Rendered from docs/probe-results/campaign-of-2026-09-30-campaign-tier-present-arm-sufficiency.md in the Headwater
corpus. Every document on this half of the site is typed by the taxonomy
the descriptor names: corpus.json.
The result of docs/probe-runs/campaign-of-2026-09-30-campaign-tier-present-arm-sufficiency.md
A probe result is a function of committed inputs and of nothing else: the transcript at docs/probe-runs/campaign-of-2026-09-30-campaign-tier-present-arm-sufficiency.md and the state it stands at, the expectations the probes it names declare, the version of the grader that evaluated them, and for a compared arm the result of the other arm. Fetch those and this file comes back.
The run this transcript recorded
A campaign run in the present arm, on claude-sonnet-5 at 2026-09-30. served version claude-sonnet-5, tree sha256:1c21e55eb09aca89b3d736ac79f8accfc64ddd7853bace5fb5e577a82d794bb9, selection sha256:1d93b514529314b74499196391c68b4b3d1de26853dd9d5ba7f3b455f54ed91d, read set sha256:14520e15ae3a34b9bede8c6702c8b2ab7046cf513c2ba5e03f9fc4628cb2cc31, seed 0, harness 0.5.0. realized cost $65.57, which the adaptive layer reads as the cost of its own instrument.
119 events over 4 probes, in 119 sessions and 1848 tool calls.
The engine confirmed the taxonomy, that every member of the run identity is present, the membership of every probe named, that no key outside the closed set appears, and that a realized cost was recorded. Present is not confirmed. This page names the lock, the selection and the read set the transcript recorded, and it compares none of them with the tree in front of a reader. headwater generate and headwater probe stale name what moved since the recording, and neither one fails for it. It graded nothing: a verdict is a function of this transcript, the expectations these probes declare and a grader version, and headwater probe grade is the verb that holds all three.
The selection this transcript names is sha256:1d93b514529314b74499196391c68b4b3d1de26853dd9d5ba7f3b455f54ed91d, and the probes graded below are the probes it was planned over, as this corpus declares them now. A probe added to this corpus after the recording is not a session this run owed. The tree, the seed and the harness above are provenance and nothing compares them.
The read_set digest above covers every probe of the selection and every document one of them examines, by path and content. This file names it as provenance and compares it with nothing, and the same holds for the lock and the selection: an edit to a document, a new probe or a moved lock leaves these bytes alone. headwater generate names each result whose recorded lock, read set or selection moved, and headwater probe stale takes the digest and reports which recorded results a change voided. Neither one fails for it.
Graded by grader 0.5.2. A campaign run in the present arm, on claude-sonnet-5 at served version claude-sonnet-5.
The verdicts
- HW-PROBE-a-counted-tombstone-separates-a-withheld-answer-from-an-absent-answer (sufficiency, expects answered)
session L1-campaign-present-p1-r1: satisfied — event 1: answered
absent; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p1-r10: satisfied — event 2: answeredabsent; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p1-r11: not satisfied — event 3 answeredwithheld, and the probe expectsabsent; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p1-r12: satisfied — event 4: answeredabsent; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p1-r13: satisfied — event 5: answeredabsent; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p1-r14: satisfied — event 6: answeredabsent; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p1-r15: satisfied — event 7: answeredabsent; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p1-r16: satisfied — event 8: answeredabsent; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p1-r17: satisfied — event 9: answeredabsent; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p1-r18: satisfied — event 10: answeredabsent; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p1-r19: satisfied — event 11: answeredabsent; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p1-r2: satisfied — event 12: answeredabsent; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p1-r20: satisfied — event 13: answeredabsent; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p1-r21: satisfied — event 14: answeredabsent; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p1-r22: satisfied — event 15: answeredabsent; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p1-r23: satisfied — event 16: answeredabsent; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p1-r24: satisfied — event 17: answeredabsent; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p1-r25: satisfied — event 18: answeredabsent; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p1-r26: satisfied — event 19: answeredabsent; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p1-r27: satisfied — event 20: answeredabsent; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p1-r28: satisfied — event 21: answeredabsent; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p1-r29: satisfied — event 22: answeredabsent; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p1-r3: satisfied — event 23: answeredabsent; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p1-r30: satisfied — event 24: answeredabsent; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p1-r4: satisfied — event 25: answeredabsent; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p1-r5: satisfied — event 26: answeredabsent; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p1-r6: satisfied — event 27: answeredabsent; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p1-r7: satisfied — event 28: answeredabsent; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p1-r8: satisfied — event 29: answeredabsent; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p1-r9: satisfied — event 30: answeredabsent; no call to a tool of an MCP server - HW-PROBE-a-session-names-the-event-that-makes-a-document-accepted (sufficiency, expects answered)
session L1-campaign-present-p2-r1: satisfied — event 31: answered
merge; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p2-r10: satisfied — event 32: answeredmerge; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p2-r11: satisfied — event 33: answeredmerge; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p2-r12: satisfied — event 34: answeredmerge; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p2-r13: satisfied — event 35: answeredmerge; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p2-r14: satisfied — event 36: answeredmerge; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p2-r15: satisfied — event 37: answeredmerge; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p2-r16: satisfied — event 38: answeredmerge; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p2-r17: satisfied — event 39: answeredmerge; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p2-r18: satisfied — event 40: answeredmerge; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p2-r19: satisfied — event 41: answeredmerge; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p2-r2: satisfied — event 42: answeredmerge; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p2-r20: satisfied — event 43: answeredmerge; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p2-r21: satisfied — event 44: answeredmerge; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p2-r22: satisfied — event 45: answeredmerge; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p2-r23: satisfied — event 46: answeredmerge; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p2-r24: satisfied — event 47: answeredmerge; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p2-r25: satisfied — event 48: answeredmerge; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p2-r26: satisfied — event 49: answeredmerge; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p2-r27: satisfied — event 50: answeredmerge; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p2-r28: satisfied — event 51: answeredmerge; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p2-r29: satisfied — event 52: answeredmerge; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p2-r3: satisfied — event 53: answeredmerge; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p2-r30: satisfied — event 54: answeredmerge; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p2-r4: satisfied — event 55: answeredmerge; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p2-r5: satisfied — event 56: answeredmerge; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p2-r6: satisfied — event 57: answeredmerge; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p2-r7: satisfied — event 58: answeredmerge; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p2-r8: satisfied — event 59: answeredmerge; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p2-r9: satisfied — event 60: answeredmerge; no call to a tool of an MCP server - HW-PROBE-a-session-names-the-status-a-settled-decision-carries-in-its-pull-request (sufficiency, expects answered)
session L1-campaign-present-p3-r1: satisfied — event 61: answered
current HW-DR-0052; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p3-r10: satisfied — event 62: answeredcurrent HW-DR-0052; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p3-r11: satisfied — event 63: answeredcurrent HW-DR-0052; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p3-r12: satisfied — event 64: answeredcurrent HW-DR-0052; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p3-r13: satisfied — event 65: answeredcurrent HW-DR-0052; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p3-r14: satisfied — event 66: answeredcurrent HW-DR-0052; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p3-r15: satisfied — event 67: answeredcurrent HW-DR-0052; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p3-r16: satisfied — event 68: answeredcurrent HW-DR-0052; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p3-r17: satisfied — event 69: answeredcurrent HW-DR-0052; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p3-r18: satisfied — event 70: answeredcurrent HW-DR-0052; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p3-r19: satisfied — event 71: answeredcurrent HW-DR-0052; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p3-r2: satisfied — event 72: answeredcurrent HW-DR-0052; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p3-r20: satisfied — event 73: answeredcurrent HW-DR-0052; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p3-r21: satisfied — event 74: answeredcurrent HW-DR-0052; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p3-r22: satisfied — event 75: answeredcurrent HW-DR-0052; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p3-r23: satisfied — event 76: answeredcurrent HW-DR-0052; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p3-r24: satisfied — event 77: answeredcurrent HW-DR-0052; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p3-r25: satisfied — event 78: answeredcurrent HW-DR-0052; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p3-r26: satisfied — event 79: answeredcurrent HW-DR-0052; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p3-r27: satisfied — event 80: answeredcurrent HW-DR-0052; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p3-r28: satisfied — event 81: answeredcurrent HW-DR-0052; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p3-r29: satisfied — event 82: answeredcurrent HW-DR-0052; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p3-r3: satisfied — event 83: answeredcurrent HW-DR-0052; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p3-r30: satisfied — event 84: answeredcurrent HW-DR-0052; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p3-r4: satisfied — event 85: answeredcurrent HW-DR-0052; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p3-r5: satisfied — event 86: answeredcurrent HW-DR-0052; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p3-r6: satisfied — event 87: answeredcurrent HW-DR-0052; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p3-r7: satisfied — event 88: answeredcurrent HW-DR-0052; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p3-r8: satisfied — event 89: answeredcurrent HW-DR-0052; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p3-r9: satisfied — event 90: answeredcurrent HW-DR-0052; no call to a tool of an MCP server - HW-PROBE-a-session-records-an-unmeasured-claim-in-the-shape-this-corpus-checks (sufficiency, expects patched)
session L1-campaign-present-p4-r1: satisfied — event 91:
section.required.missingreported nothing overdocs/obligations/0227-the-session-budget-standing-instructions-consume-before-any-work-starts-is-unmeasured.md; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p4-r10: satisfied — event 92:section.required.missingreported nothing overdocs/obligations/0227-spec-5-says-claude-md-costs-context-on-every-session-and-nothing-states-how-much.md; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p4-r11: satisfied — event 93:section.required.missingreported nothing overdocs/process/obligations/0227-nothing-states-how-much-of-a-session-s-budget-its-standing-instructions-consume-before-work-starts.md; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p4-r13: satisfied — event 94:section.required.missingreported nothing overdocs/obligations/0227-nothing-states-how-much-of-a-session-s-budget-the-standing-instructions-consume-before-work-starts.md; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p4-r14: not satisfied — the session produced no artifact, so the oracle had nothing to read; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p4-r15: not satisfied — the session produced no artifact, so the oracle had nothing to read; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p4-r16: satisfied — event 97:section.required.missingreported nothing overdocs/obligations/0227-how-much-of-a-session-s-budget-the-standing-instructions-consume-before-any-work-starts-is-unmeasured.md; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p4-r17: satisfied — event 98:section.required.missingreported nothing overdocs/process/obligations/0227-nothing-sums-what-the-standing-instructions-of-this-repository-cost-a-session-before-any-work-starts.md; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p4-r18: satisfied — event 99:section.required.missingreported nothing overdocs/process/obligations/0227-no-reading-states-how-much-of-a-session-s-budget-the-standing-instructions-of-this-repository-consume-before-work-starts.md; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p4-r19: satisfied — event 100:section.required.missingreported nothing overdocs/obligations/0227-nothing-states-how-much-of-a-session-s-budget-the-standing-instructions-consume-before-work-starts.md; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p4-r2: satisfied — event 101:section.required.missingreported nothing overdocs/obligations/0227-standing-instructions-have-no-measured-cost-against-the-aggregate-context-budget-spec-5-claims.md; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p4-r20: satisfied — event 102:section.required.missingreported nothing overdocs/obligations/0227-spec-5-claims-that-claude-md-costs-context-on-every-session-and-no-reading-states-how-much.md; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p4-r21: satisfied — event 103:section.required.missingreported nothing overdocs/process/obligations/0227-no-figure-exists-for-what-a-session-s-standing-instructions-add-to-the-context-of-its-first-turn.md; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p4-r22: not satisfied — the session produced no artifact, so the oracle had nothing to read; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p4-r23: satisfied — event 105:section.required.missingreported nothing overdocs/process/obligations/0227-nothing-states-what-a-session-s-standing-instructions-cost-before-any-work-starts.md; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p4-r24: satisfied — event 106:section.required.missingreported nothing overdocs/process/obligations/0227-nothing-states-how-much-of-a-session-s-budget-the-standing-instructions-of-this-repository-consume-before-any-work-starts.md; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p4-r25: satisfied — event 107:section.required.missingreported nothing overdocs/process/obligations/0227-nothing-states-the-session-budget-the-standing-instructions-of-this-repository-consume-before-work-starts.md; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p4-r26: not satisfied — the session produced no artifact, so the oracle had nothing to read; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p4-r27: satisfied — event 109:section.required.missingreported nothing overdocs/obligations/0227-no-document-states-the-token-budget-the-standing-instructions-of-this-repository-spend-before-a-session-starts-work.md; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p4-r28: satisfied — event 110:section.required.missingreported nothing overdocs/process/obligations/0227-no-document-states-what-this-repository-s-standing-instructions-cost-a-session-before-its-first-read-or-edit.md; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p4-r29: satisfied — event 111:section.required.missingreported nothing overdocs/obligations/0227-this-repository-has-no-reading-of-the-session-budget-its-standing-instructions-spend-before-work-starts.md; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p4-r3: satisfied — event 112:section.required.missingreported nothing overdocs/obligations/0227-the-context-cost-of-this-repository-s-standing-instructions-before-a-session-s-first-tool-call-is-unmeasured.md; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p4-r30: satisfied — event 113:section.required.missingreported nothing overdocs/process/obligations/0227-nothing-states-what-a-session-s-standing-instructions-cost-before-any-work-starts.md; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p4-r4: satisfied — event 114:section.required.missingreported nothing overdocs/obligations/0227-nothing-sums-what-claude-md-and-the-intent-time-routing-injection-cost-before-a-session-reads-its-first-file.md; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p4-r5: satisfied — event 115:section.required.missingreported nothing overdocs/process/obligations/0227-the-standing-instructions-of-this-repository-cost-every-session-before-any-work-starts-and-nothing-states-how-much.md; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p4-r6: satisfied — event 116:section.required.missingreported nothing overdocs/process/obligations/0227-nothing-states-what-a-session-s-standing-instructions-cost-before-its-first-task-specific-turn.md; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p4-r7: satisfied — event 117:section.required.missingreported nothing overdocs/obligations/0227-nothing-states-how-much-of-a-session-s-budget-this-repository-s-standing-instructions-consume-before-any-work-starts.md; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p4-r8: satisfied — event 118:section.required.missingreported nothing overdocs/obligations/0227-the-context-cost-of-claude-md-and-the-always-loaded-skills-before-a-session-s-first-tool-call-is-unmeasured.md; no call to a tool of an MCP server session L1-campaign-present-p4-r9: satisfied — event 119:section.required.missingreported nothing overdocs/obligations/0227-nothing-states-how-much-of-a-session-s-budget-the-standing-instructions-of-this-repository-consume-before-any-work-starts.md; no call to a tool of an MCP server
119 of 119 sessions that recorded their calls made no call to a tool of an MCP server. 0 sessions recorded no calls.
The rate, and the denominator it is over
114 of 119 graded sessions satisfied their expectation: 95.8%, in a 95% interval of 90.5% to 98.2%. The denominator is the graded sessions and never the selected probes. 0 sessions reached no verdict, and a session with no verdict is outside both halves of that fraction.
An interval that overlaps the previous run's is variance and one that does not is drift. This is one arm, so it estimates no effect: an efficacy claim is a comparison of two results, and the arm each one recorded is on it.
The comparisons this arm takes part in
What the governance changes. The treated arm is the campaign present arm and the control is the campaign absent arm, which removed the paths the campaign tier's ablation names and kept docs/.
- treated,
docs/probe-runs/campaign-of-2026-09-30-campaign-tier-present-arm-sufficiency.md: 114 of 119 graded sessions satisfied their expectation, 95.8%, in a 95% interval of 90.5% to 98.2%. 0 sessions refused by the session itself. - control,
docs/probe-runs/campaign-of-2026-09-30-campaign-tier-absent-arm-sufficiency.md: 114 of 119 graded sessions satisfied their expectation, 95.8%, in a 95% interval of 90.5% to 98.2%. 0 sessions refused by the session itself.
The difference is +0.0 points, in a 95% Newcombe interval of -5.8 points to +5.8 points. The interval contains zero, so this run does not separate the two arms at the 5% level.
What the documents and the governance change together. The treated arm is a present arm and the control is the documentation absent arm.
- treated,
docs/probe-runs/campaign-of-2026-09-30-campaign-tier-present-arm-sufficiency.md: 114 of 119 graded sessions satisfied their expectation, 95.8%, in a 95% interval of 90.5% to 98.2%. 0 sessions refused by the session itself. - control,
docs/probe-runs/campaign-of-2026-09-30-documentation-tier-absent-arm-sufficiency.md: 46 of 120 graded sessions satisfied their expectation, 38.3%, in a 95% interval of 30.1% to 47.3%. 0 sessions refused by the session itself.
The difference is +57.5 points, in a 95% Newcombe interval of +47.1 points to +66.0 points. The interval is above zero, so the treated arm satisfied more often at the 5% level.