Rendered from docs/probe-runs/tombstone-probe-pilot-of-2026-09-29-campaign-tier-present-arm-sufficiency.md in the Headwater
corpus. Every document on this half of the site is typed by the taxonomy
the descriptor names: corpus.json.
Tombstone probe pilot of 2026-09-29, campaign tier, present arm, sufficiency
Run identity
model: claude-sonnet-5
served_version: claude-sonnet-5
tree: sha256:6e992f8aad533584b81d2565735072d21572d958f390787da3e15714159fcbf9
lock: sha256:badb09836f1099bd2d72472dc6370ac7fa0d14e93001264d38a69b5e59210e44
selection: sha256:5ae5921d66889c1262ef7918402f57485f928baa6eba615a9c3a42c81fb5e58d
read_set: sha256:c3c61a60b3affe195bea364448c4e769f0d622cc24098b5e69dfcaf1d50bf764
seed: 0
harness: 0.5.0
tier: campaign
arm: present
at: 2026-09-29
cost_cents: 369
This is a pilot of one probe and not the campaign. tools/probe/campaign.sh recorded it on 2026-09-29 (UTC) for the first step of #1384. It ran the probe HW-PROBE-a-counted-tombstone-separates-a-withheld-answer-from-an-absent-answer alone, at 10 repetitions per arm, after the changes to the recorder, the grader, the read set and the seal had merged (#1394, #1396, #1414 and #1413). The owner ruled on #1384 on 2026-09-30 (AEST) that this pilot spends no more than $10.00, at 10 sessions per arm. No comparison pools it with the campaign of 2026-09-28, because the seal, the turn cap and the harness moved between the two.
One batch, one tree. Every session ran in a fresh copy of one git archive of commit 59d3bc1a, an empty pin commit on 16eecca0, with the engine that commit builds. The sessions ran in one order that seed 980 shuffled, two at a time, on claude-sonnet-5 with a cap of 80 turns, and the cap stopped 0 of the 10 sessions of this arm. Each workspace lost the instrument, every record under docs/ that names the probe, and every file outside docs/ that names it and is not a declared fold. Each absent workspace also lost the ablation of the campaign tier. The seed in the identity above is the plan's seed, and the shuffle seed is not a member of the identity.
What the seal cannot find. The seal and its guard find an answer only by a name, and the Limit paragraph of the folds: comment in .headwater/probe.yml states that bound.
Events
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-counted-tombstone-separates-a-withheld-answer-from-an-absent-answer"
session: "L1-campaign-present-p1-r1"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && ls -la && ls docs 2>/dev/null | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== amber occurrences ===\\\" && grep -ril \\\"amber\\\" docs/ && echo \\\"=== tombstone occurrences ===\\\" && grep -ril \\\"tombstone\\\" docs/\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== amber ===\\\" && grep -ril \\\"amber\\\" docs/ ; echo \\\"exit:$?\\\"; echo \\\"=== tombstone ===\\\" && grep -ril \\\"tombstone\\\" docs/ ; echo \\\"exit:$?\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -ril \\\"recovery word\\\" docs/ engine/ .headwater/ 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---\\\"; grep -ril \\\"recovery\\\" docs/ 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rli \\\"amber\\\\|recovery.word\\\\|recovery word\\\" docs/ --include=*.md | grep -v fixtures ; echo \\\"---case-insensitive whole docs incl fixtures---\\\"; grep -rli \\\"amber\\\" docs/ ; echo \\\"---\\\"; find docs -maxdepth 1 -type d\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find docs -iname \\\"*tombstone*\\\"; echo \\\"---\\\"; grep -rn \\\"tombstone\\\" docs/spec/*.md | head -60\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"tombstone\\\\|projections\\\" .headwater/ 2>/dev/null | grep -v fixtures\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find . -iname \\\"*counted-tombstone*\\\" 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---git log for that path---\\\"; git log --all --oneline -- \\\"docs/probes/a-counted-tombstone-separates-a-withheld-answer-from-an-absent-answer.md\\\" 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---search whole repo for probes dir---\\\"; find . -type d -name probes 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find docs -iname \\\"*open-questions*\\\"; echo \\\"---\\\"; find docs -iname \\\"*tombstone*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*counted*\\\"; echo \\\"---check .headwater/taxonomy.lock projections---\\\"; sed -n '1130,1170p' .headwater/taxonomy.lock\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '440,470p' .headwater/nav.yml; echo \\\"=== probe.yml context ===\\\"; sed -n '220,270p' .headwater/probe.yml\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find docs -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort; echo \\\"=== looking for the specific probe doc by identifier in obligations/evaluations (since seal deletes evaluation/obligation answer keys) ===\\\"; grep -rl \\\"counted-tombstone\\\\|counted tombstone\\\" docs/obligations docs/evaluations docs/decisions docs/spec 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"probe\\\" .gitignore; echo \\\"---git ls-files for docs/probes---\\\"; git ls-files -- 'docs/probes/*' 'docs/probe-runs/*' | head -30; echo \\\"---git status---\\\"; git status --short | head -20\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"wc -l docs/spec/09-open-questions.md && head -60 docs/spec/09-open-questions.md\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git ls-files | grep -c '^docs/' ; git ls-files | grep '^docs/probe' | head; echo \\\"---full repo git log depth---\\\"; git log --oneline -5; echo \\\"--- is this a shallow clone? ---\\\"; git rev-parse --is-shallow-repository\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git rev-parse --show-toplevel; git status --short docs | head -5; echo \\\"count untracked docs files:\\\"; git status --porcelain docs | wc -l\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find docs -maxdepth 2 -iname \\\"README.md\\\"; echo \\\"---\\\"; for f in docs/decisions/README.md docs/spec/README.md; do echo \\\"== $f ==\\\"; test -f \\\"$f\\\" && cat \\\"$f\\\" | head -30; done\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"tombstone: counted\\\\|tombstone:counted\\\\|grain: counted\\\" docs/ ; echo \\\"---broader 'counted' search---\\\"; grep -rn \\\"\\\\bcounted\\\\b\\\" docs/ | grep -v fixtures\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /home/james/.claude/jobs/1338ac1e/tmp/issue-1384/campaign/ws/L1-campaign-present-p1-r1/docs/spec && grep -oE '\\\\(\\\\.\\\\./decisions/[a-zA-Z0-9._-]+\\\\.md\\\\)' 09-open-questions.md | sed 's/[()]//g' | sort -u | while read f; do\\n path=\\\"../$(echo $f | sed 's#^\\\\.\\\\./##')\\\"\\n full=\\\"$(realpath -m \\\"$f\\\" 2>/dev/null)\\\"\\n if [ ! -f \\\"$f\\\" ]; then echo \\\"MISSING: $f\\\"; fi\\ndone\\necho \\\"done\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /home/james/.claude/jobs/1338ac1e/tmp/issue-1384/campaign/ws/L1-campaign-present-p1-r1 && find docs -type f | wc -l; find docs -type f | xargs grep -il \\\"amber\\\" 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"exit:$?\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -ril \\\"recovery.word\\\\|codeword\\\\|code word\\\\|secret word\\\\|passphrase\\\" docs/ 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---\\\"; grep -rniE \\\"\\\\b(amber|red|green|scarlet|crimson|ochre|amethyst)\\\\b\\\" docs/ 2>/dev/null | grep -v fixtures | head -30\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"accounts for\\\" docs/ | grep -v fixtures; echo \\\"=== withheld counts ===\\\"; grep -rn \\\"withheld\\\" docs/ | grep -v fixtures | head -40\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: "absent"
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-counted-tombstone-separates-a-withheld-answer-from-an-absent-answer"
session: "L1-campaign-present-p1-r10"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -ril \\\"amber\\\" docs/ 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Search docs directory for 'amber'\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -ril \\\"tombstone\\\" docs/ 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Search docs directory for 'tombstone'\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -ril \\\"recovery\\\" docs/ 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---\\\"; grep -rn \\\"tombstone\\\" docs/spec/07-distribution-and-federation.md docs/spec/13-open-obligations.md 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Search for 'recovery' term and tombstone context in spec files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"docs exists?\\\" && ls -la docs | head -30 && echo \\\"---count files---\\\" && find docs -type f | wc -l && echo \\\"---grep amber case insens---\\\" && grep -rli \\\"amber\\\" docs 2>/dev/null | wc -l\",\"description\":\"Check docs directory structure and search for amber\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"tombstone\\\" --include=\\\"*.md\\\" docs | grep -iv \\\"fixtures\\\" | grep -iE \\\"count|accounts|ledger|manifest\\\"\",\"description\":\"Search for tombstone counting language in docs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find docs -iname \\\"*export*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*manifest*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*index*\\\" | grep -v fixtures | grep -v taxonomies\",\"description\":\"Look for export/manifest/index files in docs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rliE \\\"amber\\\" docs 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"exit: $?\\\"; find docs -type f ! -name \\\"*.md\\\" | head -50\",\"description\":\"Broader search for amber including non-markdown files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"tombstone: counted\\\\|reason:.*withheld\\\\|withheld-by\\\\|census\\\" docs --include=\\\"*.yml\\\" --include=\\\"*.yaml\\\" --include=\\\"*.json\\\" 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Search for actual tombstone/census entries in structured files\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: "absent"
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-counted-tombstone-separates-a-withheld-answer-from-an-absent-answer"
session: "L1-campaign-present-p1-r2"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -ril \\\"amber\\\" docs/ 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---tombstone---\\\"; grep -ril \\\"tombstone\\\" docs/ 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Search docs/ for 'amber' and 'tombstone' mentions\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== recovery ===\\\"; grep -ril \\\"recovery\\\" docs/ 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"=== word (with amber nearby) ===\\\"; grep -rn \\\"amber\\\" docs/ -i 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"=== find tombstone files ===\\\"; find docs -iname \\\"*tombstone*\\\"\",\"description\":\"Search docs for recovery, amber, and tombstone files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n -i \\\"tombstone\\\" docs/spec/glossary.md docs/spec/13-open-obligations.md docs/obligations/0057-a-retrofit-cannot-recover-the-two-dates-or-the-acceptance.md 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Show tombstone mentions in key spec/obligation docs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/home/james/.claude/jobs/1338ac1e/tmp/issue-1384/campaign/ws/L1-campaign-present-p1-r2/docs/spec/glossary.md"
result: "sha256:81423ebb8cd1b20753090916ef3b3c1ef81a25957373fbc4936ae1a911dd243f"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== grep kind tombstone in frontmatter ===\\\"; grep -rl \\\"tombstone\\\" docs --include=\\\"*.md\\\" -i | grep -v \\\"taxonomies/.*fixtures\\\" ; echo \\\"=== check docs top-level structure ===\\\"; find docs -maxdepth 1 -type d\",\"description\":\"List non-fixture files mentioning tombstone and top-level docs dirs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n -i \\\"tombstone\\\\|counted\\\\|sealed\\\\|withheld\\\" docs/evaluations/the-serving-boundary.md\",\"description\":\"Show tombstone/counted/sealed/withheld mentions in serving-boundary doc\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"withheld\\\" docs --include=\\\"*.md\\\" -il | grep -v \\\"taxonomies/.*fixtures\\\"\",\"description\":\"List non-fixture docs mentioning withheld\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== all files under docs (non-fixture) count ===\\\"; find docs -type f | grep -v \\\"taxonomies/.*fixtures\\\" | wc -l; echo \\\"=== grep amber everywhere in repo (not just docs) for sanity, excluding .git ===\\\"; grep -rli \\\"amber\\\" --exclude-dir=.git . 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Count docs files and search whole repo for amber\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find docs -iname \\\"*recovery*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*answer*\\\" | grep -v fixtures\",\"description\":\"Look for recovery/answer files in top-level docs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find docs -iname \\\"*census*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*.tombstone*\\\"; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls docs/verifications | head -30; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls docs/process; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls docs/w3id\",\"description\":\"Look for census/tombstone artifacts and inspect a few doc dirs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"amb\\\" docs --include=\\\"*.md\\\" -i | grep -v \\\"taxonomies/.*fixtures\\\" | grep -iv \\\"ambig\\\\|ambient\\\\|amble\\\\|ambitio\\\"\",\"description\":\"Search for amb substring in top-level docs excluding fixtures and common words\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: "absent"
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-counted-tombstone-separates-a-withheld-answer-from-an-absent-answer"
session: "L1-campaign-present-p1-r3"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && ls -la && echo \\\"---docs---\\\" && ls docs/ 2>/dev/null | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rIl \\\"amber\\\" docs/ 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---tombstone---\\\"; grep -rIl \\\"tombstone\\\" docs/ 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rIln \\\"recovery word\\\\|recovery-word\\\" docs/ 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---\\\"; grep -rIn \\\"tombstone\\\" docs/spec/*.md docs/decisions/0009* 2>/dev/null | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rIln \\\"recovery\\\" docs/ 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---amber anywhere in repo---\\\"; grep -rIl \\\"amber\\\" . --include=\\\"*.md\\\" 2>/dev/null | grep -v \\\"^./engine/\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rIln \\\"census\\\" docs/ 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---\\\"; find docs -iname \\\"*recovery*\\\"; echo \\\"---export files---\\\"; find docs -iname \\\"*export*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*projection*\\\" | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rIn \\\"recovery word\\\" docs/ 2>/dev/null; grep -rIn \\\"recovery-word\\\\|recoveryWord\\\" docs/ 2>/dev/null; find docs -iname \\\"*tombstone*\\\"; find docs -iname \\\"*.lock\\\" -o -iname \\\"*census*\\\"\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: "absent"
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-counted-tombstone-separates-a-withheld-answer-from-an-absent-answer"
session: "L1-campaign-present-p1-r4"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && ls docs/ | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"--- amber ---\\\" && grep -ril \\\"amber\\\" docs/ ; echo \\\"--- recovery word ---\\\" && grep -ril \\\"recovery word\\\" docs/ ; echo \\\"--- tombstone ---\\\" && grep -ril \\\"tombstone\\\" docs/\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"--- recovery ---\\\" && grep -ril \\\"recovery\\\" docs/ ; echo \\\"--- word ---\\\" && grep -ril \\\"the word\\\" docs/ ; echo \\\"--- git log for this dir ---\\\" && git log --oneline -10\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git rev-parse --show-toplevel && git log --oneline -5 -- docs/ | head -20\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"tombstone\\\" docs/ --include=*.md -i | grep -v fixtures\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rli \\\"amber\\\" docs/ 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---count---\\\"; grep -rio \\\"amber\\\" docs/ 2>/dev/null | wc -l; echo \\\"---find non-md---\\\"; find docs -type f ! -name \\\"*.md\\\" | grep -v fixtures | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"documents withheld\\\\|document withheld\\\\|withheld:\\\" docs/ --include=*.md | grep -v fixtures; echo \\\"---\\\"; grep -rln \\\"tombstone: counted\\\" docs/ --include=*.yml docs/ --include=*.md 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---overlay---\\\"; find . -iname \\\"overlay.yml\\\" -not -path \\\"*/fixtures/*\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rlin \\\"amber\\\\|traffic.light\\\\|red.*amber.*green\\\\|amber.*green\\\" docs/ .headwater/ 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---frontmatter status values---\\\"; grep -rn \\\"^status:\\\" docs/**/*.md 2>/dev/null | sed 's/.*status: //' | sort -u | head -30\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find . -maxdepth 1 -name \\\".git*\\\"; ls -la | head -20\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"counted\\\\|withheld\\\\|tombstone\\\" docs/spec/09-open-questions.md 2>/dev/null | head -20; echo \\\"exists?\\\"; ls docs/spec/09-open-questions.md 2>&1\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: "absent"
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-counted-tombstone-separates-a-withheld-answer-from-an-absent-answer"
session: "L1-campaign-present-p1-r5"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && ls -la && ls docs | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"--- amber matches ---\\\" && grep -rIn \\\"amber\\\" docs/ && echo \\\"--- tombstone matches ---\\\" && grep -rIln \\\"tombstone\\\" docs/\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"--- amber ci ---\\\" && grep -rIni \\\"amber\\\" docs/ ; echo \\\"--- tombstone ci ---\\\" && grep -rIni \\\"tombstone\\\" docs/ ; echo \\\"--- recovery ci ---\\\" && grep -rIni \\\"recovery\\\" docs/ ; echo \\\"--- find non-md files ---\\\" && find docs -type f -not -name \\\"*.md\\\" ; echo \\\"--- total md count ---\\\" && find docs -type f -name \\\"*.md\\\" | wc -l\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cat /home/james/.claude/projects/-home-james--claude-jobs-1338ac1e-tmp-issue-1384-campaign-ws-L1-campaign-present-p1-r5/385d2f01-b5d7-4ee2-8ac1-c98a96903b2e/tool-results/bn84tkxpn.txt\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/home/james/.claude/projects/-home-james--claude-jobs-1338ac1e-tmp-issue-1384-campaign-ws-L1-campaign-present-p1-r5/385d2f01-b5d7-4ee2-8ac1-c98a96903b2e/tool-results/bf1hp110l.txt"
result: "sha256:2dd6dbde4cbfe3b7f48dab32ebd8715ea9a6f7124087b33e8a630dee216e7d23"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"--- amber anywhere in repo ---\\\" && grep -rIni \\\"amber\\\" . --include=\\\"*.md\\\" --include=\\\"*.yml\\\" --include=\\\"*.yaml\\\" --include=\\\"*.txt\\\" 2>/dev/null | grep -v \\\"^Binary\\\" | head -50\\necho \\\"--- recovery word phrase ---\\\"\\ngrep -rIni \\\"recovery word\\\" . 2>/dev/null | head -20\\necho \\\"--- withheld documents phrasing, actual counted grain in real corpus (not fixtures) ---\\\"\\ngrep -rIn \\\"documents withheld\\\\|withheld\\\\]\\\\|withheld\\\\\\\"\\\" docs --include=\\\"*.md\\\" | grep -v fixtures | head -30\\n\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find docs -iname \\\"*answer*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*recovery*\\\" 2>/dev/null\\necho \\\"---\\\"\\ngrep -rn \\\"tombstone_grain\\\\|tombstone:\\\" .headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null\\necho \\\"---\\\"\\nfind docs -iname \\\"*.tombstone*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*withheld*\\\"\\n\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: "absent"
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-counted-tombstone-separates-a-withheld-answer-from-an-absent-answer"
session: "L1-campaign-present-p1-r6"
calls:
- tool: "ToolSearch"
argument: "{\"query\":\"select:EnterWorktree\",\"max_results\":3}"
result: ""
- tool: "EnterWorktree"
argument: "{}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"ls && echo --- && grep -ril \\\"amber\\\" docs/ | head -50\",\"description\":\"List repo root and search docs/ for amber\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git rev-parse --show-toplevel && git remote -v && git worktree list && echo --- && find . -maxdepth 2 -iname 'docs' \",\"description\":\"Inspect repo root, remotes, worktrees, and docs dirs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find /home/james/.claude/jobs/1338ac1e/tmp/issue-1384/campaign -maxdepth 6 -iname 'docs' -o -iname '*.headwater*' 2>/dev/null | head -50\",\"description\":\"Search campaign directory tree for docs or headwater dirs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"cd /home/james/.claude/jobs/1338ac1e/tmp/issue-1384/campaign/ws/L1-campaign-present-p1-r6 && git rev-parse --show-toplevel 2>&1; echo ---; ls -la; echo ---; ls docs\",\"description\":\"Check if campaign directory is its own git repo and list docs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "ToolSearch"
argument: "{\"query\":\"select:ExitWorktree\",\"max_results\":3}"
result: ""
- tool: "ExitWorktree"
argument: "{\"action\":\"remove\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find docs -maxdepth 3 -type d | sort && echo --- && find docs -type f | wc -l\",\"description\":\"List docs directory structure and file count\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== amber matches ===\\\" && grep -rni \\\"amber\\\" docs/ 2>/dev/null && echo \\\"=== tombstone matches ===\\\" && grep -rni \\\"tombstone\\\" docs/ 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Search docs directory for amber and tombstone mentions\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rni \\\"amber\\\" docs/ ; echo \\\"amber exit: $?\\\"; grep -rni \\\"tombstone\\\" docs/ ; echo \\\"tombstone exit: $?\\\"\",\"description\":\"Search docs for amber and tombstone with explicit exit codes\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== withheld ===\\\" && grep -rli \\\"withheld\\\" docs/ | sort && echo \\\"=== census ===\\\" && grep -rli \\\"census\\\" docs/ | sort\",\"description\":\"Search docs for withheld and census files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rni \\\"recovery\\\" docs/ ; echo \\\"recovery exit: $?\\\"\\necho \\\"---\\\"\\ngrep -rn \\\"documents withheld\\\\|document withheld\\\\|withheld]\\\\|\\\\[withheld\\\\|counted tombstone\\\\|tombstone: counted\\\" docs/ 2>/dev/null\\necho \\\"---\\\"\\nfind docs -iname \\\"*export*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*census*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*withheld*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*tombstone*\\\" 2>/dev/null\",\"description\":\"Search for recovery keyword and concrete tombstone artifacts\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find . -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort && echo --- && find .headwater -maxdepth 3 -type f 2>/dev/null | sort\",\"description\":\"List top-level dirs and .headwater contents\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rni \\\"recovery word\\\" . 2>/dev/null\\necho \\\"---probes---\\\"\\nfind . -iname \\\"*probe*\\\" -path \\\"*docs*\\\" | head -30\\necho \\\"---amber anywhere in repo---\\\"\\ngrep -rlin \\\"amber\\\" --exclude-dir=.git --exclude-dir=target . 2>/dev/null | head -30\",\"description\":\"Search whole repo for recovery word phrase and amber occurrences outside docs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find docs -iname \\\"*recovery*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*answer*\\\" 2>/dev/null\\necho \\\"---\\\"\\ncat engine/crates/cli/fixtures/answered-export/docs/answers/recovery.md\\necho \\\"---verify.py---\\\"\\ncat engine/crates/cli/fixtures/answered-export/verify.py 2>/dev/null | head -50\",\"description\":\"Check docs for recovery-related files and inspect the fixture files\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: "absent"
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-counted-tombstone-separates-a-withheld-answer-from-an-absent-answer"
session: "L1-campaign-present-p1-r7"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && ls docs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -ril \\\"amber\\\" docs/ ; echo \\\"---tombstone---\\\"; grep -ril \\\"tombstone\\\" docs/\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"tombstone\\\" docs/ | head -80\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== case-insensitive amber ===\\\" && grep -rniI \\\"amber\\\" docs/ ; echo \\\"=== done ===\\\" ; echo \\\"=== documents withheld literal ===\\\" && grep -rniI \\\"document.*withheld\\\\|withheld.*document\\\" docs/ | head -40\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"=== recovery word ===\\\" && grep -rniI \\\"recovery\\\" docs/ ; echo \\\"=== find files mentioning amber anywhere in repo ===\\\" && grep -rniI \\\"amber\\\" --include=\\\"*\\\" . 2>/dev/null | grep -v \\\"^Binary\\\" ; echo \\\"=== done ===\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find docs -maxdepth 2 -iname \\\"*answer*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*recovery*\\\" | head; echo \\\"---\\\"; find docs -iname \\\"*recovery*\\\"; echo \\\"---\\\"; find docs -iname \\\"*tombstone*\\\"; echo \\\"---export dirs---\\\"; find . -maxdepth 4 -iname \\\"*export*\\\" -not -path \\\"./engine/*\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n \\\"projections\\\\|tombstone\\\\|export\\\" .headwater/overlay.yml 2>/dev/null | head -50; echo \\\"---taxonomy lock exportable---\\\"; grep -n \\\"export\\\\|tombstone\\\\|projections\\\" .headwater/taxonomy.lock 2>/dev/null | head -50\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1610,1790p' .headwater/overlay.yml\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: "absent"
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-counted-tombstone-separates-a-withheld-answer-from-an-absent-answer"
session: "L1-campaign-present-p1-r8"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && ls -la\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"amber\\\" docs/ 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"--- case-insensitive amber ---\\\" && grep -rni \\\"amber\\\" docs/ 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"--- tombstone ---\\\" && grep -rni \\\"tombstone\\\" docs/ 2>/dev/null | head -50; echo \\\"--- recovery word ---\\\" && grep -rni \\\"recovery.word\\\\|recovery word\\\" docs/ 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rniE \\\"withheld|counted\\\" docs/ 2>/dev/null | grep -viE \\\"docs/evaluations|docs/decisions|docs/spec|docs/obligations|docs/how-to\\\" \"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rni \\\"amber\\\" . --include=\\\"*.md\\\" --include=\\\"*.json\\\" --include=\\\"*.yml\\\" --include=\\\"*.yaml\\\" 2>/dev/null | grep -v \\\"^\\\\./site/\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find docs -iname \\\"*recovery*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*answer*\\\" | grep -v site; echo \\\"---\\\"; find docs -maxdepth 2 -type d | sort\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find docs -iname \\\"*export*\\\" -o -iname \\\"*census*\\\" | grep -v site; echo \\\"---.headwater---\\\"; ls .headwater; echo \\\"---overlay grep tombstone---\\\"; grep -n \\\"tombstone\\\" .headwater/*.yml 2>/dev/null; find .headwater -iname \\\"*export*\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find docs -iname \\\"*counted-tombstone*\\\"; find . -iname \\\"*counted-tombstone*\\\" 2>/dev/null | grep -v site\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find . -type d -iname \\\"probes\\\" 2>/dev/null; find . -path \\\"*probes*counted*\\\" 2>/dev/null\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"a-counted-tombstone-separates-a-withheld-answer-from-an-absent-answer\\\" . 2>/dev/null | grep -v \\\"/site/\\\"\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find . -iname \\\"*.census\\\" -not -path \\\"*/fixtures/*\\\" -not -path \\\"*/site/*\\\" 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---\\\"; find . -iname \\\"corpus.census\\\" 2>/dev/null | grep -v fixtures; echo \\\"--- git log for the probe doc ---\\\"; git log --oneline --all -- \\\"docs/probes/a-counted-tombstone-separates-a-withheld-answer-from-an-absent-answer.md\\\" 2>/dev/null | head -20\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"git log --oneline -5; echo \\\"---\\\"; git log --oneline --all | wc -l; echo \\\"--- full history search ---\\\"; git log --all --diff-filter=D --summary | grep -i \\\"counted-tombstone\\\" \"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find docs -iname \\\"*probe*\\\"; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls docs\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"sed -n '1,60p' docs/spec/09-open-questions.md 2>/dev/null | head -80\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rniE \\\"document(s)? withheld|withheld:|reason: withheld|tombstone: counted\\\" docs/ --include=\\\"*.md\\\" --include=\\\"*.yml\\\" --include=\\\"*.json\\\" 2>/dev/null | grep -v \\\"docs/taxonomies.*fixtures\\\"\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: "absent"
- probe: "HW-PROBE-a-counted-tombstone-separates-a-withheld-answer-from-an-absent-answer"
session: "L1-campaign-present-p1-r9"
calls:
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"pwd && ls\",\"description\":\"Show working directory and list files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"--- amber ---\\\" && grep -ril \\\"amber\\\" docs/ && echo \\\"--- tombstone ---\\\" && grep -ril \\\"tombstone\\\" docs/ && echo \\\"--- recovery ---\\\" && grep -ril \\\"recovery\\\" docs/\",\"description\":\"Search docs/ for amber, tombstone, recovery mentions\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"echo \\\"--- amber ---\\\"; grep -ril \\\"amber\\\" docs/; echo \\\"--- tombstone ---\\\"; grep -ril \\\"tombstone\\\" docs/; echo \\\"--- recovery ---\\\"; grep -ril \\\"recovery\\\" docs/; echo \\\"done\\\"\",\"description\":\"Search docs/ for amber, tombstone, recovery mentions (non-short-circuit)\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -ril \\\"recovery word\\\" docs/; echo \\\"---\\\"; grep -ril \\\"recovery.word\\\" docs/ 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---glossary---\\\"; grep -n -i \\\"amber\\\\|tombstone\\\\|recovery\\\" docs/spec/glossary.md\",\"description\":\"Search for literal recovery word phrase and glossary entries\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Read"
argument: "/home/james/.claude/jobs/1338ac1e/tmp/issue-1384/campaign/ws/L1-campaign-present-p1-r9/docs/spec/glossary.md"
result: "sha256:81423ebb8cd1b20753090916ef3b3c1ef81a25957373fbc4936ae1a911dd243f"
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -rn \\\"tombstone\\\" docs/spec/06-engine-architecture.md docs/spec/07-distribution-and-federation.md; echo \\\"---front matter status tombstone---\\\"; grep -rln \\\"^status: tombstone\\\\|tombstone:\\\" docs/; echo \\\"---any yaml files---\\\"; find docs -iname \\\"*tombstone*\\\"; echo \\\"---export profile files---\\\"; grep -rln \\\"export profile\\\\|projections:\\\" docs/ | head -30\",\"description\":\"Search for tombstone mechanism details and any literal tombstone data files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find . -iname \\\"*.headwater*\\\" -maxdepth 2; echo \\\"---\\\"; ls -la .headwater 2>/dev/null; echo \\\"---overlay---\\\"; find . -iname \\\"overlay.yml\\\"; echo \\\"---taxonomy.lock---\\\"; find . -iname \\\"taxonomy.lock\\\"\",\"description\":\"Look for .headwater directory and config files\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"find docs -maxdepth 1 -type d; echo \\\"---non-fixture tombstone hits---\\\"; grep -rln \\\"tombstone\\\" docs/ | grep -v fixtures; echo \\\"---check corpus.json for tombstone counts (not docs/ but context)---\\\"; grep -o '\\\"tombstone[^\\\"]*\\\"[^,}]*' .headwater/corpus.json | head -20\",\"description\":\"List top-level docs subdirectories and check for real tombstone data\"}"
result: ""
- tool: "Bash"
argument: "{\"command\":\"grep -n -B2 -A5 \\\"tombstone\\\" docs/evaluations/the-serving-boundary.md\",\"description\":\"Show tombstone context in the-serving-boundary.md\"}"
result: ""
produced: []
answer: "absent"