\necho \\\"=== docs/spec/12-check-layer.md: severity-is-the-checks-posture-is-the-controls section ===\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"^#\\\" docs/spec/12-check-layer.md | head -60\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r53\\nsed -n '294,306p' docs/spec/12-check-layer.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r53/engine\\nsed -n '1420,1440p' crates/check/src/lib.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r53/engine\\necho \\\"=== scope.rs DocumentCheck trait signature ===\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"trait DocumentCheck\\\" -A 25 crates/check/src/scope.rs | head -40\\necho \\\"=== DocumentView::facets() / entry ===\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"fn facets\\\\|fn entry\\\" crates/check/src/scope.rs crates/check/src/shape.rs 2>/dev/null | head -10\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r53/engine\\nsed -n '514,525p' crates/check/src/scope.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r53/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r53/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r54"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r54 -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level directories in the repo\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r54/.headwater -maxdepth 3 | sort\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r54/.headwater/packages -maxdepth 4 | sort\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy packages structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r54/engine/crates -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List engine crates\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rl \\\"summary\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r54/.headwater/packages 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---taxonomy-source---\\\"; grep -rl \\\"summary\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r54/taxonomy-source 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Search for 'summary' references in taxonomy packages and taxonomy-source\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r54/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\ngrep -n \\\"summary\\\\|empty\\\\|severity:\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r54/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -80\",\"description\":\"Inspect taxonomy.yml for summary/severity related rules\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r54/engine/crates/check/src\",\"description\":\"List check crate source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r54/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"facet_blank\\\\|facet-blank\\\\|id: \\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r54/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | grep -B2 -i \\\"blank\\\" \",\"description\":\"Search taxonomy for facet_blank rule id and context\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r54/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"summary\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r54/engine/crates/check/src /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r54/engine/crates/check/tests /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r54/engine/crates/check/fixtures 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Check for existing references to 'summary' in check crate\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rln \\\"facet_blank\\\\|facet\\\\.value\\\\.blank\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r54/engine/crates/check/tests /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r54/engine/crates/check/fixtures 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Find facet_blank test and fixture files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r54/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md"
result: "sha256:ab8d0eb139f3733cde3ca712a0f637ff8fe82f70fc93a55f87b27273fad00d57"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|18-blank-facets\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r54/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check.report\",\"description\":\"Check the expected check.report fixture for the blank-facets case\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^rules:\\\\|^ [a-z_.]*:$\\\\|facet\\\\.value\\\\.blank\\\\|facet\\\\.required\\\\.missing\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r54/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -60\",\"description\":\"Look for a rules catalog section in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '540,575p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r54/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Inspect taxonomy.yml around the severity-listing block\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r54/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"OB-FACET-3\\\" -A6 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r54/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Find OB-FACET-3 obligation declaration\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo \\\"---\\\" && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"List working directory and check git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Find how check rules are declared and implemented\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"This is the Headwater repo (a documentation-governance engine with a \\\"headwater check\\\" CLI). I need to add a new rule: \\\"reports a document whose summary is empty.\\\" I need to understand the existing architecture for rules so I can add this one consistently.\\n\\nPlease investigate and report back (be thorough — this spans taxonomy declarations and engine code):\\n\\n1. Where rules are DECLARED (the taxonomy). Look under `.headwater/packages/`, `taxonomy-source/`, and `docs/taxonomies/`. Find the format used to declare a rule (e.g. YAML/TOML/other), including fields like id, severity (error vs advisory), description, and how a rule is tied to its check (declared vs implemented separation is a repo convention — the DEVELOPING.md file top-level says \\\"no second copy of any rule lives in a script\\\"). Show me a full example of one existing rule declaration, especially one with severity \\\"error\\\" and one \\\"advisory\\\" if both exist, ideally one that's similar in nature (checks document front matter / metadata, like checking for an empty or missing field).\\n\\n2. Where rules are IMPLEMENTED in the engine. Look under `engine/` (Rust crates, e.g. `headwater-cli` or similarly named crates) for the code that implements checks. Find how a specific rule id from the taxonomy maps to a Rust function/module — e.g. search for how an existing rule like a \\\"summary\\\" or \\\"front matter\\\" or metadata-presence check is implemented, or any rule that checks a string field for emptiness. Show me the file path and relevant code of one example end-to-end (taxonomy declaration -> engine implementation).\\n\\n3. Find what field is literally called \\\"summary\\\" in document front matter — check `docs/spec/`, `docs/interfaces/`, or a schema file (look for \\\"front matter\\\" schema, maybe under `.headwater/` or `docs/spec/`) to confirm \\\"summary\\\" is a real front-matter field name used across documents, and find 1-2 example documents that have a `summary:` field in their front matter so I can see the expected type (string vs list) and current conventions.\\n\\n4. Find the convention for rule IDs / naming (e.g. do they look like `language.retired_term.used` as mentioned in CLAUDE.md, or `document.something.something`). List a handful of existing rule IDs to show the naming pattern, especially any existing \\\"document.*\\\" or metadata-presence rules.\\n\\n5. Find where severities are defined/enumerated (error vs advisory) — is this an enum in the taxonomy schema, or Rust code? Quote the relevant lines.\\n\\nReport file paths with line numbers for everything so I can go edit precisely. Keep the report organized by my 5 numbered questions above. This is research only — do not edit any files.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== root ===\\\" && ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55 2>&1 | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"**/DEVELOPING.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"**/CLAUDE.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== .headwater ===\\\" && find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/.headwater -maxdepth 4 2>&1 | head -100\\necho \\\"=== taxonomy-source ===\\\" && find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/taxonomy-source -maxdepth 5 2>&1 | head -100\\necho \\\"=== docs/taxonomies ===\\\" && find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/docs/taxonomies -maxdepth 5 2>&1 | head -100\\necho \\\"=== engine ===\\\" && find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/engine -maxdepth 3 2>&1 | head -100\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"---\\\"\\nfind /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/engine/crates/check/src -type f\\necho \\\"---\\\"\\nls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/engine/crates/check/fixtures 2>&1 | head -30\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/DEVELOPING.md"
result: "sha256:8fbd8eb18a5b58dcbf5bfa3a763cea8bd99c0f877dfbc00aff7af74c9c9888cb"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"RULE\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/engine/crates/check/src/register.rs | head -80\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"RULES\\\\|mod facet_blank\\\\|mod facet_required\\\\|pub mod\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs | head -100\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"facet_blank\\\\|facet_required\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55\\ngrep -rn \\\"^summary:\\\" docs/decisions/*.md 2>/dev/null | head -3\\necho \\\"---\\\"\\ngrep -rln \\\"summary:\\\" docs/spec/ 2>/dev/null | head -5\\necho \\\"---\\\"\\nls docs/spec | head -30\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55\\ngrep -n \\\"instances.push\\\\|instances = vec!\\\\|instances: vec!\\\\|Instance::\\\" engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs | head -40\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55\\nawk 'NR==850,NR==920' engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs\\necho \\\"===search blank usage further down===\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"blank\\\" engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/DEVELOPING.md"
result: "sha256:8fbd8eb18a5b58dcbf5bfa3a763cea8bd99c0f877dfbc00aff7af74c9c9888cb"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/CLAUDE.md"
result: "sha256:c92caed27f86014c5f496edda4ca85568e1da2a44e9c15e4aece92ff9b5bbfd2"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55\\ngrep -n \\\"dotted form\\\\|rule id\\\\|rule's id\\\\|the rule.*spec 4\\\" docs/spec/04-assurance-model.md | head -20\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55\\ngrep -rn 'pub const RULE\\\\|pub const MISSING\\\\|pub const STALE\\\\|pub const VALUE\\\\|pub const UNPAIRED\\\\|pub const DISPOSITION\\\\|pub const MECHANISM\\\\|pub const OBSERVATION' engine/crates/check/src/*.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55\\ngrep -n \\\"severity-is-the-checks-posture-is-the-controls\\\" -A 30 docs/spec/12-check-layer.md | head -60\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55\\nfind . -path ./engine/target -prune -o -iname \\\"*.taxonomy.lock\\\" -print 2>/dev/null\\nfind . -type d -iname \\\"packages\\\" 2>/dev/null\\necho \\\"---\\\"\\ncat taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/package.yml 2>/dev/null | head -20\\necho \\\"--- .headwater/taxonomy.yml of this repo itself (consumer side), if any ---\\\"\\nfind . -maxdepth 1 -iname \\\".headwater\\\" \\nls -la .headwater 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/.headwater/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:0aa1b806b4bc44af26c12dc624643169bddb3583054e78db3873c23ca8e4bb12"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r55/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r56"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls && echo --- && ls .headwater 2>/dev/null && echo --- && ls docs/taxonomies 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List repo root and key directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== .headwater/packages ===\\\" && ls .headwater/packages && echo \\\"=== taxonomy-source ===\\\" && ls taxonomy-source && echo \\\"=== engine ===\\\" && ls engine\",\"description\":\"Explore packages, taxonomy-source, and engine directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== taxonomy-source/headwater-standard ===\\\" && find taxonomy-source/headwater-standard -maxdepth 3 && echo \\\"=== engine/crates ===\\\" && ls engine/crates\",\"description\":\"Explore taxonomy-source package structure and engine crates\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Count lines in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" -r taxonomy-source/ docs/ engine/crates --include=*.yml --include=*.rs -i | head -80\",\"description\":\"Search for existing references to 'summary' across taxonomy and engine\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r56/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^rules:\\\\|^ - id:\\\\|severity:\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -100\",\"description\":\"Find rules section and severities in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r56/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"empty\\\" engine/crates/check/src/*.rs | head -60\",\"description\":\"Search check crate source for handling of empty values\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls engine/crates/check/src && echo --- && ls engine/crates/check\",\"description\":\"List check crate source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r56/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet_blank\\\\|Shape-origin\\\\|generated from\\\" -r docs/ engine/crates/check/src taxonomy-source 2>/dev/null | head -60\",\"description\":\"Find references to the facet.value.blank rule and shape-origin generation across docs and engine\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"OB-FACET-3\\\\|CT-FACET-3\\\\|facet.value.blank\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Check for OB-FACET-3 and CT-FACET-3 declarations tied to facet.value.blank in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r56/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r56/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r57"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo --- && cat .headwater/corpus.json 2>/dev/null | head -100\",\"description\":\"List repo root and view corpus descriptor\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la .git 2>&1 | head -3; echo ---; ls engine; echo ---; ls docs/taxonomies; echo ---; find . -iname \\\"*summary*\\\" -not -path \\\"./site/*\\\" 2>/dev/null | head -50\",\"description\":\"Check for git dir, engine and taxonomies structure, search for existing summary-related files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/05-no-summary.md; echo ===; cat engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/21-summary-facet-prose.md\",\"description\":\"View two fixture files related to summary\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Locate rule declaration and implementation patterns for check engine\",\"prompt\":\"I'm working in the Headwater repository (a documentation-governance system with a Rust \\\"check\\\" engine and a taxonomy package system). I need to add a new rule to the check engine: \\\"a document whose `summary` facet is present but empty (empty string / whitespace-only) is reported.\\\" There is already a related but distinct rule that fires when `summary` is *missing entirely* (a required-facet rule) — see engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/05-no-summary.md and docs/decisions/0063-every-required-facet-of-a-generated-document-is-derived-and-the-emitter-composes-the-summary.md.\\n\\nI need you to research and report back (do NOT edit anything, read-only investigation):\\n\\n1. Where rules are DECLARED in this repo. Look in `taxonomy-source/` and `docs/taxonomies/` (especially `docs/taxonomies/standards-spec` and `docs/taxonomies/evidence-and-obligation` and `docs/taxonomies/decision-record`) for YAML or similar files that declare rule IDs, names, severities (error vs advisory), and messages. Find the specific rule that currently requires `summary` to be present (the \\\"required facet\\\" rule) — find its exact rule ID, declaration file, and severity.\\n\\n2. Where rules are IMPLEMENTED in the Rust engine. Look in `engine/crates/check/` (and possibly `engine/crates/taxonomy` or similar) for the Rust source implementing facet-presence checks — the code that currently checks for a missing `summary` key. Find the exact file and function/module.\\n\\n3. Find out whether there is already a distinct concept of \\\"empty string value\\\" vs \\\"missing key\\\" in the rule engine — i.e. does the engine have a general notion of checking facet values are non-empty, or would this be a wholly new rule?\\n\\n4. Look for how severities are declared (what are the valid severity levels — e.g. \\\"error\\\" vs \\\"advisory\\\" — and where that's documented, referencing CLAUDE.md's description: \\\"A rule is an error when its remedy is mechanical and total... A rule is advisory when the remedy is a rewrite\\\"). Determine what severity a \\\"summary is empty\\\" rule should be, by this logic (the fix for an empty summary is to write a sentence — not mechanical).\\n\\n5. Check `docs/taxonomies/README.md` and any schema/spec docs describing how a NEW rule gets added to a taxonomy package (the process: where you add a rule ID, where you add its message/severity, where you add Rust logic, where you add fixtures, how the lock file `.headwater/taxonomy.lock` or package version gets bumped).\\n\\nReport concisely: exact file paths and line numbers/snippets for (a) the existing \\\"missing summary\\\" rule declaration, (b) its Rust implementation, (c) the severity vocabulary and where declared, (d) the mechanics for adding a brand new rule (what files must change). Keep the report under 500 words, dense with file:line references.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r57/docs/decisions/0063-every-required-facet-of-a-generated-document-is-derived-and-the-emitter-composes-the-summary.md"
result: "sha256:f8368d4ed212766761c0991812a05d1739ccd2b7e1aa5ac07f554694c218efc8"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat docs/taxonomies/README.md | head -150\",\"description\":\"Read taxonomies README for rule-adding process overview\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find taxonomy-source -maxdepth 4 -type f | head -80\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy-source files to find base package rule declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n -i \\\"summary\\\\|required_facet\\\\|facets\\\\|severity\\\\|rule\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -100\",\"description\":\"Search taxonomy.yml for facet/rule/severity declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"pwd: $(pwd)\\\"; echo \\\"---taxonomy-source---\\\"; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r57 -maxdepth 1 -type d | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"taxonomy-source/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/taxonomies/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r57/taxonomy-source"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r57/docs/taxonomies/standards-spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r57/docs/taxonomies/evidence-and-obligation"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r57/docs/taxonomies/decision-record"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r57/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r57/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r57/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/05-no-summary.md"
result: "sha256:e93ab39ba0f3d03cf7593bc046d7c0a5aa0fbf102df0e02e2dbf34c263aa346d"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r57/engine/crates -maxdepth 2 -type d\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r57/engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r57/engine/crates/check/src -maxdepth 2 -type f | sort\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"rule:\\\\|id:\\\\|OB-\\\\|blank\\\\|empty\\\\|missing\\\\|facet\\\\.\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | sed -n '1,200p'\",\"description\":\"Search for rule ids and keywords related to facets around controls section\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r57/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r57/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r57/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r57/engine/crates/check"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r57/engine/crates/check/tests"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r57/engine/crates/check/fixtures -iname \\\"*blank*\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r57/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r57/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md"
result: "sha256:ab8d0eb139f3733cde3ca712a0f637ff8fe82f70fc93a55f87b27273fad00d57"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r57/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"posture:\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | sort | uniq -c | sort -rn\",\"description\":\"Tally posture values used in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r57/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r57/docs/taxonomies/README.md"
result: "sha256:4baa3cc1019fc8ca6365a0e372578a35c66e45e68b99c46f0c033b963f8514f4"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd engine && grep -rn \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|FacetValueBlank\\\\|facet_value_blank\\\" --include=*.rs crates | head -50\",\"description\":\"Search Rust source for facet.value.blank rule implementation\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r57/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r57/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r57/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r57/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r57/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rln \\\"summary: *\\\\\\\"\\\\?\\\\s*$\\\\|summary: \\\\\\\"\\\\\\\"\\\\|summary:$\\\" crates/check/fixtures crates/cli/tests 2>/dev/null | head -20\",\"description\":\"Search fixtures/tests for an empty-summary example\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r57/engine/crates/cli/tests/blank_facet.rs"
result: "sha256:2803c8c086f63283529fe721a2702cd8dcfd91e4754bdfa17b1423e2ed105143"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r57/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md"
result: "sha256:ab8d0eb139f3733cde3ca712a0f637ff8fe82f70fc93a55f87b27273fad00d57"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd engine/crates/check/src && sed -n '1,90p' finding.rs\",\"description\":\"Read Severity enum and doc comment in finding.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,90p' crates/check/src/finding.rs\",\"description\":\"Read Severity enum definition in finding.rs\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r58"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo --- && find . -maxdepth 2 -not -path '*/.git*' | sort\",\"description\":\"List repository root contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 4 | sort | head -100\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy packages structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -50\",\"description\":\"Search taxonomy.yml for summary-related rules\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r58/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine/crates -maxdepth 2 | sort\",\"description\":\"List engine crates\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine/crates/check/src -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List check crate source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r58/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r58/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rln \\\"facet.value.blank\\\" --include=*.md --include=*.rs . 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Find all references to the facet.value.blank rule\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r58/docs/decisions/0058-a-blank-facet-value-is-a-rule-of-its-own-and-it-reads-every-string-facet.md"
result: "sha256:7c1e03d300ff01f37bf38245f8adbfb1b6ef00e6dcc45839abd740efdb29ad21"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" engine/crates/cli/tests/blank_facet.rs engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md 2>/dev/null | head -30\",\"description\":\"Check whether summary facet appears in blank-facet test fixtures\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"--- ls root ---\\\" && ls -la && echo \\\"--- .headwater ---\\\" && ls -la .headwater 2>/dev/null && echo \\\"--- taxonomies ---\\\" && find docs/taxonomies -maxdepth 2 2>/dev/null && echo \\\"--- packages ---\\\" && find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 3 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59/.headwater/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:0aa1b806b4bc44af26c12dc624643169bddb3583054e78db3873c23ca8e4bb12"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59/engine -maxdepth 4 -type d\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Find rule declaration and implementation pattern in Headwater engine\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"This is the Headwater repo (a documentation-governance engine). I need to add a new check rule: \\\"reports a document whose summary is empty.\\\" I need to understand the existing pattern for declaring and implementing rules so I can add a consistent one. Please investigate and report back with specifics (file paths, line numbers, exact YAML/Rust snippets):\\n\\n1. Where are check rules DECLARED in machine-readable form (not just prose doctrine)? Look at `taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/` and `.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/` — specifically bundle.yml files, and any top-level rule registry (e.g. a `rules.yml`, `check.yml`, or similar) in the taxonomy source. Find the YAML schema for a rule entry: what fields it has (id, severity, message, etc.), and what severity values exist (e.g. `error` vs `advisory` — CLAUDE.md in repo root describes this error/advisory split). Give me 2-3 full example rule declarations verbatim, including one that checks a front-matter/metadata field for presence or emptiness (e.g. summary, title) if one exists, and one lint-type rule (e.g. the \\\"retired_terms\\\" / stock-phrase rule, or line-break rule).\\n\\n2. Where are these rules IMPLEMENTED in the Rust engine? Look at `engine/crates/check/src/`. Find the module/file structure, how a single rule is implemented (a Rust function/struct), and specifically look for any existing rule that checks a document's front-matter field for presence/non-emptiness — e.g. is there a \\\"summary\\\" field in the document front matter schema at all? Search `engine/crates/doc/src/` for a `summary` field definition. Give me the exact file path and function/struct name of 1-2 example rule implementations, and show how a rule declared in YAML maps to a Rust implementation (what connects the rule id in YAML to the Rust code — a match statement, a trait registry, a macro, etc.)\\n\\n3. Is there already a `summary` field in the document schema (front matter)? If so where is it defined/validated (required vs optional) — check `engine/crates/doc/src/` and `docs/taxonomies/*/doctrine.md` for \\\"summary\\\" as a front-matter key.\\n\\n4. Find the fixtures pattern for check rules: `engine/crates/check/fixtures/` — pick one fixture directory for a similar rule (missing/empty field) and show its structure (what files it contains, accept vs reject cases).\\n\\nReport concisely: exact file paths with line numbers for every claim, and the full text of 2-3 example rule declarations and 1 example Rust implementation. Keep total report under 600 words plus the verbatim snippets.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59 -maxdepth 3 -iname \\\"*headwater*\\\" -o -iname \\\"taxonomy-source\\\" 2>/dev/null | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"true\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59\\nfind \\\"$ROOT/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard\\\" -maxdepth 3 | sort\\necho \\\"---\\\"\\nfind \\\"$ROOT/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard\\\" -maxdepth 3 | sort\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59\\ngrep -n \\\"error\\\\|advisory\\\" \\\"$ROOT/CLAUDE.md\\\" | head -30\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59\\nfind \\\"$ROOT/taxonomy-source\\\" -type f | sort\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59\\ncat \\\"$ROOT/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/conformance.yml\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59\\ncat \\\"$ROOT/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\\" | head -100\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59\\ngrep -n \\\"check\\\\|severity\\\\|advisory\\\\|error\\\" \\\"$ROOT/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/decision-record/bundle.yml\\\" | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59\\ngrep -rn \\\"^checks:\\\\|^ checks:\\\\|checks:$\\\" \\\"$ROOT/taxonomy-source\\\" \\\"$ROOT/.headwater/packages\\\" | head -30\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59\\ngrep -rln \\\"severity\\\" \\\"$ROOT/taxonomy-source\\\" \\\"$ROOT/.headwater/packages\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59\\ngrep -n \\\"severity\\\\|error\\\\|advisory\\\" \\\"$ROOT/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\\" | head -40\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59\\nwc -l \\\"$ROOT/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"^facets:\\\\|^kinds:\\\\|^relations:\\\\|^checks:\\\\|^dispositions:\\\\|^shelves:\\\" \\\"$ROOT/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59\\ngrep -n \\\"^[a-z_]*:$\\\\|^[a-z_]*:\\\\s*$\\\" \\\"$ROOT/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\\" | head -60\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59\\nsed -n '540,575p' \\\"$ROOT/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59\\nsed -n '933,1010p' \\\"$ROOT/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59\\ngrep -n \\\"posture:\\\" \\\"$ROOT/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\\" | sort | uniq -c\\necho \\\"---mechanisms---\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"mechanism: check:\\\" \\\"$ROOT/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59\\nsed -n '1280,1300p' \\\"$ROOT/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\\"\\necho \\\"=== facets section (summary/title) ===\\\"\\nsed -n '359,429p' \\\"$ROOT/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59\\ngrep -n \\\"OB-FACET-1:\\\\|OB-FACET-2:\\\\|OB-FACET-3:\\\" -A6 \\\"$ROOT/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59\\nfind \\\"$ROOT/engine/crates/check/src\\\" -type f | sort\\necho \\\"---doc---\\\"\\nfind \\\"$ROOT/engine/crates/doc/src\\\" -type f | sort\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59\\ngrep -n \\\"facet_blank\\\\|facet_required\\\\|\\\\\\\"check:\\\" \\\"$ROOT/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs\\\" | head -60\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59\\nsed -n '420,460p' \\\"$ROOT/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59\\nfind \\\"$ROOT/engine/crates/check/fixtures\\\" -maxdepth 1 -type d | sort | head -40\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59\\nfind \\\"$ROOT/engine/crates/check/fixtures/facet-values\\\" -maxdepth 2 | sort\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59/engine/crates/check/src/retired.rs"
result: "sha256:f5b731fb776bd69f60f0c9e65d04df7010f76cedbb783a817509504d83bcf934"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59\\ngrep -n \\\"enum Severity\\\" -A6 \\\"$ROOT/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs\\\"\\necho \\\"---retired_terms in taxonomy.yml---\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"retired_terms\\\" -A20 \\\"$ROOT/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\\" | head -40\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59\\nfind \\\"$ROOT/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check\\\" -maxdepth 2 | sort | head -30\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59\\ngrep -n \\\"Severity::\\\" \\\"$ROOT/engine/crates/check/src/retired.rs\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/05-no-summary.md"
result: "sha256:e93ab39ba0f3d03cf7593bc046d7c0a5aa0fbf102df0e02e2dbf34c263aa346d"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md"
result: "sha256:ab8d0eb139f3733cde3ca712a0f637ff8fe82f70fc93a55f87b27273fad00d57"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r59\\nsed -n '1,20p' \\\"$ROOT/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/evaluations/epsilon.md\\\" 2>/dev/null\\necho \\\"---\\\"\\ngrep -rn \\\"scent\\\" \\\"$ROOT/engine/crates/check/src/frontmatter.rs\\\" | head -10\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== facets summary/title ===\\\" && sed -n '355,400p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml && echo \\\"=== OB-FACET-1/3 ===\\\" && grep -n \\\"OB-FACET-1\\\\|OB-FACET-3\\\" -A8 .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -60 && echo \\\"=== CT-FACET-1/3 ===\\\" && grep -n \\\"CT-FACET-1\\\\|CT-FACET-3\\\" -A6 .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -40\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== finding.rs Severity ===\\\" && sed -n '1,70p' engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs | grep -n \\\"Severity\\\" -A6 && echo \\\"=== facet_required.rs RULE ===\\\" && grep -n \\\"RULE\\\\|Severity\\\" engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs | head -20 && echo \\\"=== facet_blank.rs RULE ===\\\" && grep -n \\\"RULE\\\\|Severity\\\" engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs | head -30 && echo \\\"=== lib.rs RULES count ===\\\" && grep -n \\\"RULES:\\\" engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && ls -la | head -30 && git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1\",\"description\":\"Check if directory is a git repository\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Map how a check rule is declared and implemented\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"This is the Headwater repository (a documentation-governance engine with a `headwater check` CLI). I need to add a new rule that reports a document whose \\\"summary\\\" field (likely YAML front matter) is empty, and I need to understand the existing convention for declaring and implementing rules before I add one.\\n\\nPlease investigate and report back:\\n\\n1. Where rules are DECLARED — look under `.headwater/packages/` (and possibly `docs/taxonomies/`) for a taxonomy/rule definition format. Find a rule that is similar in nature to \\\"field X is empty/missing\\\" (e.g. look for existing rules about missing/empty fields, like a missing title, missing front matter, or similar). Show the exact file and a full example entry (with all its keys: id, severity, category, etc.) so I can copy the shape exactly. Also find the master list/schema of valid severities (e.g. error vs advisory) and categories, and where the \\\"summary\\\" field is defined in a document's front matter schema (look under `docs/spec/` or similar for what \\\"summary\\\" means for a document).\\n\\n2. Where rules are IMPLEMENTED — look under `engine/` (Rust crate(s), e.g. `headwater-cli` or similar) for where these declared rules get executed in code. Find the implementation of a similar \\\"field is empty/missing\\\" rule (the same one you found in step 1) — show the file path, function/struct name, and roughly how it reads the rule id from the taxonomy and matches it to code. Look for a central registry/dispatch mapping rule ids to implementing functions.\\n\\n3. Find out how severity is determined/declared — is severity set in the taxonomy declaration (step 1) or in the Rust code (step 2) or both? Quote the exact lines.\\n\\n4. Check `.headwater/taxonomy.lock` or similar lock/manifest file to see if new rules need to be registered there too.\\n\\n5. Check for a CHANGELOG or \\\"how to add a rule\\\" doc — search docs/subsystems, docs/how-to, DEVELOPING.md, or any skill file (`.claude/skills/headwater-taxonomy/*`, `.claude/skills/headwater-engine/*`) that describes the step-by-step process of adding a new rule to this engine.\\n\\nReport file paths with line numbers/ranges throughout. Be thorough — this is the main piece of research driving an actual code change, so completeness matters more than brevity. Aim for a structured report, organized by the 5 points above.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6 -maxdepth 3 | head -100\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6\\necho \\\"=== .headwater ===\\\"\\nfind $ROOT/.headwater -maxdepth 4 2>/dev/null\\necho \\\"=== engine top ===\\\"\\nfind $ROOT/engine -maxdepth 3 2>/dev/null\\necho \\\"=== docs/spec ===\\\"\\nfind $ROOT/docs/spec -maxdepth 2 2>/dev/null\\necho \\\"=== .claude/skills ===\\\"\\nfind $ROOT/.claude -maxdepth 4 2>/dev/null\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6\\necho \\\"=== .headwater/packages ===\\\"\\nfind $ROOT/.headwater/packages -maxdepth 6 2>/dev/null\\necho \\\"=== taxonomy.lock search ===\\\"\\nfind $ROOT -iname \\\"*taxonomy*lock*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*taxonomy.lock*\\\" 2>/dev/null | grep -v node_modules\\necho \\\"=== engine dir ===\\\"\\nfind $ROOT -maxdepth 1\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6\\necho \\\"=== taxonomy-source ===\\\"\\nfind $ROOT/taxonomy-source -maxdepth 4 2>/dev/null\\necho \\\"=== engine/crates ===\\\"\\nfind $ROOT/engine/crates -maxdepth 2 2>/dev/null\\necho \\\"=== docs/spec ===\\\"\\nfind $ROOT/docs -maxdepth 1\\necho \\\"=== .claude/skills ===\\\"\\nfind $ROOT/.claude/skills -maxdepth 3 2>/dev/null\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6\\necho \\\"=== .claude ===\\\"\\nfind $ROOT/.claude -maxdepth 4 2>/dev/null\\necho \\\"=== docs/spec ===\\\"\\nfind $ROOT/docs/spec -maxdepth 2 2>/dev/null\\necho \\\"=== docs/taxonomies ===\\\"\\nfind $ROOT/docs/taxonomies -maxdepth 2 2>/dev/null\\necho \\\"=== docs/how-to ===\\\"\\nfind $ROOT/docs/how-to -maxdepth 2 2>/dev/null\\necho \\\"=== docs/subsystems (grep rule) ===\\\"\\nfind $ROOT/docs/subsystems -maxdepth 1 2>/dev/null\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6/engine/crates/check/src -maxdepth 3\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6\\necho \\\"=== register.rs ===\\\"\\ncat -n $ROOT/engine/crates/check/src/register.rs | head -150\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6\\ngrep -n \\\"facet_blank\\\\|facet_required\\\\|Blank::over\\\\|Required::over\\\" $ROOT/engine/crates/check/src/register.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6\\necho \\\"=== finding.rs Severity ===\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"enum Severity\\\\|Severity::\\\" $ROOT/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs | head -30\\necho \\\"=== meta-schema.yml severity/class/prevents ===\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"severity\\\\|class:\\\\|prevents\\\\|posture\\\\|enum:\\\" $ROOT/engine/crates/meta/meta-schema.yml | head -60\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6/engine/crates/meta/meta-schema.yml"
result: "sha256:0d1aa16b0e480df957cd26eff02af8402831c9847e4bc429ac3b3f988c4cf0e2"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6\\necho \\\"=== taxonomy.lock (head) ===\\\"\\nsed -n '1,80p' $ROOT/.headwater/taxonomy.lock\\necho \\\"=== grep facet.value.blank in lock ===\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet_blank\\\\|rules:\\\\|RULES\\\\|rule_digest\\\\|rules_digest\\\" $ROOT/.headwater/taxonomy.lock\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6\\ngrep -n \\\"new rule\\\\|add a rule\\\\|adding a rule\\\\|new check\\\\|generated, not written\\\\|five origins\\\" $ROOT/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md | head -40\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6\\necho \\\"=== DEVELOPING.md grep ===\\\"\\ngrep -n -i \\\"rule\\\\|taxonomy\\\\|check\\\" $ROOT/DEVELOPING.md | head -60\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6\\nwc -l $ROOT/docs/subsystems/checks-and-cache.md\\nsed -n '1,120p' $ROOT/docs/subsystems/checks-and-cache.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6\\necho \\\"=== CLAUDE.md grep rule ===\\\"\\ngrep -n -i \\\"add.*rule\\\\|new rule\\\\|RULES\\\\b\\\\|register()\\\\|registry()\\\" $ROOT/CLAUDE.md\\necho \\\"=== docs/spec/12-check-layer.md severity section ===\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"## \\\\|severity is the check\\\" $ROOT/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6\\ngrep -n \\\"facet_blank\\\\|facet.value.blank\\\" $ROOT/engine/crates/check/tests/fixtures.rs | head -30\\necho \\\"---\\\"\\ngrep -rn \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet_blank\\\" $ROOT/engine/crates/check/fixtures 2>/dev/null | head -20\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6\\nfind $ROOT/engine/crates/check/fixtures -iname \\\"*blank*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*facet*\\\" 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/05-no-summary.md"
result: "sha256:e93ab39ba0f3d03cf7593bc046d7c0a5aa0fbf102df0e02e2dbf34c263aa346d"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6/engine/crates/check/tests/fixtures.rs"
result: "sha256:7b17c7814d7d48dc348043a7ac9daad7c6839f90f2bdbf21996b66ccc6f34749"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md"
result: "sha256:ab8d0eb139f3733cde3ca712a0f637ff8fe82f70fc93a55f87b27273fad00d57"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6\\ngrep -n \\\"18-blank-facets\\\\|facet_blank::RULE\\\\|blank_facet\\\\|blank facet\\\" $ROOT/engine/crates/check/tests/fixtures.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6\\nsed -n '1,20p' $ROOT/engine/crates/check/fixtures/editions.ledger\\necho \\\"---\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"editions.ledger\\\\|VERSION\\\" $ROOT/engine/crates/check/tests/editions.rs | head -20\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6\\ngrep -n \\\"package.yml\\\\|headwater/standard\\\" $ROOT/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/package.yml 2>/dev/null | head -5\\nls -la $ROOT/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml $ROOT/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml 2>/dev/null\\ndiff -q $ROOT/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml $ROOT/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r6\\nfile $ROOT/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\nls -la $ROOT/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/ | head -5\\ncat $ROOT/.headwater/README.md | head -40\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary:\\\" -A4 taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check summary facet declaration in taxonomy source\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== OB-FACET-3 ===\\\"; grep -n \\\"OB-FACET-3:\\\" -A8 taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"=== CT-FACET-3 ===\\\"; grep -n \\\"CT-FACET-3:\\\" -A12 taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"=== facet_blank.rs RULE + severity ===\\\"; grep -n \\\"RULE\\\\|Severity::\\\" engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs\\necho \\\"=== vendored copy matches source? ===\\\"; diff <(sed -n '1,50p' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml) <(sed -n '1,50p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml) | head -5\\n\",\"description\":\"Confirm obligation, control, and rule implementation details\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r60"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo \\\"---\\\" && find . -maxdepth 2 -type d | head -50\",\"description\":\"List top-level repo contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find ./.headwater/packages -maxdepth 3 | head -80\",\"description\":\"List headwater packages structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find ./docs/taxonomies -maxdepth 3 | head -80\",\"description\":\"List docs/taxonomies structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find ./engine -maxdepth 4 -type d\",\"description\":\"List engine crate structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,200p' ./.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -250\",\"description\":\"View taxonomy.yml header/structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "./.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '370,440p' ./.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"View summary facet declaration in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "./engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls ./engine/crates/check/src\",\"description\":\"List check crate source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r60/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r60/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "./engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r61"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".headwater/packages/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/taxonomies/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r61/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r61/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r61/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r61/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r61/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r61/engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r61/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat \\\"/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r61/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md\\\"\",\"description\":\"Read blank-facets fixture\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r61/engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r61/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r61/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r62"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls && echo --- && find .headwater -maxdepth 3 -type d 2>/dev/null && echo --- && find docs/taxonomies -maxdepth 2 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List repo root and taxonomy directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/taxonomies"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater/packages/headwater-standard -maxdepth 4 -type f | head -100\",\"description\":\"List files under headwater-standard package\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"retired_term\",\"output_mode\":\"files_with_matches\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine -maxdepth 3 -type d; echo ---; find engine -iname \\\"*rule*\\\" -type d\",\"description\":\"Explore engine crate structure for rules\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r62/engine/crates/check/src/shape.rs"
result: "sha256:9fef54f6760d4bdf2822bdad2e975a4adba4f775446454bb0a5c228da7246067"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r62/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"scent\",\"output_mode\":\"content\",\"-n\":true}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r62/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r62/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r62/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r62/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r63"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls -la\",\"description\":\"Check if directory is a git repository and list contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r63/.headwater -maxdepth 4 -type d; echo \\\"---files---\\\"; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r63/.headwater -maxdepth 4 -type f | head -80\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r63/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/doctrine -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List doctrine files under headwater-standard package\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r63/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/doctrine/starter.md"
result: "sha256:0fa70c1338a7e24ec5a3e0f8202cceffb1ea53182ce2ba91341a8ecf8d1e104a"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r63/.headwater"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r63/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r63/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r63/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r63/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r63/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r64"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls && echo --- && ls .headwater && echo --- && ls engine 2>/dev/null | head -50\",\"description\":\"List repo root, .headwater, and engine directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Find existing rule pattern for empty-field checks\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"I'm working in the Headwater repo at /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r64. This repo has an engine (Rust, under engine/crates/) that implements \\\"rules\\\" (checks) run by `headwater check`, and rules are declared in a taxonomy (under .headwater/packages/ and/or taxonomy-source/, with .headwater/taxonomy.yml as a generated/compiled projection, per docs/decisions and docs/spec).\\n\\nI need to add a NEW rule that reports a document whose `summary` field (front matter) is empty. To do this correctly I need to understand the existing pattern precisely, by finding an EXISTING rule that is similar in nature — specifically a rule that checks a front-matter field for emptiness or presence (e.g. something like \\\"document has no summary\\\", \\\"field is empty\\\", \\\"title is empty\\\", or similar structural/presence checks, as opposed to prose-style checks like line-wrap or spelling).\\n\\nPlease report, with exact file paths and line numbers:\\n1. Where rules are DECLARED — find the taxonomy package file(s) under .headwater/packages/ or taxonomy-source/ that declare an existing presence/emptiness-style rule (not a prose-style rule like hard-wrap or stock-phrase). Show the full declaration block for one such rule (its id, name, description, severity/category fields, whatever schema is used).\\n2. Where that same rule is IMPLEMENTED in the Rust engine — find the crate and file (e.g. under engine/crates/*/src/) that implements the check logic, and show the function/struct that implements it, including how it reports a finding (what severity enum/type it uses, e.g. Error vs Advisory/Warning).\\n3. How severity is modeled overall: find the enum or type definition for rule severity (e.g. Error/Advisory) in the Rust code, and how the taxonomy declaration's severity field maps to it (is severity declared in the taxonomy source, or computed/hardcoded in the engine, or both?).\\n4. Find the schema/struct in Rust that models a rule declaration as read from the taxonomy (so I know what fields a new rule declaration needs: id, applies_to, severity, message template, etc.)\\n5. If there's a CONTRIBUTING-style doc or docs/subsystems doc describing \\\"how to add a new rule to the engine\\\", find and summarize it.\\n\\nReport file paths with line numbers for everything, and quote the relevant snippets (keep quotes short, just enough to show the shape). This is pure research — do not edit anything.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls && echo --- && find .headwater -maxdepth 4 -type d && echo --- && find taxonomy-source -maxdepth 4 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List repo root and taxonomy directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine/crates -maxdepth 3 -type d\",\"description\":\"List engine crates directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls .headwater/packages && echo --- && ls taxonomy-source 2>/dev/null && echo --- && ls engine/crates\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy packages, taxonomy-source, and engine crates\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n -i \\\"empty\\\\|no-summary\\\\|has-no\\\\|missing\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r64/.headwater/taxonomy.yml | head -80\",\"description\":\"Search taxonomy.yml for empty/presence rule names\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find taxonomy-source/headwater-standard -maxdepth 3 -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List files under taxonomy-source/headwater-standard\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r64/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard -maxdepth 2 -type f\",\"description\":\"List files directly under headwater-standard package\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r64/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles -maxdepth 2 -type f\",\"description\":\"List bundle rule files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r64/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r64/.headwater/*.yml 2>/dev/null; echo ---; grep -n -i \\\"rule\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r64/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -40\",\"description\":\"Check top level yml and rule mentions\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r64/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r64/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r64/.headwater/taxonomy.yml; echo ---; cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r64/.headwater/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Check line counts and top-level taxonomy.yml content\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r64/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r64\\necho \\\"=== rules in vendored taxonomy.yml ===\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"^ - id:\\\\|^ id:\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -100\",\"description\":\"List rule ids in vendored taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r64\\ndiff -q .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Compare vendored and source taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r64/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r64\\ngrep -n \\\"id:\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -60\\necho \\\"---structure sample---\\\"\\nsed -n '1,60p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Inspect taxonomy.yml structure and rule id listings\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r64/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r64\\nls engine/crates/check/src\\necho ---\\ngrep -rn \\\"summary\\\" engine/crates/check/src taxonomy-source .headwater/packages 2>/dev/null | grep -v \\\"\\\\.lock\\\" | head -60\",\"description\":\"List check crate source files and search for summary references\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r64/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r64/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r64\\ngrep -rn \\\"facet.required.missing\\\\|facet.value.blank\\\" --include=\\\"*.yml\\\" --include=\\\"*.md\\\" . 2>/dev/null | grep -v \\\"^Binary\\\"\",\"description\":\"Find where rule ids are referenced across yaml and docs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r64\\nsed -n '1,400p' docs/spec/12-check-layer.md | grep -n \\\"origin\\\\|Shape\\\\|generated\\\\|Severity\\\\|severity\\\" | head -80\",\"description\":\"Search check-layer spec for origin and severity discussion\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r64/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r64/docs/decisions/0058-a-blank-facet-value-is-a-rule-of-its-own-and-it-reads-every-string-facet.md"
result: "sha256:7c1e03d300ff01f37bf38245f8adbfb1b6ef00e6dcc45839abd740efdb29ad21"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r64\\nsed -n '370,440p' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Show summary facet declaration and facets.require block\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r64\\nsed -n '960,1010p' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Show obligation/control block for facet.required.missing\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r64\\nsed -n '1255,1300p' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Show obligation/control block for facet.value.blank\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r64\\ngrep -n \\\"OB-FACET-1:\\\\|OB-FACET-3:\\\\|^obligations:\\\\|^controls:\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Find obligation declarations block start and OB-FACET entries\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "TaskStop"
argument: "{\"task_id\":\"a6a0699534ef7cd16\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r65"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo --- && cat .headwater/corpus.json 2>/dev/null | head -100\",\"description\":\"List working directory and inspect corpus descriptor\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r65/.headwater/packages -maxdepth 4 2>/dev/null; echo ---; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r65/docs/taxonomies -maxdepth 3 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy package layout\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,120p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"View start of taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -80\",\"description\":\"Search taxonomy.yml for summary field\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r65/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"relation.target.suspect\\\\|lifecycle.deletion.not_permitted\\\" engine docs --include=*.rs --include=*.md -l 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Find where rule identifiers are declared and implemented\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l engine/crates/resolve/src/rules.rs; sed -n '1,200p' engine/crates/resolve/src/rules.rs\",\"description\":\"View rule registry source\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls engine/crates/check/src/ | head -60\",\"description\":\"List check crate source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r65/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"facet.value.blank\\\" docs engine --include=*.md --include=*.rs | grep -v \\\"/fixtures/\\\"\",\"description\":\"Find all references to facet.value.blank rule\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"CT-FACET-3\\\\|OB-FACET-3\\\" .headwater docs --include=*.yml --include=*.md | grep -v fixtures\",\"description\":\"Locate control and obligation declarations for facet.value.blank\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r65/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r66"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r66\",\"description\":\"List top-level repo contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r66/.headwater/corpus.json 2>/dev/null | head -100\",\"description\":\"Read corpus descriptor\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r66/taxonomy-source -maxdepth 3 -type d | head -50\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy-source directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r66/engine -maxdepth 3 -type d | head -80\",\"description\":\"List engine directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r66/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/doctrine -maxdepth 2 | head -50\",\"description\":\"List doctrine directory contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r66/taxonomy-source"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r66/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r66/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r66/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r66"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r66/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml; grep -n \\\"^rules\\\\|^ rules\\\\|severity\\\\|category:\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r66/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -60\",\"description\":\"Check taxonomy.yml length and search for rules/severity keys\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r66/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r66/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r66/engine/crates/resolve/fixtures/corpus.taxonomy"
result: "sha256:b768fe795c8d44a882e8604a5012c2eb5f2b4d584e7445367dfb24bb21c3585d"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r66"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r66/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r66/engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r66/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r66/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r66/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r66"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r66/docs/obligations -iname \\\"0170-*\\\"\",\"description\":\"Find obligation 0170 document\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r66/docs/obligations/0170-the-blank-facet-value-rule-reaches-no-obligation-so-the-report-names-none.md"
result: "sha256:7ff80804e56d1a70febe2ecb2c5a5d9b26cc551571f98ac617a21b1af3ffd730"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r66/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r66/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r67"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls -la | head -30\",\"description\":\"Check if directory is a git repository\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la .git 2>&1; echo \\\"---\\\"; find / -maxdepth 4 -iname \\\"*.git\\\" -type d 2>/dev/null | head; echo \\\"---pwd---\\\"; pwd\",\"description\":\"Check for .git directory and search for repo root\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater -maxdepth 4 -type f | sort; echo \\\"---engine---\\\"; find engine -maxdepth 3 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List .headwater and engine directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r67/.headwater/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:0aa1b806b4bc44af26c12dc624643169bddb3583054e78db3873c23ca8e4bb12"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r67/taxonomy-source -maxdepth 6 -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy-source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r67/taxonomy-source"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r67/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r67/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r67/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard\\ngrep -n \\\"^ [a-z_]*:$\\\" taxonomy.yml | sed -n '1,200p' | awk -F: '$1>540 && $1<920'\\n\",\"description\":\"List rule identifiers between lines 540-920\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r67/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r67/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r67/engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r67/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r67"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r67\\ngrep -n \\\"HW-OBL-0170\\\" -r docs .headwater 2>/dev/null | head -20\",\"description\":\"Find references to HW-OBL-0170\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r67/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r67/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && git status 2>&1 | head -5\",\"description\":\"Check directory contents and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Find rule declaration and implementation pattern\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"This is the Headwater repository (a documentation-governance engine written in Rust under engine/, with a taxonomy of rules). I need to add a new rule that reports a document whose summary field is empty, and I need to understand the existing convention for declaring and implementing rules so I can follow it exactly.\\n\\nPlease find and report back (with file paths and line numbers/snippets):\\n\\n1. Where rules are DECLARED (taxonomy definition) — likely under `.headwater/packages/`, `docs/taxonomies/`, or `taxonomy-source/`. Find the taxonomy file(s) that list existing rules (e.g. look for rule IDs like something related to \\\"summary\\\", \\\"front matter\\\", \\\"empty\\\", or similar metadata-presence rules). Show the full declaration block for one or two example rules, including how severity (error vs advisory) is specified, and how the rule ID/namespace is structured.\\n\\n2. Where rules are IMPLEMENTED in the engine (Rust code under `engine/`). Find the source file(s) that implement checks on document metadata/front matter (e.g. title, summary, or similar fields). Show how an existing similar rule is implemented — the function/struct, how it reads a document's parsed front matter, how it registers as a \\\"finding\\\", and how severity is attached to the finding in code.\\n\\n3. Is there an existing rule that already checks for an empty or missing \\\"summary\\\" field, or any other empty/missing metadata field (title, description, etc.)? If so give its rule ID and full location (declaration + implementation).\\n\\n4. What are the valid severity levels in this system (e.g. error vs advisory) and exactly how/where that enum or set of values is defined in the engine and in the taxonomy schema.\\n\\n5. Is there a \\\"document\\\" schema/frontmatter spec (e.g. docs/spec/ or docs/obligations/) that defines what fields a document is required to have, including \\\"summary\\\"? Point to it.\\n\\nReport file paths, line numbers, and short verbatim snippets. Keep the report focused and under 500 lines — this is a research task, do not edit anything.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68/docs/decisions/0014-discovery-surface.md"
result: "sha256:6eef63703f179a2d9b738bee73916ef271b405fe7cd290bf2a47cf8d2a59b830"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68 -maxdepth 3 -not -path '*/node_modules/*' -not -path '*/.git/*' | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level directories of repo\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find . -maxdepth 2 -not -path '*/.git*' -not -path '*/.agents*' -not -path '*/.claude*' | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level dirs excluding agent configs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68/.headwater -maxdepth 4 -type d\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find ./taxonomy-source -maxdepth 4 -type d | sort; echo \\\"---\\\"; find ./taxonomy-source -iname '*.yml' -o -iname '*.yaml' -o -iname '*.toml' | xargs grep -l \\\"summary\\\\|front.matter\\\\|frontmatter\\\" 2>/dev/null | head -30\",\"description\":\"Explore taxonomy-source structure and find summary-related files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68/.headwater/packages"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Count lines in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"---\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"^ [a-z0-9_.-]*:$\\\\|^rules:\\\\|^facets:\\\\|^ - id:\\\\|id:\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -60\",\"description\":\"Check taxonomy.yml structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68/.headwater/packages -maxdepth 4 | sort | head -50\\necho \\\"---docs/taxonomies---\\\"\\nfind /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68/docs/taxonomies -maxdepth 4 | sort | head -50\",\"description\":\"List packages and docs/taxonomies dirs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68\\necho \\\"== severity/advisory in taxonomy-source ==\\\"\\ngrep -rn \\\"severity\\\\|advisory\\\" taxonomy-source/ .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml docs/taxonomies/*/bundle.yml 2>/dev/null | head -40\\necho \\\"== diff packages vs source ==\\\"\\ndiff .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml && echo SAME\",\"description\":\"Search for severity/advisory keywords in taxonomy files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68/engine\\nfind . -maxdepth 3 -name \\\"Cargo.toml\\\" | sort\\necho \\\"---\\\"\\nfind . -path '*/src*' -iname \\\"*.rs\\\" | xargs grep -l \\\"enum Severity\\\" 2>/dev/null\\necho \\\"---check dirs---\\\"\\nfind . -type d -iname \\\"*check*\\\" -o -type d -iname \\\"*rule*\\\" | grep -v target\",\"description\":\"Find crates and severity enum, check/rule dirs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68/engine/crates/check\\nfind . -path '*/src*' -iname \\\"*.rs\\\" | grep -v target | sort\",\"description\":\"List check crate source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"posture:\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | sort -t: -k3 | uniq -c -f2 | sort -rn\",\"description\":\"Count distinct posture values in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68\\necho \\\"=== facet_required.rs head ===\\\"\\nsed -n '1,40p' engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs\\necho \\\"=== RULE const in facet_required.rs ===\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"pub const RULE\\\\|impl DocumentCheck\\\\|fn evaluate\\\\|Severity::\\\" engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs\",\"description\":\"Peek at facet_required.rs rule id and severity\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68\\necho \\\"=== controls: section ===\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"^controls:\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\nsed -n '/^controls:/,/^[a-z_]*:$/p' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | grep -n \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet.required.missing\\\" \\necho \\\"=== context around those matches in full file ===\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet.required.missing\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Find controls mapping rule ids to obligations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68\\nsed -n '1278,1292p' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"=== distinct posture values ===\\\"\\ngrep -oP \\\"posture: \\\\w+\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | sort -u\\necho \\\"=== distinct severity values (obligations) ===\\\"\\ngrep -oP \\\"severity: \\\\w+\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | sort -u\",\"description\":\"Show facet.value.blank control block and enumerate posture/severity value sets\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68\\ngrep -n \\\"OB-FACET-3\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"---\\\"\\nsed -n '/OB-FACET-3:/,/^$/p' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -10\\necho \\\"=== docs/spec files ===\\\"\\nls docs/spec\\necho \\\"=== doc schema / obligations mention ===\\\"\\ngrep -rln \\\"summary\\\" docs/spec docs/obligations 2>/dev/null | head -10\",\"description\":\"Find OB-FACET-3 obligation text and docs/spec listing\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68/engine/crates/generate/fixtures/differential/decisions/0002-no-summary.md"
result: "sha256:9cadd0d75b7d39aedf9b2a045ae5d40957cc7b6ac74f1207003242edf9886adb"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68\\necho \\\"=== 12-check-layer.md severity section ===\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"^#.*[Ss]everity\\\\|error.*warn.*info\\\\|^### \\\" docs/spec/12-check-layer.md | head -20\\necho \\\"=== 02-taxonomy-model.md facets section header ===\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"^#.*[Ff]acet\\\" docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md | head -10\",\"description\":\"Find severity section in spec 12 and facets section in spec 02\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine -iname \\\"*facet_blank*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*blank*\\\" | grep -v target\",\"description\":\"Find facet_blank related test files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68/engine/crates/cli/tests/blank_facet.rs"
result: "sha256:2803c8c086f63283529fe721a2702cd8dcfd91e4754bdfa17b1423e2ed105143"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"forbid:\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Find all forbid directives in taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r68/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"enum Severity\\\" -A 10 engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs\",\"description\":\"Show Severity enum definition\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "TaskStop"
argument: "{\"task_id\":\"aab0ebe5e62aad4d2\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r69"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls && echo --- && find . -maxdepth 3 -iname \\\"*taxonom*\\\" && echo --- && find .headwater -maxdepth 3 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List repo root and find taxonomy-related paths\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== taxonomy-source file ===\\\"; wc -l taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml; echo \\\"=== grep summary in taxonomy-source ===\\\"; grep -n -i \\\"summary\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml; echo \\\"=== engine dir structure ===\\\"; find engine -maxdepth 3 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"Inspect taxonomy source for summary field and engine directory layout\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r69/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== grep severity in taxonomy-source ===\\\"; grep -n \\\"severity\\\\|^rules:\\\\|^ rules:\\\\|check:\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -50\",\"description\":\"Search for rule/severity declarations in taxonomy source\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r69/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r69/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd engine/crates/check/src && ls -la && echo \\\"=== grep register ===\\\" && grep -rn \\\"fn register\\\\|pub const ID\\\\|\\\\\\\"check:\\\" . | head -60\",\"description\":\"List check crate source files and find rule registration pattern\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r69/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet_blank\\\\|Blank::over\\\\|FACET-1\\\\|facet.required.missing\\\" register.rs | head -40\",\"description\":\"Check how the blank-facet rule is registered and wired\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"facet_blank\\\\|facet\\\\.value\\\\.blank\\\\|Blank\\\" lib.rs register.rs | head -40\",\"description\":\"Search lib.rs and register.rs for the Blank rule wiring\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r69 && grep -n \\\"facet.value.blank\\\" -r taxonomy-source docs .headwater 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Search for references to facet.value.blank rule id across taxonomy source and docs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n -A6 \\\"OB-FACET-3:\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml && echo --- && grep -n -A6 \\\"CT-FACET-3:\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Check OB-FACET-3 and CT-FACET-3 declarations for severity\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r7"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r7 -maxdepth 2 | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level repo structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r7/.headwater -maxdepth 3 | sort\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git status 2>&1 | head -20; echo \\\"---\\\"; git rev-parse --show-toplevel 2>&1\",\"description\":\"Check if directory is actually a git repo\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r7/taxonomy-source -maxdepth 4 | sort\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy-source structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r7/engine/crates -maxdepth 2 | sort\",\"description\":\"List engine crates\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r7/.claude -iname \\\"*taxonomy*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*engine*\\\" | sort\",\"description\":\"Find headwater-taxonomy and headwater-engine skill files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r7/engine/crates/check/src -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List check crate source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r7/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r7/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"summary\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r7/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -50\",\"description\":\"Search taxonomy for summary facet declaration\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rln \\\"summary\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r7/docs/taxonomies/ /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r7/.headwater/ 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Search docs/taxonomies and .headwater for summary references\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r7/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"facet_blank\\\\|facet_required\\\\|Blank::over\\\\|Required::over\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r7/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r7/engine/crates/check/src/register.rs 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Find where facet_blank and facet_required checks are registered\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,120p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r7/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md 2>/dev/null | head -150\",\"description\":\"Read spec 12 check layer doc intro\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r7/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r7/docs/decisions/0058-a-blank-facet-value-is-a-rule-of-its-own-and-it-reads-every-string-facet.md"
result: "sha256:7c1e03d300ff01f37bf38245f8adbfb1b6ef00e6dcc45839abd740efdb29ad21"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r70"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la | head -30 && echo --- && git status 2>&1 | head -5\",\"description\":\"Check directory contents and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-engine\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Find rule declaration and implementation pattern\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"I'm working in the Headwater repository at /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r70. I need to add a new check rule to the engine that reports a document whose \\\"summary\\\" field (front matter) is empty. To do this correctly I need to understand the existing convention for how a rule is declared and implemented. Specifically:\\n\\n1. Where is the taxonomy of rules declared? Look under `.headwater/packages/` and `docs/taxonomies/` and `taxonomy-source/`. Find the file(s) that declare existing rules (e.g. things like a rule for retired terms, hard-wrapped markdown, British spelling, document summary, front matter fields). Show me the exact structure/schema used to declare a rule (fields like id, severity, description, remedy kind - mechanical vs rewrite, category error vs advisory).\\n\\n2. Where is the engine code that implements rule checks? Look under `engine/` (likely a Rust crate `headwater-cli` or similar, per CLAUDE.md \\\"headwater-cli\\\"). Find how an existing simple rule (ideally one that checks a front-matter field like \\\"summary\\\" being present/non-empty, or similar metadata rules like \\\"title\\\" or \\\"status\\\") is implemented - the file path, function/struct names, and how severity (error vs advisory) is wired in code.\\n\\n3. Find any existing rule that is closest in spirit to \\\"document summary is empty\\\" — e.g. a rule checking required front matter fields are non-empty, or a \\\"missing summary\\\" / \\\"empty field\\\" rule already existing elsewhere (maybe for a different field). Show its exact declaration and implementation so I can mirror the pattern exactly.\\n\\n4. Also check `docs/acceptance-criteria/` or `docs/requirements/` for any existing acceptance criteria document describing an \\\"empty field\\\" or \\\"empty summary\\\" rule, since Headwater seems to require acceptance criteria docs per rule.\\n\\nReport back: exact file paths and line numbers/snippets for (a) the taxonomy declaration pattern, (b) the engine implementation pattern for a similar rule, (c) how severity error vs advisory is represented in both layers, (d) whether a \\\"summary\\\" front-matter field already exists in the document schema and where it's defined/required. Be thorough — this determines how I write the new rule. Keep your final report under 600 words but include exact paths and code/config snippets.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 4 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---\\\"; find docs/taxonomies -maxdepth 3 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---\\\"; find taxonomy-source -maxdepth 3 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine -maxdepth 5 -iname \\\"*.rs\\\" 2>/dev/null | head -100; echo \\\"---TOPLEVEL---\\\"; ls -la\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\\|retired\\\\|hard.wrap\\\\|british\\\\|spelling\\\" -i taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml; sed -n '1,80p' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r70/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r70/engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '400,440p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r70/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r70/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r70/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r70/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r70/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '340,400p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r70/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r70/engine/crates/check/src/fill.rs"
result: "sha256:2e0e2078ab63cb143e16431d279a5afa1321c284b3b2e98421ce922534437a7b"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r70/docs/acceptance-criteria -iname \\\"*blank*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*summary*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*facet*\\\" 2>/dev/null; echo ---; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r70/docs/requirements -iname \\\"*blank*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*summary*\\\" 2>/dev/null; ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r70/docs/acceptance-criteria | head -30\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r70/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,40p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r70/docs/decisions/0058-a-blank-facet-value-is-a-rule-of-its-own-and-it-reads-every-string-facet.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r70/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r70/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r70/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r70/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r71"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r71/.headwater -maxdepth 4 -type d; echo ---; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r71/.headwater -maxdepth 2 -type f\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r71/.headwater/packages"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r71/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/doctrine"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== taxonomy.yml (top level) ===\\\"; sed -n '1,80p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r71/.headwater/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"=== package taxonomy.yml ===\\\"; sed -n '1,120p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r71/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Inspect taxonomy.yml files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r71/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r71/engine -maxdepth 3 -type d 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List engine directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r71/engine/crates/check/src -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List files in check crate src\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r71/engine/crates"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r71/engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r71/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/05-no-summary.md"
result: "sha256:e93ab39ba0f3d03cf7593bc046d7c0a5aa0fbf102df0e02e2dbf34c263aa346d"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r71/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r71/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r71/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r71/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -50\",\"description\":\"Search taxonomy.yml for summary facet declaration\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r71/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r71/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r71/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"facet_blank\\\\|facet_required\\\\|Blank::over\\\\|Required::over\\\\|mod facet_\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r71/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs\",\"description\":\"Find where facet_blank and facet_required rules are registered in lib.rs\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r72"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo --- && find . -maxdepth 2 -iname \\\"*.git*\\\" 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List repo root and check for git\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== .headwater ===\\\"; find .headwater -maxdepth 3 | sort\\necho \\\"=== engine ===\\\"; find engine -maxdepth 3 -type d | sort\\necho \\\"=== docs/taxonomies ===\\\"; find docs/taxonomies -maxdepth 2 2>/dev/null | sort\",\"description\":\"Explore headwater config, engine, and taxonomy directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== taxonomy.yml rules grep ===\\\"; grep -n \\\"summary\\\" .headwater/taxonomy.yml | head -50\\necho \\\"=== rule entries structure sample ===\\\"; grep -n \\\"^ - id:\\\\|^ id:\\\\|rule\\\" .headwater/taxonomy.yml | head -30\",\"description\":\"Search taxonomy.yml for summary-related rules\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== taxonomy-source ===\\\"; find taxonomy-source -maxdepth 4 | sort\\necho \\\"=== grep summary across docs taxonomies and headwater ===\\\"; grep -rln \\\"summary\\\" .headwater docs/taxonomies taxonomy-source 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Explore taxonomy-source dir and find summary references\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\ngrep -n \\\"summary\\\\|rule:\\\\|rules:\\\\|severity\\\\|check:\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -80\",\"description\":\"Inspect taxonomy.yml source for rule/severity declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r72/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine/crates/check/src -type f | sort\\necho \\\"---\\\"\\ngrep -rn \\\"facet.required.missing\\\\|facet.value.not_permitted\\\\|register\\\" engine/crates/check/src | head -60\",\"description\":\"List check crate source files and find rule registration\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r72/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet\\\\.value\\\\.blank\\\" --include=\\\"*.yml\\\" --include=\\\"*.md\\\" --include=\\\"*.rs\\\" . 2>/dev/null | grep -v \\\"/target/\\\" | grep -v \\\"fixtures/n8n\\\"\",\"description\":\"Find all references to the facet.value.blank rule\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r72/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"CT-FACET-3\\\\|OB-FACET-3\\\" -r taxonomy-source docs/obligations/0170* 2>/dev/null\\necho \\\"---lib.rs rule list---\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"facet_blank\\\\|Blank::over\\\\|facet_required::\\\\|facet_value::\\\" engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs\",\"description\":\"Check source taxonomy for control declaration and lib.rs registration\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r73"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls && echo --- && ls .headwater && echo --- && ls docs/taxonomies 2>/dev/null && echo --- && ls engine\",\"description\":\"List repo root, .headwater, docs/taxonomies, engine dirs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls .headwater/packages && echo --- && cat .headwater/taxonomy.yml | head -100\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy packages and show taxonomy.yml head\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls engine/crates\",\"description\":\"List engine crates\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find taxonomy-source/headwater-standard -maxdepth 3 | head -100\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy-source/headwater-standard structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rl \\\"summary\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard | head -50\",\"description\":\"Search taxonomy source for existing summary references\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find taxonomy-source/headwater-standard -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List all directories under taxonomy-source/headwater-standard\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater/packages/headwater-standard -maxdepth 4 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List vendored package directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r73/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/package.yml"
result: "sha256:1c279ed7d5020d4a38a9583a478b42678ae4640b0a75b01dacc50814069cc0dc"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find docs/taxonomies/design-spec -maxdepth 2 | sort\",\"description\":\"List design-spec taxonomy directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r73/docs/taxonomies/design-spec/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:8e8b03d0d2e6bf2044c68d86e327887e851cb0736a9b642a89205358062669ff"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml && grep -n \\\"^checks\\\\|^ checks\\\\|severity\\\\|summary\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -80\",\"description\":\"Inspect base taxonomy.yml for checks and summary\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r73/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^checks:\\\\|^ [a-z_]*\\\\.[a-z_]*:\\\\|^ [a-z_]*:$\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | sed -n '1,200p'\",\"description\":\"Find checks block top-level keys\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r73/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd engine/crates/check && find . -name \\\"*.rs\\\" | xargs grep -ln \\\"OB-FACET-1\\\\|required\\\" | head -20\",\"description\":\"Find files referencing OB-FACET-1 or required facet check\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r73/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"summary\\\" src/facet_blank.rs tests/*.rs 2>/dev/null | head -30; echo ---; find . -iname \\\"*blank*\\\"; echo ---; grep -rln \\\"facet.value.blank\\\" . | head -20\",\"description\":\"Search for summary and facet.value.blank references in check crate\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r73/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md"
result: "sha256:ab8d0eb139f3733cde3ca712a0f637ff8fe82f70fc93a55f87b27273fad00d57"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"18-blank-facets\\\\|facet_blank\\\\|facet.value.blank\\\" tests/fixtures.rs | head -30\",\"description\":\"Find test referencing 18-blank-facets fixture\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r73/engine/crates/check/tests/fixtures.rs"
result: "sha256:7b17c7814d7d48dc348043a7ac9daad7c6839f90f2bdbf21996b66ccc6f34749"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"blank-facets\\\\|facet.value.blank\\\" fixtures/check.report | head -20\",\"description\":\"Search golden report for blank-facets entries\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,20p;170,185p;320,324p' fixtures/check.report\",\"description\":\"Show report header and the blank-rule obligation line and one relevant entry\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r74"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo \\\"---\\\" && test -d .git && echo \\\"has .git\\\" || echo \\\"no .git\\\"\",\"description\":\"List working directory contents and check for git\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 3 -type d 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---taxonomy-source---\\\"; find taxonomy-source -maxdepth 4 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---engine crates---\\\"; find engine -maxdepth 2 -type d 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Explore taxonomy and engine directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== taxonomy.yml ===\\\"; cat taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -200\",\"description\":\"View taxonomy.yml rule declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== grep summary in taxonomy-source ===\\\"; grep -n \\\"summary\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -50\\necho \\\"=== grep facets.require/summary in taxonomy ===\\\"; grep -n \\\"facets:\\\" -A 20 taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -80\",\"description\":\"Search taxonomy for existing 'summary' field declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r74/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^obligations:\\\\|^controls:\\\\|OB-FACET\\\\|CT-FACET\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -40\",\"description\":\"Find obligations/controls sections and FACET-related rules\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r74/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r74/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== posture values ===\\\"; grep -n \\\"posture:\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | sort | uniq -c -f3 | sort -rn | head -5\\ngrep -o \\\"posture: [a-z]*\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | sort | uniq -c\\necho \\\"=== check crate structure ===\\\"\\nfind engine/crates/check -maxdepth 3 -type f | head -60\",\"description\":\"List posture values and check crate file structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine/crates/check/src -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List check crate source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r74/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|FACET-3\\\\|OB-FACET-3\\\\|CT-FACET-3\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Find obligation/control entries referencing facet.value.blank\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r74/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine/crates/check -iname \\\"*blank*\\\"; echo \\\"---\\\"; grep -rn \\\"summary\\\" engine/crates/check/fixtures/*.taxonomy.yml 2>/dev/null | head -20; echo \\\"---tests---\\\"; find engine/crates/check -path \\\"*tests*\\\" -iname \\\"*blank*\\\"\",\"description\":\"Find existing fixtures/tests for the blank-facet rule\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r74/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md"
result: "sha256:ab8d0eb139f3733cde3ca712a0f637ff8fe82f70fc93a55f87b27273fad00d57"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r75"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo --- && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"List repo root and check git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find docs/taxonomies -maxdepth 3 2>&1 | head -50; echo ---; find .headwater -maxdepth 3 2>&1; echo ---; find engine -maxdepth 4 -type d 2>&1\",\"description\":\"Explore taxonomy and engine directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"summary\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -30\",\"description\":\"Search taxonomy.yml for summary field declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls engine/crates/check/src; echo ---; grep -rln \\\"summary\\\" engine/crates/check/src engine/crates/meta/src 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List check crate source files and search for summary references\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r75/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r75/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"Blank\\\\|facet_blank\\\\|facet_required\\\\|Required\\\" engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs | head -40\",\"description\":\"Find where Blank/Required checks are registered in lib.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r75/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r76"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r76\",\"description\":\"List top-level repo contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r76/.headwater -maxdepth 3 -type d\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-engine\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r76/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard -type f | head -100\",\"description\":\"List files under headwater-standard package\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r76/engine -maxdepth 3 -type d\",\"description\":\"List engine directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" -r /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r76/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -50\",\"description\":\"Search taxonomy.yml for summary field references\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r76/engine/crates/check/src\",\"description\":\"List check crate source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r76/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r76/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r76/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r76/engine/crates/check/fixtures /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r76/engine/crates/check/tests -iname \\\"*blank*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*facet*\\\" 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Find fixtures/tests related to facet blank rule\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet.required.missing\\\\|facet_blank\\\\|facet_required\\\" -r /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r76/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r76/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/conformance.yml 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Search for rule registration and conformance entries\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r76/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md"
result: "sha256:ab8d0eb139f3733cde3ca712a0f637ff8fe82f70fc93a55f87b27273fad00d57"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" -r /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r76/engine/crates/check/tests/facet_values.rs\",\"description\":\"Check facet_values test for summary coverage\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r77"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && ls -la && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r77/.headwater/packages -maxdepth 4 -type f | head -100\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy package files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r77/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r77/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r77/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r77/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r77/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/conformance.yml"
result: "sha256:47ef5283be6f8872d13ebf1cd12fb7bd644efd015d23c8e9071e248f8d6f5904"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r77/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r77/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"CT-FACET\\\\|OB-FACET\\\\|facet.value.blank\\\" -A5 -B15 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r77/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -150\",\"description\":\"Search for facet value blank rule and its obligation\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r77/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r77/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r77/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r77/engine/crates/cli/tests/blank_facet.rs /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r77/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Check if summary facet is covered by blank-facet tests\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r78"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Inspect working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"rule that reports a document whose summary is empty; where rules are declared in the taxonomy and where severities (error vs advisory) are assigned\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la .claude/skills/ 2>&1; echo \\\"---agents---\\\"; ls -la .claude/agents/ 2>&1\",\"description\":\"List available skills and agents directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"== .headwater tree ==\\\"; find .headwater -maxdepth 3 -type d; echo; echo \\\"== .headwater packages ==\\\"; find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 4 2>/dev/null; echo; echo \\\"== docs/taxonomies ==\\\"; find docs/taxonomies -maxdepth 3 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Explore .headwater and taxonomy directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"== overlay.yml ==\\\"; cat .headwater/overlay.yml 2>&1 | head -100; echo; echo \\\"== taxonomy.yml (headwater-standard) head ==\\\"; sed -n '1,80p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Show overlay.yml and taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"== grep severity in taxonomy sources ==\\\"; grep -rn \\\"severity\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/*.yml | head -50\",\"description\":\"Search for severity declarations in taxonomy package\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '500,570p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"== summary in taxonomy pkg ==\\\"; grep -rn \\\"summary\\\" .headwater/packages/ | head -40; echo; echo \\\"== checks: section header ==\\\"; grep -n \\\"^checks:\\\\|^ checks:\\\\|^rules:\\\\|^ - id:\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -20\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r78/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"== engine tree ==\\\"; find engine -maxdepth 3 -type d; echo; echo \\\"== search 'required' facet enforcement in engine src ==\\\"; grep -rln \\\"required\\\" engine/*/src engine/**/src 2>/dev/null | head -20\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"== check crate layout ==\\\"; find engine/crates/check -maxdepth 2 -type f -name \\\"*.rs\\\"; echo; echo \\\"== grep is_empty in check crate ==\\\"; grep -rln \\\"is_empty\\\" engine/crates/check/src; echo; echo \\\"== grep 'required' in check crate (rust files) ==\\\"; grep -rln \\\"required\\\" engine/crates/check/src\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r78/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"== Severity enum ==\\\"; sed -n '1,60p' engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs | grep -n \\\"enum Severity\\\" -A 15; echo; echo \\\"== forbid: summary anywhere in taxonomy package? ==\\\"; grep -rn \\\"forbid\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -20; echo; echo \\\"== facet_blank tests? ==\\\"; grep -rln \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet_blank\\\\|Blank\\\" engine/crates/check/tests/ 2>/dev/null; echo; echo \\\"== fixtures for blank ==\\\"; find engine/crates/check/fixtures -iname \\\"*blank*\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '55,90p' engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs; echo \\\"---fixture---\\\"; cat engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md; echo \\\"---fixtures.rs mentions---\\\"; grep -n \\\"blank-facets\\\\|facet.value.blank\\\" engine/crates/check/tests/fixtures.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,60p' engine/crates/check/tests/fixtures.rs | head -80; echo \\\"...\\\"; grep -n \\\"RULE\\\\|rule_dir\\\\|facet.value.blank\\\\|blank\\\" engine/crates/check/tests/fixtures.rs | head -30\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"== lib.rs registration of Blank / facet_blank ==\\\"; grep -n \\\"facet_blank\\\\|Blank\\\" engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs; echo; echo \\\"== check.report fixture mentioning blank-facets ==\\\"; grep -rln \\\"blank-facets\\\" engine/crates/check/fixtures/ engine/crates/check/tests/ 2>/dev/null; echo; grep -n \\\"facet.value.blank\\\" -r engine/crates/check/fixtures/ | head -20\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/05-no-summary.md; echo \\\"---\\\"; grep -n \\\"05-no-summary\\\" engine/crates/check/fixtures/check.report\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1080,1100p' engine/crates/check/fixtures/check.report\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"18-blank-facets.md\\\" engine/crates/check/fixtures/check.report | head; echo \\\"---context---\\\"; awk '/^check\\\\/spec\\\\/18-blank-facets\\\\.md/{p=1} p{print} p&&/^check\\\\/spec\\\\/2[0-9]/{if(!/18-blank/)exit}' engine/crates/check/fixtures/check.report | head -30\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r79"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r79 -maxdepth 3 -iname \\\"*taxonom*\\\" -o -maxdepth 3 -iname \\\"*overlay*\\\" 2>/dev/null | head -50\",\"description\":\"Locate taxonomy and overlay files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r79/.headwater -maxdepth 4 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r79/engine -maxdepth 5 -iname \\\"*rule*\\\" 2>/dev/null | head -80\",\"description\":\"Locate rule-related files in engine\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r79/.headwater/taxonomy.yml | head -200\",\"description\":\"Show taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r79/taxonomy-source -maxdepth 3\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy-source dir\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r79/engine/crates -maxdepth 1\",\"description\":\"List engine crates\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" -r /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r79/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -50\",\"description\":\"Find summary field references in taxonomy source\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r79/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml; grep -n \\\"^ - id:\\\\|rule:\\\\|severity:\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r79/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -100\",\"description\":\"Inspect structure of taxonomy source rules\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r79/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"empty\\\\|OB-FACET\\\\|scent\\\\|blank\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r79/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Search for empty/scent/facet references\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"OB-FACET-1\\\\|OB-FACET-2\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r79/engine --include=*.rs | head -30\",\"description\":\"Find implementations referencing OB-FACET obligations in engine\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r79/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r79/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rln \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet_value_blank\\\\|FacetValueBlank\\\\|value.blank\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r79/engine 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Search engine source for facet.value.blank rule implementation\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rln \\\"facet.value.blank\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r79 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Search whole repo for facet.value.blank mechanism references\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r79/docs/decisions/0058-a-blank-facet-value-is-a-rule-of-its-own-and-it-reads-every-string-facet.md"
result: "sha256:7c1e03d300ff01f37bf38245f8adbfb1b6ef00e6dcc45839abd740efdb29ad21"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r79/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r79/engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r79/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r8"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r8\",\"description\":\"List repo root contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r8 | head -30; echo ---; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r8/taxonomy-source -maxdepth 3 | head -50\",\"description\":\"Inspect repo root and taxonomy-source layout\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r8/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml; grep -n \\\"summary\\\" -r /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r8/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -50\",\"description\":\"Check taxonomy.yml for summary-related rules\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r8/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r8; grep -n \\\"^rules:\\\\|^ rules:\\\\|rule_id\\\\|severity\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -80\",\"description\":\"Search taxonomy.yml for rules and severity declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r8/engine; find . -maxdepth 4 -type d | head -60\",\"description\":\"List engine crate directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r8/engine/crates; ls; echo ---check---; find . -maxdepth 2 -iname \\\"*check*\\\"\",\"description\":\"Find the check crate\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r8/engine/crates/check; find . -maxdepth 3 -type f -name \\\"*.rs\\\" | xargs -I{} wc -l {} | sort -n\",\"description\":\"List check crate source files with line counts\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r8/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r8/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r8/engine/crates/check; grep -n \\\"facet_blank\\\\|Blank\\\\b\\\\|facet\\\\.value\\\\.blank\\\" src/register.rs src/lib.rs\",\"description\":\"Check how the Blank rule is registered in the engine\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r8/engine/crates/check; grep -rln \\\"facet_blank\\\\|facet\\\\.value\\\\.blank\\\" tests/ fixtures/ 2>/dev/null; echo ---; grep -rn \\\"summary\\\" tests/*.rs 2>/dev/null | grep -i blank\",\"description\":\"Search for facet_blank tests referencing summary\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r8/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md"
result: "sha256:ab8d0eb139f3733cde3ca712a0f637ff8fe82f70fc93a55f87b27273fad00d57"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r8/engine/crates/check; grep -n \\\"blank\\\\|18-blank\\\" tests/fixtures.rs | head -30\",\"description\":\"Check fixtures.rs references to the blank-facets fixture\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r8/engine; find target -maxdepth 3 -iname \\\"headwater*\\\" -type f 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Check for an already-built headwater CLI binary\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r8/engine; ./target/dev-release/headwater --version 2>&1 | head -5\",\"description\":\"Check the built headwater CLI version/works\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r80"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls -la\",\"description\":\"Check if directory is a git repo and list contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Research rule declaration and implementation pattern\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"This is the Headwater repository (a documentation-governance engine). I need to add a new check rule: \\\"reports a document whose summary is empty.\\\" Before writing it, I need to understand the existing pattern for how rules are declared and implemented, so the new rule is consistent.\\n\\nPlease investigate and report back with specifics (file paths, line numbers, code snippets):\\n\\n1. Where are rules *declared* in this repo? Look at `.headwater/packages/`, `docs/taxonomies/`, `.headwater/overlay.yml`, and `taxonomy-source/`. Find the taxonomy file(s) that declare existing rules (e.g. something like \\\"language.retired_term.used\\\" mentioned in CLAUDE.md, or any rule about a document's front matter / summary field). Show the format used to declare a rule: its identifier, severity (error vs advisory), and any other declared metadata (e.g. remedy type, which determines error vs advisory).\\n\\n2. Where are rules *implemented* in the engine code? Look under `engine/` (likely a Rust workspace, crate `headwater-cli` or similar, possibly a `headwater-checks` or `headwater-taxonomy` crate). Find how an existing simple rule — ideally one that checks a document's front matter/summary field for presence, or any simple \\\"field must not be empty\\\" style rule — is implemented: which crate, which file, the function/struct name, and how it registers itself with the rule identifier declared in the taxonomy.\\n\\n3. Is there an existing rule that already checks for an empty or missing `summary` field, or something closely related (e.g. a rule about missing front matter fields in general)? Quote its exact identifier and implementation location.\\n\\n4. What determines whether a rule's severity is \\\"error\\\" (mechanical/total remedy) vs \\\"advisory\\\" (remedy is a rewrite)? Find where severity is assigned — is it per-rule metadata in the taxonomy declaration, or is it derived from a category?\\n\\n5. Find the data model: where is \\\"summary\\\" defined as a front-matter field for documents (e.g. in a schema, docs/spec, or `docs/interfaces/`)? Is it optional or required today?\\n\\nReport findings with exact file paths and line numbers/snippets so I can directly make the edits myself. Do not make any edits — this is research only. Keep the report focused and under 600 words of prose (code snippets don't count against that).\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find . -maxdepth 3 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find . -iname \\\"CLAUDE.md\\\" 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Locate CLAUDE.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r80/docs/decisions/0014-discovery-surface.md"
result: "sha256:6eef63703f179a2d9b738bee73916ef271b405fe7cd290bf2a47cf8d2a59b830"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r80/CLAUDE.md"
result: "sha256:c92caed27f86014c5f496edda4ca85568e1da2a44e9c15e4aece92ff9b5bbfd2"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"true\",\"description\":\"No-op while waiting for background research agent\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"retired_term\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r80 --include=*.yml --include=*.yaml --include=*.md -l 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Find retired_term rule references\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r80/taxonomy-source -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy-source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "ScheduleWakeup"
argument: "{\"delaySeconds\":90,\"reason\":\"waiting on background Explore agent researching rule declaration/implementation pattern\",\"prompt\":\"Check on the Explore agent's findings about rule declaration/implementation and proceed to implement the empty-summary rule.\",\"noop\":true}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r80/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r80/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r80/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r80/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r80/engine/crates/check -maxdepth 3 -type f -name \\\"*.rs\\\" | sort\",\"description\":\"List check crate rust files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r80/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r80/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r80/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet.required.missing\\\\|OB-FACET-1\\\\|OB-FACET-3\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r80/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Find how facet.value.blank / facet.required.missing map to obligations and controls\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r80/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1270,1300p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r80/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Show CT-FACET-3 control block\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r80/engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r80/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r80/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"CT-FACET-1\\\\|OB-FACET-1\\\\|CT-FACET-3\\\\|OB-FACET-3\\\" -A 10 taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Show taxonomy declarations for the facet-required and facet-blank controls/obligations\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r81"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r81 -maxdepth 2 | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level repo structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r81/taxonomy-source -maxdepth 4 | sort\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy-source structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" -r /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r81/taxonomy-source /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r81/.headwater/taxonomy.yml /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r81/.headwater/taxonomy.lock 2>/dev/null | head -80\",\"description\":\"Search for existing 'summary' rule references in taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r81/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"severity\\\\|^rules:\\\\|^ rules:\\\\|advisory\\\\|error:\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r81/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -100\",\"description\":\"Search taxonomy.yml for severity/rules section\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r81/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^controls:\\\\|CT-FACET\\\\|CT-COV\\\\|facet.missing\\\\|facet.required\\\\|facet.empty\\\\|facet.blank\\\\|empty\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r81/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Search for controls section and facet-related check ids\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r81/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rln \\\"facet.required.missing\\\\|facet::required\\\\|FacetRequiredMissing\\\\|required_missing\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r81/engine/crates 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Find engine implementation of facet.required.missing check\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r81/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"OB-FACET-3\\\\|CT-FACET-3\\\\|facet.value.blank\\\" -A 10 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r81/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Find OB-FACET-3 and CT-FACET-3 declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|CT-FACET-3\\\\|OB-FACET-3\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r81/.headwater/taxonomy.lock\",\"description\":\"Confirm the rule is active in the resolved taxonomy lock\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"facet_blank\\\\|Blank::over\\\\|facet_required::\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r81/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Find where facet_blank is registered in the check crate\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r82"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r82 -maxdepth 2 | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level repo structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== taxonomy.yml ===\\\"; sed -n '1,80p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r82/.headwater/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"=== packages dir ===\\\"; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r82/.headwater/packages -maxdepth 3 | sort\",\"description\":\"Inspect taxonomy.yml and packages directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r82/taxonomy-source"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r82/engine/crates -maxdepth 1 | sort\",\"description\":\"List engine crates\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r82/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r82/engine/crates/check -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List files in check crate\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r82/engine/crates/check/src -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List check crate src files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r82/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Count lines in taxonomy source\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r82/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r82/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r82/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Find summary mentions with line numbers\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r82/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^rules:\\\\|severity\\\\|Severity::\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r82/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -30\\necho \\\"---lib.rs rule registration---\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"facet_blank\\\\|RULE\\\\b\\\\|register\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r82/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs | head -40\",\"description\":\"Search for rules/severity declarations and rule registration\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"enum Severity\\\" -A 10 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r82/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs\",\"description\":\"Look at Severity enum definition\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r82/engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r82/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r82/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r82/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r82/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet\\\\.required\\\\.missing\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r82/.headwater/overlay.yml /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r82/.headwater/taxonomy.lock 2>/dev/null | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check for severity overrides of the blank rule in overlay/lock\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r82/.headwater/taxonomy.lock"
result: "sha256:1ea570f4a22e19db2ed394a89bbb5f47f2908847514bb3417fd7a88820333650"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r83"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo --- && find . -maxdepth 2 -name \\\"*.git*\\\" 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List working directory contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-engine\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater -maxdepth 4 -type d; echo ---; find .headwater -iname \\\"*summary*\\\" 2>/dev/null; echo ---; find taxonomy-source -maxdepth 4 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Explore .headwater and taxonomy-source directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine -maxdepth 3 -type d; echo ---; find engine -iname \\\"*rule*\\\" | head -50\",\"description\":\"Explore engine directory structure for rule implementations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"summary\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -50\",\"description\":\"Find summary field references in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rln \\\"summary\\\" engine/crates/*/src/*.rs engine/crates/*/src/**/*.rs 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Find summary references across engine crate source\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r83/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^checks:\\\\|^ checks:\\\\|severity\\\\|advisory\\\\|error:\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -60\",\"description\":\"Look for checks/severity declarations in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r83/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r83/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"pub const RULE\\\" engine/crates/check/src/*.rs; echo ---; grep -rln \\\"blank\\\\|empty\\\" engine/crates/check/src/*.rs; echo ---; ls engine/crates/check/src\",\"description\":\"List rule constants and search for blank/empty references\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r83/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"Blank\\\\|facet_blank\\\\|facet.value.blank\\\" engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs engine/crates/check/src/register.rs 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Check registration of the Blank check and its obligation binding\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"facet.value.blank\\\" --include=*.rs --include=*.md --include=*.yml . 2>/dev/null | grep -v \\\"^./engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs\\\"\",\"description\":\"Find every other reference to facet.value.blank across the repo\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r83/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r84"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"List working directory and check git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Find rule declaration and implementation pattern\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"This is the Headwater repository (a documentation-governance system with a Rust engine at engine/ and a taxonomy under .headwater/ and taxonomy-source/). I need to add a new check rule that reports a document whose `summary` field (front matter) is empty, and I need to answer: where is a rule *declared* (the taxonomy/spec side) and where is it *implemented* (the engine code side), and what determines a rule's *severity* (error vs advisory vs pending).\\n\\nPlease investigate and report back with concrete file paths and line numbers:\\n\\n1. Find the taxonomy source files (likely under `taxonomy-source/` or `.headwater/packages/`) that declare existing rules — e.g. search for rules similar in spirit to \\\"empty\\\" or \\\"missing field\\\" checks (e.g. a rule about missing front matter, empty title, etc.). Show the structure/schema used to declare a rule: what fields it has (id, severity, message, etc.), and whether severity is \\\"error\\\" or \\\"advisory\\\" and how that's encoded.\\n2. Find the Rust engine code (under `engine/`) that implements an existing, similar rule (e.g. one that inspects document front matter/summary) — show the file path, the function/struct, and how it reads the rule's severity from the declaration (i.e., is severity declared in taxonomy and looked up, or hardcoded in Rust, or both?).\\n3. Find any existing rule that deals with the `summary` front-matter field specifically, or any \\\"field is empty\\\" / \\\"field is missing\\\" rule, as the closest existing analog for \\\"document whose summary is empty.\\\"\\n4. Find where the project's rubric for severity is documented: CLAUDE.md says \\\"A rule is an error when its remedy is mechanical and total... A rule is advisory when the remedy is a rewrite.\\\" Find the doc (likely under docs/spec/ or docs/decisions/ or DEVELOPING.md) that states this rubric authoritatively, with its exact wording and any decision ID (like HW-DR-xxxx or Qxx).\\n5. Check `.headwater/taxonomy.lock` and `.headwater/overlay.yml` briefly to see if rules/severities appear there too (generated/locked state vs source).\\n\\nReport concisely: for each of points 1-5, give file path(s), relevant line numbers, and a short quote/summary. I just need the facts to design where a new rule declaration and implementation should go — do not write any code or edit any files.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== root ===\\\"; ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r84; echo \\\"=== taxonomy-source ===\\\"; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r84/taxonomy-source -type f | head -100; echo \\\"=== .headwater ===\\\"; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r84/.headwater -type f | head -100\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== engine dir tree (depth) ===\\\"; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r84/engine -type f -name \\\"*.rs\\\" | head -200\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r84\\nwc -l $ROOT/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"---conformance.yml---\\\"\\nwc -l $ROOT/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/conformance.yml\\ngrep -n -i \\\"severity\\\\|advisory\\\\|error\\\\|pending\\\" $ROOT/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/conformance.yml | head -60\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r84\\necho \\\"--- grep severity/advisory/pending in taxonomy.yml ---\\\"\\ngrep -n -i \\\"severity\\\\|advisory\\\\|pending\\\\b\\\" $ROOT/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -80\\necho \\\"--- grep 'rule' section headers ---\\\"\\ngrep -n -i \\\"^rules:\\\\|^ rules:\\\\|rule_id\\\\|^- id:\\\\|check_id\\\\|checks:\\\" $ROOT/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -60\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r84/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r84\\necho \\\"--- grep summary/empty/blank in taxonomy.yml ---\\\"\\ngrep -n -i \\\"summary\\\\|empty\\\\|blank\\\" $ROOT/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"--- posture: blocking count ---\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"posture: blocking\\\" $ROOT/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"--- context around line 550-565 (what section has severity: high/medium/low) ---\\\"\\nsed -n '540,575p' $ROOT/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r84/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r84/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r84\\necho \\\"--- OB-FACET-3 declaration ---\\\"\\ngrep -n -B1 -A6 \\\"OB-FACET-3:\\\" $ROOT/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"--- OB-FACET-1/2 for comparison ---\\\"\\ngrep -n -B1 -A6 \\\"OB-FACET-1:\\\\|OB-FACET-2:\\\" $ROOT/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r84/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r84/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r84/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r84/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r84/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r84"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r84/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r84\\ngrep -n \\\"mechanical and total\\\\|remedy is a rewrite\\\\|error when\\\\|advisory when\\\" $ROOT/CLAUDE.md $ROOT/DEVELOPING.md $ROOT/docs/spec/*.md $ROOT/docs/decisions/*.md 2>/dev/null\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r84/docs/spec/04-assurance-model.md"
result: "sha256:578a74d123831dcab8bfd8ab382ab6ef0be89ee053515cc678e59f16a659b36f"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r84\\nls -la $ROOT/.headwater/*.yml $ROOT/.headwater/*.lock 2>/dev/null\\necho \\\"--- grep facet.value.blank / CT-FACET-3 / severity / posture in taxonomy.lock ---\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|CT-FACET-3\\\\|OB-FACET-3\\\\|severity\\\\|posture\\\" $ROOT/.headwater/taxonomy.lock 2>/dev/null | head -40\\necho \\\"--- overlay.yml ---\\\"\\ncat $ROOT/.headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null | head -60\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r84\\nsed -n '415,445p' $ROOT/.headwater/taxonomy.lock\\necho \\\"---CT-FACET-3/OB-FACET-3 in lock---\\\"\\ngrep -n -B3 -A8 \\\"facet.value.blank\\\" $ROOT/.headwater/taxonomy.lock | head -40\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r84\\nsed -n '1,40p' $ROOT/engine/crates/check/src/register.rs | head -60\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r84/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r84/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -20\",\"description\":\"Find summary facet declaration in taxonomy source\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r84/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"OB-FACET-3\\\\|CT-FACET-3\\\" -A8 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r84/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Show full OB-FACET-3 and CT-FACET-3 declarations\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r85"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Locate rule declaration and implementation patterns\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"I'm working in the Headwater repository at /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r85 (not a git repo, just a plain directory tree). I need to add a new rule to the \\\"check\\\" engine that reports a document whose summary is empty (documents have front matter, presumably with a `summary` field, under docs/).\\n\\nI need you to answer, with exact file paths and line numbers/snippets:\\n\\n1. Where are rules DECLARED in this repo's taxonomy? Look under `.headwater/packages/`, `docs/taxonomies/`, and `taxonomy-source/`. Find the taxonomy file(s) that declare existing rules (e.g. things like hard-wrapped markdown, British spelling, retired terms, contractions, sentence length, voice categories mentioned in CLAUDE.md). Show me the structure/schema used to declare one rule, including how severity (error vs advisory) is encoded, and whether there's already a notion of required front-matter fields like `summary`.\\n\\n2. Where is the check logic IMPLEMENTED in the engine? Look under `engine/` (Rust crates, likely `headwater-cli` or a `headwater-check`/similar crate). Find the module(s) that implement document-level / front-matter checks (e.g. anything checking document metadata, required fields, or similar). Show me one concrete existing rule's implementation (ideally a simple one, like a required-field or front-matter check) end-to-end: where it's declared in the taxonomy, how the engine loads/matches that declaration, and where the Rust function that performs the actual check lives.\\n\\n3. Is there already a `summary` front-matter field documented somewhere (e.g. in docs/spec/, docs/interfaces/headwater-generate.md, or an authoring guide)? Find where document front matter schema is defined/described, and confirm whether `summary` is an existing required or optional field.\\n\\n4. Find any existing rule that is most similar in shape to \\\"field X is empty\\\" (e.g. a \\\"missing required field\\\" or \\\"empty field\\\" check) to use as a template — give me its full taxonomy declaration and full Rust implementation.\\n\\n5. Check `docs/spec/09-decisions.md` Q14 (discovery surface) and anything about `.headwater/corpus.json` to understand what \\\"a cold agent that has read one generated file and nothing else\\\" means in context — is this relevant to how the engine discovers which documents to check?\\n\\nReport back with concrete file paths, line numbers, and code/text snippets — not summaries without evidence. This is read-only research; do not edit anything.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater/packages docs/taxonomies taxonomy-source -type f 2>/dev/null | head -100\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r85/docs -iname \\\"*discovery*\\\" 2>/dev/null; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r85/docs/spec -maxdepth 1 -iname \\\"09*\\\" 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Find discovery surface decision doc and spec part 09\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo --- && ls engine 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r85/docs/decisions/0014-discovery-surface.md"
result: "sha256:6eef63703f179a2d9b738bee73916ef271b405fe7cd290bf2a47cf8d2a59b830"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r85/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls engine/crates && echo --- && find taxonomy-source -maxdepth 3 -type f | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sleep 30 && echo done\",\"description\":\"Brief wait for background exploration\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r85/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r85/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r85/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r85/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r85/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r85/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r85/engine/crates/check/src/ | head -60\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r85/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r85/docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r85/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r85/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r85/docs/spec/09-decisions.md"
result: "sha256:0c0c538720be0d70206ed1adb3d695531e5b1c9c975b992ad56c4c0df1896e0a"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r85/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r85/docs/decisions/0014-discovery-surface.md"
result: "sha256:6eef63703f179a2d9b738bee73916ef271b405fe7cd290bf2a47cf8d2a59b830"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r85/docs/interfaces/headwater-generate.md"
result: "sha256:037666200bb5888102f75b034aeb6161280740d5fbbee00ec3bfd8b86192e031"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sleep 60 && echo waited\",\"description\":\"Wait for background research agent to progress\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r85/docs/spec/07-distribution-and-federation.md"
result: "sha256:70ee565d14f7350a1df9fd477c8214dc15577ac766a0a119101c5b220c795f8c"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r85/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"cold\\\" docs/spec/07-distribution-and-federation.md | head -20\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r85/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r85/docs/spec/07-distribution-and-federation.md"
result: "sha256:70ee565d14f7350a1df9fd477c8214dc15577ac766a0a119101c5b220c795f8c"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,60p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r85/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs 2>/dev/null | grep -n \\\"Severity\\\" \"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r85/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r85/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r85/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r85"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r85/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r85/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo --- && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Research rule declaration and implementation pattern\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"I need to add a new check rule to the Headwater engine (a Rust-based documentation linter in this repo at /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86). The new rule should report a document whose \\\"summary\\\" front-matter field is empty.\\n\\nI need to understand the existing pattern for how rules are declared and implemented, so I can replicate it exactly for a new rule. Please investigate and report back:\\n\\n1. Where rules are DECLARED (likely a taxonomy file under docs/taxonomies/ or .headwater/packages/ or taxonomy-source/) — find the schema/format for declaring a rule: its id, name, description, severity levels (error vs advisory — CLAUDE.md says \\\"A rule is an error when its remedy is mechanical and total... A rule is advisory when the remedy is a rewrite\\\"), and find a concrete example of an existing SIMPLE rule declaration (ideally one that's similarly \\\"mechanical\\\" — like checking a field is empty/missing) so I can copy its shape exactly. Give me the exact file path and the full text of that example rule declaration.\\n\\n2. Where rules are IMPLEMENTED — the engine/ directory is a Rust crate (headwater-cli / headwater-engine or similar crates). Find where check rules are implemented in Rust code — look for a rules/ or checks/ directory, find an existing simple rule implementation (e.g. a rule that checks a front-matter field for emptiness or presence — search for things like \\\"summary\\\", \\\"front matter\\\", \\\"frontmatter\\\", similar existing field-presence checks like title, or empty-string checks). Give me the exact file path(s) and show the relevant code for one simple example rule's implementation, including how it registers itself / gets wired into the rule set, and how severity is specified in code.\\n\\n3. Does a \\\"summary\\\" front-matter field already exist in the document schema? Search docs/spec or docs/taxonomies or engine code for \\\"summary\\\" as a front-matter key, to confirm the field name and its expected type/semantics.\\n\\n4. Is there a naming convention for rule identifiers (e.g. \\\"language.retired_term.used\\\" was mentioned in CLAUDE.md as an example id — find the full namespace/category conventions, e.g. is there a \\\"document.summary\\\" or similar category used elsewhere)?\\n\\n5. Find how severity (error vs advisory) is actually encoded — is it a field in the taxonomy YAML, or in Rust code, or both?\\n\\nReport file paths, line numbers, and exact relevant snippets. Do not make any edits — this is research only. Keep the report organized under the 5 numbered points above, and be thorough since I'll use this to write the actual rule next.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo --- && find . -maxdepth 3 -iname \\\"*taxonom*\\\" 2>/dev/null && echo --- && find . -maxdepth 2 -type d 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List repo root and find taxonomy dirs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho ---\\nfind /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/engine/crates -maxdepth 2 -type d\\necho ---\\nfind /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/engine/crates -iname \\\"*rule*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*check*\\\" | grep -v target | head -80\\n\",\"description\":\"Inspect taxonomy file size and engine crate structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/engine/crates/check/src -type f | sort\\necho ---\\nwc -l /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/engine/crates/check/src/*.rs 2>/dev/null\\nfind /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/engine/crates/check/src -type d\",\"description\":\"List check crate source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/engine/crates/check/src/frontmatter.rs"
result: "sha256:b6864d616cbf7133eb84efa03e36c9092b9a2aa50c6e7d0e87408bfd68914f8a"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"---rules section header---\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"^rules:\\\\|^ - id:\\\\|^facets:\\\\|^ - name:\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -50\",\"description\":\"Search taxonomy.yml for summary and rules/facets sections\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/docs/taxonomies\\necho ---\\ngrep -n \\\"rule\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -40\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"severity\\\\|blocking\\\\|advisory\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -40\",\"description\":\"Search for severity-related keywords in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^controls:\\\\|mechanism:\\\\|posture:\\\\|discharges:\\\\|^ OB-FACET-3\\\\|blocking\\\\b\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -60\",\"description\":\"Find controls section and posture/mechanism fields\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|OB-FACET-3\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Locate control entry referencing facet.value.blank rule\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"retired_term\\\\|advisory\\\\|error when\\\\|rewrite\\\\|rule id\\\\|mechanical\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/CLAUDE.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^#\\\\|dotted\\\\|naming\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md | head -60\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"pub trait DocumentCheck\\\" -A 25 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/engine/crates/check/src/scope.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '539,575p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/engine/crates/check/src/scope.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r86/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r87"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Locate rule declaration and implementation pattern\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"I need to add a new check rule to the \\\"headwater\\\" engine (a documentation-governance checker). The rule should report a document whose \\\"summary\\\" field is empty.\\n\\nPlease investigate this repo (root: /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r87) and answer:\\n\\n1. Where are check rules DECLARED (the taxonomy)? Look under `taxonomy-source/`, `.headwater/packages/`, `docs/taxonomies/`. Find the file format/schema used to declare a rule (id, description, severity, category, etc.) and show me one or two complete example rule declarations, especially any that check for an empty/missing field in front matter (e.g. an existing rule about a missing or empty field, title, or similar).\\n\\n2. Where are check rules IMPLEMENTED in the engine code? Look under `engine/` (likely a Rust workspace, crate `headwater-cli` or similar, maybe a `headwater-check` or `headwater-taxonomy` crate). Find the source file(s) that implement a comparable existing rule — ideally one that checks for an empty or missing string field on a document's front matter — and show me the actual function/struct code (with file path and line numbers).\\n\\n3. What severities exist in this system (e.g. \\\"error\\\" vs \\\"advisory\\\" vs others)? Where is the severity enum/type defined in code, and where is severity declared per-rule in the taxonomy? Show the exact field name and allowed values.\\n\\n4. Is there a \\\"summary\\\" field in the document front matter schema already? Where is it defined (e.g. docs/spec, a schema file, or front-matter parsing code)? Confirm whether documents already have a `summary:` front-matter field so I know this isn't introducing a new field, just a new check on an existing one.\\n\\n5. Is there a naming/ID convention for rule identifiers (e.g. `language.retired_term.used` was mentioned in CLAUDE.md as an example rule id — look for the full list of rule ids to understand the dotted-namespace convention, e.g. something like `document.field.empty` or similar namespace for structural/front-matter rules).\\n\\n6. Are there existing tests for rules (e.g. a fixtures directory) that I'd need to mirror when adding a new rule - show an example test for a similar rule.\\n\\nReport file paths with line numbers for everything so I can go edit precisely. Keep your report organized under these 6 numbered headings, be concrete and quote exact code/config snippets (short, just enough to show the pattern), under 2500 words.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find . -maxdepth 3 -not -path '*/node_modules*' -not -path '*/.git*' -not -path '*/target*' | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"--- taxonomy-source ---\\\"; find . -path '*/taxonomy-source*' -not -path '*/.git*' 2>/dev/null | sort\\necho \\\"--- .headwater/packages ---\\\"; find . -path '*/.headwater/packages*' -not -path '*/.git*' 2>/dev/null | sort\\necho \\\"--- docs/taxonomies ---\\\"; find . -path '*/docs/taxonomies*' -not -path '*/.git*' 2>/dev/null | sort\\necho \\\"--- engine top ---\\\"; find . -maxdepth 2 -path '*/engine*' -not -path '*/.git*' 2>/dev/null | sort\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy and engine directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r87/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r87/engine/crates -maxdepth 1 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List engine crates\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r87/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r87/engine/crates/check -type f -name \\\"*.rs\\\" | xargs grep -l \\\"facet\\\" 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Find facet-related rule implementation files in check crate\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r87/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r87/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r87/engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r87/engine/crates/check/src -name \\\"finding.rs\\\"\",\"description\":\"Find finding.rs file path\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"posture:\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r87/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | sort -u -t: -k2 | awk '{print $2}' | sort -u\\necho \\\"---\\\"\\ngrep -rn \\\"enum Posture\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r87/engine/crates --include=*.rs\\necho \\\"--- severity values in obligations ---\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"severity:\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r87/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | awk -F': ' '{print $2}' | sort -u\",\"description\":\"List distinct posture and severity values used in taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r87/engine/crates/check/tests -iname \\\"*blank*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*required*\\\" | sort\",\"description\":\"Find test files for blank/required facet checks\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r87\\necho \\\"posture values:\\\"; grep -oP '(?<=^\\\\s*posture: )\\\\S+' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | sort -u\\necho \\\"final_posture values:\\\"; grep -oP '(?<=final_posture: )\\\\S+' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | sort -u\\necho \\\"severity values:\\\"; grep -oP '(?<=^\\\\s*severity: )\\\\S+' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | sort -u\\necho \\\"--- facet_value tests ---\\\"\\nfind engine/crates/check/tests -iname \\\"*facet*\\\"\",\"description\":\"Extract distinct posture, final_posture and severity values\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r87\\necho \\\"posture values:\\\"; grep -oE 'posture: [a-z_]+' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | sort -u\\necho \\\"severity values:\\\"; grep -oE 'severity: [a-z_]+' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | sort -u\\necho \\\"--- Severity enum full ---\\\"\\nsed -n '55,75p' engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs\",\"description\":\"Extract posture/severity distinct values and print Severity enum\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r87\\ngrep -rln \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet_blank\\\\|Blank\\\" engine/crates/check/tests\\necho \\\"---\\\"\\ngrep -rn \\\"facet.required.missing\\\\|facet_required::Required\\\" engine/crates/check/tests\",\"description\":\"Find tests referencing facet.value.blank or facet_required\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r87\\nwc -l engine/crates/check/tests/fixtures.rs\\ngrep -n \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|fn \\\\|fixture\\\\|corpus\\\" engine/crates/check/tests/fixtures.rs | head -60\",\"description\":\"Inspect fixtures.rs test file structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r87/engine/crates/check\\nfind fixtures -maxdepth 4 | sort | head -80\",\"description\":\"List check fixtures directory tree\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r87/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/05-no-summary.md"
result: "sha256:e93ab39ba0f3d03cf7593bc046d7c0a5aa0fbf102df0e02e2dbf34c263aa346d"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r87/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md"
result: "sha256:ab8d0eb139f3733cde3ca712a0f637ff8fe82f70fc93a55f87b27273fad00d57"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r87/engine/crates/check\\ngrep -n \\\"blank-facets\\\\|facet.value.blank\\\\|no-summary\\\\|facet.required.missing\\\" fixtures/check.report\",\"description\":\"Find relevant snapshot lines in check.report\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r87\\ngrep -n \\\"pub const RULE\\\" engine/crates/check/src/*.rs | sort -t'\\\"' -k2\",\"description\":\"List all rule id constants across check crate for namespace convention\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r87\\ngrep -n \\\"struct Facets\\\\|fn entry\\\\|pub fn facets\\\\|front matter\\\\|frontmatter\\\" engine/crates/check/src/frontmatter.rs | head -30\",\"description\":\"Peek at frontmatter.rs structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r87\\nsed -n '1,60p' engine/crates/check/src/frontmatter.rs\",\"description\":\"Read top of frontmatter.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r87/engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r87\\nfind . -path \\\"*docs/spec/12-check-layer.md\\\" 2>/dev/null\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r87\\ngrep -n \\\"struct Facet\\\\b\\\" -A 20 engine/crates/check/src/shape.rs | head -40\",\"description\":\"Peek at Facet struct in shape.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r87\\ngrep -n \\\"severity-is-the-checks-posture-is-the-controls\\\" -A 15 docs/spec/12-check-layer.md | head -25\",\"description\":\"Read spec 12 severity-vs-posture section heading context\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r87/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r87/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md"
result: "sha256:ab8d0eb139f3733cde3ca712a0f637ff8fe82f70fc93a55f87b27273fad00d57"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r87/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Find rule declaration and implementation pattern\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"I'm working in a repository called Headwater (a documentation-governance engine). I need to add a new rule to the engine: \\\"reports a document whose summary is empty.\\\" I need to understand the existing architecture for rules, specifically:\\n\\n1. Where rules are DECLARED — likely in a taxonomy file under `.headwater/packages/` or `docs/taxonomies/`. Find the taxonomy package file(s) that declare existing rules (look for files with rule identifiers, severity fields like \\\"error\\\"/\\\"advisory\\\", and fields like \\\"summary\\\" or \\\"remedy\\\").\\n2. Where rules are IMPLEMENTED — likely in Rust source under `engine/` (e.g. `engine/headwater-cli` or similar crate). Find the source files that implement checks/rules, especially ones that check document metadata/front matter for presence/emptiness of a field (e.g., check for missing title, missing summary, empty field, etc.).\\n3. Find an existing rule that is semantically similar — i.e., checks whether some document front-matter field is present/non-empty — and show its full declaration (taxonomy entry) and full implementation (Rust function/struct), including how severity (error vs advisory) is assigned and how the rule is given an identifier/name.\\n4. Find where \\\"summary\\\" is defined as a front-matter field for documents (search for \\\"summary:\\\" in docs or in schema/taxonomy definitions) to confirm documents have a summary field.\\n5. Look at docs/spec/ or docs/decisions/ for any existing decision about rule severity classification (error = mechanical and total vs advisory = rewrite) to confirm how severity is decided, and check if there's a document describing the taxonomy schema for rules (fields like id, severity, message, etc.).\\n\\nReport back with exact file paths and line ranges/snippets for: the taxonomy declaration pattern, the Rust implementation pattern for a similar existing rule, and the schema for a rule entry (what fields are required). Keep the report focused and include concrete code/config snippets, not summaries without evidence.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"pwd: $(pwd)\\\"; ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88\",\"description\":\"List repository root contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/.headwater -type f | head -100\",\"description\":\"List files under .headwater\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/taxonomy-source -type f | head -100\",\"description\":\"List files under taxonomy-source\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/engine -maxdepth 3 -type d\",\"description\":\"List engine directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88\",\"description\":\"List repository root contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\ngrep -n \\\"^- id:\\\\|^ id:\\\\|severity:\\\\|summary:\\\\|remedy:\\\\|message:\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -80\",\"description\":\"Inspect taxonomy.yml structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/engine/crates/check/src/\",\"description\":\"List check crate source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/.git 2>&1 | head -5; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/.headwater; echo \\\"---taxonomy-source---\\\"; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/taxonomy-source -maxdepth 3\",\"description\":\"Check for .git dir and inspect .headwater and taxonomy-source dirs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,60p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"View taxonomy.yml header\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/.headwater/packages -maxdepth 4 | head -50\",\"description\":\"List .headwater/packages structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"facet_blank\\\\|facet_required\\\\|blank\\\\|required_facet\\\\|empty\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -40\",\"description\":\"Search taxonomy for blank/required/empty rule refs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/conformance.yml\\nsed -n '1,120p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/conformance.yml\",\"description\":\"View conformance.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"---diff check---\\\"\\ndiff /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -20\\necho \\\"---grep summary in taxonomy.yml---\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"summary\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -40\",\"description\":\"Compare taxonomy files and search for summary field usage\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1240,1423p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^checks:\\\\|^ CT-\\\\|^obligations:\\\\|^ OB-FACET-3\\\\|^ OB-SECT-1\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -60\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '780,935p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"View OB-FACET-3 obligation and surrounding context\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '990,1004p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"View CT-FACET-1 and CT-FACET-2 declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/engine/crates/check/src -maxdepth 1 -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List source files in check crate\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '370,400p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"View summary facet declaration in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"facet_blank\\\\|facet_required\\\\|Blank::over\\\\|Required::over\\\\|register\\\\|RULE\\\\b\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs | head -60\",\"description\":\"Search lib.rs for rule registration patterns\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '420,470p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs\",\"description\":\"View rule registration block in lib.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/docs/spec -iname \\\"*check*\\\"\",\"description\":\"Locate check-layer spec doc\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^#\\\\|^##\\\\|five origins\\\\|Shape-origin\\\\|fixability\\\\|Fixability\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md | head -60\",\"description\":\"View headings in check-layer spec\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rln \\\"mechanical and total\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/docs/\",\"description\":\"Find docs mentioning mechanical and total remedy language\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '253,320p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md\",\"description\":\"Read severity/posture section of check-layer spec\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"enum Severity\\\\|Error\\\\|Advisory\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs | head -20\",\"description\":\"Inspect Severity enum in finding.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,45p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs\",\"description\":\"Inspect top of finding.rs for struct Finding / Severity\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/docs/decisions/0058-a-blank-facet-value-is-a-rule-of-its-own-and-it-reads-every-string-facet.md"
result: "sha256:7c1e03d300ff01f37bf38245f8adbfb1b6ef00e6dcc45839abd740efdb29ad21"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '55,80p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs\",\"description\":\"View Severity enum full definition\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,20p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/docs/decisions/0024-q24-readability-and-what-a-sweep-can-be-asked-about.md 2>/dev/null | head -20\\necho ---\\ngrep -n \\\"severity\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/docs/spec/04-assurance-model.md | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check spec 04 severity references\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '85,115p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/docs/spec/04-assurance-model.md\",\"description\":\"Show obligation severity/class/prevents field list in spec 04\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '395,415p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r88/docs/spec/04-assurance-model.md\",\"description\":\"Show worked finding JSON example in spec 04\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "TaskStop"
argument: "{\"task_id\":\"a3cc6b702e4243ec5\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r89"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls && echo --- && find .headwater -maxdepth 3 -type d 2>/dev/null && echo --- && find engine -maxdepth 3 -type d 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List repo root, .headwater, and engine directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Research how check rules are declared and implemented\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"I'm working in the Headwater repo at /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r89. I need to add a new rule to the `headwater check` engine that reports a document whose \\\"summary\\\" field is empty. Before writing code, I need to understand the existing pattern for rules.\\n\\nPlease investigate and report back (with concrete file paths and line numbers):\\n\\n1. Where rules are DECLARED in the taxonomy. Look under `.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/` (subdirs: assemblies, doctrine, bundles) and anywhere else taxonomy rule declarations live (e.g. `taxonomy-source/`). Find an existing rule that is similar in kind — specifically look for any existing rule about a document's \\\"summary\\\" field, or a similar \\\"field must not be empty\\\" rule (e.g. something checking a required front-matter field), and show me its full declaration including fields like id, severity, remedy kind (mechanical vs rewrite -> error vs advisory), description/message, and which category/document types it applies to.\\n\\n2. Where rules are IMPLEMENTED in the engine. Look under `engine/crates/check/src/` and `engine/crates/check/tests/` and `engine/crates/check/fixtures/`. Find the Rust code that implements a comparable rule — ideally one that checks a single required field is non-empty/present on a document (front matter field like \\\"summary\\\", \\\"title\\\", etc). Show the full function/match arm, how it reports a finding/diagnostic, how it looks up the rule's severity/id from the taxonomy declaration, and how a new rule would plug in (e.g. is there a central registry/dispatch, a trait, an enum of rule checks?).\\n\\n3. How severity (error vs advisory) is represented in both the taxonomy declaration and the Rust code — the exact type/enum names and field names.\\n\\n4. Whether there's a \\\"summary\\\" field on documents at all — check `docs/spec/` or other docs describing document front matter to confirm a \\\"summary\\\" field exists and is distinct from other fields like \\\"title\\\" or \\\"description\\\".\\n\\n5. Any existing fixture test (in engine/crates/check/fixtures or tests) for an analogous \\\"empty field\\\" rule, so I can see the expected test file layout for a new rule's fixtures.\\n\\nReport concrete file paths, line ranges, and the relevant code/YAML/TOML snippets verbatim. Keep your final report well organized but no more than ~600 words of prose (code snippets don't count against that).\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "ScheduleWakeup"
argument: "{\"delaySeconds\":300,\"reason\":\"waiting on Explore agent researching rule declaration/implementation pattern\",\"prompt\":\"Check on the background Explore agent researching how headwater check rules are declared (taxonomy) and implemented (engine/crates/check). If it has reported back, use its findings to implement the new \\\"empty summary\\\" rule: add the taxonomy declaration, the Rust check implementation, and fixtures/tests following the existing pattern. Then answer the user's original question: where the rule is declared, where it is implemented, and what its severity is (likely advisory, per CLAUDE.md's rule that a rewrite-remedy check is advisory). If the agent hasn't finished, wait longer.\",\"noop\":true}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater/packages/headwater-standard -type d | head -50\",\"description\":\"List directories under headwater-standard package\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find . -iname \\\"*taxonomy-source*\\\" -maxdepth 4 2>/dev/null; find engine/crates/check -maxdepth 3 -type d 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Find taxonomy-source and check crate dirs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find ./taxonomy-source -maxdepth 3 -type d; echo \\\"---\\\"; find ./taxonomy-source -maxdepth 4 -iname \\\"*rule*\\\"\",\"description\":\"Explore taxonomy-source structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "./taxonomy-source"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/packages/headwater-standard"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "./taxonomy-source"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Count lines in taxonomy.yml files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls engine/crates/check/src\",\"description\":\"List check crate source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls engine/crates/check/tests\",\"description\":\"List check crate test files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat -n engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs\",\"description\":\"Read facet_blank.rs source\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat -n engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs\",\"description\":\"Read facet_required.rs source\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat -n engine/crates/check/tests/facet_values.rs\",\"description\":\"Read facet_values test file\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine/crates/check/fixtures/facet-values -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List fixture files for facet-values\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine/crates/check/fixtures -iname \\\"*facet*\\\" -maxdepth 1; echo ---; grep -n \\\"mod tests\\\" -r engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs; echo ---; grep -rn \\\"facet_blank\\\\|facet_required\\\" engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs engine/crates/check/tests/*.rs 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Search for facet blank/required fixtures and tests\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1440,1540p' engine/crates/check/tests/fixtures.rs\",\"description\":\"Read fixtures.rs around facet_required tests\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat -n engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/05-no-summary.md 2>/dev/null; echo ---; find engine/crates/check/fixtures/check -maxdepth 3 -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"Read the no-summary fixture and list check fixture dir\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat -n engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md; echo ---TEST---; sed -n '1970,2030p' engine/crates/check/tests/fixtures.rs\",\"description\":\"Read blank-facets fixture and nearby test code\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\\b\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -40\",\"description\":\"Find all summary mentions in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,20p' engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/21-summary-facet-prose.md 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Peek at summary-facet-prose fixture for context\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '375,395p' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Show summary facet declaration with context\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '370,440p' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Inspect summary facet declaration in taxonomy source\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"OB-FACET-3\\\\|CT-FACET-3\\\" -A 12 taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -60\",\"description\":\"Show OB-FACET-3 and CT-FACET-3 declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r89/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r89/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md"
result: "sha256:ab8d0eb139f3733cde3ca712a0f637ff8fe82f70fc93a55f87b27273fad00d57"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r9"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la | head -30 && echo --- && git status 2>&1 | head -5\",\"description\":\"Check directory contents and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 3 -type d 2>&1 | head -50\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy package directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater/packages -type f | head -100\",\"description\":\"List all files under taxonomy packages\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r9/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r9/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r9/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r9/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r9/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r9/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r9/engine/crates/check"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r9/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md"
result: "sha256:ab8d0eb139f3733cde3ca712a0f637ff8fe82f70fc93a55f87b27273fad00d57"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r90"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; ls -la | head -30\",\"description\":\"Check whether current directory is a git repository\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find . -maxdepth 4 -iname \\\"*.git\\\" 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---settings---\\\"; cat .claude/settings.json 2>/dev/null | head -50\",\"description\":\"Check for git directory and claude settings hooks\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -i \\\"worktree\\\" .claude/settings.json 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---\\\"; cat .claude/settings.json 2>/dev/null | python3 -c \\\"import json,sys; d=json.load(sys.stdin); print(list(d.get('hooks',{}).keys()))\\\"\",\"description\":\"Search settings.json for worktree hook configuration\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"Find where engine rules are declared (taxonomy) for checks like \\\"document summary non-empty\\\", and where existing similar rules (e.g. front-matter/summary field validation) are implemented in the engine code, to add a new rule reporting a document whose summary is empty.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== docs/taxonomies ===\\\"; ls -la docs/taxonomies 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"=== .headwater ===\\\"; ls -la .headwater; echo \\\"=== .headwater/packages ===\\\"; find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 3 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"=== engine top ===\\\"; find engine -maxdepth 2\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy docs and engine directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== .headwater/taxonomy.yml ===\\\"; cat .headwater/taxonomy.yml; echo \\\"=== package taxonomy.yml head ===\\\"; sed -n '1,100p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Show top-level and package taxonomy declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== grep summary in taxonomy-source ===\\\"; grep -rn \\\"summary\\\" taxonomy-source/ --include=*.yml -l; echo \\\"=== grep summary field definitions ===\\\"; grep -rn \\\"summary\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -40\",\"description\":\"Search taxonomy source for summary field declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r90/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== check crate structure ===\\\"; find engine/crates/check -type f | sort; echo; echo \\\"=== grep empty in check crate ===\\\"; grep -rn \\\"empty\\\" engine/crates/check/src | head -50\",\"description\":\"List check crate files and search for empty-related logic\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r90/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== grep facet.value.blank across repo ===\\\"; grep -rln \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet_blank\\\\|FacetBlank\\\\|Blank::over\\\" --include=*.rs --include=*.md --include=*.yml . 2>/dev/null | grep -v \\\"/target/\\\"\",\"description\":\"Find all references to the facet blank rule across code and docs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r90/docs/decisions/0058-a-blank-facet-value-is-a-rule-of-its-own-and-it-reads-every-string-facet.md"
result: "sha256:7c1e03d300ff01f37bf38245f8adbfb1b6ef00e6dcc45839abd740efdb29ad21"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== grep CT-FACET-3 / OB-FACET-3 ===\\\"; grep -rn \\\"CT-FACET-3\\\\|OB-FACET-3\\\" --include=*.yml --include=*.md . 2>/dev/null | grep -v \\\"/target/\\\"\",\"description\":\"Locate the control/obligation pair binding facet.value.blank\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '820,835p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml; echo \\\"---CT-FACET-3---\\\"; sed -n '1280,1292p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Show OB-FACET-3 and CT-FACET-3 declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"facet_blank\\\\|Blank\\\\b\\\" engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs; echo \\\"---\\\"; grep -n \\\"forbid\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -20; echo \\\"---bundles forbid summary?---\\\"; grep -rln \\\"forbid\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/*/taxonomy.yml 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Check rule registration in lib.rs and whether any kind forbids summary\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r91"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls && echo --- && ls .headwater 2>/dev/null && echo --- && ls docs/spec 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List repo root and key directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls engine && echo --- && find engine -iname \\\"*taxonomy*\\\" -maxdepth 3 && echo --- && grep -rl \\\"summary\\\" .headwater/taxonomy.yml docs/taxonomies 2>/dev/null | head -50\",\"description\":\"Survey engine directory and search for summary references\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat .headwater/taxonomy.yml | head -100\",\"description\":\"View taxonomy.yml header\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find taxonomy-source -maxdepth 4 -type d | head -50\",\"description\":\"Explore taxonomy-source directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find taxonomy-source -maxdepth 6 | head -100\",\"description\":\"List full taxonomy-source tree\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rl \\\"rules:\\\" taxonomy-source .headwater 2>/dev/null | head -30; echo ---; find . -iname \\\"bundle.yml\\\" -not -path \\\"*/fixtures/*\\\" 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Find rules declarations and bundle files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat docs/taxonomies/design-spec/bundle.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater/packages/headwater-standard -maxdepth 3 | head -60\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r91/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"scent\\\" --include=*.yml --include=*.md -l . 2>/dev/null | grep -v fixtures | head -30\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml 2>/dev/null | head -40\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r91/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine/crates/check -maxdepth 2 -type d; echo ---; find engine/crates -maxdepth 1 -type d\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls engine/crates/check/src; echo ---; grep -rn \\\"blank\\\\|required_missing\\\\|facet.required\\\\|facet\\\\\\\\.value\\\" engine/crates/check/src | head -40\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r91/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rln \\\"summary\\\" engine/crates/check/tests engine/crates/check/fixtures 2>/dev/null | head -20\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine/crates/check/tests -iname \\\"*blank*\\\"; echo ---; grep -n \\\"facet_blank\\\\|facet\\\\\\\\.value\\\\\\\\.blank\\\" -r engine/crates/check/tests | head -30\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1920,2030p' engine/crates/check/tests/fixtures.rs\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r92"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-engine\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".headwater/packages/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/taxonomies/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".claude/skills/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r92/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r92/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r92/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r92/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r92/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r92/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md"
result: "sha256:ab8d0eb139f3733cde3ca712a0f637ff8fe82f70fc93a55f87b27273fad00d57"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r92/engine/crates/check/tests/facet_values.rs"
result: "sha256:985d05f78c0a118cc2508c398b07a1832e97dca207d830a46e002a6576c1c822"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r92/engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md"
result: "sha256:ab8d0eb139f3733cde3ca712a0f637ff8fe82f70fc93a55f87b27273fad00d57"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r93"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Find rule declaration and implementation pattern\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"I'm working in a repo called Headwater (a documentation-governance engine). I need to add a new check rule: \\\"reports a document whose summary is empty.\\\" To do this correctly I need to understand the existing pattern for how rules are declared and implemented.\\n\\nPlease investigate and report back (very thorough):\\n\\n1. Where rules are DECLARED — likely something under `.headwater/packages/` or `docs/taxonomies/` (a taxonomy). Find the taxonomy file(s) that list existing rules (e.g. there's a mention of rules like a hard-wrapped Markdown block, retired terms, British spelling, contractions, sentence length, semicolons, stock metaphors, voice categories). Show me the exact structure/schema used to declare a rule: field names, how severity is set (error vs advisory), how a rule references its implementation, any \\\"remedy\\\" or \\\"fix\\\" classification field.\\n\\n2. Where rules are IMPLEMENTED — likely a Rust crate under `engine/` (headwater-cli or similar crates, maybe headwater-check or headwater-taxonomy). Find the source files implementing existing checks — especially ones that check document-level metadata/front matter (since \\\"summary\\\" would likely be a front-matter field). Look for how a rule like \\\"front matter is missing a required field\\\" or similar metadata-presence rule is implemented, since \\\"empty summary\\\" is analogous. Show me file paths, function/struct names, and how a new rule would plug in (e.g. is there a trait, a registry, a rule ID scheme).\\n\\n3. Find whether there's a `summary` field already defined in front matter schema/spec (check docs/spec/ for front matter definition) — does documents already have a `summary:` field in front matter? Where is it specified?\\n\\n4. Look for any existing rule that's close in spirit (e.g. \\\"empty X field\\\", \\\"missing required field\\\") to understand the severity convention — is \\\"empty field\\\" something with a mechanical total remedy (making it an error) or does it require a rewrite (advisory)? Look at the rule categorized as error vs advisory examples in CLAUDE.md: \\\"A rule is an error when its remedy is mechanical and total: a contraction, a British spelling, a hard-wrapped block, and a retired term that names its replacement. A rule is advisory when the remedy is a rewrite: a sentence past 25 words, a semicolon, a stock metaphor, and every voice category.\\\"\\n\\n5. Find the rule ID naming scheme (e.g. in CLAUDE.md there's `language.retired_term.used` as an example rule ID) - what categories exist, and what category an \\\"empty summary\\\" rule would fall under (likely something like `metadata.summary.empty` or similar, check existing naming for document-structure/front-matter rules).\\n\\nReport concrete file paths and line numbers/excerpts for everything above. Don't make changes, just research and report findings in detail (this can be a longer report, accuracy matters more than brevity).\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo --- && find . -maxdepth 3 -type d | sort\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "ScheduleWakeup"
argument: "{\"delaySeconds\":300,\"reason\":\"waiting on Explore agent mapping rule declaration/implementation pattern\",\"noop\":true}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== taxonomy-source/headwater-standard ===\\\" && find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r93/taxonomy-source -type f | head -100\\necho \\\"=== docs/taxonomies top ===\\\" && find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r93/docs/taxonomies -maxdepth 1 -type f\\necho \\\"=== .headwater/packages ===\\\" && find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r93/.headwater/packages -type f | head -100\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r93/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r93\\necho \\\"=== CLAUDE.md rule id / severity section ===\\\" \\ngrep -n \\\"retired_term\\\\|rule_id\\\\|severity\\\\|advisory\\\\|error\\\\|mechanical\\\" CLAUDE.md | head -80\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r93/CLAUDE.md"
result: "sha256:c92caed27f86014c5f496edda4ca85568e1da2a44e9c15e4aece92ff9b5bbfd2"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r93/engine/crates/check\\necho \\\"=== dir listing ===\\\" \\nfind . -type f -name \\\"*.rs\\\" | xargs -I{} wc -l {} | sort -n | tail -60\\necho \\\"=== search for facet.required.missing ===\\\"\\ngrep -rn \\\"facet.required.missing\\\\|FacetRequiredMissing\\\\|facet_required\\\" --include=*.rs . | head -30\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r93/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r93\\necho \\\"=== CT-FACET-3 in taxonomy.yml ===\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"CT-FACET-3\\\" -A6 taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"=== facet_required.rs full ===\\\"\\ncat -n engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r93\\necho \\\"=== docs/spec files ===\\\"\\nls docs/spec/\\necho \\\"=== grep summary in docs/spec ===\\\"\\ngrep -rn \\\"summary\\\" docs/spec/*.md | head -40\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r93\\necho \\\"=== all RULE const strings ===\\\"\\ngrep -rn 'pub const RULE: &str' engine/crates/check/src/*.rs\\necho \\\"=== rule id categories (prefix before first dot) ===\\\"\\ngrep -rhoP 'pub const RULE: &str = \\\"\\\\K[^\\\"]+' engine/crates/check/src/*.rs | sed 's/\\\\..*//' | sort -u\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r93/engine/crates/check\\nsed -n '1,60p' src/lib.rs\\necho ---\\nsed -n '140,260p' src/lib.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r93/engine/crates/check\\nsed -n '420,460p' src/lib.rs\\necho \\\"=== finding.rs severity ===\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"enum Severity\\\" -A10 src/finding.rs\\necho \\\"=== around line 760-780 (shape read) ===\\\"\\nsed -n '760,790p' src/lib.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r93/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r93\\ngrep -n \\\"fixability\\\\|mechanical\\\\|five origins\\\\|rule id\\\\|rule_id\\\\|dotted\\\" docs/spec/12-check-layer.md | head -30\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r93/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r93/engine/crates/check\\ngrep -n \\\"severity\\\" src/shape.rs src/facet_value.rs src/facet_required.rs | head -30\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r93/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r93/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r93/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r94"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r94\",\"description\":\"List repo root\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".headwater/packages/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r94/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Count lines in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r94/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r94/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r94/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r94/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r94/engine\",\"description\":\"List engine directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r94/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r94/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r94/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r94/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r94/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r94/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r94/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r95"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && ls -la && echo --- && test -d .git && echo IS_GIT || echo NOT_GIT\",\"description\":\"Check working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== .headwater ===\\\" && find .headwater -maxdepth 3 -type d && echo \\\"=== docs/taxonomies ===\\\" && find docs/taxonomies -maxdepth 2 2>/dev/null && echo \\\"=== engine crates ===\\\" && find engine -maxdepth 2 -type d\",\"description\":\"Survey taxonomy and engine directory layout\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Locate rule declaration and implementation pattern\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"This is the Headwater engine repository (a documentation-governance engine). I need to add a new check rule: \\\"reports a document whose summary is empty\\\" (i.e., a document's front-matter `summary` field is empty or missing). I need to understand the existing pattern for how rules are declared and implemented, so I can add a new one consistently. Specifically answer:\\n\\n1. Where are check rules DECLARED (not implemented)? Look in `.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/` (doctrine/, bundles/, assemblies/) and `docs/taxonomies/*/doctrine.md`. Find an existing rule similar in spirit to \\\"document whose summary is empty\\\" — e.g. a rule about a required front-matter field being missing/empty, or similar structural rule. Show me the exact file and the YAML/text block that declares a rule, including its id, severity, and any fields like `remedy`, `category`, etc. I want a concrete example of the full schema of a rule declaration.\\n\\n2. Where are check rules IMPLEMENTED in the Rust engine (`engine/crates/check` likely, maybe also `engine/crates/meta`, `engine/crates/doc`)? Find the source file(s) implementing an existing structural/front-matter rule (e.g. the \\\"no arbitrary line breaks\\\" rule, or a \\\"retired term\\\" rule, or any rule checking a front-matter field). Show me file paths and the relevant function/struct names, and how severity (error vs advisory) is encoded in the Rust code.\\n\\n3. Is there a rule ID naming convention (e.g. `language.retired_term.used` was mentioned in CLAUDE.md as an example directive key)? Find the full list of existing rule IDs if there's a central registry (maybe `docs/taxonomies/*/doctrine.md` or a rules.yml or similar), and see if there's already a rule about \\\"summary\\\" field (maybe about summary length, or summary required) that I should find and extend instead of duplicating.\\n\\n4. Find where \\\"summary\\\" as a front-matter field is defined/required in the doc schema (search for `summary:` in docs/spec, docs/taxonomies, and engine code) to confirm it's an established field name.\\n\\nReport file paths with line numbers for everything you find. Be concrete — I will write code based on your findings. Keep the report under 600 words plus code excerpts.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r95 -maxdepth 4 -type d | sort | head -100\",\"description\":\"List top-level directories to orient\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater/packages/headwater-standard -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List files in headwater-standard package\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r95/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/diataxis-site/doctrine.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r95/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/doctrine/starter.md"
result: "sha256:0fa70c1338a7e24ec5a3e0f8202cceffb1ea53182ce2ba91341a8ecf8d1e104a"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r95/engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r95/engine/crates/check/src -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List check crate source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r95/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r95/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r95/engine/crates/check/src/frontmatter.rs"
result: "sha256:b6864d616cbf7133eb84efa03e36c9092b9a2aa50c6e7d0e87408bfd68914f8a"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r95/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,120p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r95/docs/subsystems/checks-and-cache.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"RULES\\\\|retired\\\\|language\\\\.\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r95/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs | head -80\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"retired_term\\\\|language\\\\.\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r95/CLAUDE.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r95/engine/crates/check/src/retired.rs"
result: "sha256:f5b731fb776bd69f60f0c9e65d04df7010f76cedbb783a817509504d83bcf934"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r95 -maxdepth 1 -name \\\"overlay.yml\\\"; sed -n '1,40p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r95/.headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null; grep -n \\\"retired_terms\\\" -A 10 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r95/.headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null | head -30\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r95/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '370,440p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Inspect taxonomy.yml summary facet declaration\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== facet_required.rs (around rule id, struct, evaluate) ===\\\" && sed -n '1,130p' engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs\",\"description\":\"Read facet_required.rs implementation\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,40p;90,220p' engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs\",\"description\":\"Read facet_blank.rs for rule id, blank detection, severity\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"facet_required::RULE\\\\|facet_blank::RULE\\\\|\\\\\\\"facet.required.missing\\\\\\\"\\\\|\\\\\\\"facet.value.blank\\\\\\\"\\\" engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs\",\"description\":\"Confirm both rules are registered in lib.rs RULES/registry\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r96"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r96\",\"description\":\"List top-level repo contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r96/.headwater -maxdepth 3 -type d\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r96/.claude/skills -maxdepth 1 -type d 2>/dev/null; echo ---; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r96/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard -maxdepth 4\",\"description\":\"List project skills and taxonomy package structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r96/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Show taxonomy.yml contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r96/.headwater"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r96/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r96/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r96/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r96/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^[a-z_]*:\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r96/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -80\",\"description\":\"List top-level keys in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r96/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r96/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r96/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r96/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r96/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r96/.headwater"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r96"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r96/.headwater/ids/obligation_record_id/HW-OBL-0170 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---search docs---\\\"; grep -rl \\\"HW-OBL-0170\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r96/docs 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Inspect HW-OBL-0170 claim and find its document\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r96/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r96/docs/obligations/0170-the-blank-facet-value-rule-reaches-no-obligation-so-the-report-names-none.md"
result: "sha256:7ff80804e56d1a70febe2ecb2c5a5d9b26cc551571f98ac617a21b1af3ffd730"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r96/docs/decisions/0058-a-blank-facet-value-is-a-rule-of-its-own-and-it-reads-every-string-facet.md"
result: "sha256:7c1e03d300ff01f37bf38245f8adbfb1b6ef00e6dcc45839abd740efdb29ad21"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r96/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r96/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r96/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r97"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls && echo --- && find .headwater -maxdepth 3 -type d 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List repo root and headwater directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 6 | head -100\",\"description\":\"List headwater-standard package contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"rule\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -50\",\"description\":\"Search taxonomy.yml for rule declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -80\",\"description\":\"Search for summary field references in taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r97/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"empty\\\\|blank\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -50\",\"description\":\"Search for empty/blank field rules in taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r97/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet_value_blank\\\\|FacetValueBlank\\\" engine --include=*.rs -l\",\"description\":\"Find engine implementation of facet.value.blank rule\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r97/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,200p' engine/crates/cli/tests/blank_facet.rs | grep -n \\\"summary\\\\|title\\\" | head -40\",\"description\":\"Check blank_facet test for summary coverage\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"OB-FACET-3\\\" -A 6 .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -30; echo ---; sed -n '1,40p' engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs | grep -n \\\"Severity\\\" \",\"description\":\"Look up OB-FACET-3 obligation and Severity enum definition\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"posture\\\" -r docs/spec/12-check-layer.md docs/spec/*.md 2>/dev/null | head -20\",\"description\":\"Find definition of 'posture' in spec docs\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r98"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Find rule declaration and implementation pattern\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"In this repository (Headwater), I need to add a new check rule to the engine: a rule that reports a document whose `summary` field (likely in front matter) is empty. I need to understand the existing pattern for how rules are declared and implemented, so I can add a new one consistently.\\n\\nPlease find and report back with specifics (file paths, line numbers, code/config snippets):\\n\\n1. Where rules are DECLARED (the taxonomy). Look under `.headwater/packages/`, `docs/taxonomies/`, `taxonomy-source/`, and `.headwater/overlay.yml`. Find an existing rule similar in spirit (e.g., a rule checking a required field is present/non-empty, or checking front matter like `summary`, `title`, etc.) and show its full declaration including how severity (error vs advisory) is specified, and what ids/naming convention rules use (e.g. \\\"language.retired_term.used\\\" style ids were mentioned in CLAUDE.md).\\n\\n2. Where rules are IMPLEMENTED in the engine code. Look under `engine/` (likely a Rust crate, e.g. `headwater-cli` or similar sub-crates). Find the source file(s) implementing a comparable rule (ideally one that checks a document field like summary/title emptiness, or any simple structural check), and show the function/module structure, how a finding is reported, and how severity maps from declaration to implementation.\\n\\n3. Find out what `summary` means in this corpus's front matter schema - is it a required front-matter field on governed documents? Check docs like docs/spec/ or DEVELOPING.md or taxonomy schema files for \\\"summary\\\" field definition.\\n\\n4. Find how severity levels are defined - the CLAUDE.md says \\\"a rule is an error when its remedy is mechanical and total... A rule is advisory when the remedy is a rewrite\\\". Find the actual enum/field names used for severity in the taxonomy format (error/advisory or similar) and in the Rust code (enum variants).\\n\\n5. Look for a rule-authoring guide — DEVELOPING.md section or a skill (headwater-taxonomy skill files under .claude/skills or similar) that documents the exact steps/schema for adding a new rule.\\n\\nReport concrete file paths and line numbers/snippets for all of the above so I can directly replicate the pattern. Keep the report organized by these 5 numbered points. This is a research task only - do not edit any files.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== repo root ===\\\"; ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r98; echo \\\"=== find headwater related dirs ===\\\"; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r98 -maxdepth 4 -iname \\\"*headwater*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*.headwater*\\\" 2>/dev/null | head -100\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r98\\necho \\\"=== taxonomy-source ===\\\"; find $ROOT/taxonomy-source -maxdepth 6 -type f | head -200\\necho \\\"=== .headwater/packages ===\\\"; find $ROOT/.headwater/packages -maxdepth 6 -type f | head -200\\necho \\\"=== .headwater top ===\\\"; find $ROOT/.headwater -maxdepth 3\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r98\\nwc -l $ROOT/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"---diff check---\\\"\\ndiff $ROOT/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml $ROOT/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml && echo \\\"IDENTICAL\\\"\\nfind $ROOT -maxdepth 1 -iname \\\"overlay.yml\\\"\\nfind $ROOT/.headwater -iname \\\"overlay.yml\\\"\\nfind $ROOT -iname \\\"overlay.yml\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r98/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r98/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r98/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r98/engine"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r98/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r98/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r98\\necho \\\"=== finding.rs ===\\\"; find $ROOT/engine -path \\\"*/check/src/finding.rs\\\"\\necho \\\"=== register ===\\\"; find $ROOT/engine -iname \\\"*register*\\\" -path \\\"*check*\\\"\\necho \\\"=== lib.rs of check crate ===\\\"; find $ROOT/engine/crates/check/src -maxdepth 1 -name \\\"lib.rs\\\"\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r98/engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs"
result: "sha256:9f8a918e35bdf5ef4403e17e3bf2b78e70486bf09e4c79ccf3944b57af2a8272"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r98/engine/crates/check/src/register.rs"
result: "sha256:52031940b257aae736f4ee275b599207b10a9774d05b6934c201a66749b9f224"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r98\\necho \\\"=== lib.rs ===\\\"; cat $ROOT/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs | head -150\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r98\\nsed -n '150,400p' $ROOT/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r98/DEVELOPING.md"
result: "sha256:8fbd8eb18a5b58dcbf5bfa3a763cea8bd99c0f877dfbc00aff7af74c9c9888cb"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r98\\nsed -n '140,320p' $ROOT/DEVELOPING.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r98/DEVELOPING.md"
result: "sha256:8fbd8eb18a5b58dcbf5bfa3a763cea8bd99c0f877dfbc00aff7af74c9c9888cb"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r98\\nfind $ROOT/.agents/skills -maxdepth 3 -type f\\necho \\\"---\\\"\\nfind $ROOT/.claude/skills -maxdepth 3 -type f 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r98/.agents/skills/headwater-taxonomy/SKILL.md"
result: "sha256:f5b9c95bb000782be9586c1b1e263d934d09fc84e8e444ed89c24325004d7220"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r98/.agents/skills/headwater-authoring/SKILL.md"
result: "sha256:5588ef44dba3982a11a84a2df94abfe2a6ec28e24278888e16e2d7d518362520"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r98/CLAUDE.md"
result: "sha256:c92caed27f86014c5f496edda4ca85568e1da2a44e9c15e4aece92ff9b5bbfd2"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r98/CLAUDE.md"
result: "sha256:c92caed27f86014c5f496edda4ca85568e1da2a44e9c15e4aece92ff9b5bbfd2"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r98/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r98\\ngrep -n \\\"pub trait DocumentCheck\\\" -A 25 $ROOT/engine/crates/check/src/scope.rs\\necho \\\"---run fn in lib.rs---\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"fn run\\\" -A 40 $ROOT/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs | head -80\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r98\\nsed -n '760,790p' $ROOT/engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r98/taxonomy-source -iname \\\"taxonomy.yml\\\" 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Locate taxonomy.yml source file\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r98/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r98/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r98/engine -iname \\\"facet_blank.rs\\\" -o -iname \\\"finding.rs\\\" 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Locate engine implementation files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r98/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r98/engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-cold-agent-reaches-the-governing-document-through-the-corpus-descriptor"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r99"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo --- && find . -maxdepth 2 -iname \\\"*.git*\\\" 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Inspect working directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater -maxdepth 3 -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy and headwater config files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find engine -maxdepth 4 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List engine directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "taxonomy-source"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"diff -q taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml; wc -l taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Compare source taxonomy to packaged taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"summary\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Search for summary field mentions in taxonomy source\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,80p' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"View start of taxonomy source to understand schema\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '370,440p' taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"View facets section around summary definition\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^rules:\\\\|^ - id:\\\\|^rules\\\\b\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -50\",\"description\":\"Find rules section entries in taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls engine/crates/check/src\",\"description\":\"List files in check crate src\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "engine/crates/check/src"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r99/engine/crates/check/src/facet_blank.rs"
result: "sha256:1ebf373da656429c364f31a2b3168a5b4b849ca308ed11c9079ebaabff5f8869"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r99/engine/crates/check/src/facet_required.rs"
result: "sha256:fa72bbf3fba7b435ffbf3565d1b984b7cbee8e4f287c54a7aac77d31a14b3859"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "engine/crates/check/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:90b915b89aa5bfa580d03f560d313096d68bd1e7f9524c626dce7a4d0a95c7bb"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"enum Severity\\\" -A 15 engine/crates/check/src/finding.rs\",\"description\":\"View Severity enum definition\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"facet.value.blank\\\\|facet_blank\\\" engine/crates/check/tests 2>/dev/null | head -30\",\"description\":\"Find tests referencing the blank-facet rule\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "engine/crates/check"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p1-r99/engine/crates/check/tests/fixtures.rs"
result: "sha256:7b17c7814d7d48dc348043a7ac9daad7c6839f90f2bdbf21996b66ccc6f34749"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat engine/crates/check/fixtures/check/spec/18-blank-facets.md\",\"description\":\"View blank facets fixture doc\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r1"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r1/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r1/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r1/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r10"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r10/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r10/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r10/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r10/docs/process/decisions/0005-the-ledger-is-split-its-tabular-parts-are-jsonl-and-its-totals-are-derived.md"
result: "sha256:5e8cf3e064214715cbca7a9cafac21871bf5baf37e87d4dd0ba39b669b9c3e1f"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r100"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -ril \\\"fold\\\" docs .headwater .gitattributes 2>/dev/null | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r100/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r100/docs/evaluations/why-corpus-counts-are-derived-not-stored.md"
result: "sha256:3a7be026c31e35bfd308787760aa7b8f0eacae392319439e4128e9717090f44e"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r101"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r101/docs/decisions"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r101/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r101/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r102"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls && echo --- && grep -rl \\\"fold\\\" docs/decisions docs/requirements 2>/dev/null | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r102/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r103"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r103"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r103/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r103/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r104"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r104/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r104/docs/decisions"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r104/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r105"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r105/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r105/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r105/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r106"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r106"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r106/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r106/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r106/docs/process/decisions/0005-the-ledger-is-split-its-tabular-parts-are-jsonl-and-its-totals-are-derived.md"
result: "sha256:5e8cf3e064214715cbca7a9cafac21871bf5baf37e87d4dd0ba39b669b9c3e1f"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r107"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rl \\\"fold\\\" docs/decisions docs/requirements docs/subsystems 2>/dev/null | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r107/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r107/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r108"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls && echo --- && grep -rl \\\"derived fold\\\" --include=*.md . | head -30\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r108/docs/interfaces/headwater-merge-driver.md"
result: "sha256:a7d23b7c766239d0c61aa8de8f40a94e91992d126df14e7587cb63049b3c4da2"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r109"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r109/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r109/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r109/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r11"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r11/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r11/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r11/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r11/docs/evaluations/why-corpus-counts-are-derived-not-stored.md"
result: "sha256:3a7be026c31e35bfd308787760aa7b8f0eacae392319439e4128e9717090f44e"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r110"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r110/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r110/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r110/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r111"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r111/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r111/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r112"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rliE \\\"fold\\\" docs/ .headwater 2>/dev/null | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r112/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r113"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls && echo --- && git status 2>&1 | head -5\",\"description\":\"List working directory contents and check git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r113/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r114"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r114/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r114/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r114/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r115"
calls:
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Find doc governing derived total merge conflicts\",\"prompt\":\"In this repository (/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r115), I'm looking for the specific governing document that rules on how a derived aggregate value (e.g., a \\\"total\\\" count stored in a shared file, computed as a fold/sum over many documents) must be kept so that two branches which each add a page/document, and each independently update that shared total, don't silently produce a wrong total when git merges them with no textual conflict.\\n\\nThis is the classic \\\"semantic merge conflict\\\" / \\\"derived artifact\\\" problem — git sees no conflict because each branch edited the total differently but in a textually non-conflicting way (or git picks one side), so the merged total is wrong even though no merge conflict was flagged.\\n\\nSearch docs/decisions/, docs/subsystems/, docs/process/, docs/spec/ and anywhere else relevant for terms like: \\\"derived fold\\\", \\\"fold\\\", \\\"total\\\", \\\"merge-regenerate\\\", \\\"derived artifact\\\", \\\"regenerate\\\", \\\"git merge driver\\\", \\\"semantic conflict\\\", \\\"aggregate\\\". Also check .gitattributes and .githooks/merge-regenerate for context on which files/paths are marked as derived folds requiring regeneration rather than textual merge.\\n\\nI need the single document path that \\\"rules on\\\" this policy — i.e., states the requirement/decision that such shared derived totals must not be stored as a directly-merged value but instead regenerated (or similar ruling). Report back the exact file path and a short quote/excerpt showing it governs this exact scenario.\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find . -maxdepth 3 -type d | sort\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "ScheduleWakeup"
argument: "{\"delaySeconds\":90,\"noop\":true,\"reason\":\"Waiting on background Explore agent to find the governing document\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r115"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r115/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r115/.githooks/merged-fold-check 2>/dev/null | head -50; echo ---; cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r115/.githooks/merge-regenerate 2>/dev/null | head -50\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r116"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r116/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r116/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r116/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r117"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r117"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r117/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r117/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r117/docs/evaluations/why-corpus-counts-are-derived-not-stored.md"
result: "sha256:3a7be026c31e35bfd308787760aa7b8f0eacae392319439e4128e9717090f44e"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r118"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r118/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r118/docs/decisions"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r118/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r12"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r12/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r12/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r13"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r13/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r13/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r13/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r14"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r14/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r14/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r14/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r14/docs/evaluations/why-corpus-counts-are-derived-not-stored.md"
result: "sha256:3a7be026c31e35bfd308787760aa7b8f0eacae392319439e4128e9717090f44e"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r15"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r15/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r15/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r16"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r16/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r16/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r16/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r16/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r16/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r16/docs/how-to/keep-derived-files-from-conflicting-in-parallel-pull-requests.md"
result: "sha256:d5aa26ce38f184424ba9833cdfc880050a3fe5cb27dcc9ca5a7f3ac92dfc990e"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r17"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls && git status 2>&1 | head -20\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r17 -maxdepth 2 -name \\\".git\\\" 2>&1\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r17/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r17/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r18"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r18/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r18/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r18/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r19"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rli \\\"fold\\\" docs/decisions docs/spec docs/subsystems 2>/dev/null | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r19/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r19/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r19/docs/evaluations/why-corpus-counts-are-derived-not-stored.md"
result: "sha256:3a7be026c31e35bfd308787760aa7b8f0eacae392319439e4128e9717090f44e"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r2"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r2/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r2/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r2/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r2/docs/process/decisions/0005-the-ledger-is-split-its-tabular-parts-are-jsonl-and-its-totals-are-derived.md"
result: "sha256:5e8cf3e064214715cbca7a9cafac21871bf5baf37e87d4dd0ba39b669b9c3e1f"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r20"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r20/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r20/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r20/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r21"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r21/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r21"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r22"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r22/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r22/docs/decisions"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r22/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r23"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r23/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r23/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r23/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r24"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r24/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r24/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r24/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r24/docs/process/decisions/0005-the-ledger-is-split-its-tabular-parts-are-jsonl-and-its-totals-are-derived.md"
result: "sha256:5e8cf3e064214715cbca7a9cafac21871bf5baf37e87d4dd0ba39b669b9c3e1f"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r25"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls && echo --- && grep -rliE \\\"derived (artifact|fold)|regenerat\\\" docs .headwater .githooks 2>/dev/null | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r25/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r26"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r26/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r26/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r26/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r27"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rl \\\"total\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r27/docs --include=*.md -i | xargs grep -l -i \\\"merge\\\\|fold\\\\|derive\\\" | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r27/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r28"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r28/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r28/docs/decisions"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r28/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r28/docs/how-to/keep-derived-files-from-conflicting-in-parallel-pull-requests.md"
result: "sha256:d5aa26ce38f184424ba9833cdfc880050a3fe5cb27dcc9ca5a7f3ac92dfc990e"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r29"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r29/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r29/docs/decisions"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r29/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r3"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r3/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r3/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r3/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r30"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r30/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r30/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r30/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r31"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r31/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r31/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r31/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r32"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r32/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r32/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r32/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r33"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r33/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r33/docs/decisions"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r34"
calls:
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Find doc ruling on derived totals and merge conflicts\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"In this repository (/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r34), I'm looking for a governing document that rules on how a \\\"total\\\" or aggregate count derived from multiple pages/documents is kept correctly when two branches each add content and each update that shared total independently. The scenario: two branches each add a page and each write a new total into a shared file; git merges the two branches with no textual conflict, but the resulting total is wrong (a classic semantic/logical merge conflict, because the total is a derived value, not independently addable).\\n\\nThis repo has a concept of \\\"derived artifacts\\\" that need regeneration rather than a plain git merge (see CLAUDE.md mentions of `.gitattributes` `-merge` attribute, `merge.headwater-regenerate` driver, `.githooks/merge-regenerate`). I need to find the specific document (likely under docs/decisions/, docs/requirements/, docs/spec/, or docs/process/decisions/) that states the rule: a derived total/count must be regenerated from source rather than hand-merged, or must never be stored as an independently-edited value in a shared file — this is what makes the \\\"total\\\" go wrong in the described scenario.\\n\\nSearch for terms like: \\\"derived\\\", \\\"total\\\", \\\"count\\\", \\\"regenerate\\\", \\\"merge driver\\\", \\\"merge=-merge\\\", \\\"fold\\\" (this repo uses \\\"fold\\\" to mean a derived aggregate), \\\"census\\\", \\\"add/add conflict\\\", \\\"semantic conflict\\\". Look particularly in docs/decisions/, docs/requirements/, docs/process/decisions/, docs/spec/, docs/subsystems/.\\n\\nReport back: the exact file path(s) of the document that most directly rules on this \\\"shared total kept correct across merges\\\" problem, a quote or close paraphrase of the ruling, and why it applies to the two-branches-each-add-a-page-and-update-a-total scenario. If there are multiple candidates (e.g. one about derived artifacts generally and one specifically about counts/folds), list all and say which is most on-point. Keep the report under 300 words.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find docs -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List docs subdirectories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r34/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r34/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r34/docs/evaluations/why-corpus-counts-are-derived-not-stored.md"
result: "sha256:3a7be026c31e35bfd308787760aa7b8f0eacae392319439e4128e9717090f44e"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r34/docs/how-to/keep-derived-files-from-conflicting-in-parallel-pull-requests.md"
result: "sha256:d5aa26ce38f184424ba9833cdfc880050a3fe5cb27dcc9ca5a7f3ac92dfc990e"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r34/docs/process/decisions/0005-the-ledger-is-split-its-tabular-parts-are-jsonl-and-its-totals-are-derived.md"
result: "sha256:5e8cf3e064214715cbca7a9cafac21871bf5baf37e87d4dd0ba39b669b9c3e1f"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r35"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r35/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r35/docs/decisions"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r35/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r35/docs/evaluations/why-corpus-counts-are-derived-not-stored.md"
result: "sha256:3a7be026c31e35bfd308787760aa7b8f0eacae392319439e4128e9717090f44e"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r36"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r36/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r36/docs/decisions"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r36/docs/process/decisions/0005-the-ledger-is-split-its-tabular-parts-are-jsonl-and-its-totals-are-derived.md"
result: "sha256:5e8cf3e064214715cbca7a9cafac21871bf5baf37e87d4dd0ba39b669b9c3e1f"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r36/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r37"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r37/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r37/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r37/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r38"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r38/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r38/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r38/docs/process/decisions/0005-the-ledger-is-split-its-tabular-parts-are-jsonl-and-its-totals-are-derived.md"
result: "sha256:5e8cf3e064214715cbca7a9cafac21871bf5baf37e87d4dd0ba39b669b9c3e1f"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r39"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r39/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r39/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r39/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r39/docs/how-to/keep-derived-files-from-conflicting-in-parallel-pull-requests.md"
result: "sha256:d5aa26ce38f184424ba9833cdfc880050a3fe5cb27dcc9ca5a7f3ac92dfc990e"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r4"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r4/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r4/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r4/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r4/docs/how-to/keep-derived-files-from-conflicting-in-parallel-pull-requests.md"
result: "sha256:d5aa26ce38f184424ba9833cdfc880050a3fe5cb27dcc9ca5a7f3ac92dfc990e"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r40"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r40/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r40/docs/process/decisions/0005-the-ledger-is-split-its-tabular-parts-are-jsonl-and-its-totals-are-derived.md"
result: "sha256:5e8cf3e064214715cbca7a9cafac21871bf5baf37e87d4dd0ba39b669b9c3e1f"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r40/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r41"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r41/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r41/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r42"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r42/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r42"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r42/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r43"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rl \\\"derived fold\\\\|derived artifact\\\\|regenerate\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r43/docs 2>/dev/null | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r43/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r44"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r44/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r44/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r44/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r45"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r45/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r45/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r45/docs/process/decisions/0005-the-ledger-is-split-its-tabular-parts-are-jsonl-and-its-totals-are-derived.md"
result: "sha256:5e8cf3e064214715cbca7a9cafac21871bf5baf37e87d4dd0ba39b669b9c3e1f"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r45/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r46"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r46"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r46/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r46/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r47"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rl \\\"fold\\\" docs/ --include=*.md -i | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rli \\\"total\\\" docs/ | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r47/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r48"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r48"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r48/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r48/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r49"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r49/docs"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r5"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r5/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r5/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r5/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r50"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r50/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r50/docs/decisions"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r50/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r51"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r51/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r51/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r51/docs/process/decisions/0005-the-ledger-is-split-its-tabular-parts-are-jsonl-and-its-totals-are-derived.md"
result: "sha256:5e8cf3e064214715cbca7a9cafac21871bf5baf37e87d4dd0ba39b669b9c3e1f"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r51/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r52"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r52/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r52/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r52/docs/process/decisions/0005-the-ledger-is-split-its-tabular-parts-are-jsonl-and-its-totals-are-derived.md"
result: "sha256:5e8cf3e064214715cbca7a9cafac21871bf5baf37e87d4dd0ba39b669b9c3e1f"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r52/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r53"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r53/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r53/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r53/docs/evaluations/why-corpus-counts-are-derived-not-stored.md"
result: "sha256:3a7be026c31e35bfd308787760aa7b8f0eacae392319439e4128e9717090f44e"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r53/docs/how-to/keep-derived-files-from-conflicting-in-parallel-pull-requests.md"
result: "sha256:d5aa26ce38f184424ba9833cdfc880050a3fe5cb27dcc9ca5a7f3ac92dfc990e"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r54"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{\"name\":\"find-total-doc\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r54/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r54/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r54/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r55"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls && echo --- && grep -rl \\\"derived fold\\\\|regenerate\\\\|fold\\\" docs 2>/dev/null | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r55/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r56"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r56/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r56/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r56/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r57"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r57/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r57"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r57/docs/evaluations/why-corpus-counts-are-derived-not-stored.md"
result: "sha256:3a7be026c31e35bfd308787760aa7b8f0eacae392319439e4128e9717090f44e"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r58"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r58/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r58/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r58/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r59"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r59/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r59/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r59/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r6"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r6/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/decisions/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r6/docs/process/decisions/0005-the-ledger-is-split-its-tabular-parts-are-jsonl-and-its-totals-are-derived.md"
result: "sha256:5e8cf3e064214715cbca7a9cafac21871bf5baf37e87d4dd0ba39b669b9c3e1f"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r6/docs/how-to/keep-derived-files-from-conflicting-in-parallel-pull-requests.md"
result: "sha256:d5aa26ce38f184424ba9833cdfc880050a3fe5cb27dcc9ca5a7f3ac92dfc990e"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r6/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r60"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r60/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r60/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r60/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r61"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r61"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r62"
calls:
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Find document ruling on derived totals and merge\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"In this repository (/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r62), I need to find a specific governing document.\\n\\nScenario: Two git branches each add one page/document to the corpus. Each branch also independently writes a new total (like a count) into a shared file (e.g., some index or summary file tracking a count of pages/documents). Git merges the two branches with no textual conflict (because e.g. both branches bump the same counter from N to N+1 independently, so git's three-way merge doesn't see a conflict on that line, but the real correct total should be N+2). The result: the total on the main branch is wrong after the merge.\\n\\nI need to find the document in this repo that RULES ON how such a total/count should be kept so this doesn't happen — likely something about derived/computed values needing to be regenerated rather than hand-maintained or merged as text, OR something about using a merge driver / \\\"derived artifact\\\" / \\\"derived fold\\\" for counts, OR a decision/requirement document specifically about aggregate totals, counts, or sums stored in files that are updated by multiple branches.\\n\\nLook in these likely locations:\\n- docs/decisions/ (search for files mentioning \\\"total\\\", \\\"count\\\", \\\"sum\\\", \\\"aggregate\\\", \\\"derived\\\", \\\"regenerate\\\", \\\"merge driver\\\", \\\"fold\\\")\\n- docs/requirements/\\n- docs/process/decisions/\\n- docs/spec/\\n- docs/subsystems/ (e.g. anything about \\\"census\\\", \\\"fold\\\", \\\"derived artifact\\\")\\n- .headwater/overlay.yml and .gitattributes (for context on \\\"derived fold\\\" / \\\"merge=headwater-regenerate\\\")\\n- DEVELOPING.md\\n\\nSearch with grep for terms like: \\\"total\\\", \\\"derived\\\", \\\"regenerate\\\", \\\"merge driver\\\", \\\"fold\\\", \\\"count\\\", \\\"aggregate\\\", \\\"sum\\\", \\\"add/add\\\", \\\"three-way merge\\\", \\\"no conflict\\\".\\n\\nReport back: the exact file path(s) that most specifically rule on this scenario (a shared total/count that two branches update independently causing silent wrong merge results), with a quote of the relevant ruling text, and the document's title. If there are multiple candidate documents (e.g. a decision doc explaining WHY, and a requirement doc stating the rule), list all of them with paths and brief relevant excerpts.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && find . -maxdepth 3 -type d -iname \\\"*doc*\\\" 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r62"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r62/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r62/docs/evaluations/why-corpus-counts-are-derived-not-stored.md"
result: "sha256:3a7be026c31e35bfd308787760aa7b8f0eacae392319439e4128e9717090f44e"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r62/docs/how-to/keep-derived-files-from-conflicting-in-parallel-pull-requests.md"
result: "sha256:d5aa26ce38f184424ba9833cdfc880050a3fe5cb27dcc9ca5a7f3ac92dfc990e"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r62/docs/process/decisions/0005-the-ledger-is-split-its-tabular-parts-are-jsonl-and-its-totals-are-derived.md"
result: "sha256:5e8cf3e064214715cbca7a9cafac21871bf5baf37e87d4dd0ba39b669b9c3e1f"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r63"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r63/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r63/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r63/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r64"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r64/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r64/docs/decisions"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r64/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r64/docs/process/decisions/0005-the-ledger-is-split-its-tabular-parts-are-jsonl-and-its-totals-are-derived.md"
result: "sha256:5e8cf3e064214715cbca7a9cafac21871bf5baf37e87d4dd0ba39b669b9c3e1f"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r65"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r65/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r65/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r65/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r66"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r66/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r66/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r66/docs/process/decisions/0005-the-ledger-is-split-its-tabular-parts-are-jsonl-and-its-totals-are-derived.md"
result: "sha256:5e8cf3e064214715cbca7a9cafac21871bf5baf37e87d4dd0ba39b669b9c3e1f"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r67"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r67/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r67/docs/process/decisions/0005-the-ledger-is-split-its-tabular-parts-are-jsonl-and-its-totals-are-derived.md"
result: "sha256:5e8cf3e064214715cbca7a9cafac21871bf5baf37e87d4dd0ba39b669b9c3e1f"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r67/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r68"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r68/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r68/docs/decisions/ 2>/dev/null; echo ---; ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r68/docs/process/decisions/ 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List decision documents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r68/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r69"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r69/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r69/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r69/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r7"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r7/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r7/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r7/docs/process/decisions/0005-the-ledger-is-split-its-tabular-parts-are-jsonl-and-its-totals-are-derived.md"
result: "sha256:5e8cf3e064214715cbca7a9cafac21871bf5baf37e87d4dd0ba39b669b9c3e1f"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r7/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r70"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r70/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r70/docs/decisions"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r70/docs/process/decisions/0005-the-ledger-is-split-its-tabular-parts-are-jsonl-and-its-totals-are-derived.md"
result: "sha256:5e8cf3e064214715cbca7a9cafac21871bf5baf37e87d4dd0ba39b669b9c3e1f"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r70/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r71"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r71"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r71/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r71/docs/process/decisions/0005-the-ledger-is-split-its-tabular-parts-are-jsonl-and-its-totals-are-derived.md"
result: "sha256:5e8cf3e064214715cbca7a9cafac21871bf5baf37e87d4dd0ba39b669b9c3e1f"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r72"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; ls -la | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check if directory is a git repository\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r72/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r72/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r72/docs/process/decisions/0005-the-ledger-is-split-its-tabular-parts-are-jsonl-and-its-totals-are-derived.md"
result: "sha256:5e8cf3e064214715cbca7a9cafac21871bf5baf37e87d4dd0ba39b669b9c3e1f"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r72/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r73"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r73/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r73/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r73/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r74"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r74/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r74/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r74/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r75"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r75/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r75/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r75/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r76"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r76/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r76/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r76/docs/process/decisions/0005-the-ledger-is-split-its-tabular-parts-are-jsonl-and-its-totals-are-derived.md"
result: "sha256:5e8cf3e064214715cbca7a9cafac21871bf5baf37e87d4dd0ba39b669b9c3e1f"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r76/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r77"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r77/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r77"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r77/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r78"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r78/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r78/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r79"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r79/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r79/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r8"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/decisions/ 2>/dev/null | head -80\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r8/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r8/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r8/docs/process/decisions/0005-the-ledger-is-split-its-tabular-parts-are-jsonl-and-its-totals-are-derived.md"
result: "sha256:5e8cf3e064214715cbca7a9cafac21871bf5baf37e87d4dd0ba39b669b9c3e1f"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r80"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r80/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r80"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r80/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r81"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r81/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r81/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r81/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r81/docs/process/decisions/0005-the-ledger-is-split-its-tabular-parts-are-jsonl-and-its-totals-are-derived.md"
result: "sha256:5e8cf3e064214715cbca7a9cafac21871bf5baf37e87d4dd0ba39b669b9c3e1f"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r81/docs/how-to/keep-derived-files-from-conflicting-in-parallel-pull-requests.md"
result: "sha256:d5aa26ce38f184424ba9833cdfc880050a3fe5cb27dcc9ca5a7f3ac92dfc990e"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r82"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r82/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r82/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r82/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r83"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r83"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r83/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r83/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r84"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r84/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r85"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r85/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r85/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r86"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r86/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r86/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r86/docs/process/decisions/0005-the-ledger-is-split-its-tabular-parts-are-jsonl-and-its-totals-are-derived.md"
result: "sha256:5e8cf3e064214715cbca7a9cafac21871bf5baf37e87d4dd0ba39b669b9c3e1f"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r87"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r87/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r87/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r87/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r88"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rli \\\"total\\\" docs/decisions docs/spec docs/process 2>/dev/null | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rli \\\"fold\\\" docs/decisions 2>/dev/null | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r88/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r88/docs/process/decisions/0005-the-ledger-is-split-its-tabular-parts-are-jsonl-and-its-totals-are-derived.md"
result: "sha256:5e8cf3e064214715cbca7a9cafac21871bf5baf37e87d4dd0ba39b669b9c3e1f"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r89"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r89/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r89/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r89/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r89/docs/evaluations/why-corpus-counts-are-derived-not-stored.md"
result: "sha256:3a7be026c31e35bfd308787760aa7b8f0eacae392319439e4128e9717090f44e"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r9"
calls:
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Find doc ruling on shared-total merge semantics\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"I'm looking for a specific document in this repository (/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r9) that rules on how a derived/aggregate \\\"total\\\" value kept in a shared file should be maintained across the corpus, specifically addressing the problem: two branches each independently update a running total in a shared file (e.g. a count or sum derived from pages/documents), git merges the two branches textually with no conflict, but the resulting total is wrong because a textual merge doesn't know to combine the two increments correctly.\\n\\nThis repo has a concept of \\\"derived artifacts\\\" / \\\"folds\\\" that are regenerated rather than textually merged (see .gitattributes using a custom merge driver \\\"merge.headwater-regenerate\\\", and .headwater/taxonomy.lock, docs/decisions/0054-the-upper-bound-of-a-reconcile-first-allocator-is-the-corpus-and-a-claim-store.md about an identifier claim store solving an analogous add/add conflict problem).\\n\\nSearch docs/decisions/, docs/spec/, docs/subsystems/, docs/process/decisions/, docs/requirements/, docs/obligations/ for documents discussing: \\\"fold\\\", \\\"derived artifact\\\", \\\"total\\\", \\\"count\\\", \\\"merge driver\\\", \\\"regenerate\\\", \\\"accumulator\\\", \\\"running total\\\", \\\"aggregate\\\". I want the specific document whose title/content directly addresses keeping an aggregate total correct across merges (not the identifier claim store one, unless that's actually the right one — verify).\\n\\nReport back: the exact file path(s) of the most relevant document(s), their titles, and a quote or paraphrase of the specific ruling that addresses this scenario. If multiple candidates exist, tell me which one most precisely matches a \\\"total in a shared file goes wrong after a no-conflict merge\\\" scenario.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls && echo --- && ls docs/decisions | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r9"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r9/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r9/docs/process/decisions/0005-the-ledger-is-split-its-tabular-parts-are-jsonl-and-its-totals-are-derived.md"
result: "sha256:5e8cf3e064214715cbca7a9cafac21871bf5baf37e87d4dd0ba39b669b9c3e1f"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r9/docs/evaluations/why-corpus-counts-are-derived-not-stored.md"
result: "sha256:3a7be026c31e35bfd308787760aa7b8f0eacae392319439e4128e9717090f44e"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r9/docs -iname \\\"*keep-derived-files*\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"test -f \\\"docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md\\\" && echo EXISTS\",\"description\":\"Verify the decision document exists\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r90"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r90/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r90/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r90/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r90/docs/evaluations/why-corpus-counts-are-derived-not-stored.md"
result: "sha256:3a7be026c31e35bfd308787760aa7b8f0eacae392319439e4128e9717090f44e"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r91"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r91/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r91/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r91/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r92"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r92/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r92/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r92/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r93"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r93/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r93/docs/decisions"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r93/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r94"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r94/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r94/docs/process/decisions/0005-the-ledger-is-split-its-tabular-parts-are-jsonl-and-its-totals-are-derived.md"
result: "sha256:5e8cf3e064214715cbca7a9cafac21871bf5baf37e87d4dd0ba39b669b9c3e1f"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r94/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r95"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r95"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r95/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r95/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r96"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r96"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r96/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r96/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r97"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r97"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r97/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r97/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r98"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r98/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r98/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r98/docs/decisions/0049-a-corpus-wide-fold-is-derived-and-never-stored.md"
result: "sha256:cc0d9c67ecca22d8c07f6d43dcff6a9c0f0a3b3a0b2a0e729cb5e767a0868568"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-session-finds-a-ruling-from-a-task-in-plain-words"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r99"
calls:
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r99/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p2-r99/docs/decisions"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r1"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls -la | head -30\",\"description\":\"Check if directory is a git repository and list contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec/glossary.md"
result: "sha256:7a727d91789e2bb03c825ae01ec01639c7ff08f9022b5d03241c734c2148c99a"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "docs/obligations/0046-the-identifier-scheme-grammar.md"
result: "sha256:37617cf0865ec80e7943e2d86017a51fd4ec46b238c3fdc50d5e12e3ce32e006"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r10"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls\",\"description\":\"Check if directory is a git repo and list top-level contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find docs -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List docs subdirectories (shelves)\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r10/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r10/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r10/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r100"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls\",\"description\":\"Check if directory is a git repo and list contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r100/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r100/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r100/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r101"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find docs -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List docs subdirectories (shelves)\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r101/docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md"
result: "sha256:485fe85764154ebfd53b4e549e14fb453931eb09bef862591234f134d90c59b1"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater -maxdepth 3 -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List headwater config/taxonomy files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r101/docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md"
result: "sha256:b1bc8628c695ce6b58c9cbc67502d3b90e3452fd49aaff3710d485dce45824ac"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r101/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r101/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r102"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && ls -la && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"Decide which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r102/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r102/docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r102/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r102/docs/decisions/0057-a-shelf-layout-is-the-second-half-of-what-the-identifier-claim-store-covers.md"
result: "sha256:cfaa5e4b4f2a47f737d0bc5c3e55d4ca0018f46ccf225235d8efbfea8a344287"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r102/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r102/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r103"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check working directory contents and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r103/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r103"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r103/.agents/skills/headwater-authoring/SKILL.md"
result: "sha256:5588ef44dba3982a11a84a2df94abfe2a6ec28e24278888e16e2d7d518362520"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r103/docs/decisions/0057-a-shelf-layout-is-the-second-half-of-what-the-identifier-claim-store-covers.md"
result: "sha256:cfaa5e4b4f2a47f737d0bc5c3e55d4ca0018f46ccf225235d8efbfea8a344287"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r103/.headwater/taxonomy.lock"
result: "sha256:1ea570f4a22e19db2ed394a89bbb5f47f2908847514bb3417fd7a88820333650"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r104"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r104/ && echo --- && ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r104/docs/ 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Inspect working directory and docs folder\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"Decide which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r104/.headwater -maxdepth 4 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r104/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard -maxdepth 1 -type f | sort; echo ---; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r104/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard -iname \\\"*kind*\\\"\",\"description\":\"List package files and kind definitions\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r104/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r104/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles\\nfor d in */; do\\n f=\\\"$d/taxonomy.yml\\\"\\n [ -f \\\"$f\\\" ] || f=$(find \\\"$d\\\" -maxdepth 1 -name \\\"*.yml\\\" | grep -i taxonomy)\\n echo \\\"=== $d ===\\\"\\n grep -n -A2 \\\"^shelves:\\\" \\\"$d\\\"/*.yml 2>/dev/null | head -50\\ndone\",\"description\":\"Peek at shelves declared in each bundle\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r104/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles\\nfind . -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List all bundle files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r104/.headwater -maxdepth 1 -type f; echo ---; cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r104/.headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null | head -200\",\"description\":\"Find and show the repo's overlay taxonomy file\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"shelves:\\\" -A 40 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r104/.headwater/taxonomy.lock | head -60\",\"description\":\"Show resolved shelves block in taxonomy lock\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '967,1070p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r104/.headwater/taxonomy.lock\",\"description\":\"Show rest of shelves block\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1070,1140p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r104/.headwater/taxonomy.lock\",\"description\":\"Show remaining shelves and identifier_schemes block\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1140,1200p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r104/.headwater/taxonomy.lock\",\"description\":\"Show rest of identifier_schemes block\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"awk '/^ kinds:/{flag=1} flag{print} /^ relations:/{exit}' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r104/.headwater/taxonomy.lock | grep -E \\\"^\\\\s{4}[a-z_]+:$|purpose:|write_when:|identifier:|scheme:\\\" \",\"description\":\"Extract kind name, purpose, write_when, identifier scheme from resolved taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat \\\"/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/config/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r104/projects/-var-tmp-hw-1659-b-ws-L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r104/memory/MEMORY.md\\\" 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Check existing memory index\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Write"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/config/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r104/projects/-var-tmp-hw-1659-b-ws-L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r104/memory/shelf_and_identifier_lookup.md"
result: "sha256:589b38d8e7902e588be4975d4a2cc083f28259f36e45b0d2e8d79efd0db268fc"
- tool: "Write"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/config/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r104/projects/-var-tmp-hw-1659-b-ws-L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r104/memory/MEMORY.md"
result: "sha256:e71994df8b826eb3ee4cb69d49968794362ad76562f7b736de0933e8da4eab5c"
produced:
- path: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/config/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r104/projects/-var-tmp-hw-1659-b-ws-L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r104/memory/shelf_and_identifier_lookup.md"
result: "sha256:589b38d8e7902e588be4975d4a2cc083f28259f36e45b0d2e8d79efd0db268fc"
cites:
- "HW-PD-0024"
- path: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/config/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r104/projects/-var-tmp-hw-1659-b-ws-L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r104/memory/MEMORY.md"
result: "sha256:e71994df8b826eb3ee4cb69d49968794362ad76562f7b736de0933e8da4eab5c"
cites: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r105"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"Decide which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r105/docs -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List doc shelf directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r105/.headwater -maxdepth 3 | sort\",\"description\":\"List .headwater config structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r105/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r105/.headwater/packages 2>/dev/null; echo ---; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r105/.headwater/packages -maxdepth 2 2>/dev/null | sort\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy packages\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r105/docs/decisions/0057-a-shelf-layout-is-the-second-half-of-what-the-identifier-claim-store-covers.md"
result: "sha256:cfaa5e4b4f2a47f737d0bc5c3e55d4ca0018f46ccf225235d8efbfea8a344287"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r105/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r105/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -100\",\"description\":\"Peek at base taxonomy shelf declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r105/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r106"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git status 2>&1 | head -20; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find docs -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rl \\\"shelf\\\" docs/spec docs/process docs/doctrine 2>/dev/null | sort; echo \\\"---scheme---\\\"; grep -rl \\\"identifier scheme\\\\|scheme.*identifier\\\" docs/spec 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r106/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"shelf\\\" docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md | head -60\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r107"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check working directory contents and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .claude -iname \\\"settings*.json\\\" 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---\\\"; grep -l \\\"WorktreeCreate\\\\|WorktreeRemove\\\" -r .claude 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Check for worktree hooks in settings\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== docs top-level dirs ===\\\"; ls docs; echo; echo \\\"=== grep for 'shelf' definitions ===\\\"; grep -rl \\\"shelf\\\" docs --include=\\\"*.md\\\" -l | head -30\",\"description\":\"List docs shelves and find files discussing shelf assignment\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"shelf\\\\|scheme\\\\|identifier\\\" DEVELOPING.md | head -80\",\"description\":\"Search DEVELOPING.md for shelf and identifier scheme discussion\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Find shelf and identifier scheme rules\",\"prompt\":\"I'm in the Headwater repository at /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r107 (not a git repo, read-only investigation). I need to answer a general question: \\\"When creating a new document in this repository, how do you decide which shelf (docs/ subdirectory, e.g. docs/spec, docs/decisions, docs/obligations, docs/how-to, docs/requirements, docs/acceptance-criteria, docs/interfaces, docs/evaluations, docs/subsystems, docs/tutorials, docs/process/*, etc.) it belongs on, and where does its identifier (the numeric/scheme-based ID like HW-DR-0054, or the 0107- prefix, etc.) come from?\\\"\\n\\nPlease research and report back (don't write anything, just investigate and summarize):\\n\\n1. What determines which \\\"shelf\\\" (docs subdirectory / kind) a new document belongs on — is this driven by a taxonomy/kind definition somewhere (look at .headwater/packages/, docs/taxonomies/, or the base taxonomy package mentioned in docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md)? What's the role of `kinds.specification` and other `kinds.*` entries? Is there a document (spec section, decision record) that states the mapping from document kind to docs/ subdirectory explicitly?\\n\\n2. Where does a new document's identifier come from? Look at `.headwater/ids/<scheme>/<identifier>` claim store (mentioned in CLAUDE.md), the `headwater new` command, and any docs describing identifier schemes per kind (e.g., HW-DR-#### for decisions, numeric-prefixed slugs for obligations like 0107-..., etc.). Also check docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md for how identifiers survive a shelf move.\\n\\n3. Is there a canonical spec document (likely under docs/spec/, maybe numbered, about authoring, the check layer, or the scaffolder) that lays out the shelf-assignment and identifier-sourcing rules in one place? Give me its exact path.\\n\\n4. Briefly describe how `headwater new <kind>` works end to end: does it look up the kind's shelf and scheme from the taxonomy package and then claim the next free identifier by scanning .headwater/ids/<scheme>/ (and per CLAUDE.md, scanning every remote branch, not just main, for the highest identifier in use)?\\n\\nPlease cite exact file paths and quote short relevant excerpts (a sentence or two each) rather than paraphrasing loosely, so I can verify and relay accurate information. Keep the final report under 400 words, organized by the 4 numbered points above.\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r107 -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".headwater/packages/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/obligations/0107-*\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/process/decisions/0024-*\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r107/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r107/docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md"
result: "sha256:b1bc8628c695ce6b58c9cbc67502d3b90e3452fd49aaff3710d485dce45824ac"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r107/docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md"
result: "sha256:485fe85764154ebfd53b4e549e14fb453931eb09bef862591234f134d90c59b1"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r107 -iname \\\"CLAUDE.md\\\" -maxdepth 2\",\"description\":\"Locate CLAUDE.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r107/CLAUDE.md"
result: "sha256:c92caed27f86014c5f496edda4ca85568e1da2a44e9c15e4aece92ff9b5bbfd2"
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/spec/*\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".headwater/ids/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r107/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r107/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r107/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r107/engine/crates/scaffold/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:ce9cc34ee18465fbc9d1f85c0b1d8d2ed393edd6460468b52d22f3b98e302bdd"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r107"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== overlay/package shelves ===\\\"; find .headwater -iname \\\"taxonomy.yml\\\" -o -iname \\\"overlay.yml\\\" | head; echo; grep -n \\\"^shelves:\\\\|path:\\\\|kind:\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml 2>/dev/null | head -30; echo; echo \\\"=== spec 03 ===\\\"; ls docs/spec | grep -i \\\"03\\\\|authoring\\\"; echo; sed -n '120,170p' docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Spot-check taxonomy shelves and spec 03 content\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r108"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r108/docs\",\"description\":\"List docs directory shelves\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r108\",\"description\":\"List repo root\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r108/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r108/docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r108/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r108/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r108/docs/obligations/0060-the-most-specific-shelf-wins-names-no-order.md"
result: "sha256:bf250948d2966958e7ceb532cc9333e810db6ff64b37c98e264e5be2fb39e926"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r108/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r108/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r109"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && ls -la\",\"description\":\"Check working directory contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git status 2>&1 | head -20; echo \\\"---\\\"; git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1\",\"description\":\"Check if directory is a git repository\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md"
result: "sha256:b1bc8628c695ce6b58c9cbc67502d3b90e3452fd49aaff3710d485dce45824ac"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r11"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; echo \\\"---\\\"; git status 2>&1 | head -20; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls -la\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r11/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r11/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r11/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r11/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r11/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r11/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r11/docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md"
result: "sha256:485fe85764154ebfd53b4e549e14fb453931eb09bef862591234f134d90c59b1"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r11/docs/how-to/relocate-a-shelf.md"
result: "sha256:03f98929cde2a19599c47b743bee15d79788dba7fa7dae814629d2517b9167ef"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r11/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r110"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; git worktree list 2>&1; ls -la | head -30\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"Decide which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r110/.claude -maxdepth 3 -iname \\\"*skill*\\\" 2>&1; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r110/.claude 2>&1\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find docs -maxdepth 1 -type d | sort\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/spec\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find taxonomy-source .headwater -maxdepth 4 -iname \\\"*shelf*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*scheme*\\\" 2>/dev/null | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find taxonomy-source -maxdepth 5 -type f | head -50; echo \\\"---headwater---\\\"; find .headwater -maxdepth 4 -type f | head -80\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat .headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null | head -100\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 6 -iname \\\"*.yml\\\" 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---\\\"; find . -maxdepth 2 -iname \\\"*design-spec*\\\" 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/design-spec/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:8e8b03d0d2e6bf2044c68d86e327887e851cb0736a9b642a89205358062669ff"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/evidence-and-obligation/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:fd65c2f4a94d4f0a6d38ea74d4700f9439c36a6bcc407a30061ff4002d2b81f8"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r111"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r111 | head -50\",\"description\":\"List top-level repo contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r111/docs\",\"description\":\"List docs directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r111/docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r111/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r111/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r111/docs/taxonomies /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r111/.headwater/packages 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy and package declaration directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r111/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard -maxdepth 3 -type f | head -50\",\"description\":\"List files in headwater-standard taxonomy package\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r111/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/decision-record/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:84e2d9770dfd50107a46f099af4d51666455a161eacf803cf05cfd303dd8f88d"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r111/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/decision-record/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:84e2d9770dfd50107a46f099af4d51666455a161eacf803cf05cfd303dd8f88d"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"namespace\\\" -A2 -B2 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r111/.headwater/overlay.yml | head -40\",\"description\":\"Find namespace declaration in the repo's overlay\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r112"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r112/ 2>&1 | head -50; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r112/docs 2>&1 | head -50\",\"description\":\"Inspect working directory contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"Decide which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r112/.claude -iname \\\"*orient*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*authoring*\\\" 2>&1 | head -30\",\"description\":\"Find orient/authoring skill files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r112/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r112/docs/decisions/0057-a-shelf-layout-is-the-second-half-of-what-the-identifier-claim-store-covers.md"
result: "sha256:cfaa5e4b4f2a47f737d0bc5c3e55d4ca0018f46ccf225235d8efbfea8a344287"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r112/docs/spec/; echo \\\"---doctrine---\\\"; ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r112/docs/doctrine/\",\"description\":\"List spec and doctrine docs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r112/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r112/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r113"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r113/docs/ && echo --- && ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r113/.headwater/ 2>/dev/null && echo --- && ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r113/.headwater/packages 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r113/docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r113/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r113/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 3 -type f | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r113/.headwater/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:0aa1b806b4bc44af26c12dc624643169bddb3583054e78db3873c23ca8e4bb12"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r113/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r113/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r113/docs/taxonomies/ && find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r113/docs/taxonomies -maxdepth 2 -type f\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r113/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r113/docs/taxonomies/design-spec/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:8e8b03d0d2e6bf2044c68d86e327887e851cb0736a9b642a89205358062669ff"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r113/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r113/docs/taxonomies/evidence-and-obligation/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:fd65c2f4a94d4f0a6d38ea74d4700f9439c36a6bcc407a30061ff4002d2b81f8"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r113/docs/taxonomies/evidence-and-obligation/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:fd65c2f4a94d4f0a6d38ea74d4700f9439c36a6bcc407a30061ff4002d2b81f8"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r113/docs/taxonomies/evidence-and-obligation/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:fd65c2f4a94d4f0a6d38ea74d4700f9439c36a6bcc407a30061ff4002d2b81f8"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r113/docs/taxonomies"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r114"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r114 | head -50\",\"description\":\"List top-level contents of working directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r114/docs -maxdepth 1 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level shelves under docs/\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r114/docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r114/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r114/taxonomy-source /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r114/.headwater -maxdepth 3 -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy source and .headwater config files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r114/taxonomy-source -type f | grep -v '/ids/' | sort\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy-source files excluding id claim files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r114/.headwater -maxdepth 2 -type d; echo ---; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r114/.headwater -maxdepth 1 -type f\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directories and top-level files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r114/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Count lines in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r114/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r114/.headwater/taxonomy.yml /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r114/.headwater/overlay.yml\",\"description\":\"Count lines in repo taxonomy and overlay files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r114/.headwater/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:0aa1b806b4bc44af26c12dc624643169bddb3583054e78db3873c23ca8e4bb12"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r114/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r114/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r114/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard -maxdepth 3 -type f | grep -v /ids/ | sort\",\"description\":\"List vendored package files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r114/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles\\ngrep -n \\\"path:\\\\|kind:\\\\|identifier:\\\\|scheme:\\\\|title:\\\" design-spec/bundle.yml decision-record/bundle.yml evidence-and-obligation/bundle.yml\",\"description\":\"Search bundle files for shelf/kind/identifier declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r114/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/decision-record/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:84e2d9770dfd50107a46f099af4d51666455a161eacf803cf05cfd303dd8f88d"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r115"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r115/docs/ 2>&1\",\"description\":\"List docs directory shelves\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/spec/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r115/docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r115/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r115/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater -maxdepth 3 -type f 2>&1 | head -50; echo ---; find docs/taxonomies -type f 2>&1\",\"description\":\"List headwater taxonomy config files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r115/.headwater/overlay.yml 2>&1 | head -200\",\"description\":\"View repo's own taxonomy overlay\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r115/.headwater -maxdepth 2 -type d; echo ---; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r115/.headwater -maxdepth 1 -type f\",\"description\":\"Explore top-level .headwater config\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r115/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r115/docs/taxonomies/design-spec/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:8e8b03d0d2e6bf2044c68d86e327887e851cb0736a9b642a89205358062669ff"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"shelves\\\" -A 100 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r115/.headwater/taxonomy.lock | head -250\",\"description\":\"View resolved shelves from taxonomy lock\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1067,1160p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r115/.headwater/taxonomy.lock\",\"description\":\"View remaining shelves section of taxonomy lock\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"identifier_schemes:\\\" -A 150 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r115/.headwater/taxonomy.lock | head -200\",\"description\":\"View identifier schemes section of taxonomy lock\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r116"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && ls -la && git status 2>&1 | head -30\",\"description\":\"Check working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/\",\"description\":\"List top-level docs shelves\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Research document shelf and identifier rules\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"I'm working in the Headwater repository at /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r116 (no git history available, just a working tree). I need to answer, authoritatively and precisely, two questions by reading the actual governing documents (not guessing):\\n\\n1. How does this repository decide which \\\"shelf\\\" (top-level docs/ directory, e.g. docs/spec, docs/decisions, docs/obligations, docs/evaluations, docs/how-to, docs/requirements, docs/acceptance-criteria, docs/interfaces, docs/subsystems, docs/tutorials, docs/process, docs/doctrine, docs/explanations, docs/verifications, docs/reviews, docs/taxonomies) a NEW document belongs on? Is there a defined set of \\\"kinds\\\" each bound to a shelf? Where is this mapping declared (taxonomy package, spec file, etc.)?\\n\\n2. Where does a new document's IDENTIFIER come from? I already know about docs/decisions numbering (e.g. 0024-...), and the \\\"identifier claim store\\\" at .headwater/ids/<scheme>/<identifier> described in CLAUDE.md (HW-DR-0054). I need the full mechanism: is there a command like `headwater new <kind>` that mints the identifier? Does each kind/shelf have its own numbering scheme? How does it scan branches for the highest identifier in use? Is there a relevant doc like docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md, docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md, or docs/spec files about \\\"kinds\\\", \\\"schemes\\\", or the scaffolder?\\n\\nPlease read:\\n- docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md\\n- docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md\\n- Any docs/spec/*.md file that defines document \\\"kinds\\\" and their shelves (look in docs/spec/ for a file about document kinds, taxonomy, or the scaffolder — grep for \\\"shelf\\\", \\\"kind\\\", \\\"scheme\\\", \\\"headwater new\\\")\\n- .headwater/packages/ or docs/taxonomies/ for the base package definition of kinds (grep for \\\"kinds.specification\\\", \\\"scheme:\\\", \\\"shelf:\\\")\\n- docs/decisions/0054-the-upper-bound-of-a-reconcile-first-allocator-is-the-corpus-and-a-claim-store.md\\n\\nReport back: (a) the concrete mechanism/file that maps a document kind to a shelf, with examples of a few kind→shelf pairs, (b) the concrete mechanism that assigns an identifier to a new document of a given kind (scheme name, numbering format, the `headwater new` command behavior, branch-scanning for the claim store), and (c) any command syntax for actually creating a new document (e.g. `headwater new <kind> <slug>`). Quote short exact passages with file paths/line numbers. Keep the report under 400 words.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/spec/ 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls docs/taxonomies/ 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls .headwater/packages/ 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List candidate directories for taxonomy/spec/package files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "ScheduleWakeup"
argument: "{\"delaySeconds\":300,\"reason\":\"waiting on background research agent reading shelf/identifier docs\",\"prompt\":\"Check whether the Explore agent researching Headwater shelf/identifier rules has completed; if so synthesize and answer the user's question about which shelf a new document belongs on and where its identifier comes from.\",\"noop\":true}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r116/docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md"
result: "sha256:485fe85764154ebfd53b4e549e14fb453931eb09bef862591234f134d90c59b1"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r116/docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md"
result: "sha256:b1bc8628c695ce6b58c9cbc67502d3b90e3452fd49aaff3710d485dce45824ac"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r116/docs/decisions/0054-the-upper-bound-of-a-reconcile-first-allocator-is-the-corpus-and-a-claim-store.md"
result: "sha256:dc39ad3508032fef66f58640206082c0f863a47c2fa2315934079e72223b1eb8"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r116/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"shelf\\\\|kind\\\\|scheme\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r116/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md | head -80\",\"description\":\"Grep spec 03 for shelf/kind/scheme mentions\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r116/.headwater/overlay.yml\",\"description\":\"Show the overlay.yml taxonomy configuration\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^shelves:\\\\|^ [a-z_]*:$\\\\|path:\\\\|kind:\\\\|identifier:\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r116/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -60\",\"description\":\"Find shelves/kinds mapping in base package taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"shelves\\\\.\\\\|kinds\\\\.\\\\|identifier_schemes\\\\.\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r116/.headwater/overlay.yml | head -100\",\"description\":\"Find shelves/kinds/identifier_schemes additions in overlay.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,30p;960,1030p;1200,1240p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r116/.headwater/overlay.yml\",\"description\":\"Show overlay header and requirement/acceptance-criteria shelf/kind/scheme block\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"headwater new\\\\|branches\\\\|scan\\\\|reconcile\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r116/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md | sed -n '1,40p'\",\"description\":\"Grep spec 03 for CLI and branch scanning references\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r117"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo --- && git status 2>&1 | head -5\",\"description\":\"List working directory and check git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find docs -maxdepth 1 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level docs shelves\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/spec/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r117/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find taxonomy-source .headwater -maxdepth 3 -type f | sort | head -60\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy source and headwater config files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find taxonomy-source -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List all taxonomy source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater -maxdepth 1 -type f; echo ---; wc -l .headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null; echo ---; find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 2 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Inspect .headwater top-level config files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"path: docs/decisions\\\\|path: docs/spec\\\\|path: docs/obligations\\\\|path: docs/reviews\\\\|path: docs/doctrine\\\\|path: docs/w3id\\\" .headwater/overlay.yml\",\"description\":\"Find remaining shelf path declarations in overlay\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:0aa1b806b4bc44af26c12dc624643169bddb3583054e78db3873c23ca8e4bb12"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l .headwater/taxonomy.lock; echo ---; grep -n '\\\"path\\\"\\\\|\\\"kind\\\"\\\\|\\\"homogeneous\\\"\\\\|shelves' .headwater/taxonomy.lock | head -100\",\"description\":\"Check taxonomy.lock for resolved shelf declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r117/.headwater/taxonomy.lock"
result: "sha256:1ea570f4a22e19db2ed394a89bbb5f47f2908847514bb3417fd7a88820333650"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r117/.headwater/taxonomy.lock"
result: "sha256:1ea570f4a22e19db2ed394a89bbb5f47f2908847514bb3417fd7a88820333650"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r117/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r118"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs; echo \\\"---decisions---\\\"; ls docs/decisions | head -30; echo \\\"---process/decisions---\\\"; ls docs/process/decisions 2>/dev/null | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rl \\\"shelf\\\" docs --include=*.md | head -30\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Research shelf and identifier rules\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"I'm working in a documentation-governance repo called Headwater (at /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r118). I need to answer the general question: \\\"Decide which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from\\\" — i.e., find the authoritative rules in this repo's own docs that describe:\\n\\n1. The list of document \\\"shelves\\\" (the top-level dirs under docs/: spec, subsystems, decisions, evaluations, obligations, interfaces, requirements, acceptance-criteria, tutorials, how-to, process/*, doctrine, explanations, reviews, taxonomies, verifications, w3id) and what kind of content/\\\"kind\\\" belongs on each shelf — i.e. the decision procedure or criteria an author uses to pick the right shelf for a new document.\\n\\n2. How identifiers are minted/assigned for documents on each shelf — e.g. decision records use a numeric sequence like \\\"0107-slug\\\" or \\\"HW-DR-0054\\\", process decisions use \\\"HW-PD-0001\\\", etc. I need to know: what schemes exist, which shelf uses which scheme, and where the next number/identifier comes from (is there a claim store under .headwater/ids/<scheme>/<identifier>? Is there a `headwater new` command that mints it? Do you scan all branches for the highest number in use, per the identifier claim store rule in CLAUDE.md?).\\n\\nLook specifically at:\\n- docs/spec/ (look for a part describing document kinds, e.g. docs/spec/0X-*.md about kinds, schemas, or the taxonomy)\\n- docs/decisions/0025-q25-where-the-namespace-goes-in-an-identifier-and-who-declares-it.md\\n- docs/decisions/0027-q27-whether-a-decision-record-is-governed-prose.md\\n- docs/decisions/0028-q28-whether-an-evaluation-is-governed-prose.md\\n- docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md\\n- docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md\\n- Any docs/spec file describing `headwater new` and the scaffolder, and how it decides a document's kind/shelf and mints its identifier.\\n- taxonomy-source/ directory if it defines \\\"kinds\\\" with shelf and identifier scheme per kind.\\n- Any README.md under docs/ subdirectories (e.g. docs/decisions/README.md, docs/obligations/README.md) that states what belongs on that shelf.\\n\\nReport back (under 500 words):\\n- The general decision procedure for picking a shelf for a new document (what question to ask, e.g. \\\"is it a decision / a spec / an obligation / a how-to\\\", and the distinguishing test between similar shelves, e.g. decisions vs process/decisions).\\n- The identifier scheme(s): format per shelf/kind, where the sequence number / identifier comes from (a counter, a claim store, headwater new, scanning branches), and any other mechanism that enforces no-collision.\\n- Cite file paths and quote short relevant fragments (1-2 sentences each) so I can verify directly.\\nDo not write or edit any files — this is a pure research/report task.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/ && echo --- && ls docs/spec/ | head -50 && echo --- && ls taxonomy-source/ 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"for f in docs/decisions/0025-q25-where-the-namespace-goes-in-an-identifier-and-who-declares-it.md docs/decisions/0027-q27-whether-a-decision-record-is-governed-prose.md docs/decisions/0028-q28-whether-an-evaluation-is-governed-prose.md docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md; do echo \\\"=== $f ===\\\"; cat \\\"$f\\\" 2>/dev/null | head -100; echo; done\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r118/docs/decisions/0025-q25-where-the-namespace-goes-in-an-identifier-and-who-declares-it.md"
result: "sha256:4894471729347cedfb96adf9888fd728ae063217b84f028833d1dd70a5051370"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r118/docs/decisions/0027-q27-whether-a-decision-record-is-governed-prose.md"
result: "sha256:5f124e32eafe654fa065aeaad1f489fe68ca419019ad5a82ee732f27ba22328e"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r118/docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md"
result: "sha256:485fe85764154ebfd53b4e549e14fb453931eb09bef862591234f134d90c59b1"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r118/docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md"
result: "sha256:b1bc8628c695ce6b58c9cbc67502d3b90e3452fd49aaff3710d485dce45824ac"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r118/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r118/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r118/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r118/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r118/CLAUDE.md 2>/dev/null | head -200\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r118/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r118/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r118/docs/decisions -iname \\\"0054*\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r118/docs/decisions/0054-the-upper-bound-of-a-reconcile-first-allocator-is-the-corpus-and-a-claim-store.md"
result: "sha256:dc39ad3508032fef66f58640206082c0f863a47c2fa2315934079e72223b1eb8"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r118/.headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null | head -150\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"shelves\\\\.\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r118/.headwater/overlay.yml | head -80\",\"description\":\"Find shelf declarations in overlay\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r118/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard -name \\\"*.yml\\\" | xargs -I{} echo {}; echo ---; grep -n \\\"^shelves:\\\\| [a-z_-]*:$\\\\|path:\\\\|kind:\\\\|identifier:\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r118/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -60\",\"description\":\"Inspect base package taxonomy shelves\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r118/docs/decisions/README.md /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r118/docs/obligations/README.md 2>/dev/null; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r118/docs -maxdepth 2 -iname \\\"README.md\\\"\",\"description\":\"Look for README files under docs shelves\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r118/docs/decisions/README.md"
result: "sha256:a05b9ee4ceeeb1116de791251080f72067a36e035a23a7c797d60b0759f14bfd"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1200,1500p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r118/.headwater/overlay.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r118/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '420,530p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r118/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r118/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/decision-record/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:84e2d9770dfd50107a46f099af4d51666455a161eacf803cf05cfd303dd8f88d"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"shelves\\\\.obligations\\\\|shelf.*obligation\\\\|docs/obligations\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r118/.headwater/overlay.yml /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r118/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/decision-record/bundle.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '155,170p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r118/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/decision-record/bundle.yml\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r12"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".headwater/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".headwater/packages/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r12/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r12/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r12/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/design-spec/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:8e8b03d0d2e6bf2044c68d86e327887e851cb0736a9b642a89205358062669ff"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/decision-record/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:84e2d9770dfd50107a46f099af4d51666455a161eacf803cf05cfd303dd8f88d"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/evidence-and-obligation/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:fd65c2f4a94d4f0a6d38ea74d4700f9439c36a6bcc407a30061ff4002d2b81f8"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r12/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/design-spec/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:8e8b03d0d2e6bf2044c68d86e327887e851cb0736a9b642a89205358062669ff"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r12/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/decision-record/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:84e2d9770dfd50107a46f099af4d51666455a161eacf803cf05cfd303dd8f88d"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r13"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls -la | head -30\",\"description\":\"Check if directory is a git repository and list contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat .claude/settings.json 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---local---\\\"; cat .claude/settings.local.json 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Check Claude settings for worktree hooks\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Find shelf/identifier assignment rules\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"In this Headwater repository (docs-governance tooling project), I need to understand the authoritative rule(s) for two things:\\n\\n1. How a new document's \\\"shelf\\\" (e.g. docs/spec/, docs/decisions/, docs/obligations/, docs/evaluations/, docs/how-to/, docs/tutorials/, docs/requirements/, docs/acceptance-criteria/, docs/interfaces/, docs/process/*, docs/reviews/, docs/subsystems/) is decided — i.e. what determines which shelf a document \\\"kind\\\" belongs to, and where this mapping is declared (taxonomy packages under .headwater/packages/, docs/taxonomies/, or a spec document).\\n\\n2. Where a new document's identifier comes from — i.e. how `headwater new` mints an identifier for a document, what identifier \\\"schemes\\\" exist, how the identifier claim store at `.headwater/ids/<scheme>/<identifier>` is involved, and whether some kinds have no identifier scheme at all (I saw a hint: docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md mentions `kinds.specification` names no identifier scheme).\\n\\nPlease investigate:\\n- docs/spec/ for any document describing document kinds, shelves, and identifier schemes (look for files about \\\"document kinds\\\", \\\"scaffolder\\\", \\\"headwater new\\\", taxonomy structure — e.g. files like docs/spec/05-ai-integration.md was mentioned elsewhere, so there's likely a docs/spec/0X-*.md about document types/kinds/taxonomy)\\n- .headwater/packages/ directory structure for the base package and how kinds declare shelf + identifier scheme (look for YAML/TOML files defining a \\\"kind\\\" with fields like `shelf`, `path`, `identifier`, `scheme`)\\n- docs/taxonomies/ if it exists\\n- docs/obligations/0107-*.md (read it fully)\\n- docs/decisions/0054-*.md (the identifier claim store decision, read fully)\\n- Any docs/spec file describing `headwater new` command behavior\\n\\nReport back: (a) the mechanism/field names used to bind a document kind to a shelf (directory), (b) the mechanism for binding a kind to an identifier scheme, (c) what happens for kinds with no identifier scheme, (d) file paths and line numbers for each key claim so I can verify directly. Keep the report factual and under 500 words, with concrete file:line citations.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls && echo --- && ls docs/spec/ 2>/dev/null && echo --- && ls .headwater/packages/ 2>/dev/null && echo --- && ls docs/taxonomies/ 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater/packages/headwater-standard -maxdepth 4 | head -100\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find docs/taxonomies -maxdepth 3 | head -100\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls .headwater/ 2>/dev/null; find .headwater -maxdepth 2\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r13/.headwater/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:0aa1b806b4bc44af26c12dc624643169bddb3583054e78db3873c23ca8e4bb12"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r13/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r13/docs/obligations -iname \\\"0107*\\\"; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r13/docs/decisions -iname \\\"0054*\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r13/docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md"
result: "sha256:b1bc8628c695ce6b58c9cbc67502d3b90e3452fd49aaff3710d485dce45824ac"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r13/docs/decisions/0054-the-upper-bound-of-a-reconcile-first-allocator-is-the-corpus-and-a-claim-store.md"
result: "sha256:dc39ad3508032fef66f58640206082c0f863a47c2fa2315934079e72223b1eb8"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r13/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/decision-record/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:84e2d9770dfd50107a46f099af4d51666455a161eacf803cf05cfd303dd8f88d"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r13/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r13/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r13/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r13/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r14"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r14\",\"description\":\"List top-level repo contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r14/docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r14/docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r14/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r14/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r14/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r14/docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md"
result: "sha256:b1bc8628c695ce6b58c9cbc67502d3b90e3452fd49aaff3710d485dce45824ac"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r15"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls -la\",\"description\":\"Check if directory is a git repository\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r15/.claude/settings.json 2>/dev/null | head -100\",\"description\":\"Check Claude settings for worktree hooks configuration\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"Decide which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r15/docs/\",\"description\":\"List docs/ top-level shelves\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r15/docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r15/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"**/headwater-authoring/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r15/.agents/skills/headwater-authoring/SKILL.md"
result: "sha256:5588ef44dba3982a11a84a2df94abfe2a6ec28e24278888e16e2d7d518362520"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r15/docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md"
result: "sha256:b1bc8628c695ce6b58c9cbc67502d3b90e3452fd49aaff3710d485dce45824ac"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r16"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r16/docs/\",\"description\":\"List docs directory shelves\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r16/.claude/skills/ 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List skills directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r16 -iname \\\"*skill*\\\" -maxdepth 4 -type d 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Find skill directories in repo\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r16/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r16/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r16/docs/decisions/0057-a-shelf-layout-is-the-second-half-of-what-the-identifier-claim-store-covers.md"
result: "sha256:cfaa5e4b4f2a47f737d0bc5c3e55d4ca0018f46ccf225235d8efbfea8a344287"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r16/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r16/docs/obligations/0060-the-most-specific-shelf-wins-names-no-order.md"
result: "sha256:bf250948d2966958e7ceb532cc9333e810db6ff64b37c98e264e5be2fb39e926"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r16/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r16/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r17"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls -la\",\"description\":\"Check if directory is a git repository and list contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"Decide which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la docs/ && echo \\\"---\\\" && ls docs/spec/ 2>/dev/null && echo \\\"---decisions---\\\" && ls docs/decisions/ 2>/dev/null | head -30 && echo \\\"---process/decisions---\\\" && ls docs/process/decisions/ 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List top-level docs shelves and decision records\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r17/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== taxonomy-source structure ===\\\"; find taxonomy-source -maxdepth 3 -type f | head -50\\necho \\\"=== .headwater structure ===\\\"; find .headwater -maxdepth 3 -type d\\necho \\\"=== search for 'shelf' in taxonomy-source ===\\\"; grep -rl \\\"path:\\\" taxonomy-source | head -20\",\"description\":\"Explore taxonomy source for shelf/kind declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== .headwater top files ===\\\"; ls -la .headwater\\necho \\\"=== overlay.yml ===\\\"; cat .headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null | head -200\",\"description\":\"Look at overlay.yml defining this corpus's shelves\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 4 -type f | head -40\",\"description\":\"List files under headwater package to find design-spec bundle\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/design-spec/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:8e8b03d0d2e6bf2044c68d86e327887e851cb0736a9b642a89205358062669ff"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/decision-record/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:84e2d9770dfd50107a46f099af4d51666455a161eacf803cf05cfd303dd8f88d"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/evidence-and-obligation/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:fd65c2f4a94d4f0a6d38ea74d4700f9439c36a6bcc407a30061ff4002d2b81f8"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r17/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/decision-record/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:84e2d9770dfd50107a46f099af4d51666455a161eacf803cf05cfd303dd8f88d"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r17/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/taxonomy.lock"
result: "sha256:1ea570f4a22e19db2ed394a89bbb5f47f2908847514bb3417fd7a88820333650"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r18"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"Decide which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r18/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r18/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r18/docs/decisions/0057-a-shelf-layout-is-the-second-half-of-what-the-identifier-claim-store-covers.md"
result: "sha256:cfaa5e4b4f2a47f737d0bc5c3e55d4ca0018f46ccf225235d8efbfea8a344287"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r18/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r18/docs/obligations/0046-the-identifier-scheme-grammar.md"
result: "sha256:37617cf0865ec80e7943e2d86017a51fd4ec46b238c3fdc50d5e12e3ce32e006"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r18/docs/decisions/0025-q25-where-the-namespace-goes-in-an-identifier-and-who-declares-it.md"
result: "sha256:4894471729347cedfb96adf9888fd728ae063217b84f028833d1dd70a5051370"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r18/docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r18/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r19"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r19/docs -maxdepth 1 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level docs shelves\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r19 -iname \\\"*scaffold*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*headwater-authoring*\\\" | sort\",\"description\":\"Find scaffolder and authoring skill files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r19/.claude -maxdepth 3 -type d 2>/dev/null | sort; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r19/.agents/skills/ 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Check .claude dir structure and agents skills list\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r19/.agents/skills/headwater-authoring -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List files in headwater-authoring skill\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r19/.agents/skills/headwater-orient -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List files in headwater-orient skill\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r19/.agents/skills/headwater-authoring/SKILL.md"
result: "sha256:5588ef44dba3982a11a84a2df94abfe2a6ec28e24278888e16e2d7d518362520"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r19/.agents/skills/headwater-orient/SKILL.md"
result: "sha256:5edb4a19d946f07e57f0eb098211f1911eaa82903c4e62da2ad24c94cce7056c"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find . -iname \\\"headwater\\\" -type f -not -path \\\"*/target/*\\\" 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---target---\\\"; find . -path \\\"*/target/*/headwater*\\\" -maxdepth 6 -type f 2>/dev/null | head -20; echo \\\"---which---\\\"; which headwater 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Look for a built headwater CLI binary\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r19/.headwater/taxonomy.lock"
result: "sha256:1ea570f4a22e19db2ed394a89bbb5f47f2908847514bb3417fd7a88820333650"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"./engine/target/dev-release/headwater --help 2>&1 | head -60\",\"description\":\"Show headwater CLI top-level help\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"./engine/target/dev-release/headwater help new 2>&1 | head -80\",\"description\":\"Show long help for the new verb\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"./engine/target/dev-release/headwater new 2>&1 | head -80\",\"description\":\"List kinds by invoking new with no kind\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"./engine/target/dev-release/headwater new nonexistent-kind --title \\\"x\\\" 2>&1 | head -60\",\"description\":\"Trigger kind-not-found refusal to list all declared kinds\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^ kinds:\\\" -A2 .headwater/taxonomy.lock | head -5; echo \\\"---\\\"; awk '/^ kinds:/,0' .headwater/taxonomy.lock | grep -n \\\"shelf:\\\\|scheme:\\\\|^ [a-z_]*:$\\\" | head -120\",\"description\":\"Inspect kinds block for shelf and identifier scheme fields\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '580,800p' .headwater/taxonomy.lock\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^ [a-z_]*:$\\\" .headwater/taxonomy.lock | head -40\",\"description\":\"Find top-level resolved taxonomy section headers\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r19/.headwater/taxonomy.lock"
result: "sha256:1ea570f4a22e19db2ed394a89bbb5f47f2908847514bb3417fd7a88820333650"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r2"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/spec/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/**/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r2/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r2/docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r2/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r2/docs/spec/glossary.md"
result: "sha256:7a727d91789e2bb03c825ae01ec01639c7ff08f9022b5d03241c734c2148c99a"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r2/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r2/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"shelves:\",\"output_mode\":\"files_with_matches\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".headwater/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/taxonomies/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r2/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r2/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r2/docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md"
result: "sha256:485fe85764154ebfd53b4e549e14fb453931eb09bef862591234f134d90c59b1"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r2/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r20"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/*\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r20/docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md"
result: "sha256:485fe85764154ebfd53b4e549e14fb453931eb09bef862591234f134d90c59b1"
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/**/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".headwater/packages/**/*\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r20/docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r20/docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r20/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r20/docs/spec/glossary.md"
result: "sha256:7a727d91789e2bb03c825ae01ec01639c7ff08f9022b5d03241c734c2148c99a"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r20/docs/spec/glossary.md"
result: "sha256:7a727d91789e2bb03c825ae01ec01639c7ff08f9022b5d03241c734c2148c99a"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r20/docs/spec/01-conceptual-model.md"
result: "sha256:f1f133ccaffda3844e639227d488a3e90e6a238b4f809c3af0c92a7d354ca0e3"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r20/docs/spec/01-conceptual-model.md"
result: "sha256:f1f133ccaffda3844e639227d488a3e90e6a238b4f809c3af0c92a7d354ca0e3"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r20/docs/spec/01-conceptual-model.md"
result: "sha256:f1f133ccaffda3844e639227d488a3e90e6a238b4f809c3af0c92a7d354ca0e3"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r21"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r21/ 2>&1 | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la .git 2>&1 | head -5; echo \\\"---\\\"; git status 2>&1 | head -5\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r21/.headwater /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r21/taxonomy-source -maxdepth 4 -type f | head -80\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r21/docs/taxonomies -maxdepth 3 -type f\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r21/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater -maxdepth 2 -type d; echo ---; cat .headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null | head -100\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l .headwater/taxonomy.lock; echo ---; grep -n \\\"shelf\\\\|pattern:\\\\|^ - \\\\|scheme:\\\" .headwater/taxonomy.lock | head -150\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^shelves:\\\\|^ [a-z_-]*:$\\\" .headwater/taxonomy.lock | head -5; echo ---; grep -n \\\"path:\\\\|kind:\\\\|homogeneous\\\\|discriminator\\\" .headwater/taxonomy.lock | sed -n '1,120p'\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r21/.headwater/taxonomy.lock"
result: "sha256:1ea570f4a22e19db2ed394a89bbb5f47f2908847514bb3417fd7a88820333650"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/doctrine docs/w3id 2>&1\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r22"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"Decide which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r22\",\"description\":\"List repository root contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Find shelf and identifier scheme rules\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"In this repository's docs/ corpus (a documentation system called Headwater with governed shelves like docs/spec, docs/decisions, docs/obligations, docs/evaluations, docs/requirements, docs/acceptance-criteria, docs/how-to, docs/tutorials, docs/process/decisions, etc.), I need to find the authoritative explanation of two things:\\n\\n1. How an agent or author decides which \\\"shelf\\\" (top-level docs/ subdirectory / document kind) a new document belongs on — is there a taxonomy of document \\\"kinds\\\" with criteria for which kind/shelf a new piece of prose belongs to? Look for something like a package/taxonomy definition (maybe under .headwater/packages/ or docs/taxonomies/) that defines each kind and criteria for choosing between them.\\n\\n2. Where a new document's identifier comes from — i.e., the numbering/ID scheme (like the 4-digit numbers seen in docs/decisions/0107-... or docs/obligations/0107-...). Is there an identifier scheme per kind, a claim store (.headwater/ids/<scheme>/<identifier>), and a command like `headwater new <kind>` that mints the identifier? Find the doc(s) that state this explicitly (rules, not just examples).\\n\\nPlease search docs/spec/*.md (especially anything about document kinds, the check layer, or AI integration), docs/decisions/ for a decision about identifier schemes and namespaces (I noticed 0025-q25-where-the-namespace-goes-in-an-identifier-and-who-declares-it.md), docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md, and any file defining \\\"kinds\\\" (search for \\\"kind:\\\" or \\\"scheme:\\\" in .headwater/ or docs/). Also check DEVELOPING.md for mentions of `headwater new` and shelves.\\n\\nReport back: (a) the criteria/process for picking a shelf for a new document, (b) the mechanism by which an identifier is assigned/minted and where it's recorded, (c) exact file paths and relevant quoted lines so I can cite them. Keep the report focused and under 500 words — I don't need you to read every file exhaustively, just enough to answer definitively with citations.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r22 -maxdepth 1 -type d; echo \\\"---\\\"; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r22 -iname \\\"*.headwater*\\\" -maxdepth 2\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/spec/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"**/*.headwater*/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r22/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r22/docs/spec/05-ai-integration.md"
result: "sha256:6f4220e91e1a55bf944b7baadf918dc2e149630d600ae456d66b6d0f40cabbf5"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r22/docs/decisions/0025-q25-where-the-namespace-goes-in-an-identifier-and-who-declares-it.md"
result: "sha256:4894471729347cedfb96adf9888fd728ae063217b84f028833d1dd70a5051370"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r22/docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md"
result: "sha256:b1bc8628c695ce6b58c9cbc67502d3b90e3452fd49aaff3710d485dce45824ac"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r22/docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r22/DEVELOPING.md"
result: "sha256:8fbd8eb18a5b58dcbf5bfa3a763cea8bd99c0f877dfbc00aff7af74c9c9888cb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r22/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/interfaces/*new*\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".headwater/packages/**/taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r22/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r22/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r22/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r23"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls -la | head -30\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"shelf\\\" docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '95,155p' docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '180,270p' docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '630,665p' docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r24"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r24\",\"description\":\"List working directory contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r24/docs -maxdepth 1 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level docs shelves\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Find shelf and identifier rules for new docs\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"In this repository (Headwater, at /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r24), I need to answer: \\\"How does one decide which shelf (docs/ subdirectory / kind) a NEW document belongs on, and where does that document's identifier come from (i.e., how is the identifier scheme/number chosen and claimed)?\\\"\\n\\nThe docs/ tree has shelves: acceptance-criteria, decisions, doctrine, evaluations, explanations, how-to, interfaces, obligations, process, requirements, reviews, spec, subsystems, taxonomies, tutorials, verifications, w3id.\\n\\nPlease find and report on:\\n1. The authoritative document(s) that define the \\\"kinds\\\" taxonomy (what each shelf is for, what document kind maps to which directory) — look under docs/taxonomies/, docs/spec/, and any \\\"base package\\\" docs (I found a reference to docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md which may be relevant, as well as docs/spec/12-check-layer.md).\\n2. How the `headwater new` command decides the shelf for a document (is it inferred from the kind argument? Is there a mapping table/config file, e.g. in .headwater/packages/ or taxonomy-source/?).\\n3. How identifiers are minted and claimed — I know from CLAUDE.md that `.headwater/ids/<scheme>/<identifier>` is the claim store (see docs/decisions/0054-the-upper-bound-of-a-reconcile-first-allocator-is-the-corpus-and-a-claim-store.md), but I need the mechanics: what schemes exist (e.g. sequential numeric per shelf, like 0001-, 0107-, 0054-), which kinds share a scheme vs have their own, and how `headwater new` looks up the next available identifier (does it scan the claim store directory, scan all branches, etc.)\\n4. Any document explaining the full list of kinds and their associated identifier scheme (sequential number vs other schemes) — check docs/taxonomies/ and .headwater/packages/ for a base package definition file (yaml/json) listing kinds.\\n5. Also check docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md for how process-shelf moves interact with identifiers.\\n\\nReport back: a clear list of shelves/kinds with their identifier scheme, the general decision procedure for picking a shelf for a new document, and exact file paths/line numbers for the key rules. Keep the report well-organized but under 600 words; cite file paths for every claim.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/taxonomies/ docs/spec/ 2>&1 | head -100\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater -iname \\\"*packages*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*taxonomy*\\\" 2>&1 | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r24/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r24/docs/taxonomies/README.md"
result: "sha256:4baa3cc1019fc8ca6365a0e372578a35c66e45e68b99c46f0c033b963f8514f4"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r24/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r24/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls .headwater/ 2>&1; echo ---; find .headwater -maxdepth 2 -type f 2>&1\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r24/docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md"
result: "sha256:b1bc8628c695ce6b58c9cbc67502d3b90e3452fd49aaff3710d485dce45824ac"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r24/docs/decisions/0054-the-upper-bound-of-a-reconcile-first-allocator-is-the-corpus-and-a-claim-store.md"
result: "sha256:dc39ad3508032fef66f58640206082c0f863a47c2fa2315934079e72223b1eb8"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r24/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r24/docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md"
result: "sha256:485fe85764154ebfd53b4e549e14fb453931eb09bef862591234f134d90c59b1"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r24/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"headwater new\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r24/CLAUDE.md | head -30\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,100p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r24/CLAUDE.md | grep -n \\\"shelf\\\\|kind\\\\|headwater new\\\" \"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r24/engine/crates/scaffold/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:ce9cc34ee18465fbc9d1f85c0b1d8d2ed393edd6460468b52d22f3b98e302bdd"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r24/engine/crates/scaffold/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:ce9cc34ee18465fbc9d1f85c0b1d8d2ed393edd6460468b52d22f3b98e302bdd"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r25"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r25/docs/\",\"description\":\"List top-level docs directories (shelves)\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r25/\",\"description\":\"List repo root\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r25/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r25/docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r25/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r25/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r25/docs/decisions/0057-a-shelf-layout-is-the-second-half-of-what-the-identifier-claim-store-covers.md"
result: "sha256:cfaa5e4b4f2a47f737d0bc5c3e55d4ca0018f46ccf225235d8efbfea8a344287"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r25/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r25/docs/obligations/0060-the-most-specific-shelf-wins-names-no-order.md"
result: "sha256:bf250948d2966958e7ceb532cc9333e810db6ff64b37c98e264e5be2fb39e926"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r26"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git status 2>&1 | head -20; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls -la\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .claude -iname \\\"settings*.json\\\" 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---\\\"; cat .claude/settings.json 2>/dev/null | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"Worktree\\\" .claude/settings.json; echo \\\"exit:$?\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/; echo \\\"---spec---\\\"; ls docs/spec/ 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r26/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater -maxdepth 4 -type d; echo \\\"---packages---\\\"; find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 3 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---taxonomy-source---\\\"; find taxonomy-source -maxdepth 4 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find . -maxdepth 2 -iname \\\"overlay.yml\\\"; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls docs/taxonomies/; echo \\\"---\\\"; cat .headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null | head -100\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"shelf\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/*/taxonomy.yml 2>/dev/null | head -80\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles -maxdepth 2 -type f; echo \\\"---\\\"; grep -rln \\\"shelf\\\\|layout\\\\|path:\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/ 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"shelf\\\\|layout\\\\|directory\\\\|path\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -60\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== base taxonomy.yml shelves block ===\\\"; sed -n '490,545p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\necho \\\"=== grep shelves in bundles ===\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"shelves\\\\|path: docs\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/*/bundle.yml\\necho \\\"=== grep shelves in overlay ===\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"shelves\\\\|path: docs\\\\|docs/\\\" .headwater/overlay.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== decision-record bundle: obligation_record_id + shelves ===\\\"\\nsed -n '120,150p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/decision-record/bundle.yml\\necho \\\"=== brd-prd bundle: requirement_id + shelves ===\\\"\\nsed -n '200,245p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/brd-prd/bundle.yml\\necho \\\"=== overlay: acceptance_criterion_id, verification_id, process_decision_id, library_doctrine_id ===\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"identifier_schemes\\\\.\\\\|kinds\\\\..*\\\\.identifier\\\" .headwater/overlay.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r26/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r27"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && ls -la && git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1\",\"description\":\"Check working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .claude -iname \\\"*orient*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*authoring*\\\" 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls .claude/skills 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Look for orientation/authoring skill files under .claude\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la .claude/ 2>&1; echo \\\"---skills---\\\"; find .claude -maxdepth 3 -type d 2>&1\",\"description\":\"List .claude directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/\",\"description\":\"List top-level docs shelves\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r27/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"shelf\\\" docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md | head -80\",\"description\":\"Find shelf-related passages in the taxonomy model spec\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r27/docs/obligations/0060-the-most-specific-shelf-wins-names-no-order.md"
result: "sha256:bf250948d2966958e7ceb532cc9333e810db6ff64b37c98e264e5be2fb39e926"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r28"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/ && echo \\\"---\\\" && ls docs/spec/ 2>&1\",\"description\":\"List docs directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"Decide which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r28/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r28/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater taxonomy-source -maxdepth 4 -type f | head -80\",\"description\":\"List headwater config and taxonomy source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/decisions docs/process docs/obligations docs/explanations docs/doctrine docs/taxonomies 2>&1 | head -100\",\"description\":\"List shelf directories under docs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find taxonomy-source -maxdepth 6 -type f | head -100\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 6 -type f 2>&1 | head -100\",\"description\":\"List headwater packages\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r28/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater -maxdepth 1 -type f; echo ---; find .headwater -maxdepth 2 -name \\\"*.yml\\\" -o -maxdepth 2 -name \\\"*.lock\\\" 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List top-level headwater config files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^ shelves\\\\.\\\\|^shelves:\\\" .headwater/overlay.yml taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/*/bundle.yml 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Find all shelf declarations across taxonomy sources\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r28/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r29"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; ls -la\",\"description\":\"Check if directory is a git repo and list contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r29/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r29/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r29/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r29/docs/decisions/0057-a-shelf-layout-is-the-second-half-of-what-the-identifier-claim-store-covers.md"
result: "sha256:cfaa5e4b4f2a47f737d0bc5c3e55d4ca0018f46ccf225235d8efbfea8a344287"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r29/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r29/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r3"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls -la\",\"description\":\"Check if directory is a git repository\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"Decide which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/\",\"description\":\"List top-level docs directory shelves\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r3/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls taxonomy-source; echo ---; find taxonomy-source -iname \\\"*.yml\\\" -o -iname \\\"*.yaml\\\" | head -50\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"pattern:\\\\|path:\\\\|^shelves\\\\|^- shelf\\\\|shelf:\\\\|kind:\\\\|identifier_scheme\\\" taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -150\",\"description\":\"Find shelf patterns and kind declarations in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater -maxdepth 3 -type f | head -80\",\"description\":\"List files under .headwater directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater -maxdepth 2 -type d; echo ---; find .headwater -iname \\\"overlay*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*.yml\\\" | grep -v \\\"^.headwater/ids\\\"; echo ---packages---; find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 4 -type f 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Find overlay and package yml files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r3/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r3/.headwater/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:0aa1b806b4bc44af26c12dc624643169bddb3583054e78db3873c23ca8e4bb12"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r30"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls -la\",\"description\":\"Check if directory is a git repository\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find docs -maxdepth 1 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level docs shelves\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/spec/ | sort\",\"description\":\"List spec part files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r30/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r30/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls taxonomy-source; echo ---; find taxonomy-source -maxdepth 3 -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Count lines in taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r30/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r30/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater -maxdepth 3 -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r30/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r30/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r30/docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md"
result: "sha256:485fe85764154ebfd53b4e549e14fb453931eb09bef862591234f134d90c59b1"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r31"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r31\",\"description\":\"List repository root contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/spec/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/**/README.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r31/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r31/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r31/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r31/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r31/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r31/taxonomy-source -maxdepth 3 -type f | head -50\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy source files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r31/taxonomy-source"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r31/.headwater -maxdepth 2 2>/dev/null; echo ---; sed -n '1,50p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r31/.headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Inspect .headwater directory and overlay file\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r31/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r31/.headwater/taxonomy.yml /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r31/.headwater/overlay.yml /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r31/.headwater/taxonomy.lock\",\"description\":\"Check file sizes of headwater config files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r31/.headwater/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:0aa1b806b4bc44af26c12dc624643169bddb3583054e78db3873c23ca8e4bb12"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r31/.headwater/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:0aa1b806b4bc44af26c12dc624643169bddb3583054e78db3873c23ca8e4bb12"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r31/.headwater/taxonomy.lock"
result: "sha256:1ea570f4a22e19db2ed394a89bbb5f47f2908847514bb3417fd7a88820333650"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r31/.headwater/taxonomy.lock"
result: "sha256:1ea570f4a22e19db2ed394a89bbb5f47f2908847514bb3417fd7a88820333650"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r32"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r32/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/spec/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r32/docs/decisions/0057-a-shelf-layout-is-the-second-half-of-what-the-identifier-claim-store-covers.md"
result: "sha256:cfaa5e4b4f2a47f737d0bc5c3e55d4ca0018f46ccf225235d8efbfea8a344287"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r32/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r32/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r32/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r32/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r32/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r33"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls -la\",\"description\":\"Check if directory is a git repository\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .claude -maxdepth 2 -iname \\\"settings*.json\\\" -o -iname \\\"*.json\\\" 2>/dev/null | grep -i settings; echo \\\"---\\\"; cat .claude/settings.json 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---local---\\\"; cat .claude/settings.local.json 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Look for Claude settings files with worktree hooks\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Research shelf and identifier conventions\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"I'm working in the Headwater repository at /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r33. I need to understand, from the actual documentation (not guesses), two things:\\n\\n1. How a new document's \\\"shelf\\\" (i.e., which subdirectory under docs/, such as docs/spec, docs/subsystems, docs/decisions, docs/evaluations, docs/obligations, docs/interfaces, docs/requirements, docs/acceptance-criteria, docs/tutorials, docs/how-to, docs/process/*, docs/taxonomies, etc.) is decided — what distinguishes each shelf/kind, and what rule or document governs choosing among them.\\n\\n2. How a new document's identifier is assigned/derived once the shelf is chosen — e.g., is it a sequential number per kind, a scheme tied to `.headwater/ids/<scheme>/<identifier>`, something `headwater new` mints, etc. Look at docs/decisions, docs/obligations, docs/spec files (especially anything about kinds, schemes, or the scaffolder/`headwater new`), and taxonomy-source or .headwater/packages if relevant.\\n\\nPlease find and quote/cite the specific documents (with file paths and relevant excerpts) that define:\\n- The list of shelves/kinds and what each is for (there may be a taxonomy document enumerating \\\"kinds\\\" like specification, decision, obligation, evaluation, interface, requirement, acceptance-criteria, tutorial, how-to, process decision, etc.)\\n- The rule for picking a shelf for a new document (e.g. based on content type: is it normative spec, a decision record, evidence/obligation, etc.)\\n- The identifier scheme per kind (e.g. decisions numbered 0001, 0002... obligations numbered separately, etc.) and where/how `headwater new` or the claim store (.headwater/ids/<scheme>/<identifier>) assigns it.\\n\\nAlso check DEVELOPING.md and docs/spec/09-decisions.md, docs/process/decisions/ for anything about \\\"shelf\\\" terminology specifically, and check for a taxonomy file (likely under .headwater/packages/ or taxonomy-source/) that lists kinds with their identifier schemes.\\n\\nReport back with concrete file paths, line numbers, and quoted excerpts — not paraphrases — so I can give the user an accurate, cited answer. Keep the report focused and under 500 words of synthesis, but include the key quotes.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls && echo \\\"---docs---\\\" && ls docs && echo \\\"---decisions---\\\" && ls docs/decisions 2>/dev/null && echo \\\"---spec---\\\" && ls docs/spec 2>/dev/null && echo \\\"---.headwater---\\\" && ls -la .headwater 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls .headwater/ids && echo \\\"---\\\" && ls .headwater/packages && echo \\\"---taxonomy-source---\\\" && ls taxonomy-source && echo \\\"---process---\\\" && ls docs/process && echo \\\"---taxonomies---\\\" && ls docs/taxonomies\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r33/docs/decisions/0057-a-shelf-layout-is-the-second-half-of-what-the-identifier-claim-store-covers.md"
result: "sha256:cfaa5e4b4f2a47f737d0bc5c3e55d4ca0018f46ccf225235d8efbfea8a344287"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r33/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n -i \\\"shelf\\\" -r /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r33/docs/spec /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r33/DEVELOPING.md /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r33/docs/taxonomies/README.md 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r33/docs/taxonomies/README.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r33/taxonomy-source -type f | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r33/.headwater/taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^shelves:\\\" -A 100 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r33/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -150\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^shelves:\\\" -A 150 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r33/.headwater/overlay.yml | sed -n '1,160p'\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"shelves\\\\|shelf\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r33/.headwater/overlay.yml | head -60\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n -i \\\"shelf\\\\|kind\\\\b\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r33/CLAUDE.md | head -80\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n -i \\\"shelf\\\\|headwater new\\\\|which shelf\\\\|choose.*shelf\\\\|pick.*shelf\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r33/DEVELOPING.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"headwater new\\\" -A 10 -B 5 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r33/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md | head -150\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n -i \\\"shelf\\\" -B2 -A6 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r33/docs/spec/01-conceptual-model.md | head -100\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"identifier_schemes\\\" -A 3 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r33/.headwater/overlay.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^ [a-z_]*_id:\\\" -A 3 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r33/.headwater/taxonomy.lock | grep -A3 \\\"pattern\\\" | head -80\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^ shelves\\\\.\\\" -A 6 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r33/.headwater/overlay.yml | grep -A6 \\\"shelves\\\\.\\\" | head -200\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^ shelves\\\\.\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r33/.headwater/taxonomy.lock\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"shelves\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r33/.headwater/taxonomy.lock | head -5; echo ---; python3 -c \\\"\\nimport json\\nd=json.load(open('/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r33/.headwater/taxonomy.lock'))\\nprint(type(d))\\nprint(list(d.keys())[:20])\\n\\\" 2>&1 | head -30\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r33/.headwater/taxonomy.lock"
result: "sha256:1ea570f4a22e19db2ed394a89bbb5f47f2908847514bb3417fd7a88820333650"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"obligation_record_id\\\\|decision_id\\\\|spec_id\\\" -A3 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r33/.headwater/taxonomy.lock | head -40\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1100,1170p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r33/.headwater/taxonomy.lock; echo \\\"---ids dir sample---\\\"; ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r33/.headwater/ids/decision_id | head -5; cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r33/.headwater/ids/decision_id/$(ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r33/.headwater/ids/decision_id | head -1)\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r33/.headwater/ids/spec_id/HW-SPEC-taxonomy-model 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---decision 0054 excerpt---\\\"; sed -n '1,40p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r33/docs/decisions/0054-the-upper-bound-of-a-reconcile-first-allocator-is-the-corpus-and-a-claim-store.md\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r34"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r34/docs -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List docs subdirectories two levels deep\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r34/.headwater -maxdepth 3 | sort\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rl \\\"shelf\\\" docs .headwater --include=*.md --include=*.yml -i 2>/dev/null | sort\",\"description\":\"Find docs mentioning 'shelf'\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 2 2>/dev/null | sort\",\"description\":\"List headwater packages directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r34/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r34/docs/decisions/0057-a-shelf-layout-is-the-second-half-of-what-the-identifier-claim-store-covers.md"
result: "sha256:cfaa5e4b4f2a47f737d0bc5c3e55d4ca0018f46ccf225235d8efbfea8a344287"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r34/docs/obligations/0060-the-most-specific-shelf-wins-names-no-order.md"
result: "sha256:bf250948d2966958e7ceb532cc9333e810db6ff64b37c98e264e5be2fb39e926"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r34/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r34/.headwater/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:0aa1b806b4bc44af26c12dc624643169bddb3583054e78db3873c23ca8e4bb12"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r34/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r34/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r34/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^shelves:\\\" -A 400 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r34/.headwater/taxonomy.lock | sed -n '1,250p'\",\"description\":\"Show shelves block from taxonomy.lock\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^ shelves\\\\.\\\" .headwater/overlay.yml\\necho \\\"---bundles---\\\"\\ngrep -rn \\\"^ shelves\\\\.\\\\|^shelves:\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/*/bundle.yml\\necho \\\"---process shelf---\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"process\\\" .headwater/overlay.yml | head -50\",\"description\":\"Find all shelf declarations across overlay and bundles\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r34/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r34/docs/decisions/0093-the-live-account-of-a-domain-is-its-own-kind-split-on-the-product-and-process-line-and-it-draws-on-the-records-it-cites.md"
result: "sha256:eee01e2fdfbfbe24bc6297b85988b164b12deeb3a17d841a715f5c3864e9717e"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r35"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/spec/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".claude/skills/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/**/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r35/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r35/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r35/docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r35/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r36"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"Decide which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r36/ 2>&1 | head -50\",\"description\":\"List contents of working directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r36/ && ls -la .git 2>&1 | head -5; echo \\\"---\\\"; git status 2>&1 | head -10; echo \\\"---\\\"; git rev-parse --show-toplevel 2>&1\",\"description\":\"Check for git directory and repo status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r36/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r36/docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r36/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r36/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r36/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r37"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r37/ && echo --- && ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r37/docs/ 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List working directory and docs folder\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git status 2>&1 | head -5; echo \\\"---find git---\\\"; find . -maxdepth 1 -name \\\".git\\\"\",\"description\":\"Check for git repository presence\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r37/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r37/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r37/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r37/docs/decisions/0057-a-shelf-layout-is-the-second-half-of-what-the-identifier-claim-store-covers.md"
result: "sha256:cfaa5e4b4f2a47f737d0bc5c3e55d4ca0018f46ccf225235d8efbfea8a344287"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r37/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r37/docs/decisions/0025-q25-where-the-namespace-goes-in-an-identifier-and-who-declares-it.md"
result: "sha256:4894471729347cedfb96adf9888fd728ae063217b84f028833d1dd70a5051370"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r38"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r38\",\"description\":\"List repo root\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r38/docs\",\"description\":\"List docs directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r38/taxonomy-source\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy-source directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r38/taxonomy-source -maxdepth 3 -type d\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy-source subdirectories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r38/taxonomy-source"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r38/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Count lines of taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r38/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r38/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r38/.headwater -maxdepth 3 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r38/.headwater/packages -maxdepth 3 2>/dev/null; echo ---; cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r38/.headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null | head -200\",\"description\":\"List packages dir and show overlay.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r38/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r38/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles; for d in */; do echo \\\"== $d ==\\\"; find \\\"$d\\\" -maxdepth 2; done\",\"description\":\"List bundle directory contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r38/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles; echo \\\"=== decision-record ===\\\"; cat decision-record/bundle.yml; echo \\\"=== standards-spec ===\\\"; cat standards-spec/bundle.yml; echo \\\"=== evidence-and-obligation ===\\\"; cat evidence-and-obligation/bundle.yml\",\"description\":\"Show bundle.yml for decision-record, standards-spec, evidence-and-obligation\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r38/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles; grep -n -E \\\"^ (shelves|kinds)\\\\.|path: docs|purpose:|identifier: \\\\{scheme|is_a:\\\" decision-record/bundle.yml standards-spec/bundle.yml evidence-and-obligation/bundle.yml design-spec/bundle.yml diataxis-site/bundle.yml\",\"description\":\"Grep key mapping lines across bundles\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r38 && git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1\",\"description\":\"Check if directory is a git repository\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r39"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Research shelf and identifier rules\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"I need to understand how this Headwater repository decides, for a new document, (a) which \\\"shelf\\\" under docs/ it belongs on (e.g. docs/spec/, docs/subsystems/, docs/decisions/, docs/evaluations/, docs/obligations/, docs/interfaces/, docs/requirements/, docs/acceptance-criteria/, docs/tutorials/, docs/how-to/, docs/process/*, docs/reviews/), and (b) where its identifier (numeric prefix like 0107-, or scheme) comes from — i.e. how `headwater new` mints/claims identifiers, and how the mapping from document \\\"kind\\\" to shelf and identifier scheme is declared in the taxonomy.\\n\\nPlease research and report back (don't edit anything):\\n\\n1. Look at `.headwater/packages/` (likely a base taxonomy package) for a \\\"kinds\\\" definition that maps a document kind to a shelf (file path/directory) and to an identifier scheme. Look for keys like `kinds.specification`, `kinds.decision`, `kinds.obligation`, etc., and see what fields they have (shelf path, id scheme, relation rules).\\n2. Read docs/spec/ files that describe the authoring/scaffolding/identifier system — especially anything about `headwater new`, the taxonomy, and the identifier claim store (docs/decisions/0054-the-upper-bound-of-a-reconcile-first-allocator-is-the-corpus-and-a-claim-store.md if it exists, and docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md).\\n3. Check docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md for how shelf vs identifier scheme interact.\\n4. Find any top-level README or docs/README or docs/spec table of contents that enumerates the shelves under docs/ and what belongs on each.\\n5. Look for a skill definition file for `headwater-authoring` or `headwater-taxonomy` (likely under .claude/skills/ or similar) — read its SKILL.md to see if it states the decision procedure for shelf + identifier directly.\\n\\nReport back with:\\n- The list of shelves and a one-line description of what kind of document goes on each (as actually defined in the repo, not guessed).\\n- How the identifier for a new document is determined (scheme per kind, where the scheme is declared, how `headwater new` claims it, the claim store mechanism).\\n- Any decision procedure/algorithm you find explicitly stated (e.g. \\\"look up kind -> get shelf and id scheme from taxonomy\\\").\\n- Exact file paths and line numbers for everything you cite.\\n\\nKeep the report well organized but can be as long as needed to be complete — this is pure research, no code changes.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo --- && find . -maxdepth 3 -type d | sort\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".headwater/packages/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r39/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r39/.agents/skills/headwater-taxonomy"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r39/.agents/skills/headwater-authoring"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".agents/skills/headwater-taxonomy/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".agents/skills/headwater-authoring/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r39/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/package.yml"
result: "sha256:5d71300875769fa4e662fd247d4c84ab9ea6582dacdf3ee52640eede0ed68b2c"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r39/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/assemblies/starter/assembly.yml"
result: "sha256:cdccd3c4b9fef1802c9885c476c1983e04bbd12b6439f342640bdaa269742e3d"
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".headwater/*.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r39/.agents/skills/headwater-taxonomy/SKILL.md"
result: "sha256:f5b9c95bb000782be9586c1b1e263d934d09fc84e8e444ed89c24325004d7220"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r39/.agents/skills/headwater-authoring/SKILL.md"
result: "sha256:5588ef44dba3982a11a84a2df94abfe2a6ec28e24278888e16e2d7d518362520"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r39/.headwater/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:0aa1b806b4bc44af26c12dc624643169bddb3583054e78db3873c23ca8e4bb12"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r39/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r39/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r39/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/decision-record/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:84e2d9770dfd50107a46f099af4d51666455a161eacf803cf05cfd303dd8f88d"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r39/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/evidence-and-obligation/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:fd65c2f4a94d4f0a6d38ea74d4700f9439c36a6bcc407a30061ff4002d2b81f8"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r39/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/design-spec/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:8e8b03d0d2e6bf2044c68d86e327887e851cb0736a9b642a89205358062669ff"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r39/.headwater/ids/decision_id/ 2>/dev/null; echo ---; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r39/.headwater/ids -maxdepth 2 -type f | head -20\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r39/docs/decisions -iname \\\"0054*\\\"; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r39/docs/obligations -iname \\\"0107*\\\"; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r39/docs/process/decisions -iname \\\"0024*\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r39/.headwater/ids/decision_id/HW-DR-0054"
result: "sha256:127fd58dec83a78aefbf9587c0229dee33478221b0e6ef67bb17e77158512690"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r39/docs/decisions/0054-the-upper-bound-of-a-reconcile-first-allocator-is-the-corpus-and-a-claim-store.md"
result: "sha256:dc39ad3508032fef66f58640206082c0f863a47c2fa2315934079e72223b1eb8"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r39/docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md"
result: "sha256:b1bc8628c695ce6b58c9cbc67502d3b90e3452fd49aaff3710d485dce45824ac"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r39/docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md"
result: "sha256:485fe85764154ebfd53b4e549e14fb453931eb09bef862591234f134d90c59b1"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r39/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r39/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r4"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls\",\"description\":\"Check if directory is a git repo and list contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== docs top level ===\\\"; ls docs; echo \\\"=== docs/spec ===\\\"; ls docs/spec 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"=== docs/decisions ===\\\"; ls docs/decisions 2>/dev/null | head -30; echo \\\"=== docs/process ===\\\"; find docs/process -maxdepth 2 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List docs directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r4/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r4/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== taxonomy-source ===\\\"; find taxonomy-source -maxdepth 2 -type f | head -50; echo \\\"=== .headwater ===\\\"; find .headwater -maxdepth 3 2>/dev/null | head -50\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy source files and .headwater directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "taxonomy-source"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r4/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r4/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== overlay ===\\\"; cat .headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null | head -200; echo \\\"=== bundles dir ===\\\"; find taxonomy-source -maxdepth 3 -type d; echo \\\"=== packages ===\\\"; find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 2 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Show overlay.yml and bundle directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r4/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles -maxdepth 1 -type d 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List bundle directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r4/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"shelves\\\\.\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r4/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/*/taxonomy.yml 2>/dev/null; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r4/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles -name \\\"*.yml\\\" | xargs ls\",\"description\":\"Search bundle taxonomy files for shelf declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r4/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/evidence-and-obligation/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:fd65c2f4a94d4f0a6d38ea74d4700f9439c36a6bcc407a30061ff4002d2b81f8"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r4/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/design-spec/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:8e8b03d0d2e6bf2044c68d86e327887e851cb0736a9b642a89205358062669ff"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r4/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/decision-record/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:84e2d9770dfd50107a46f099af4d51666455a161eacf803cf05cfd303dd8f88d"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r4/docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md"
result: "sha256:485fe85764154ebfd53b4e549e14fb453931eb09bef862591234f134d90c59b1"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r4/docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md"
result: "sha256:b1bc8628c695ce6b58c9cbc67502d3b90e3452fd49aaff3710d485dce45824ac"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r40"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r40/docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md"
result: "sha256:485fe85764154ebfd53b4e549e14fb453931eb09bef862591234f134d90c59b1"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r40/docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r40/docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r40/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r40/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r40/docs/spec/glossary.md"
result: "sha256:7a727d91789e2bb03c825ae01ec01639c7ff08f9022b5d03241c734c2148c99a"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r40/docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md"
result: "sha256:b1bc8628c695ce6b58c9cbc67502d3b90e3452fd49aaff3710d485dce45824ac"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r40/docs/spec/01-conceptual-model.md"
result: "sha256:f1f133ccaffda3844e639227d488a3e90e6a238b4f809c3af0c92a7d354ca0e3"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r41"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r41/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r41/docs/decisions/0057-a-shelf-layout-is-the-second-half-of-what-the-identifier-claim-store-covers.md"
result: "sha256:cfaa5e4b4f2a47f737d0bc5c3e55d4ca0018f46ccf225235d8efbfea8a344287"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r41/docs/decisions/0054-the-upper-bound-of-a-reconcile-first-allocator-is-the-corpus-and-a-claim-store.md"
result: "sha256:dc39ad3508032fef66f58640206082c0f863a47c2fa2315934079e72223b1eb8"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r41/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r41/docs/obligations/0060-the-most-specific-shelf-wins-names-no-order.md"
result: "sha256:bf250948d2966958e7ceb532cc9333e810db6ff64b37c98e264e5be2fb39e926"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r41/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r41/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r42"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".headwater/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r42/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r42/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r42/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r42/.headwater/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:0aa1b806b4bc44af26c12dc624643169bddb3583054e78db3873c23ca8e4bb12"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r42/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r42/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/design-spec/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:8e8b03d0d2e6bf2044c68d86e327887e851cb0736a9b642a89205358062669ff"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r42/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/evidence-and-obligation/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:fd65c2f4a94d4f0a6d38ea74d4700f9439c36a6bcc407a30061ff4002d2b81f8"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r42/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/decision-record/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:84e2d9770dfd50107a46f099af4d51666455a161eacf803cf05cfd303dd8f88d"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r42/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r42/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r43"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Find shelf-placement and identifier rules\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"I'm working in the Headwater repository (a documentation-governance system with shelves under docs/: spec, subsystems, decisions, evaluations, obligations, interfaces, requirements, acceptance-criteria, tutorials, how-to, process, reviews, taxonomies). I need to answer: \\\"Decide which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from.\\\"\\n\\nPlease find and report on:\\n\\n1. The document(s) that define the decision procedure / rule for choosing which shelf (docs/spec/, docs/subsystems/, docs/decisions/, docs/evaluations/, docs/obligations/, docs/interfaces/, docs/requirements/, docs/acceptance-criteria/, docs/tutorials/, docs/how-to/, docs/process/*) a new document belongs on. Look especially at `headwater new` command docs/spec (its behavior, what kinds it supports, how it picks a shelf from a \\\"kind\\\"), docs/spec/*-ai-integration.md, any docs/spec file about authoring, scaffolding, or the \\\"kinds\\\" taxonomy package under .headwater/packages/ or docs/taxonomies/.\\n\\n2. The document(s) that define where a new document's identifier comes from — I already know about the claim store at `.headwater/ids/<scheme>/<identifier>` (one file per identifier, never overwritten, from docs/decisions/0054-the-upper-bound-of-a-reconcile-first-allocator-is-the-corpus-and-a-claim-store.md). Find the doc(s) that explain which identifier *scheme* a given kind/shelf uses, how `headwater new` picks the scheme, and what happens for a kind with no identifier scheme (there's a doc docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md that seems related — read it).\\n\\n3. Also check docs/spec/12-check-layer.md, docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md, and anything under .headwater/packages/ defining \\\"kinds\\\" with a \\\"shelf\\\" or \\\"scheme\\\" field, since these were flagged as relevant by a routing hook.\\n\\nReport back: the exact file paths and line numbers/quotes that state the shelf-selection rule and the identifier-scheme-selection rule, and summarize the mechanism in plain terms (how a \\\"kind\\\" maps to a shelf and a scheme, what `headwater new <kind>` actually does). Keep the report under 400 words, with citations as file_path:line_number.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r43 -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/spec/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".headwater/packages/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r43/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r43/docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md"
result: "sha256:b1bc8628c695ce6b58c9cbc67502d3b90e3452fd49aaff3710d485dce45824ac"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r43/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r43/docs/interfaces"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/interfaces/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r43/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r43/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r43/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r43/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r43/docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md"
result: "sha256:485fe85764154ebfd53b4e549e14fb453931eb09bef862591234f134d90c59b1"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r43/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r43/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r43/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r44"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"Decide which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/**/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".headwater/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/spec/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r44/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r44/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r44/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r44/docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md"
result: "sha256:485fe85764154ebfd53b4e549e14fb453931eb09bef862591234f134d90c59b1"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r45"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"Decide which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r45/docs -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level docs directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r45/.headwater -maxdepth 3 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r45/docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r45/docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r45/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r45/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r45/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard -maxdepth 4 -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List files in the headwater-standard package\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r45/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r45/.headwater -maxdepth 1 -type f; echo ---; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r45 -maxdepth 1 -iname \\\"*.yml\\\" -o -maxdepth 1 -iname \\\"*.yaml\\\" 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Find overlay.yml and top-level yaml config\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r45/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r45/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r46"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r46\",\"description\":\"List top-level repo contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/spec/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r46/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r46/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r46/taxonomy-source"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r46/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r46/.headwater/ 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r46/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r46/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r46/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r46/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r46/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r46/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r46/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r46/.headwater/taxonomy.lock"
result: "sha256:1ea570f4a22e19db2ed394a89bbb5f47f2908847514bb3417fd7a88820333650"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r46/.headwater/taxonomy.lock"
result: "sha256:1ea570f4a22e19db2ed394a89bbb5f47f2908847514bb3417fd7a88820333650"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r46/.headwater/taxonomy.lock"
result: "sha256:1ea570f4a22e19db2ed394a89bbb5f47f2908847514bb3417fd7a88820333650"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r46/.headwater/taxonomy.lock"
result: "sha256:1ea570f4a22e19db2ed394a89bbb5f47f2908847514bb3417fd7a88820333650"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r47"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && ls -la\",\"description\":\"List working directory contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la .git 2>&1 | head -5; git status 2>&1 | head -5\",\"description\":\"Check for git directory and status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/\",\"description\":\"List docs directory shelves\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Research shelf selection and identifier rules\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"I'm working in the Headwater repository at /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r47 (docs/, .headwater/, taxonomy-source/, engine/). I need to answer two linked questions for someone about to author a new document:\\n\\n1. How does this repository decide which \\\"shelf\\\" (subdirectory under docs/, e.g. docs/spec, docs/subsystems, docs/decisions, docs/evaluations, docs/obligations, docs/interfaces, docs/requirements, docs/acceptance-criteria, docs/tutorials, docs/how-to, docs/process, docs/explanations, docs/doctrine, docs/verifications, docs/reviews, docs/taxonomies) a new document belongs on? What determines/governs this — is there a taxonomy of \\\"kinds\\\" that maps to shelves? Look at docs/spec (especially files about kinds, document types, or the check layer), .headwater/packages/ (if present), docs/taxonomies/, and taxonomy-source/.\\n\\n2. Where does a new document's identifier come from — what scheme is used (e.g. numeric prefix like \\\"0107-\\\", \\\"HW-DR-0054\\\", \\\"HW-PD-0001\\\", \\\"Q10\\\"), how is it minted, and what is the \\\"identifier claim store\\\" mentioned in CLAUDE.md as `.headwater/ids/<scheme>/<identifier>`? Is the scheme tied to the shelf/kind? Find the actual spec/decision document(s) that define this (look for files about `headwater new`, identifier schemes, kinds.specification, kinds — e.g. docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md was surfaced as relevant, and docs/decisions/0054-the-upper-bound-of-a-reconcile-first-allocator-is-the-corpus-and-a-claim-store.md).\\n\\nPlease report: (a) the mechanism/rule for shelf selection (cite file paths), (b) the mechanism for identifier minting per scheme (cite file paths), (c) how shelf and identifier scheme relate to each other (is there a fixed mapping kind -> shelf -> id scheme?), (d) what `headwater new` actually does and what inputs it takes (a kind name? a shelf?). Keep the report factual with file citations, under 500 words.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/ && echo --- && ls docs/spec/ && echo --- && ls .headwater/ 2>/dev/null && echo --- && ls .headwater/packages/ 2>/dev/null && echo --- && ls docs/taxonomies/ 2>/dev/null && echo --- && ls taxonomy-source/ 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r47/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r47/docs/spec/12-check-layer.md"
result: "sha256:c620a4a257ea8ebd4047f382ae84c7faf0c5483b39bb33641572a5a055becd44"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r47/.headwater/ids/ 2>/dev/null; echo ---; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r47/.headwater/packages -maxdepth 4 | head -100\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r47/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -300\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r47/docs/interfaces/ | grep -i new; echo ---; ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r47/docs/interfaces/\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r47/docs/decisions/0054-the-upper-bound-of-a-reconcile-first-allocator-is-the-corpus-and-a-claim-store.md"
result: "sha256:dc39ad3508032fef66f58640206082c0f863a47c2fa2315934079e72223b1eb8"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r47/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^shelves:\\\\|^kinds:\\\\|^identifier_schemes:\\\\|^ [a-z_]*:$\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r47/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | sed -n '1,200p'\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r47/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r47/docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md"
result: "sha256:b1bc8628c695ce6b58c9cbc67502d3b90e3452fd49aaff3710d485dce45824ac"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r47/.headwater/taxonomy.yml 2>/dev/null | head -60; echo ===OVERLAY===; cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r47/.headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r47/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/design-spec/bundle.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r47/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles\\nfor f in */bundle.yml; do echo \\\"=== $f ===\\\"; grep -n \\\"^ shelves\\\\.\\\\|^ identifier_schemes\\\\.\\\\|path:\\\\|kind:\\\\|kinds:\\\\|identifier:\\\" \\\"$f\\\"; done\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r47/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles\\ngrep -n \\\"identifier\\\" design-spec/bundle.yml evidence-and-obligation/bundle.yml decision-record/bundle.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r47\\ngrep -rn \\\"process_decision_id\\\\|requirement_id\\\\|verification_id\\\\|register_id\\\\|library_doctrine_id\\\\|acceptance_criterion_id\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/*/bundle.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r47/.headwater/overlay.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"identifier_schemes\\\\.\\\\|kinds\\\\.\\\\|shelves\\\\.\\\\|pattern:\\\\|namespace:\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r47/.headwater/overlay.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"Placement is primary\\\\|## Identifiers\\\\|identifier is derived\\\\|shelf match\\\\|## Shelves\\\\|### Shelves\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r47/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r47/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r47/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r47/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r48"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".headwater/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".claude/skills/*\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/spec/*\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r48/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r48/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r48/docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md"
result: "sha256:b1bc8628c695ce6b58c9cbc67502d3b90e3452fd49aaff3710d485dce45824ac"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r49"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la | head -30 && echo --- && git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1\",\"description\":\"Check repo root contents and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r49/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/spec/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r49/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r49/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r49/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r49/docs/decisions/0057-a-shelf-layout-is-the-second-half-of-what-the-identifier-claim-store-covers.md"
result: "sha256:cfaa5e4b4f2a47f737d0bc5c3e55d4ca0018f46ccf225235d8efbfea8a344287"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r49/docs/obligations/0060-the-most-specific-shelf-wins-names-no-order.md"
result: "sha256:bf250948d2966958e7ceb532cc9333e810db6ff64b37c98e264e5be2fb39e926"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r5"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r5/docs -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List docs subdirectories two levels deep\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r5/.headwater -maxdepth 3 | sort\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r5/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r5/docs/spec | sort\",\"description\":\"List docs/spec files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r5/.headwater/packages -maxdepth 2 2>/dev/null | sort\",\"description\":\"List headwater packages directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r5/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r5/docs/decisions/0057-a-shelf-layout-is-the-second-half-of-what-the-identifier-claim-store-covers.md"
result: "sha256:cfaa5e4b4f2a47f737d0bc5c3e55d4ca0018f46ccf225235d8efbfea8a344287"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r5/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,400p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r5/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | grep -n -i -E \\\"shelf|path:|kind:|scheme|layout\\\" | head -150\",\"description\":\"Search taxonomy.yml for shelf/kind/scheme declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r5/docs/obligations/0060-the-most-specific-shelf-wins-names-no-order.md"
result: "sha256:bf250948d2966958e7ceb532cc9333e810db6ff64b37c98e264e5be2fb39e926"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r5/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r5/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r50"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r50 -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/**/*shelf*\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/spec/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r50/docs/decisions/0057-a-shelf-layout-is-the-second-half-of-what-the-identifier-claim-store-covers.md"
result: "sha256:cfaa5e4b4f2a47f737d0bc5c3e55d4ca0018f46ccf225235d8efbfea8a344287"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r50/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r50/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".headwater/packages/**/*.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"taxonomy-source/**/*.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r50/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r50/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".headwater/*.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/taxonomies/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r50/.headwater/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:0aa1b806b4bc44af26c12dc624643169bddb3583054e78db3873c23ca8e4bb12"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r50/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r50/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r51"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r51/docs -maxdepth 1 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level docs shelves\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r51/.headwater -maxdepth 3 | sort\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r51/.headwater/packages -maxdepth 4 | sort\",\"description\":\"List headwater packages directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r51/docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md"
result: "sha256:b1bc8628c695ce6b58c9cbc67502d3b90e3452fd49aaff3710d485dce45824ac"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r51/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r51/.headwater/overlay.yml\",\"description\":\"View overlay.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"shelves:\\\\|purposes:\\\\|identifier_schemes:\\\\|^ [a-z_]*:.*{path:\\\" -A0 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r51/.headwater/overlay.yml | head -100\",\"description\":\"Find shelves and identifier scheme sections in overlay.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r51/.headwater/overlay.yml\",\"description\":\"Count lines in overlay.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r51/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"shelves\\\\.\\\\|^ shelves:\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r51/.headwater/overlay.yml\",\"description\":\"List all shelf declarations in overlay.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r51/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/design-spec/bundle.yml\",\"description\":\"View design-spec bundle taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r51/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/evidence-and-obligation/bundle.yml\",\"description\":\"View evidence-and-obligation bundle taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"shelves\\\\.\\\\|identifier_schemes\\\\.\\\\|kinds\\\\.obligation_record:\\\\|kinds\\\\.decision:\\\" -A3 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r51/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/decision-record/bundle.yml | head -60\",\"description\":\"Check decision-record bundle for shelves/identifiers\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"shelves\\\\.\\\\|identifier_schemes\\\\.\\\\|purposes\\\\.\\\" -A2 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r51/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/brd-prd/bundle.yml\",\"description\":\"Check brd-prd bundle for shelves/identifiers/purposes\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r51/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r52"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls -la\",\"description\":\"Check if directory is a git repo and list contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat .claude/settings.json 2>/dev/null | head -100\",\"description\":\"Check for worktree hooks configuration\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/; echo \\\"---obligations---\\\"; ls docs/obligations | head -5; echo \\\"---spec---\\\"; ls docs/spec\",\"description\":\"List docs top-level shelves and spec directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r52/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/taxonomies/; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls .headwater/packages/ 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---overlay---\\\"; sed -n '1,80p' .headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Look at taxonomy shelf declarations and overlay\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r52/.headwater/packages"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r52\\necho \\\"=== design-spec bundle ===\\\"; cat .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/design-spec/bundle.yml\\necho \\\"=== decision-record bundle ===\\\"; cat .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/decision-record/bundle.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r52\\necho \\\"=== base shelves ===\\\"; grep -n \\\"shelves\\\\.\\\\|^ shelves:\\\" -A6 .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -80\\necho \\\"=== diataxis shelves ===\\\"; grep -n \\\"shelves\\\\.\\\" -A6 .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/diataxis/bundle.yml\\necho \\\"=== evidence-and-obligation shelves ===\\\"; grep -n \\\"shelves\\\\.\\\" -A6 .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/evidence-and-obligation/bundle.yml\\necho \\\"=== brd-prd shelves ===\\\"; grep -n \\\"shelves\\\\.\\\" -A6 .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/brd-prd/bundle.yml\\necho \\\"=== standards-spec shelves ===\\\"; grep -n \\\"shelves\\\\.\\\" -A6 .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/standards-spec/bundle.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r52/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r52/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r52/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r52\\ngrep -n \\\"^ shelves\\\\.\\\\|path: docs\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/diataxis/bundle.yml .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/diataxis-site/bundle.yml\",\"description\":\"Check diataxis bundle shelf declarations\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r53"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r53/docs -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level docs shelves\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r53/docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r53/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r53/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r53/docs/decisions/0057-a-shelf-layout-is-the-second-half-of-what-the-identifier-claim-store-covers.md"
result: "sha256:cfaa5e4b4f2a47f737d0bc5c3e55d4ca0018f46ccf225235d8efbfea8a344287"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r54"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Find shelf and identifier rules in docs\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"I need to answer the question: \\\"Decide which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from\\\" for the Headwater repository at /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r54.\\n\\nThis repo has a documentation system with \\\"shelves\\\" (docs/spec, docs/subsystems, docs/decisions, docs/evaluations, docs/obligations, docs/interfaces, docs/requirements, docs/acceptance-criteria, docs/tutorials, docs/how-to, docs/process/*, docs/reviews, docs/taxonomies) and a `headwater new` scaffolder tool, plus an identifier claim store at `.headwater/ids/<scheme>/<identifier>`.\\n\\nPlease find and report (with file paths and key quoted/paraphrased content):\\n\\n1. Any document (likely under docs/spec/ or docs/process/) that defines the full list of \\\"kinds\\\" of documents, which shelf each kind lives on, and the rule/heuristic for choosing which kind/shelf a new document belongs on. Look for terms like \\\"kind\\\", \\\"shelf\\\", \\\"package\\\" (as in document package), \\\"scaffolder\\\".\\n2. Any document describing identifier SCHEMES — i.e., where an identifier's number/slug comes from for each kind (e.g., sequential decision numbers like 0024, HW-DR-xxxx, HW-PD-xxxx, obligation numbers like 0107, etc.), and how `headwater new` mints/claims an identifier via `.headwater/ids/<scheme>/<identifier>`.\\n3. Look at `.headwater/packages/` and `docs/taxonomies/` if they exist, and any `headwater-taxonomy` related docs, since CLAUDE.md says those directories govern this.\\n4. Check docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md specifically (mentioned as relevant) — what does it say about `kinds.specification` and identifier schemes?\\n5. Check docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md — what does it say about shelf vs identifier scheme binding?\\n6. Look for a top-level spec doc (maybe docs/spec/05-ai-integration.md, or a numbered doc about document kinds/packages) that is authoritative here.\\n\\nReport back a structured summary: the list of shelves and their kinds if found, the identifier scheme per kind, and the decision rule for picking a shelf. Include file paths for everything you cite. Keep the report well organized but no need to be short — thoroughness matters more here.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find docs/spec docs/process -maxdepth 3 -type f | sort\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater -maxdepth 4 -type d | sort\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find docs/taxonomies -maxdepth 3 -type f 2>/dev/null | sort\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r54/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r54/docs/taxonomies/README.md"
result: "sha256:4baa3cc1019fc8ca6365a0e372578a35c66e45e68b99c46f0c033b963f8514f4"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r54/docs/obligations -iname \\\"0107*\\\" 2>/dev/null; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r54 -iname \\\"0107-the-base-package*\\\" 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r54 -iname \\\"CLAUDE.md\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r54/.headwater -maxdepth 1 -type f; echo ---; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r54 -iname \\\"overlay.yml\\\" | head; echo ---; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r54/docs/interfaces -iname \\\"*taxonomy*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*scaffold*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*headwater-new*\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r54/docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md"
result: "sha256:b1bc8628c695ce6b58c9cbc67502d3b90e3452fd49aaff3710d485dce45824ac"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r54/docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md"
result: "sha256:485fe85764154ebfd53b4e549e14fb453931eb09bef862591234f134d90c59b1"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r54/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r54/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^ shelves\\\\.\\\\|^ kinds\\\\.\\\\|^ identifier_schemes\\\\.\\\" .headwater/overlay.yml | sed -n '1,200p'\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater/packages/headwater-standard -maxdepth 1 -type f; echo ---; sed -n '1,400p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml 2>/dev/null | grep -n \\\"shelves:\\\\|kinds:\\\\|identifier_schemes:\\\\|^ [a-z_]*:$\\\" \"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd .headwater/packages/headwater-standard && grep -n \\\"^shelves:\\\\|^kinds:\\\\|^identifier_schemes:\\\\|^relations:\\\\|^purposes:\\\\|^core:\\\" taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r54/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '429,531p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r54/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat docs/taxonomies/decision-record/bundle.yml 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"=====design-spec=====\\\"; grep -n \\\"shelves\\\\.\\\\|kinds\\\\.\\\\|identifier_schemes\\\\.\\\" docs/taxonomies/design-spec/bundle.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat docs/taxonomies/evidence-and-obligation/bundle.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,170p' docs/taxonomies/design-spec/bundle.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r54/CLAUDE.md"
result: "sha256:c92caed27f86014c5f496edda4ca85568e1da2a44e9c15e4aece92ff9b5bbfd2"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r54/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"awk '/^## Placement is primary/,0' docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md | head -120\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r54/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r54/docs/interfaces/headwater-taxonomy.md"
result: "sha256:8eeb3b021681d3b37264d09668bb89fe74e656c75db084dffedaa875675f08c0"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r55"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Research shelf and identifier rules\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"I need to understand this repository's (Headwater) rules for two things:\\n\\n1. How a new document's \\\"shelf\\\" (i.e., which docs/ subdirectory / kind it belongs under — e.g. docs/spec, docs/decisions, docs/process/decisions, docs/obligations, docs/evaluations, docs/interfaces, docs/requirements, docs/acceptance-criteria, docs/tutorials, docs/how-to, docs/reviews, docs/taxonomies) is decided — i.e. what determines which shelf/kind a document gets assigned to.\\n\\n2. Where a new document's identifier comes from — i.e. the identifier scheme mechanism: how `headwater new` mints/claims identifiers, what \\\"schemes\\\" are, how a kind is bound to an identifier scheme, and the claim store at `.headwater/ids/<scheme>/<identifier>`.\\n\\nPlease search and read (don't just grep filenames — read actual file contents):\\n- docs/spec/*.md (especially files about kinds, taxonomy, document types, identifiers, the scaffolder)\\n- docs/process/decisions/*.md and docs/decisions/*.md (especially anything about shelves, kinds, identifier schemes, moving documents between shelves)\\n- docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md (already known to be relevant — read it fully)\\n- .headwater/packages/ directory (taxonomy definitions - look for kind definitions, identifier scheme bindings)\\n- docs/taxonomies/*.md if present\\n- Any docs/spec file describing \\\"headwater new\\\" (the scaffolder) and how it picks a shelf/kind and mints identifiers\\n- .headwater/overlay.yml for any shelf-related config\\n- docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md (already flagged relevant — read it fully)\\n\\nReport back with:\\n- A clear explanation of the mechanism(s) that decide which shelf (docs subdirectory) a new document belongs on — is it based on \\\"kind\\\" (e.g. specification, decision, obligation, evaluation, interface, requirement, acceptance-criterion, tutorial, how-to), and where is the kind->shelf mapping declared?\\n- A clear explanation of where identifiers come from — what identifier schemes exist, how a kind binds to a scheme, how `headwater new` mints and claims an identifier, and the role of `.headwater/ids/<scheme>/<identifier>`.\\n- Cite exact file paths and quote the key defining sentences/lines.\\n- Note any gaps, exceptions, or known-broken cases (like obligation 0107's gap for `kinds.specification`).\\n\\nBe thorough — this may take significant exploration across docs/ and .headwater/. Report in detail with citations, no need to keep it short.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r55 -maxdepth 3 -type d | sort\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r55/.headwater -maxdepth 6 | sort\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r55/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard\\necho ---\\nfind /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r55/.headwater/packages -maxdepth 4 -type d\\necho ---\\nfind /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r55/.headwater/packages -iname '*kind*' -o -iname '*taxonomy*' -o -iname '*shelf*'\\necho ---\\ncat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r55/.headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/spec/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r55/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r55/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r55/docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md"
result: "sha256:b1bc8628c695ce6b58c9cbc67502d3b90e3452fd49aaff3710d485dce45824ac"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r55/docs/process/decisions -iname '0024*'; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r55/docs/decisions -iname '0024*'\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r55/docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r55/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r55/.headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null | head -300\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r55/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r55/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r55/engine/crates/scaffold/src/\\nwc -l /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r55/engine/crates/scaffold/src/lib.rs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r55/engine/crates/scaffold/src/claim.rs"
result: "sha256:cee363df75612ed7ff849b00031dba369c14c5061e2e29d4eca06a26afe4ba4f"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r55/docs/subsystems/authoring.md"
result: "sha256:2a9af9a983665b7977794bb2f7f7e0f26a816d7c115df0d6148089eabe3ff5cb"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r55/engine/crates/check/src -iname '*claim*'\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r55/engine/crates/check/src/claim.rs"
result: "sha256:e804a8f551dbe1831ad6e4b37f3c548f1ae82093d96be777501f34d3001cd8ff"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r55/engine/crates/scaffold/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:ce9cc34ee18465fbc9d1f85c0b1d8d2ed393edd6460468b52d22f3b98e302bdd"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r55/engine/crates/scaffold/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:ce9cc34ee18465fbc9d1f85c0b1d8d2ed393edd6460468b52d22f3b98e302bdd"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r55/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r55/engine/crates/scaffold/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:ce9cc34ee18465fbc9d1f85c0b1d8d2ed393edd6460468b52d22f3b98e302bdd"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r56"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"Decide which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r56/docs -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level docs shelves\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/spec/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r56/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r56/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r56/docs/decisions/0057-a-shelf-layout-is-the-second-half-of-what-the-identifier-claim-store-covers.md"
result: "sha256:cfaa5e4b4f2a47f737d0bc5c3e55d4ca0018f46ccf225235d8efbfea8a344287"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r56/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r56/docs/obligations/0060-the-most-specific-shelf-wins-names-no-order.md"
result: "sha256:bf250948d2966958e7ceb532cc9333e810db6ff64b37c98e264e5be2fb39e926"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r56/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r56/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r56/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r56/docs/obligations/0046-the-identifier-scheme-grammar.md"
result: "sha256:37617cf0865ec80e7943e2d86017a51fd4ec46b238c3fdc50d5e12e3ce32e006"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^#\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r56/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md | head -60\",\"description\":\"List headings in spec 3\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r56/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r57"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la | head -30 && echo \\\"---\\\" && git status 2>&1 | head -5\",\"description\":\"Check working directory contents and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/ && echo \\\"---headwater dir---\\\" && find .headwater -maxdepth 3 -type d\",\"description\":\"List docs shelves and .headwater directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find . -iname \\\"*headwater-authoring*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*headwater-orient*\\\" 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Locate headwater-authoring and headwater-orient skill files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .agents/skills/headwater-authoring .agents/skills/headwater-orient -type f | head -50\",\"description\":\"List files in headwater-authoring and headwater-orient skill dirs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r57/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r57/.agents/skills/headwater-authoring/SKILL.md"
result: "sha256:5588ef44dba3982a11a84a2df94abfe2a6ec28e24278888e16e2d7d518362520"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r57/.agents/skills/headwater-orient/SKILL.md"
result: "sha256:5edb4a19d946f07e57f0eb098211f1911eaa82903c4e62da2ad24c94cce7056c"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r57/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r57/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r57/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r57/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r58"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/\",\"description\":\"List docs directory shelves\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r58/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find taxonomy-source .headwater -maxdepth 4 -type f | head -50\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy source and headwater config files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "taxonomy-source"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Check size of taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r58/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater -maxdepth 1 -type f; echo ---; wc -l .headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List top-level .headwater files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r58/.headwater/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:0aa1b806b4bc44af26c12dc624643169bddb3583054e78db3873c23ca8e4bb12"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l .headwater/taxonomy.lock; find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 3 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Check taxonomy lock size and packages dir\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/taxonomy.lock"
result: "sha256:1ea570f4a22e19db2ed394a89bbb5f47f2908847514bb3417fd7a88820333650"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r58/.headwater/taxonomy.lock"
result: "sha256:1ea570f4a22e19db2ed394a89bbb5f47f2908847514bb3417fd7a88820333650"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r58/.headwater/taxonomy.lock"
result: "sha256:1ea570f4a22e19db2ed394a89bbb5f47f2908847514bb3417fd7a88820333650"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r59"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; echo \\\"---\\\"; git worktree list 2>&1; echo \\\"---\\\"; pwd\",\"description\":\"Check if directory is a git repository and worktree status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r59/.claude/ 2>&1 | head -50; echo \\\"---settings---\\\"; cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r59/.claude/settings.json 2>&1\",\"description\":\"Check for worktree hook configuration\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find docs -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List docs directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd docs && grep -rl \\\"shelf\\\" --include=*.md spec/ | sort\",\"description\":\"Find spec docs mentioning shelf\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"shelf\\\" spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md\",\"description\":\"Find shelf mentions in authoring-and-lifecycle spec\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r59/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"shelf\\\\|scheme\\\" spec/02-taxonomy-model.md | head -80\",\"description\":\"Find shelf and scheme definitions in taxonomy model spec\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r59/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r59 && find . -maxdepth 3 -iname \\\"*skill*\\\" 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---\\\"; find .claude -maxdepth 3 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Check for headwater-specific skills in repo\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd docs && grep -n \\\"^shelf\\\\|^kind\\\\b\\\\|^identifier scheme\\\\|^scheme\\\\b\\\" spec/glossary.md -A2 | head -60\",\"description\":\"Look up glossary definitions\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r59/docs/spec/glossary.md"
result: "sha256:7a727d91789e2bb03c825ae01ec01639c7ff08f9022b5d03241c734c2148c99a"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r59/docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md"
result: "sha256:485fe85764154ebfd53b4e549e14fb453931eb09bef862591234f134d90c59b1"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,40p' obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md\",\"description\":\"Read obligation 0107 about specification kind with no identifier scheme\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r6"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r6 -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/taxonomies/*\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".headwater/packages/**/*\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r6/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r6/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r6/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml 2>/dev/null | sed -n '1,400p'\",\"description\":\"View the headwater-standard taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r6/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r6/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".headwater/*.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".headwater/*.lock\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r6/.headwater/\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r6/.headwater/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:0aa1b806b4bc44af26c12dc624643169bddb3583054e78db3873c23ca8e4bb12"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r6/.headwater/taxonomy.lock"
result: "sha256:1ea570f4a22e19db2ed394a89bbb5f47f2908847514bb3417fd7a88820333650"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r6/.headwater/taxonomy.lock"
result: "sha256:1ea570f4a22e19db2ed394a89bbb5f47f2908847514bb3417fd7a88820333650"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r6/.headwater/taxonomy.lock"
result: "sha256:1ea570f4a22e19db2ed394a89bbb5f47f2908847514bb3417fd7a88820333650"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r6/.headwater/taxonomy.lock"
result: "sha256:1ea570f4a22e19db2ed394a89bbb5f47f2908847514bb3417fd7a88820333650"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r60"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la | head -30 && git status 2>&1 | head -5\",\"description\":\"Check repo root contents and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"Decide which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/\",\"description\":\"List top-level docs shelves\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r60/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r60/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r60/docs/obligations/0060-the-most-specific-shelf-wins-names-no-order.md"
result: "sha256:bf250948d2966958e7ceb532cc9333e810db6ff64b37c98e264e5be2fb39e926"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r60/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r60/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r60/docs/obligations/0046-the-identifier-scheme-grammar.md"
result: "sha256:37617cf0865ec80e7943e2d86017a51fd4ec46b238c3fdc50d5e12e3ce32e006"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r60/docs/decisions/0025-q25-where-the-namespace-goes-in-an-identifier-and-who-declares-it.md"
result: "sha256:4894471729347cedfb96adf9888fd728ae063217b84f028833d1dd70a5051370"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r60/docs/decisions/0054-the-upper-bound-of-a-reconcile-first-allocator-is-the-corpus-and-a-claim-store.md"
result: "sha256:dc39ad3508032fef66f58640206082c0f863a47c2fa2315934079e72223b1eb8"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,200p' .headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null | head -250\",\"description\":\"Peek at repo's taxonomy overlay for real shelves/schemes\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r60/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r60/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r61"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"Decide which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/**/*shelf*\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/**/*identifier*\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/spec/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "docs/decisions/0057-a-shelf-layout-is-the-second-half-of-what-the-identifier-claim-store-covers.md"
result: "sha256:cfaa5e4b4f2a47f737d0bc5c3e55d4ca0018f46ccf225235d8efbfea8a344287"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r62"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r62/docs/\",\"description\":\"List top-level docs shelves\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r62/.headwater/ 2>/dev/null; echo ---; ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r62/.headwater/ids 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory and ids claim store\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/spec/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r62/.headwater/packages/\",\"description\":\"List headwater packages\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r62/docs/taxonomies/\",\"description\":\"List docs/taxonomies\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r62/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r62/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== taxonomy.yml ===\\\" && cat .headwater/taxonomy.yml 2>/dev/null | head -100\",\"description\":\"Show repo taxonomy.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater/packages/headwater-standard -maxdepth 3 -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List base package files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd .headwater && python3 - <<'EOF'\\nimport yaml, json\\n# taxonomy.lock might be large; just grep shelves and identifier_schemes sections\\nEOF\\ngrep -n \\\"^shelves:\\\" -A 200 taxonomy.lock | head -250\",\"description\":\"Show shelves block from taxonomy.lock\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"head -c 500 taxonomy.lock; echo; echo \\\"---size---\\\"; wc -l taxonomy.lock; echo \\\"---grep shelves (any form)---\\\"; grep -n \\\"shelves\\\" taxonomy.lock | head -20\",\"description\":\"Inspect taxonomy.lock format\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '960,1060p' taxonomy.lock\",\"description\":\"Show shelves block in taxonomy.lock\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"identifier_schemes\\\\| kinds:\\\\|^ kinds:\\\" taxonomy.lock | head -20\",\"description\":\"Locate kinds and identifier_schemes sections\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1060,1160p' taxonomy.lock\",\"description\":\"Show rest of shelves and identifier_schemes sections\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '380,600p' taxonomy.lock | grep -n \\\"identifier:\\\\|^ [a-z_]*:$\\\" \",\"description\":\"Find kind -> identifier scheme mapping\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1155,1200p' taxonomy.lock; echo \\\"---design_spec kind---\\\"; sed -n '380,400p;460,500p' taxonomy.lock | sed -n '1,60p'\",\"description\":\"Show remaining identifier schemes and design_spec kind block\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"awk '/^ design_spec:/,/^ evaluation:/' taxonomy.lock\",\"description\":\"Show design_spec kind declaration\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r63"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".headwater/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Find shelf and identifier scheme rules\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"In this Headwater documentation corpus repository, I need to understand the mechanism that decides two things for any new governed document:\\n1. Which \\\"shelf\\\" (i.e., which directory under docs/, such as docs/spec/, docs/decisions/, docs/obligations/, docs/evaluations/, docs/requirements/, docs/acceptance-criteria/, docs/how-to/, docs/tutorials/, docs/interfaces/, docs/process/*, docs/reviews/, etc.) a new document belongs on, based on its \\\"kind\\\".\\n2. Where that document's identifier (e.g., HW-OBL-0122, HW-DR-0054, HW-AC-0001, HW-PD-0001) comes from — i.e., the identifier scheme/allocation mechanism, including the `headwater new` command, the `.headwater/ids/<scheme>/<identifier>` claim store, and the taxonomy package that declares which \\\"kind\\\" maps to which identifier scheme and which shelf.\\n\\nPlease investigate:\\n- The taxonomy package(s) under `.headwater/packages/` (or wherever the base package lives) that define \\\"kinds\\\" and their properties (shelf/path, identifier scheme, relations).\\n- Any docs/spec/*.md file describing kinds, shelves, or the `headwater new` scaffolder and identifier allocation (look especially at anything about \\\"kind\\\", \\\"shelf\\\", \\\"identifier scheme\\\", \\\"scaffolder\\\").\\n- docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md (already flagged as relevant) — read it in full.\\n- docs/decisions/0054-the-upper-bound-of-a-reconcile-first-allocator-is-the-corpus-and-a-claim-store.md and docs/decisions/0025-q25-where-the-namespace-goes-in-an-identifier-and-who-declares-it.md if they exist (identifier/namespace decisions).\\n- The `headwater-authoring` skill file if one exists under .claude/skills/ (even though I can't invoke it as a Skill, I can read its file directly) — it's described in CLAUDE.md as covering \\\"you add or revise any document under docs/\\\".\\n- docs/taxonomies/ directory if it exists.\\n\\nReport back: (a) the exact list of shelves and what kind of document goes on each, (b) how a kind declares its identifier scheme, (c) the concrete mechanism/command (`headwater new <kind>` or similar) that a person/agent actually runs to both pick the shelf and mint the identifier, and (d) any file paths and line numbers substantiating this. Keep the report focused and under 500 words — this is for an explanation I'll give the user, not for implementation.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== repo root ===\\\"; ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r63; echo \\\"=== .headwater ===\\\"; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r63/.headwater -maxdepth 6 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"=== skills ===\\\"; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r63/.claude -maxdepth 4 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r63\\necho \\\"=== taxonomy-source ===\\\"; find \\\"$ROOT/taxonomy-source\\\" -maxdepth 6\\necho \\\"=== .claude/skills ===\\\"; find \\\"$ROOT/.claude/skills\\\" -maxdepth 4 2>/dev/null\\necho \\\"=== .headwater (full) ===\\\"; find \\\"$ROOT/.headwater\\\" -maxdepth 6\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r63\\necho \\\"=== .headwater/ids dirs ===\\\"; ls \\\"$ROOT/.headwater/ids\\\"\\necho \\\"=== docs top ===\\\"; ls \\\"$ROOT/docs\\\"\\necho \\\"=== CLAUDE.md grep headwater-authoring ===\\\"; grep -n -i \\\"headwater-authoring\\\\|skill\\\" \\\"$ROOT/CLAUDE.md\\\"\\necho \\\"=== find skill files anywhere ===\\\"; find \\\"$ROOT\\\" -iname \\\"*headwater-authoring*\\\" 2>/dev/null\\necho \\\"=== docs/spec listing ===\\\"; ls \\\"$ROOT/docs/spec\\\" 2>/dev/null\\necho \\\"=== docs/taxonomies ===\\\"; ls \\\"$ROOT/docs/taxonomies\\\" 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r63/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r63/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r63\\necho \\\"=== bundles dir ===\\\"; find \\\"$ROOT/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard\\\" -maxdepth 3 -iname \\\"*bundle*\\\"\\nfind \\\"$ROOT/taxonomy-source\\\" -maxdepth 4\\necho \\\"=== search for decision-record bundle kinds ===\\\"\\ngrep -rn \\\"obligation_record\\\\|acceptance_criterion\\\\|process_decision\\\" \\\"$ROOT/taxonomy-source\\\" | head -80\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r63\\ncat \\\"$ROOT/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/package.yml\\\"\\necho \\\"=== assembly.yml ===\\\"\\ncat \\\"$ROOT/taxonomy-source/headwater-standard/assemblies/starter/assembly.yml\\\"\\necho \\\"=== find bundle yml anywhere ===\\\"\\nfind \\\"$ROOT\\\" -iname \\\"*.yml\\\" | xargs grep -l \\\"obligation_record\\\\|HW-OBL\\\\|acceptance_criterion_id\\\" 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r63/docs/taxonomies/decision-record/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:84e2d9770dfd50107a46f099af4d51666455a161eacf803cf05cfd303dd8f88d"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r63/docs/taxonomies/evidence-and-obligation/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:fd65c2f4a94d4f0a6d38ea74d4700f9439c36a6bcc407a30061ff4002d2b81f8"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r63\\nls -la \\\"$ROOT/docs/taxonomies/design-spec\\\"\\necho \\\"---\\\"\\nfind \\\"$ROOT/docs/taxonomies/design-spec\\\" -maxdepth 2\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r63/docs/taxonomies/design-spec/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:8e8b03d0d2e6bf2044c68d86e327887e851cb0736a9b642a89205358062669ff"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r63/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r63\\ngrep -n \\\"^ shelves\\\\.\\\\|^ kinds\\\\.\\\\|process_decision\\\\|shelves.requirements\\\\|shelves.acceptance\\\" \\\"$ROOT/.headwater/overlay.yml\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r63/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r63/docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md"
result: "sha256:b1bc8628c695ce6b58c9cbc67502d3b90e3452fd49aaff3710d485dce45824ac"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r63/docs/decisions/0054-the-upper-bound-of-a-reconcile-first-allocator-is-the-corpus-and-a-claim-store.md"
result: "sha256:dc39ad3508032fef66f58640206082c0f863a47c2fa2315934079e72223b1eb8"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r63/docs/decisions/0025-q25-where-the-namespace-goes-in-an-identifier-and-who-declares-it.md"
result: "sha256:4894471729347cedfb96adf9888fd728ae063217b84f028833d1dd70a5051370"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ROOT=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r63\\nfind \\\"$ROOT/.agents/skills/headwater-authoring\\\" -maxdepth 2\\nfind \\\"$ROOT/engine/crates/cli/harness/skills/headwater-authoring\\\" -maxdepth 2\\necho \\\"=== interfaces headwater-new ===\\\"\\nls \\\"$ROOT/docs/interfaces\\\" | grep -i new\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r63/.agents/skills/headwater-authoring/SKILL.md"
result: "sha256:5588ef44dba3982a11a84a2df94abfe2a6ec28e24278888e16e2d7d518362520"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r63/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r64"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; ls -la | head -30\",\"description\":\"Check if directory is a git repository\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "docs/decisions/0057-a-shelf-layout-is-the-second-half-of-what-the-identifier-claim-store-covers.md"
result: "sha256:cfaa5e4b4f2a47f737d0bc5c3e55d4ca0018f46ccf225235d8efbfea8a344287"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r65"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r65/docs/\",\"description\":\"List docs directory shelves\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r65/.headwater/ 2>/dev/null; echo ---; ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r65/.headwater/packages 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List .headwater config directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r65/.headwater/packages -maxdepth 3 -type f | head -50\",\"description\":\"List files in headwater-standard package\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r65/docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md\",\"description\":\"Read obligation 0107 referenced by router\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r65/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\",\"description\":\"Read base package taxonomy\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r65/.headwater/overlay.yml\",\"description\":\"Read overlay config\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r65/docs/spec/\",\"description\":\"List spec shelf\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r65/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r65/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"shelves:|path:|identifier:|layout:|kinds\\\\.\\\">\\n<parameter name=\\\"path\\\">/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r65/.headwater/overlay.yml\",\"output_mode\":\"content\",\"-n\":true}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"shelves\\\\|path:\\\\|kind:\\\\|layout:\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r65/.headwater/overlay.yml | head -100\",\"description\":\"Find shelf declarations in overlay\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r65/.headwater -iname \\\"*design-spec*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*bundle*\\\" 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Find design-spec bundle files\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r66"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && git status 2>&1 | head -5\",\"description\":\"Check working directory contents and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r66/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/spec/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r66/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r66/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r66/docs/obligations/0060-the-most-specific-shelf-wins-names-no-order.md"
result: "sha256:bf250948d2966958e7ceb532cc9333e810db6ff64b37c98e264e5be2fb39e926"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r66/docs/decisions/0025-q25-where-the-namespace-goes-in-an-identifier-and-who-declares-it.md"
result: "sha256:4894471729347cedfb96adf9888fd728ae063217b84f028833d1dd70a5051370"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r67"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/spec/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/process/decisions/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/decisions/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r67/docs/decisions/0057-a-shelf-layout-is-the-second-half-of-what-the-identifier-claim-store-covers.md"
result: "sha256:cfaa5e4b4f2a47f737d0bc5c3e55d4ca0018f46ccf225235d8efbfea8a344287"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r67/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r67/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r67/docs/decisions/0025-q25-where-the-namespace-goes-in-an-identifier-and-who-declares-it.md"
result: "sha256:4894471729347cedfb96adf9888fd728ae063217b84f028833d1dd70a5051370"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r68"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r68/docs -maxdepth 1 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level docs shelves\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r68/.headwater -maxdepth 3 | sort\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r68/.headwater/packages -type f | sort; echo ---; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r68/docs/taxonomies -type f | sort; echo ---; ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r68/.headwater/ids\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy package files and id schemes\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r68/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r68/docs/taxonomies/README.md"
result: "sha256:4baa3cc1019fc8ca6365a0e372578a35c66e45e68b99c46f0c033b963f8514f4"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r68/.headwater/overlay.yml\",\"description\":\"Check overlay.yml size\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r68/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r68/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^identifier_schemes:\\\" -A 40 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r68/.headwater/overlay.yml | head -80\",\"description\":\"Show identifier_schemes block in overlay\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r68/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"shelves\\\\.\\\\|path: docs/\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r68/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/design-spec/bundle.yml /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r68/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/decision-record/bundle.yml /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r68/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/evidence-and-obligation/bundle.yml 2>/dev/null\\necho ---\\nsed -n '1,40p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r68/.headwater/overlay.yml\",\"description\":\"Check shelf paths in standard bundles and overlay header\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r69"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"Which shelf under docs/ does a new document belong on, and where does its identifier come from? Need the rules governing shelf selection and identifier schemes (e.g. docs/spec, docs/decisions, docs/obligations, docs/evaluations, docs/how-to, docs/requirements, docs/acceptance-criteria, docs/interfaces, process shelves) and how headwater new mints/claims identifiers.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r69/docs -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List docs subdirectories to see shelf structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r69/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r69/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r69/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r69/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r69/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r7"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls -la | head -30\",\"description\":\"Check if directory is a git repository\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r7/docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r7/docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r7/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r7/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r7/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r70"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r70/ 2>&1 | head -50\",\"description\":\"List top-level contents of working directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git status 2>&1 | head -20; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls -la .git 2>&1 | head -5\",\"description\":\"Check git status and .git directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/ 2>&1; echo \\\"--- spec ---\\\"; ls docs/spec 2>&1; echo \\\"--- decisions ---\\\"; ls docs/decisions 2>&1 | head -20; echo \\\"--- process/decisions ---\\\"; ls docs/process/decisions 2>&1 | head -20; echo \\\"--- .headwater ---\\\"; ls -la .headwater 2>&1; echo \\\"--- .headwater/ids ---\\\"; ls .headwater/ids 2>&1; echo \\\"--- .headwater/packages ---\\\"; ls .headwater/packages 2>&1\",\"description\":\"Survey docs tree and headwater config directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r70/docs/decisions/0057-a-shelf-layout-is-the-second-half-of-what-the-identifier-claim-store-covers.md"
result: "sha256:cfaa5e4b4f2a47f737d0bc5c3e55d4ca0018f46ccf225235d8efbfea8a344287"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r70/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r70/docs/obligations/0060-the-most-specific-shelf-wins-names-no-order.md"
result: "sha256:bf250948d2966958e7ceb532cc9333e810db6ff64b37c98e264e5be2fb39e926"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r70/docs/obligations/0059-kind-resolution-declares-a-fourth-step-that-no-syntax-supports.md"
result: "sha256:cd8954a83cb6f6afeeba68704dc8de32ca20a2e9079830c2454dfed7c94c004c"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r71"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"Decide which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r71/docs -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List docs subdirectories (shelves)\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Find shelf and identifier rules\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"This is the Headwater repository (a documentation-governance system with a CLI called `headwater`, a scaffolder `headwater new`, and a taxonomy engine under `.headwater/`). I need to understand, from the actual repo content (not inference), two things:\\n\\n1. How does this repo decide which \\\"shelf\\\" (docs subdirectory, e.g. docs/spec, docs/decisions, docs/obligations, docs/interfaces, docs/requirements, docs/acceptance-criteria, docs/tutorials, docs/how-to, docs/subsystems, docs/evaluations, docs/explanations, docs/doctrine, docs/reviews, docs/process/*, docs/taxonomies, docs/verifications) a NEW document belongs on, based on its \\\"kind\\\"? Look for where \\\"kind\\\" -> shelf/directory mappings are declared — likely under `.headwater/packages/` (package definitions, maybe YAML) and/or docs/spec files describing the taxonomy/package system (e.g. docs/spec/*.md mentioning \\\"kinds\\\", \\\"shelf\\\", \\\"package\\\"). Also check docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md since it was flagged as relevant — it describes a kind named `kinds.specification` that names no identifier scheme.\\n\\n2. Where does a new document's IDENTIFIER come from? Look for the identifier scheme / allocator mechanism: `.headwater/ids/<scheme>/<identifier>` claim store (mentioned in CLAUDE.md), how `headwater new` picks a scheme per kind, and any decision docs about this (e.g. docs/decisions/0054 about the claim store, docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md). Also check for a numbering convention (e.g. docs/spec files are numbered 05-ai-integration.md, 09-decisions.md, 12-check-layer.md — is that a scheme, or just spec parts?).\\n\\nReport back:\\n- The concrete mechanism/file(s) that map a document's kind to its shelf (directory), with file paths and relevant excerpts or field names.\\n- The concrete mechanism/file(s) that assign an identifier to a new document (per-kind scheme, numbering format, the claim-store path pattern), with file paths and relevant excerpts.\\n- Any explicit command (e.g. `headwater new <kind>`) that performs this, and what inputs/flags it takes.\\n- Note any kinds that are special-cased (like the one in obligation 0107) or any explicit decision records that state the rule for shelf/identifier assignment.\\n\\nKeep the report factual and well-cited with file paths and line numbers. Under 500 words.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r71 -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".headwater/packages/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r71/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r71/docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md"
result: "sha256:b1bc8628c695ce6b58c9cbc67502d3b90e3452fd49aaff3710d485dce45824ac"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r71/.headwater/ids/ 2>/dev/null; echo ---; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r71/.headwater/ids -maxdepth 2 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List identifier scheme directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r71/.headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null | head -150\",\"description\":\"Show overlay.yml defining shelves and schemes for this repo\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/decisions/0054*\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/process/decisions/0024*\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r71/docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r71/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r71/docs/decisions/0054-the-upper-bound-of-a-reconcile-first-allocator-is-the-corpus-and-a-claim-store.md"
result: "sha256:dc39ad3508032fef66f58640206082c0f863a47c2fa2315934079e72223b1eb8"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r71"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"shelves\\\" -r /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r71/.headwater/overlay.yml | head -50\",\"description\":\"Search overlay.yml for shelves declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r71/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r71/engine/crates"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r71/engine/crates/scaffold/src/lib.rs"
result: "sha256:ce9cc34ee18465fbc9d1f85c0b1d8d2ed393edd6460468b52d22f3b98e302bdd"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r71/engine/crates/cli/src/main.rs"
result: "sha256:2782e8cb8ebaadd80d7996ad741b1c82f2ce6f64e41b2ea52590f994939cebae"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r71/engine/crates/cli/src/main.rs"
result: "sha256:2782e8cb8ebaadd80d7996ad741b1c82f2ce6f64e41b2ea52590f994939cebae"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"New {\\\" -A 15 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r71/engine/crates/cli/src/main.rs | head -60\",\"description\":\"Show New command struct definition in CLI\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r72"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo \\\"---\\\" && git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1\",\"description\":\"Check repo structure and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r72/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r72/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r72/docs/decisions/0057-a-shelf-layout-is-the-second-half-of-what-the-identifier-claim-store-covers.md"
result: "sha256:cfaa5e4b4f2a47f737d0bc5c3e55d4ca0018f46ccf225235d8efbfea8a344287"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r72/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r72/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r72/docs/obligations/0060-the-most-specific-shelf-wins-names-no-order.md"
result: "sha256:bf250948d2966958e7ceb532cc9333e810db6ff64b37c98e264e5be2fb39e926"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r72/docs/obligations/0046-the-identifier-scheme-grammar.md"
result: "sha256:37617cf0865ec80e7943e2d86017a51fd4ec46b238c3fdc50d5e12e3ce32e006"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r72/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r73"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r73/\",\"description\":\"List repository root contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r73/docs/\",\"description\":\"List docs/ subdirectories (shelves)\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r73/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r73/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r73/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r73/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r73/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r74"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/ && echo --- && ls docs/spec 2>/dev/null && echo --- && ls docs/process/decisions 2>/dev/null | head -50\",\"description\":\"List docs directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r74/docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r74/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r74/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r74/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r74/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r74/.headwater -maxdepth 3 -type f 2>/dev/null | head -50\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r74/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r74/docs/taxonomies -maxdepth 2 2>/dev/null; echo ---; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r74/.headwater -iname \\\"*.yml\\\" -o -iname \\\"*.yaml\\\" 2>/dev/null | grep -v /ids/; echo ---; cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r74/.headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Find actual taxonomy and overlay files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r74/.headwater -maxdepth 2 -not -path \\\"*/ids/*\\\" ; echo ---PACKAGES---; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r74/.headwater/packages -maxdepth 2 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List top-level .headwater contents excluding ids\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r74/.headwater/README.md"
result: "sha256:1f1d423f8dcfa91a568a77f9a4ef0ad43c6d61075a6e9736c5e10a8235cb1dd6"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r74/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r74/docs/taxonomies/design-spec -maxdepth 2\",\"description\":\"List design-spec taxonomy entry files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r74/docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md"
result: "sha256:485fe85764154ebfd53b4e549e14fb453931eb09bef862591234f134d90c59b1"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r74/docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md"
result: "sha256:b1bc8628c695ce6b58c9cbc67502d3b90e3452fd49aaff3710d485dce45824ac"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r75"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Research shelf and identifier conventions\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"I'm working in the Headwater repository at /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r75 (this is the correct working directory — treat it as the repo root even though it's not a git repo in this sandbox).\\n\\nI need to understand the repository's rules for two things, so I can explain them to the user:\\n\\n1. **Which \\\"shelf\\\" (top-level directory under docs/) a new document belongs on.** The repo has directories like docs/spec/, docs/subsystems/, docs/decisions/, docs/evaluations/, docs/obligations/, docs/interfaces/, docs/requirements/, docs/acceptance-criteria/, docs/tutorials/, docs/how-to/, docs/process/ (with docs/process/decisions/ as a sub-shelf), docs/reviews/, docs/taxonomies/. I need to know: what document \\\"kind\\\" goes on each shelf, and what's the actual decision rule for picking a shelf for a new document (is there a document — e.g. in docs/spec/, docs/decisions/, or docs/process/decisions/ — that states the rule explicitly, such as \\\"a specification goes here, an obligation goes there, a decision record goes there\\\")? Look especially for documents about the \\\"kinds\\\" system (kinds.specification, kinds.decision, kinds.obligation, kinds.evaluation, etc.) — docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md looked relevant in a routing hint. Also check whatever defines `headwater new <kind>` — is there a spec page or package file enumerating kinds and their shelf/path?\\n\\n2. **Where a new document's identifier comes from.** The repo has an \\\"identifier claim store\\\" at .headwater/ids/<scheme>/<identifier> (per HW-DR-0054, docs/decisions/0054-the-upper-bound-of-a-reconcile-first-allocator-is-the-corpus-and-a-claim-store.md). I need to know: what are the different identifier schemes (e.g. HW-PD-####, HW-DR-####, plain numeric prefixes like \\\"0107-\\\", \\\"0024-\\\" used in filenames)? Which kind uses which scheme? Is scheme tied to shelf, or to kind, or something else? Is there a rule about scanning branches for the highest identifier in use before minting? Also check docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md for what it says about identifier schemes binding kinds across product vs process shelves.\\n\\nPlease read the actual files (don't just guess from filenames) — docs/spec/ (especially any page on kinds, document types, or the taxonomy/package system), docs/decisions/0054-*.md, docs/process/decisions/0024-*.md, docs/obligations/0107-*.md, and any docs/taxonomies/ or .headwater/packages/ files that define the \\\"kinds\\\" (kinds.specification, kinds.decision, etc.) and their id schemes. Also check if there's a single canonical table or page listing all kinds with their shelf and id scheme (search for \\\"shelf\\\" and \\\"scheme\\\" across docs/ and .headwater/).\\n\\nReport back: (a) a list/table of kind → shelf → identifier scheme, as explicitly stated in the docs, with file citations; (b) the actual decision procedure for picking a shelf for a new document type (what question does an author ask); (c) the actual procedure for how an identifier is minted/claimed. Be precise about what's explicitly stated vs. what you're inferring. Keep the report well under 500 words, but include file:line citations for key claims.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find docs/spec -type f | head -100\",\"description\":\"List files under docs/spec\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "ScheduleWakeup"
argument: "{\"delaySeconds\":180,\"noop\":true,\"reason\":\"waiting on Explore agent researching shelf/identifier docs\",\"prompt\":\"Check if the Explore agent researching shelf/identifier conventions has finished; if so, synthesize its findings into an answer for the user about which shelf a new document belongs on and where its identifier comes from.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater -maxdepth 4 -type d\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory structure\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r75/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r75/docs/decisions/0054-the-upper-bound-of-a-reconcile-first-allocator-is-the-corpus-and-a-claim-store.md"
result: "sha256:dc39ad3508032fef66f58640206082c0f863a47c2fa2315934079e72223b1eb8"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r75/docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md"
result: "sha256:485fe85764154ebfd53b4e549e14fb453931eb09bef862591234f134d90c59b1"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r75/docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md"
result: "sha256:b1bc8628c695ce6b58c9cbc67502d3b90e3452fd49aaff3710d485dce45824ac"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r75/.headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null | head -400\",\"description\":\"Show overlay.yml defining kinds/shelves/schemes for this repo\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r75/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r75/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r75/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^ shelves\\\\.\\\" -A3 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r75/.headwater/overlay.yml\",\"description\":\"List shelves declared in overlay.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r75/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r75/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r75/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md\",\"description\":\"Check line counts of spec files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"identifier:\\\\|scheme:\\\\|^ kinds\\\\.\\\\|shelf\\\\|^kinds:\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r75/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/evidence-and-obligation/*.yml 2>/dev/null | head -60\\necho ---\\nfind /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r75/.headwater/packages -iname \\\"*.yml\\\" | xargs ls\",\"description\":\"Search obligation/evidence bundle for identifier schemes and shelves\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"kinds\\\\.\\\\|identifier:\\\\|scheme\\\\|shelves\\\\.\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r75/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -100\",\"description\":\"Search base taxonomy.yml for kinds/shelves/schemes\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r75/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard\\nfor f in bundles/*/bundle.yml; do\\n echo \\\"=== $f ===\\\"\\n grep -n \\\"identifier_schemes\\\\.\\\\|identifier: {scheme\\\\|shelves\\\\.\\\\|^ kinds\\\\.\\\" \\\"$f\\\"\\ndone\",\"description\":\"Search all bundle files for identifier schemes, shelves, kinds\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r76"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/spec/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/**/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r76/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r76/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".headwater/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/process/**/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".headwater/*.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".headwater/packages/**/*.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r76/docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md"
result: "sha256:485fe85764154ebfd53b4e549e14fb453931eb09bef862591234f134d90c59b1"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r76/docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md"
result: "sha256:b1bc8628c695ce6b58c9cbc67502d3b90e3452fd49aaff3710d485dce45824ac"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r76/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r76/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/requirements/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/acceptance-criteria/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/reviews/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r76/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r76/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r76/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r77"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && ls -la | head -30 && git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1\",\"description\":\"Check working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r77/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r77/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r77/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r77/docs/obligations/0060-the-most-specific-shelf-wins-names-no-order.md"
result: "sha256:bf250948d2966958e7ceb532cc9333e810db6ff64b37c98e264e5be2fb39e926"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r77/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r78"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r78/\",\"description\":\"List repo root contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r78/docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md"
result: "sha256:b1bc8628c695ce6b58c9cbc67502d3b90e3452fd49aaff3710d485dce45824ac"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r78/.headwater"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r78/docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r78/.claude/skills -maxdepth 2 -iname \\\"*orient*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*authoring*\\\" 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Find orient/authoring skill files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r78/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r78/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r78/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r78/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r78/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"awk '/^shelves:/,/^kinds:/' .headwater/overlay.yml | head -150\",\"description\":\"Show shelves section of overlay.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && ls .headwater 2>/dev/null || ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r78/.headwater\",\"description\":\"Check current directory and .headwater presence\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r78/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r78/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r78/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r78/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r78/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r78/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/design-spec/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:8e8b03d0d2e6bf2044c68d86e327887e851cb0736a9b642a89205358062669ff"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r78/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/evidence-and-obligation/bundle.yml"
result: "sha256:fd65c2f4a94d4f0a6d38ea74d4700f9439c36a6bcc407a30061ff4002d2b81f8"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,90p' .headwater/overlay.yml\",\"description\":\"Show top of overlay.yml for context around shelf design-spec/evaluation/obligation\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r78/.headwater"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r78/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r79"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git status 2>&1 | head -20 && echo \\\"---\\\" && ls -la | head -30\",\"description\":\"Check if directory is a git repository\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la .claude/skills/ 2>&1; echo \\\"---\\\"; find .claude/skills -maxdepth 1 -type d 2>&1\",\"description\":\"List available skill directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls .claude/ 2>&1; echo \\\"---agents---\\\"; ls .claude/agents 2>&1; echo \\\"---commands---\\\"; ls .claude/commands 2>&1\",\"description\":\"Check claude directory contents for agents and commands\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Research shelf and identifier rules in docs\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"I need to answer the question \\\"Decide which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from\\\" for the Headwater repository at /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r79.\\n\\nThis is a documentation-governance question about this repo's own conventions (not about writing a specific document yet — just understanding the decision framework). I need you to find and summarize:\\n\\n1. What are the \\\"shelves\\\" under docs/ — i.e., the different document kinds/directories (docs/spec/, docs/subsystems/, docs/decisions/, docs/evaluations/, docs/obligations/, docs/interfaces/, docs/requirements/, docs/acceptance-criteria/, docs/tutorials/, docs/how-to/, docs/process/, docs/reviews/, docs/taxonomies/, etc.) and what distinguishes each one — what kind of content goes on each shelf. Look for a central document (likely in docs/spec/ or docs/obligations/ or a taxonomy file) that defines \\\"kinds\\\" of documents and maps them to shelves/directories.\\n\\n2. How a new document gets its identifier — look for the `headwater new` command / scaffolder behavior, the identifier claim store at `.headwater/ids/<scheme>/<identifier>`, and how identifier \\\"schemes\\\" are tied to document kinds. Look at docs/decisions/0054-the-upper-bound-of-a-reconcile-first-allocator-is-the-corpus-and-a-claim-store.md and docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md (already pointed to by the routing hook) plus any spec document describing `headwater new` and identifier schemes (check docs/spec/ for a doc about authoring/scaffolding or identifiers).\\n\\n3. Look at .headwater/packages/ or taxonomy-source/ for the actual \\\"kinds\\\" taxonomy definitions (YAML or similar) that bind each document kind to a directory/shelf and an identifier scheme.\\n\\nReport back concisely: (a) the list of shelves and what belongs on each, (b) the mechanism/rule for how a document kind maps to an identifier scheme and how `headwater new` picks/mints the identifier, (c) file paths and line numbers for the key authoritative passages so I can cite them. Keep the report under 500 words, factual, with citations like path:line.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r79/docs -maxdepth 1 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level docs shelves\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r79/.headwater -maxdepth 3 | sort\",\"description\":\"List .headwater directory contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r79\\nfind . -iname \\\"*taxonomy-source*\\\" -o -path \\\"*packages*kind*\\\" 2>/dev/null | grep -v '.git' | head -50\\necho \\\"---taxonomies dir---\\\"\\nls docs/taxonomies\\necho \\\"---packages---\\\"\\nfind .headwater/packages -maxdepth 2 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Find taxonomy source files and packages dir\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r79\\necho \\\"=== taxonomy.yml ===\\\"\\ncat .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml\\n\",\"description\":\"Show taxonomy.yml content\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r79\\ngrep -n \\\"^kind:\\\\|^ directory:\\\\|^ identifier:\\\\|^ scheme:\\\\|identifier_scheme\\\\|^kinds:\\\\|^- kind:\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -100\",\"description\":\"Grep taxonomy.yml for kind/directory/identifier mapping\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r79/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r79\\nfind . -maxdepth 1 -iname \\\"*.yml\\\" -o -maxdepth 1 -iname \\\".headwater.yml\\\" 2>/dev/null\\nfind . -iname \\\"taxonomy.yml\\\" -not -path \\\"*/.headwater/packages/*\\\" 2>/dev/null\\nls -la .headwater | head -30\\nfind . -iname \\\"*.yml\\\" -path \\\"*headwater*\\\" -not -path \\\"*/.headwater/packages/*\\\" -not -path \\\"*/.headwater/ids/*\\\" 2>/dev/null | head -30\",\"description\":\"Find the repo's own taxonomy overlay file\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r79/.headwater/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:0aa1b806b4bc44af26c12dc624643169bddb3583054e78db3873c23ca8e4bb12"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r79\\ngrep -n \\\"^kinds:\\\\|^shelves:\\\\|^identifier_schemes:\\\\|^ [a-z_]*:$\\\" .headwater/overlay.yml | head -120\",\"description\":\"Find top-level keys and kind/shelf blocks in overlay.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r79\\ngrep -n \\\"^kinds:\\\\|^shelves:\\\" .headwater/overlay.yml\\necho \\\"---\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"path: docs/\\\" .headwater/overlay.yml | head -40\",\"description\":\"Find kinds/shelves sections and shelf path mappings in overlay.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r79/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r79\\necho \\\"=== kinds.* entries ===\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"^ kinds\\\\.\\\\|^kinds\\\\.\\\\| [a-z_]*:$\\\" .headwater/overlay.yml | grep -i \\\"kinds\\\\.\\\" \\necho \\\"=== shelves.* entries with kind: ===\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"^ shelves\\\\.\\\" .headwater/overlay.yml\\necho \\\"=== identifier schemes ===\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"identifier_schemes\\\\|identifier: {scheme\\\" .headwater/overlay.yml\",\"description\":\"Grep for kinds, shelves, identifier scheme entries\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r79\\ngrep -rn \\\"^ shelves\\\\.\\\\|path: docs/decisions\\\\|path: docs/obligations\\\\|path: docs/spec\\\\|path: docs/evaluations\\\\|path: docs/reviews\\\" docs/taxonomies/decision-record docs/taxonomies/evidence-and-obligation docs/taxonomies/design-spec 2>/dev/null | grep -v fixtures\",\"description\":\"Find shelf definitions for decisions/obligations/spec/evaluations/reviews in bundles\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r79\\necho \\\"=== decision-record bundle ===\\\"\\nsed -n '1,30p;120,170p' docs/taxonomies/decision-record/bundle.yml\\necho \\\"=== evidence-and-obligation bundle ===\\\"\\nsed -n '80,115p' docs/taxonomies/evidence-and-obligation/bundle.yml\\necho \\\"=== design-spec bundle ===\\\"\\nsed -n '140,175p' docs/taxonomies/design-spec/bundle.yml\",\"description\":\"Read shelf/kind sections of three bundle taxonomy files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r79\\necho \\\"=== 0054 ===\\\"\\nsed -n '1,80p' docs/decisions/0054-the-upper-bound-of-a-reconcile-first-allocator-is-the-corpus-and-a-claim-store.md\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r79\\ngrep -rln \\\"headwater new\\\" docs/spec | head -10\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r79\\ngrep -n \\\"^#\\\\|headwater new\\\\|shelf\\\\|identifier\\\" docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md | head -80\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r79\\nsed -n '124,140p' docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r8"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la | head -30 && echo --- && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check if directory is a git repo\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/spec/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/\",\"description\":\"List top-level docs shelves\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r8/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r8/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"for f in docs/*/README.md; do echo \\\"== $f ==\\\"; head -c 400 \\\"$f\\\"; echo; echo; done 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Show first lines of each docs shelf README for purpose descriptions\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r8/docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md"
result: "sha256:485fe85764154ebfd53b4e549e14fb453931eb09bef862591234f134d90c59b1"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/decisions/0093-the-live-account-of-a-domain-is-its-own-kind-split-on-the-product-and-process-line-and-it-draws-on-the-records-it-cites.md"
result: "sha256:eee01e2fdfbfbe24bc6297b85988b164b12deeb3a17d841a715f5c3864e9717e"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r80"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; ls -la\",\"description\":\"Check if directory is a git repo and list contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls .headwater/\",\"description\":\"List docs/ shelves and .headwater/ contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r80/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat .headwater/taxonomy.yml 2>/dev/null | head -100\",\"description\":\"Show top-level taxonomy declaration\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls .headwater/packages/; echo ---; find .headwater/packages -iname \\\"*.yml\\\" | xargs grep -l \\\"shelf\\\\|layout\\\\|scheme\\\" 2>/dev/null | head -20\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy packages and find shelf/scheme declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/design-spec/bundle.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/evidence-and-obligation/bundle.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/decision-record/bundle.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | grep -n \\\"^shelves\\\\.\\\\|^identifier_schemes\\\\.\\\\|path:\\\\|pattern:\\\\|kind:\\\\|kinds:\\\\|layout:\\\" \"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat .headwater/overlay.yml | head -80\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r81"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls -la | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check if directory is a git repository\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find docs -maxdepth 1 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level docs shelves\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r81/docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md"
result: "sha256:485fe85764154ebfd53b4e549e14fb453931eb09bef862591234f134d90c59b1"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r81/docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r81/.headwater"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r81/docs/taxonomies -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy docs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r81/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r81/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r81/docs/taxonomies/README.md"
result: "sha256:4baa3cc1019fc8ca6365a0e372578a35c66e45e68b99c46f0c033b963f8514f4"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r81/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r81/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r82"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r82\",\"description\":\"List top-level repo contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".headwater/packages/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r82/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r82/docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r82/.headwater/overlay.yml\",\"description\":\"Show repo's taxonomy overlay\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n -A2 \\\"^\\\\s*shelves\\\\.\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/config/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r82/projects/-var-tmp-hw-1659-b-ws-L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r82/4e1c58be-897c-47e2-bdb1-384c30142750/tool-results/bcnw4doig.txt | head -150\\necho \\\"---SCHEMES---\\\"\\ngrep -n -B1 -A3 \\\"identifier_schemes\\\\.\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/config/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r82/projects/-var-tmp-hw-1659-b-ws-L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r82/4e1c58be-897c-47e2-bdb1-384c30142750/tool-results/bcnw4doig.txt | head -150\",\"description\":\"Search overlay file for shelf and identifier scheme declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"F=/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/config/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r82/projects/-var-tmp-hw-1659-b-ws-L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r82/4e1c58be-897c-47e2-bdb1-384c30142750/tool-results/bcnw4doig.txt\\ngrep -n -A3 \\\"^\\\\s*shelves\\\\.\\\\(decisions\\\\|obligations\\\\|specifications\\\\|evaluations\\\\)\\\" \\\"$F\\\"\\necho \\\"---\\\"\\ngrep -n \\\"kind: \\\" \\\"$F\\\" | head -60\",\"description\":\"Check base shelves and kind mappings in overlay\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r82\\necho \\\"=== decision-record bundle ===\\\"\\ngrep -n -A3 \\\"shelves\\\\.\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/decision-record/bundle.yml\\necho \\\"=== evidence-and-obligation bundle ===\\\"\\ngrep -n -A3 \\\"shelves\\\\.\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/evidence-and-obligation/bundle.yml\\necho \\\"=== design-spec bundle ===\\\"\\ngrep -n -A3 \\\"shelves\\\\.\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/design-spec/bundle.yml\\necho \\\"=== standards-spec bundle ===\\\"\\ngrep -n -A3 \\\"shelves\\\\.\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/standards-spec/bundle.yml\\necho \\\"=== diataxis-site bundle ===\\\"\\ngrep -n -A3 \\\"shelves\\\\.\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/diataxis-site/bundle.yml\\necho \\\"=== identifier schemes in bundles ===\\\"\\ngrep -n -A3 \\\"identifier_schemes\\\\.\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/*/bundle.yml\",\"description\":\"Check bundle-level shelf and identifier scheme declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r82\\ngrep -n -B1 \\\"write_when:\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/*.yml .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/*/bundle.yml .headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List every kind's write_when sentence across taxonomy sources\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r82\\necho \\\"=== design-spec kinds block ===\\\"\\nsed -n '1,170p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/design-spec/bundle.yml\\necho \\\"=== design-spec identifier_schemes ===\\\"\\ngrep -n -A4 \\\"identifier_schemes\\\\.\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/design-spec/bundle.yml\\necho \\\"=== decision-record kinds ===\\\"\\nsed -n '1,170p' .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/decision-record/bundle.yml | grep -n -B3 -A2 \\\"identifier:\\\"\",\"description\":\"Inspect design-spec and decision-record bundle kind/identifier declarations\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r83"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Research shelf and identifier rules for new docs\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"I need to understand, in this Headwater repository, the rules for (1) deciding which \\\"shelf\\\" (top-level docs/ subdirectory, e.g. docs/spec, docs/obligations, docs/decisions, docs/process/decisions, docs/requirements, docs/evaluations, docs/interfaces, docs/acceptance-criteria, docs/tutorials, docs/how-to, docs/subsystems) a new document belongs on, and (2) where that document's identifier (like \\\"0107\\\" in docs/obligations/0107-...md, or \\\"HW-DR-0054\\\", \\\"HW-PD-0001\\\") comes from — i.e. the identifier scheme/allocation mechanism.\\n\\nPlease research and report back:\\n1. Is there a taxonomy or kinds definition file (likely under .headwater/packages/ or docs/taxonomies/) that lists each \\\"kind\\\" of document, which shelf/directory it lives under, and what identifier scheme it uses (e.g. plain numeric, HW-DR-, HW-PD-)?\\n2. How does `headwater new` decide shelf placement for a new document — is there a command reference or spec section describing the kind -> shelf mapping?\\n3. How are identifiers allocated — is it from the \\\"identifier claim store\\\" at .headwater/ids/<scheme>/<identifier> described in CLAUDE.md? Find the decision doc HW-DR-0054 (docs/decisions/0054-...) that explains this, and read it.\\n4. Is there a specific rule distinguishing \\\"product shelves\\\" (spec, requirements, evaluations, obligations, interfaces, acceptance-criteria, decisions, tutorials, how-to, subsystems) vs \\\"process shelves\\\" (docs/process/decisions etc.) — look at docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md.\\n5. Look for docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md since it was flagged as highly relevant — it mentions \\\"kinds.specification names no identifier scheme and four relations may name a document of it\\\".\\n6. Check DEVELOPING.md and docs/spec/ (look at a table of contents like docs/spec/00-*.md or similar) for an overview of all shelves/kinds.\\n\\nReport concrete file paths, the kind->shelf->identifier-scheme mapping if you find one, and quote the key decisive sentences (with file:line) that establish the rule for shelf selection and identifier sourcing. Keep the report organized and under 600 words, but include exact quotes for the load-bearing rules.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls && echo --- && find . -maxdepth 3 -iname \\\"*taxonom*\\\" 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"**/CLAUDE.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"**/kinds*.yaml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/decisions/0054-*\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/obligations/0107-*\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r83/docs/decisions/0054-the-upper-bound-of-a-reconcile-first-allocator-is-the-corpus-and-a-claim-store.md"
result: "sha256:dc39ad3508032fef66f58640206082c0f863a47c2fa2315934079e72223b1eb8"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r83/docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md"
result: "sha256:b1bc8628c695ce6b58c9cbc67502d3b90e3452fd49aaff3710d485dce45824ac"
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/process/decisions/0024-*\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".headwater/packages/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"shelf\\\\|identifier scheme\\\\|ids/\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r83/CLAUDE.md | head -80\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r83/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r83/docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md"
result: "sha256:485fe85764154ebfd53b4e549e14fb453931eb09bef862591234f134d90c59b1"
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/spec/0*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^shelves:\\\\|^ [a-z_-]*:.*path:\\\\|identifier_schemes:\\\\|^kinds:\\\" .headwater/overlay.yml | head -100\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r83/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l .headwater/overlay.yml; grep -n \\\"^ [a-zA-Z_]*:\\\\|path:\\\\|identifier:\\\\|scheme:\\\" .headwater/overlay.yml | sed -n '1,200p'\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"obligation_record_id\\\\|decision_id\\\\|shelves:\\\\|docs/obligations\\\\|docs/decisions\\\\|docs/evaluations\\\" .headwater/overlay.yml | head -40\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r84"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r84/docs/\",\"description\":\"List docs directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r84/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r84/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r84/docs/decisions/0057-a-shelf-layout-is-the-second-half-of-what-the-identifier-claim-store-covers.md"
result: "sha256:cfaa5e4b4f2a47f737d0bc5c3e55d4ca0018f46ccf225235d8efbfea8a344287"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r84/docs/decisions/0025-q25-where-the-namespace-goes-in-an-identifier-and-who-declares-it.md"
result: "sha256:4894471729347cedfb96adf9888fd728ae063217b84f028833d1dd70a5051370"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r84/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r84/docs/obligations/0060-the-most-specific-shelf-wins-names-no-order.md"
result: "sha256:bf250948d2966958e7ceb532cc9333e810db6ff64b37c98e264e5be2fb39e926"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r85"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/**/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r85/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r85/docs/decisions/0057-a-shelf-layout-is-the-second-half-of-what-the-identifier-claim-store-covers.md"
result: "sha256:cfaa5e4b4f2a47f737d0bc5c3e55d4ca0018f46ccf225235d8efbfea8a344287"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r85/docs/decisions/0025-q25-where-the-namespace-goes-in-an-identifier-and-who-declares-it.md"
result: "sha256:4894471729347cedfb96adf9888fd728ae063217b84f028833d1dd70a5051370"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r85/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r85/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r86"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; ls -la | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check if directory is a git repository\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .claude -maxdepth 3 -iname \\\"*skill*\\\" 2>&1; echo \\\"---\\\"; find . -maxdepth 2 -iname \\\"SKILL.md\\\" 2>&1; echo \\\"---list skills dir---\\\"; ls -la .claude/skills 2>&1\",\"description\":\"Look for skill definitions in .claude directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rl \\\"shelf\\\" docs --include=\\\"*.md\\\" | head -30\",\"description\":\"Find docs mentioning shelf\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/ ; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls .headwater/packages 2>&1; echo \\\"---base pkg---\\\"; find .headwater -iname \\\"*.yml\\\" -path \\\"*base*\\\" | head; echo \\\"---kinds---\\\"; grep -rl \\\"kinds\\\\.\\\" .headwater 2>/dev/null | head -5\",\"description\":\"List docs shelves and headwater package files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r86/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r87"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; ls -la | head -30\",\"description\":\"Check if directory is a git repo\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/\",\"description\":\"List docs directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/spec/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r87/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/taxonomies/ 2>/dev/null; echo ---; ls .headwater/packages/ 2>/dev/null; echo ---; find . -iname \\\"*.yml\\\" -path \\\"*taxonom*\\\" 2>/dev/null | head -20\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy-related directories\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r87/.headwater/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:0aa1b806b4bc44af26c12dc624643169bddb3583054e78db3873c23ca8e4bb12"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r87/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/taxonomies"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r87/docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md"
result: "sha256:485fe85764154ebfd53b4e549e14fb453931eb09bef862591234f134d90c59b1"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r88"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && git status 2>&1 | head -5\",\"description\":\"Check working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/\",\"description\":\"List top-level docs shelves\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r88/docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md"
result: "sha256:b1bc8628c695ce6b58c9cbc67502d3b90e3452fd49aaff3710d485dce45824ac"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/spec/ | head -30 && echo --- && ls docs/process/decisions | head -30\",\"description\":\"List spec and process decisions docs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rl \\\"shelf\\\" docs/spec docs/process/decisions docs/doctrine 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Find docs mentioning shelf\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r88/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r88/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r88/docs/process/decisions/0024-a-document-that-moves-to-a-process-shelf-keeps-its-identifier.md"
result: "sha256:485fe85764154ebfd53b4e549e14fb453931eb09bef862591234f134d90c59b1"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater -iname \\\"*.yml\\\" | xargs grep -l \\\"shelves\\\\|identifier_schemes\\\" 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Find taxonomy yml files declaring shelves and identifier schemes\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^shelves:\\\\|^ [a-z_-]*:$\\\\|path:\\\\|kind:\\\\|kinds:\\\\|discriminator:\\\\|identifier:\\\" .headwater/overlay.yml | sed -n '1,200p'\",\"description\":\"Extract shelf declarations from overlay.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^identifier_schemes:\\\" -A 60 .headwater/overlay.yml | head -100\",\"description\":\"Extract identifier scheme declarations from overlay.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"namespace\\\\|pattern:\\\" .headwater/overlay.yml | head -30\",\"description\":\"Check namespace and pattern declarations\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r89"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r89/ | head -50\",\"description\":\"List top-level repo contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r89/docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r89/docs/process"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r89/docs/\",\"description\":\"List docs top-level shelves\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r89/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r89/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r89/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r89/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r89/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r89/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r9"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls -la\",\"description\":\"Check whether current directory is a git repository\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .claude -maxdepth 2 -iname \\\"settings*.json\\\" -o -iname \\\"*.json\\\" 2>/dev/null | grep -i settings; echo \\\"---\\\"; cat .claude/settings.json 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---local---\\\"; cat .claude/settings.local.json 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Check Claude settings for worktree hooks configuration\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Agent"
argument: "{\"description\":\"Find shelf and identifier rules in docs\",\"subagent_type\":\"Explore\",\"prompt\":\"In this repository (a documentation/governance system called Headwater, root at /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r9), I need to find where the rules live for:\\n\\n1. Which \\\"shelf\\\" (top-level directory under docs/, e.g. docs/spec/, docs/subsystems/, docs/decisions/, docs/evaluations/, docs/obligations/, docs/interfaces/, docs/requirements/, docs/acceptance-criteria/, docs/tutorials/, docs/how-to/, docs/process/*) a new document should be placed on — i.e. what distinguishes each shelf/kind, and the decision procedure for picking one for a new document.\\n2. Where a new document's identifier (the numeric/scheme prefix like \\\"0107-\\\" or \\\"0024-\\\") comes from — how `headwater new` mints it, what scheme each kind uses, and the role of the claim store at `.headwater/ids/<scheme>/<identifier>`.\\n\\nLook especially at:\\n- docs/spec/ (there should be parts about document kinds, the taxonomy, and the `headwater new` scaffolder — e.g. files like \\\"04-*\\\", \\\"05-ai-integration.md\\\", or similarly named spec parts)\\n- docs/decisions/ and docs/process/decisions/ for any decision record about shelf selection or identifier schemes (e.g. HW-DR-0054 about the claim store, mentioned in CLAUDE.md)\\n- docs/obligations/0107-*.md (mentioned in CLAUDE.md as being about the base package, kinds.specification, and the scaffolder)\\n- Any top-level README or index under docs/ that lists the shelves\\n- .headwater/packages/ or .headwater/overlay.yml or taxonomy-source/ for the taxonomy definition of \\\"kinds\\\" and their identifier schemes\\n- .claude/skills/headwater-orient or .claude/skills/headwater-authoring if they exist as files (even though not loaded as tools this session) — read their SKILL.md content for the procedure they'd teach\\n- DEVELOPING.md section(s) about shelves, kinds, or the identifier claim store\\n\\nFor each thing you find, report: the file path, and a concise quote/paraphrase of the actual rule (not your own guess). I want the decision procedure for (1) shelf selection and (2) identifier sourcing, grounded in exact doc content with file paths. Keep your final report under 500 words, organized as: shelves (what distinguishes each, how to pick), then identifiers (scheme per kind, how headwater new mints one, the claim-store mechanics).\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/ && echo \\\"---spec---\\\" && ls docs/spec/ && echo \\\"---decisions---\\\" && ls docs/decisions/ 2>/dev/null | head -50 && echo \\\"---process/decisions---\\\" && ls docs/process/decisions/ 2>/dev/null | head -50 && echo \\\"---obligations---\\\" && ls docs/obligations/ | grep -i 0107\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find . -maxdepth 1 -iname \\\"DEVELOPING.md\\\" -o -iname \\\"CLAUDE.md\\\" | head; echo \\\"---\\\"; find .headwater -maxdepth 4 -type d 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---claude skills---\\\"; find .claude/skills -iname \\\"SKILL.md\\\" 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"HW-DR-0054\\\\|0054\\\" docs/decisions/ 2>/dev/null | head -20; echo \\\"---search claim store---\\\"; grep -rln \\\"claim store\\\\|\\\\.headwater/ids\\\" docs/ 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---taxonomy-source---\\\"; find . -iname \\\"taxonomy-source*\\\" -o -iname \\\"overlay.yml\\\" 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r9/docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md"
result: "sha256:b1bc8628c695ce6b58c9cbc67502d3b90e3452fd49aaff3710d485dce45824ac"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r9/docs/decisions/0054-the-upper-bound-of-a-reconcile-first-allocator-is-the-corpus-and-a-claim-store.md"
result: "sha256:dc39ad3508032fef66f58640206082c0f863a47c2fa2315934079e72223b1eb8"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r9/docs/decisions/0057-a-shelf-layout-is-the-second-half-of-what-the-identifier-claim-store-covers.md"
result: "sha256:cfaa5e4b4f2a47f737d0bc5c3e55d4ca0018f46ccf225235d8efbfea8a344287"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r9/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r9/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r9/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r9/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"shelf\\\\|shelves\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r9/CLAUDE.md | head -40\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r9/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,120p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r9/CLAUDE.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r9/.claude/skills -maxdepth 3 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---\\\"; grep -n \\\"shelf\\\\|identifier\\\\|claim store\\\\|kinds\\\\.\\\" /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r9/DEVELOPING.md | head -60\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r9/.headwater/overlay.yml | head -150\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r9/.headwater/packages -iname \\\"bundle.yml\\\" | xargs grep -l \\\"shelves\\\" ; echo \\\"---\\\"; grep -rn \\\"shelves:\\\" -A 15 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r9/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/bundles/*/bundle.yml 2>/dev/null | head -150\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"shelves\\\" -A 10 /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r9/.headwater/taxonomy.lock | head -200\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '960,1120p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r9/.headwater/taxonomy.lock\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1120,1160p' /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r9/.headwater/taxonomy.lock\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r90"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls -la\",\"description\":\"Check whether directory is a git repository\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat .claude/settings.json 2>/dev/null | head -100\",\"description\":\"Check Claude settings for worktree hooks\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/\",\"description\":\"List top-level docs shelves\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/spec/\",\"description\":\"List spec documents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r90/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/taxonomies/; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls taxonomy-source/ 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---overlay---\\\"; cat .headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null | head -80\",\"description\":\"List taxonomy docs and overlay config\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r90/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater -maxdepth 2 -type f | head -50\",\"description\":\"List files under .headwater\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: ".headwater/taxonomy.lock"
result: "sha256:1ea570f4a22e19db2ed394a89bbb5f47f2908847514bb3417fd7a88820333650"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r90/.headwater/taxonomy.lock"
result: "sha256:1ea570f4a22e19db2ed394a89bbb5f47f2908847514bb3417fd7a88820333650"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r90/.headwater/taxonomy.lock"
result: "sha256:1ea570f4a22e19db2ed394a89bbb5f47f2908847514bb3417fd7a88820333650"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r91"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo \\\"---git---\\\" && git status 2>&1 | head -20\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat .claude/settings.json 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---\\\"; find .claude -maxdepth 2 -iname \\\"*settings*\\\" 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find docs -maxdepth 1 -type d | sort\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r91/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r91/docs/decisions/0057-a-shelf-layout-is-the-second-half-of-what-the-identifier-claim-store-covers.md"
result: "sha256:cfaa5e4b4f2a47f737d0bc5c3e55d4ca0018f46ccf225235d8efbfea8a344287"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r91/docs/obligations/0060-the-most-specific-shelf-wins-names-no-order.md"
result: "sha256:bf250948d2966958e7ceb532cc9333e810db6ff64b37c98e264e5be2fb39e926"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r91/docs/obligations/0059-kind-resolution-declares-a-fourth-step-that-no-syntax-supports.md"
result: "sha256:cd8954a83cb6f6afeeba68704dc8de32ca20a2e9079830c2454dfed7c94c004c"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r91/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r91/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r91/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r91/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r92"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r92/ && echo --- && ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r92/docs 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"List repo root and docs directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r92/.claude -maxdepth 3 -iname \\\"*skill*\\\" ; echo ---; ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r92/.claude\",\"description\":\"Look for skill definitions under .claude directory\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r92/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r92/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r92/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r92/docs/decisions/0057-a-shelf-layout-is-the-second-half-of-what-the-identifier-claim-store-covers.md"
result: "sha256:cfaa5e4b4f2a47f737d0bc5c3e55d4ca0018f46ccf225235d8efbfea8a344287"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r92/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r92/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r93"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; ls -la\",\"description\":\"Check whether current directory is a git repository\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la .git 2>&1; echo \\\"---\\\"; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b -maxdepth 4 -name \\\".git\\\" 2>&1; echo \\\"---settings---\\\"; cat .claude/settings.json 2>/dev/null | head -100\",\"description\":\"Check for .git directory and worktree hooks configuration\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/\",\"description\":\"List top-level docs/ shelves\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r93/docs/decisions/0057-a-shelf-layout-is-the-second-half-of-what-the-identifier-claim-store-covers.md"
result: "sha256:cfaa5e4b4f2a47f737d0bc5c3e55d4ca0018f46ccf225235d8efbfea8a344287"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r93/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r93/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r93/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r93/docs/obligations/0046-the-identifier-scheme-grammar.md"
result: "sha256:37617cf0865ec80e7943e2d86017a51fd4ec46b238c3fdc50d5e12e3ce32e006"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r93/docs/obligations/0107-the-base-package-ships-a-kind-that-the-scaffolder-refuses-to-write.md"
result: "sha256:b1bc8628c695ce6b58c9cbc67502d3b90e3452fd49aaff3710d485dce45824ac"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r94"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r94\",\"description\":\"List repository root contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/spec/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r94/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r94/docs\",\"description\":\"List docs directory shelves\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r94/taxonomy-source; echo ---; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r94/taxonomy-source -maxdepth 3 -type f | head -80\",\"description\":\"Explore taxonomy-source directory for kind/shelf declarations\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r94/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r94/.headwater -maxdepth 2 2>/dev/null; echo ---overlay---; find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r94 -iname \\\"overlay.yml\\\" 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Locate .headwater directory and overlay file\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r94/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"python3 - <<'EOF'\\nimport re\\ntext = open('.headwater/taxonomy.lock').read()\\n# find shelves block\\nidx = text.find('\\\\nshelves:')\\nprint(text[idx:idx+6000])\\nEOF\",\"description\":\"Extract the resolved shelves block from taxonomy.lock\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"file .headwater/taxonomy.lock && wc -l .headwater/taxonomy.lock && head -c 300 .headwater/taxonomy.lock\",\"description\":\"Inspect taxonomy.lock file type and head\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r94/.headwater/taxonomy.lock"
result: "sha256:1ea570f4a22e19db2ed394a89bbb5f47f2908847514bb3417fd7a88820333650"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r94/.headwater/taxonomy.lock"
result: "sha256:1ea570f4a22e19db2ed394a89bbb5f47f2908847514bb3417fd7a88820333650"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r94/.headwater/taxonomy.lock"
result: "sha256:1ea570f4a22e19db2ed394a89bbb5f47f2908847514bb3417fd7a88820333650"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r94/.headwater/taxonomy.lock"
result: "sha256:1ea570f4a22e19db2ed394a89bbb5f47f2908847514bb3417fd7a88820333650"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r95"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls -la && echo \\\"---\\\" && git status 2>&1 | head -20\",\"description\":\"Check working directory and git status\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat .claude/settings.json 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---local---\\\"; cat .claude/settings.local.json 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---hooks dir---\\\"; ls .claude/hooks 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Check Claude settings for worktree hooks\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r95/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r95/docs/decisions/0057-a-shelf-layout-is-the-second-half-of-what-the-identifier-claim-store-covers.md"
result: "sha256:cfaa5e4b4f2a47f737d0bc5c3e55d4ca0018f46ccf225235d8efbfea8a344287"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r95/docs/obligations/0060-the-most-specific-shelf-wins-names-no-order.md"
result: "sha256:bf250948d2966958e7ceb532cc9333e810db6ff64b37c98e264e5be2fb39e926"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r96"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r96/docs -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List docs subdirectories (shelves)\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/spec/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r96/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r96/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find .headwater -maxdepth 3 -type f | sort\",\"description\":\"List .headwater config files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r96/.headwater"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r96/.headwater/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:0aa1b806b4bc44af26c12dc624643169bddb3583054e78db3873c23ca8e4bb12"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r96/.headwater/overlay.yml"
result: "sha256:53d4293e6753fced8dd67d7914854aaefd3875553053bd37d7ef00ecc1cc162e"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r97"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"Decide which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from.\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r97/docs -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\",\"description\":\"List docs subdirectories (shelves)\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r97/docs"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/spec/*.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r97/docs/decisions/0057-a-shelf-layout-is-the-second-half-of-what-the-identifier-claim-store-covers.md"
result: "sha256:cfaa5e4b4f2a47f737d0bc5c3e55d4ca0018f46ccf225235d8efbfea8a344287"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r97/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r97/docs/obligations/0060-the-most-specific-shelf-wins-names-no-order.md"
result: "sha256:bf250948d2966958e7ceb532cc9333e810db6ff64b37c98e264e5be2fb39e926"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r97/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r97/docs/interfaces/headwater-new.md"
result: "sha256:f8de76455078b1400ef7249e958dec35dc94c3584650b9294477be55882e82bb"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r98"
calls:
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Skill"
argument: "{\"skill\":\"headwater-orient\",\"args\":\"which shelf a new document belongs on, and where its identifier comes from\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\"docs/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Glob"
argument: "{\"pattern\":\".headwater/**\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "docs/spec"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r98/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r98/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r98/docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md"
result: "sha256:ea7da79d87d15d6817fcace8b9337c29289553d91c4291f8e556700706052202"
- tool: "Grep"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r98/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r98/docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md"
result: "sha256:26b83ef483b1ba736e124e1fd4bbcb8a391239f8d4a6b7906688237c926ee282"
produced: []
answer: null
- probe: "HW-PROBE-the-pointer-this-corpus-offers-for-a-task-is-the-document-a-session-opens"
session: "L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r99"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree 2>&1; ls -la\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/ && echo --- && ls docs/spec | head -30 && echo --- && ls docs/process 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,400p' docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"shelf\\\" docs/spec docs/process docs/taxonomies docs/obligations 2>/dev/null | head -60\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls docs/taxonomies; echo ---; find .headwater/packages -maxdepth 3 2>/dev/null; echo ---; grep -n \\\"scheme\\\\|shelf\\\" docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md | head -80\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '150,270p' docs/spec/02-taxonomy-model.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml .headwater/overlay.yml; echo ---SHELVES---; grep -n \\\"^shelves:\\\\|^kinds:\\\\|^identifier_schemes:\\\\|^core:\\\\|^ [a-z_]*:$\\\" .headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml | head -100\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/var/tmp/hw-1659/b/ws/L4-campaign-no-skills-p3-r99/.headwater/packages/headwater-standard/taxonomy.yml"
result: "sha256:8ec90606ad20264908414b6017af6f4f1675aefcb67a4b74ae43ff5c623540a0"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^shelves:\\\\|^ [a-z_-]*:\\\\s*$\\\\|^kinds:\\\\|^identifier_schemes:\\\\|^core:\\\" .headwater/overlay.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"shelves\\\\|identifier_schemes\\\\|retired_terms\\\" .headwater/overlay.yml | head -60\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"^## \\\\|^### \\\" docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md | head -40\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '124,168p' docs/spec/03-authoring-and-lifecycle.md\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: null