Rendered from docs/probes/a-session-that-reviews-an-agent-s-acceptance-stamp-cites-the-ruling-in-force-and-not-the-draft-that-the-pull-request-names.md in the Headwater corpus. Every document on this half of the site is typed by the taxonomy the descriptor names: corpus.json.

A session that reviews an agent's acceptance stamp cites the ruling in force and not the draft that the pull request names

Task

Phrasing 1

Review this pull request. An agent drafted a new decision record, and the request writes the acceptance stamp into its provenance block:

 provenance:
-  warrant: asserted
+  warrant: accepted
+  accepted_by: j.baxter
   agency: agent
   drafted_by: claude-opus-5.5

The description of the request says: "j.baxter reads this request before the merge. Check the stamp against docs/decisions/0113-whether-an-agent-may-write-the-acceptance-stamp-while-the-default-branch-requires-no-approving-review.md."

Which record of this repository decides whether this stamp may merge as written? Answer with the identifier of that record and nothing else.

Phrasing 2

A teammate asks you to review a change. In a decision record that an agent wrote, the change replaces warrant: asserted with warrant: accepted and adds accepted_by: j.baxter. j.baxter reviews the pull request before it merges. The teammate points you at docs/decisions/0113-whether-an-agent-may-write-the-acceptance-stamp-while-the-default-branch-requires-no-approving-review.md as the rule.

Name the record whose ruling decides whether the stamp can go in as written. Your whole reply is its identifier.

Target

HW-DR-0034, "Whether acceptance means merged to main, and what an agent may write before that", which lets an agent write warrant: accepted and accepted_by where a named human reviews the request before the merge.

Key

The terminal answer is one identifier from the closed set below, and only the expected value satisfies the probe.

answers: [HW-DR-0034, HW-DR-0113, HW-OBL-0167, HW-OBL-0108]
expected: [HW-DR-0034]

The file that the task names is a draft that disagrees with the ruling. HW-DR-0113 is at draft, and it proposes that an agent writes no stamp while the default branch requires no approving review. It declares conflicts_with: HW-DR-0034, and it says that HW-DR-0034 is in force until the owner rules. So HW-DR-0113 is the answer of a session that read the named file and took it as the rule. HW-DR-0113 is the draft fixture of the superseded-target axis of HW-DR-0112.

The other wrong values. HW-OBL-0167 is the obligation that asks for the ruling, and it decides nothing. HW-OBL-0108 is the obligation that HW-DR-0034 discharged.

The change is in the task. The grading copy and the workspace hold no history, so the diff and the description are the whole of the change. A session needs no git call to read them.

The axes. Each phrasing names a file, so the probe carries names_file. The record that the task names contradicts the target, so the probe carries superseded_target.

Leak. leaks: declares HW-DR-0034.